This page has been archived and commenting is disabled.
France Torpedoes American Movies, Shoots Itself In Foot
Wolf Richter www.testosteronepit.com www.amazon.com/author/wolfrichter
On Friday, France vetoed the launch of free-trade negotiations between the EU and the US, though France has been racking up a trade surplus with the US and has much to lose if the US retaliates. The problem: cultural protectionism. It wanted “protection of cultural services and a clear and explicit exclusion of the audio-visual sector,” whined Foreign Trade Minister Nicole Bricq at a Friday meeting of the EU trade ministers. Catch phrases for American movies and TV shows!
Her speech and the veto were hushed up in Europe, and I couldn’t find any reference to it in the major media outlets. But an unnamed “EU diplomat” leaked the text of her speech to the Chinese media group Xinhua, which wasn’t shy about spreading the word.
It was the day that the European Council was supposed to approve a mandate to start haggling over the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) with the US. All along, France had vociferously threatened to shut down the process before it even got started unless the European Commission included in advance a non-negotiable, iron-clad “cultural exception” to protect the French market from a tsunami of evils, namely American movies – a theme that goes back two decades.
France concocted this “cultural exception” under socialist President François Mitterrand and, with the support of a handful of other countries, forced it on the 1992-93 negotiations of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), the so-called Uruguay Round – under the pretense that applying GATT principles to movies and other audiovisual products “would undermine their cultural specificity (and unique status), in favour of their commercial aspects.”
Since then, the concept of “cultural exception” has become, according to UNESCO, a “tacit understanding,” without legal value, “that culture is not like any other merchandise because it goes beyond the commercial....” Sounds good. It was propagated by conservative Jacques Chirac when he ascended to the French presidential throne in 1995 and has now become part of the DNA of France’s political class.
It permitted France not only to subsidize its film industry with taxpayer money but also to impose quotas on theaters and TV channels as to the percentage of time that French productions must be shown, even if they’re lousy, and even if no one comes to see them. With the quotas, the government tried to limit access to American movies. On the basis that the State knows best what the people need to watch.
So in France, about 50% of the admissions were to American movies, while in other European countries that ratio was closer to 90%. Based on my own boots-on-the-ground impressions from when I was living in Paris in 1996/97: American movies were packed and often sold out, though Bruce Willis disturbingly spoke impeccable French with a funny voice, and the movements of his mouth never quite matched his actual French words.
But many of the French films I saw – and I’m a fan of French films – had lots of empty seats, and some of the films were walk-out bad, didn’t deserve being shown, and few people were stupid enough to buy tickets for them, but they were shown nevertheless because they’d been produced with loads of taxpayer money and were forced upon theaters through the quota system. I’m not sure what the quota system actually accomplished; French movie goers are very savvy and know how to make up their minds about what they like and what they scorn – regardless of what their government says.
That worries the government. It prefers to dictate what people should spend their money on. It wants its subjects to watch French films, not that American cultural pollution that seeps across the porous border. Hence the unlikely survival of the Exception Française.
The French audio-visual sector, lagging years behind, might not survive as US companies would introduce “technological revolutions” that their French counterparts might not be able to adapt, said Trade Minister Bricq in her speech. “Sixty percent of European screens are occupied by American movies, while European films are occupying between three and six percent of the American market,” she lamented – as if that were part of an evil plot rather than a choice by savvy movie goers.
An embarrassing internal setback for the EU. And an economic setback. The US and the EU combined make up about half of the world economy. Experts have pegged the economic benefits of a free-trade agreement at $157 billion for the EU and at a smaller $125 billion for the US. France’s veto widened the rift across the EU that had already been deepened by the trade sanctions on Chinese solar panels [here is my take on that debacle... Germany Fires Salvo In Sino-European Trade War ... At Brussels].
The US has threatened to retaliate if “special French exemptions” made it into the negotiations, which could be painful for France, given the trade surplus France has with the US. But economic rationality has never stopped the French government from shooting itself, or rather the country, in the foot.
In the US, new dynamics have surfaced. Much like scandal-ravaged Presidents Nixon and Clinton, who triangulated in favor of legislation considered vital by their opponents, President Obama is now likely to support conservative legislation that would reform corporate income tax and spur a renaissance in manufacturing. Read.... “Made In America” Renaissance Begins.
- advertisements -


It is actually 'non-cultural protectionism'. A uphill struggle since many people prefer mindless movies over something with content. Because why think?
Turkish police catch Al Qaeda-linked Syrian Al Nusra terrorists
DEBKAfile June 15, 2013, 5:04 PM (GMT+02:00)
In raids in Istanbul and southern cities near the Syrian border, Turkey police Friday arrested 12 members of al Qaeda’s Syrian affiliate, Al Nusra Front. Found in their possession were four and a half pounds of sarin nerve gas, hand guns, grenades, bullets and documents for what the Turkish daily Zaman reported was to be a bomb attack on the Turkish town of Adana..
http://debka.com/newsupdatepopup/4705/
"Her speech and the veto were hushed up in Europe, and I couldn’t find any reference to it in the major media outlets. But an unnamed “EU diplomat” leaked the text of her speech to the Chinese media group Xinhua, which wasn’t shy about spreading the word."
http://www.euronews.com/2013/06/15/french-cinema-to-be-protected-in-eu-u...
http://uk.reuters.com/article/2013/06/15/uk-eu-us-trade-idUKBRE95D0S5201...
http://www.france24.com/en/20130615-eu-deal-french-cultural-exception-us...
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/13/eu-free-trade-talks-france
Yep, in europe we had no idea due to the complete black out on this item.
Is partiotism and national pride an exclusively American trait now that is not allowed in any other country where it interferes with their complete domination?
Should be interesting to see what France does.
Should be more interesting to see how Germany tightens the noose on France.
This FTA is going through - too much power wants it to happen.
cheese eating surrender moneys
If Xinhua is reporting this story correctly, then it is truly an embarrassment that European media has not been able to.
My take is that there is a greater and greater diconect between the "socialist government" and the governed in France. I suspect that the French citizen who wants to see an American movie on a DVD will know where they can buy one....tax free. "I'm shocked I tell you shocked that black market DVD's translated into French are being sold here!" "Here is your Superman movie inspector."
And in Quebec, they passed a law that all business signs must be in French ONLY. Imagine what that did to storeowners in Chinatown?
In the 80's the Canadian government had the same system for radio, requiring a minimum level of 30% Canadian content ("Cancon") per hour. Not that excellent Canadian content didn't exist, but how many times could you listen to "Tom Sawyer"? Off air, radio DJ's used to refer derisively to Cancon discs of marginal quality (Trooper, I'm looking at you) as "Beavers".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iGJSN5CgYoY
"In Paris they just simply opened their eyes and stared when we spoke to them in French! We never did succeed in making those idiots understand their own language." - The Innocents Abroad
They are so prepared to snub you for not speaking French that they have a brain fart when you you speak to them in French.
Well if 50% of admissions are to French movies, seems like their policy is working
Aside from opportunistically seizing value from the vulnerable, it is not reasonable to expect a socialist to behave in a way that makes business sense.
Is it still like in the summer of 1984 (seriously), when every radio channel had to play like 6 minutes per hour french songs?
Especially on a "newest hits" channel that was hilariously bad, and almost as if someone poured ice water over the listeners once every hour.
I've been here in France for over almost a month now. It's horrible to see the absolute shit in the movie theatres. I cant even take my kid to see a damn cartoon 3d movie...! I have to say they are obsessed with Walker Texas Ranger though. It's on EVERY NIGHT!
Joan of Arc was Chuck Norris' maid
Maybe the NSA can release them to the French citizens.....
Hell, they might even get them sooner than we get them in the US...
Sitting through a bad French film is how the cultural elite display the differences between them and the rest of the universe.
Vive la France!
En retaliatsion four makink fun oufwe us, we are nut goeeng to permeet export oufe our fries our vins to Americaines!
Pfffft!
Stupide Americaines!
Remamber D-Day!
Remamber Rue de Wall investing in pre Seconde Guerre mondiale Nazi Alemania.
As a EU Commission loathing Brit this is great news.
It wrecks Cammerons plans to shackle the UK to the EU by claiming our trade with the US is reliant on the TTIP umbrella.
Farage will be raising a glass to the French tonight, as am I.
Sacre blue my own toe off!
Love the Mark Twain quote. LOL
The French they are a funny race.
They fight with their feet
And they f*ck with their face.
(Attributed to Mark Twain)
Well, whatever they use, they can use on themselves.
so what do americans do?
they fight with their drones and fuck with their clones?
The french fight for so called "cultural exception" to avoid drowning in US reality shows and hamburger n ketchup serial movies and tv shows. What they have to learn is to speak a universal language and not be navel gazers.
Its fine to say we don't want your shit; its better to produce excellence and not just replace imported shit with worse local shit.
The French don't want to watch 18 hours of Balloon Boy and Tom DeLay on Dancing with the Stars and many other Top Shows ?
France is just an RMB offshore now and obedient EU lapdog.