For Draghi, a Twinge of Helicopter Envy?

RickAckerman's picture


Alas, the devil is in the details for Europe’s latest attempt at financial alchemy.  Much to the investment world’s apparent dismay yesterday, it turned out that the ECB’s Draghi had nothing very specific in mind when he pledged last week to defend Europe’s monetary union by any means necessary.  In theory, and most immediately, such a rescue would entail using printing-press money to mop up Spain’s leprous bonds, lest rates push above 7%. Seven percent is the generally accepted danger threshold for sovereign borrowers, but we’d lower the red zone to around 2% ourselves. Our argument is that even a “mere” 2% rate imposes an asphyxiating burden in real terms, given the combination of deflation and fiscal austerity that has put Europe in a choke hold. Regardless, we won’t quibble over a spread of five measly percentage points if Europe’s bankers have indeed convinced themselves, as they seem to have, that servicing loans at a rate above zero is do-able in a negative-growth environment that could linger for years.



No doubt Mr. Draghi feels a twinge of Helicopter envy whenever he is called on to make heroic promises.  His colleague Mr. Bernanke can say and do things that would get Draghi hauled in front of a tribunal – if not in his native Italy, which has always thrived on gray markets, then in Germany, where bankers continue to vex the rest of Europe with their prissy insistence that i’s be dotted and t’s crossed.  With Germany riding herd on any tactic that Draghi might attempt, his task of fixing Europe is akin to Bernanke trying to bail out California with Ron Paul holding a veto.  And while Bernanke could be counted on to evade even the most deadly surface-to-air inbounds, Draghi lacks the experience and political cover to stay airborne. Whatever unfolds, the Germans cannot be comfortable with Draghi’s idea of doing “whatever it takes” to suppress market rates. Germany is owed quite a sum of money by everyone else, you see, and one can hardly blame them for acting as though their neighbors are conspiring to pay them back in crapola.



Next, a 300-Point Dow Rally?


Recall that it was barely a week ago that stock markets around the world soared on Draghi’s words, meaningless though they may have been. There was also a week’s worth of anticipation that the Fed would launch QE3.  When that failed to happen, stocks hovered for an entire day above the abyss, suspended in the air like Wyle E. Coyote; and then, yesterday, they fell. The delay is puzzling, but perhaps it took a one-two punch from the ECB and the Fed to send shares reeling.  Even so, we could not help noticing that the Dow Industrials managed to recoup half of their losses yesterday after being down almost 200 points.  Is the glass half-empty?  Or perhaps half-full, but of hemlock?  Rather than speculate about such things, we’ll rely on a purely mechanical reading of our stock charts for the answer, focusing for now on the sometimes omniscient price action of index futures.  Difficult as it is to believe, the E-Mini S&Ps look like they could explode for 40 points – equivalent to a 300-point Dow rally – if traders catch what they initially take to be a pleasant whiff from Cucina Draghi. We’ll be watching from the sidelines ourselves, waiting as we so often do for the flatulence to subside.




Trading stocks, options and commodities in these treacherous times calls for great patience and skill. Click here if you’d like to see how Rick’s Picks approaches the challenge.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Mountainview's picture

Draghi has still these Germans disturbing his plans. In comparison: Utah doesn't meddle with Bernanke (I doubt this would change with Romney Mitt)...

strangeglove's picture

Thankfully everything is fixed this AM!

bigwavedave's picture

They will print. I just dont get why so many people dont understand it. It is what they do. They print.

bank guy in Brussels's picture

Indeed Draghi is setting up the Big Print, like you suggest ... Ackerman is following a silly standard line of critique because Draghi did not do it 'now', he does not understand the EU political game

In the EU we have our fake football match (like American 'pro wrestling', or 'Obama vs. Romney'), our fake charade of 'Tough German Bankers' vs. 'Lazy Latin Spenders' ... when in fact the German banks and insurance funds, with all their bad debts, will eventually need Draghi (or the Bundesbank) to print, too ... and even Merkel knows that!

Also agreeing is the terrific Ambrose Evans-Pritchard in the UK Telegraph, that Draghi is ready to do QE and bond-buying on a massive scale, soon, at the ultra-severe-crisis point that is not long away:

Evans-Pritchard writes:

« Wow, the ECB really is preparing to hit the nuclear button.

Mario Draghi has activated the ECB's monetary policy, risk, and market committees to draw up drastic plans.

This will include open-market operations – ie bond purchases – that may be "unlimited" and may be "unsterilised" (ie QE net stimulus).

The missile is being loaded. The launch trigger is being cocked (if you cock such things).

Markets have tanked because they don’t get instant gratification, but I rather suspect that they have missed the point. »

'Draghi Delivers'

mkhs's picture

More hope?

Same story, just different cheerleaders.

BigDuke6's picture


you are just stirring up the bernanke hating mob here and thats too easy.

You say Draghi gets hauled over the coals?  Rubbish. he has carte blanche. as the frenchies say, to do whatever.   Just like Bernanke. They are the SAME.

Draghi is unelected too and the only one gives him stick is Farage and he can be portrayed by the MSM as a crackpot just like Ron Paul is in the USA.

The similarities on both sides of the Atlantic are depressing.

Seorse Gorog from that Quantum Entanglement Fund. alright_.-'s picture

You can't spell Draghi without Drag.

Seorse Gorog from that Quantum Entanglement Fund. alright_.-'s picture

No you cannot, sir. How about this one:

Drag-hi... Drag-bye.




I didn't think so, Your Greatness.

engineertheeconomy's picture

Drag boy can only steal from a few tiny European countries

Bernanke gets to steals from the entire planet

No comparison

(exchanging worthless unbacked pieces of paper for property, goods and services is a form of theft and a form of slavery)