Coxe On The Power Of Zero

Tyler Durden's picture

The one "must read" report this weekend comes from Coxe Advisors LLC. A phenomenal summation of all the relevant economic, financial, and political trends and how these will impact both the near- and the longer-term.

Key highlights from the report:

On the big picture:

  • Highlights: takeovers of General Motors and Chrysler, a deficit of 12% of GDP, $790 billion in handouts and assistance under the rubric of economic stimulus, a costly new national health care system, and a vast array of tax and trade global warming programs whose tentacles will reach into almost every sector of the economy.
  • Only Lehman was allowed to experience the Schumpeteresque-slaughter reserved for capitalist cupidity and stupidity. Operating with scripts and strategies conceived on the fly, varying prescriptions of emergency assistance were extended, under panic conditions, to Citigroup, Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley, AIG and Goldman Sachs.
  • The cheerful Reagan charmed voters by teasing his opponents. He summed up Democratic economics as, “If it moves, tax it; if it keeps moving, regulate it; and if it stops moving, subsidize it.” He summed up the goal of his policies toward the Soviets: “We win; they lose.”
  • The Pelosi-Obama stimulus package passed with no Republican votes in the House, despite heavy lobbying from some segments of the business community, notably General Electric, which became Obama’s most dedicated corporate cheerleader—itself and through MSNBC [let's not forget CNBC here]—after receiving many billions in low-cost loans to its flagging finance subsidiary, GE Capital.
  • [Obama] remains the most charming and charismatic President of modern times, and is still, quite probably, liked by more Americans—and more people abroad—than any American President. He and his radiant wife are, as The New York Times notes, America’s greatest global brand. But the reality of the Presidency is that handsome is as handsome does. His approval ratings have descended from the Heavenly to the ordinary. All polls disclose that while most Americans still like and admire him personally, they disapprove of his policies.
  • Despite a brilliant campaign, adoration from the media, a divided Republican party, and a flagging economy, he was actually behind the Bush-baggaged McCain in the polls until Lehman imploded, and suddenly it looked as if the world could end. As Larry Summers would later joke, a new Messiah was what was needed. (It hasn’t come to an end, although a recent New Yorker cartoon shows a gentleman consoling a friend, saying, “It isn’t the End of the World.” Just around the corner, riding furiously toward them, are the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse.)
  • Based on our recent trip to visit European clients, and numerous emails from foreign clients across much of the world, many global investors are alarmed about Obama’s policies and are reducing their exposure to US assets accordingly. The dollar’s decline may be one symptom of these doubts about the actions of Obama and the Democratic Congress.

On Zero interest rates:

  • Why shouldn’t the economic recovery be at least as strong as Reagan’s—if not even more robust? It’s because those Zero rates tell us that the financial system’s problems that triggered the economic collapse aren’t going away quickly—and could even be getting worse.
  • The Administration’s forecast through 2019 assumes that foreign creditors’ appetites for Treasurys will grow at least as fast as the national debt. It predicts sustained real GDP growth of 3% per year, with no recessions, no increases in taxpayer cost for health care, and—despite sustained deficits and a doubling of the national debt-to-GDP ratio (excluding Fannie and Freddie debt) from 41% to 82%—long Treasury yields will not rise more than 1%. (We spoke at a Canadian financial conference last month at which Niall Ferguson was the star. He flashed that forecast up on the screen and said, “Those aren’t real forecasts: they’re Mickey Mouse numbers.”)
  • There has been one little-remarked change in the investment strategy of America’s Sugar Daddy #1: in recent months, China has been rolling over its maturing Treasury notes into T-Bills. It thereby chooses to forgo interest of 2%–3.4% in favor of near-Zero yields. What power, one wonders, does Beijing think, comes from a Zero return in a weakening currency? And why is that putative power growing so relentlessly?
  • Led by the Fed, central banks across the OECD have been Japonized.
  • Wherever his spirit rests, Benjamin Franklin must be livid. When the hardearned savings of ordinary people are looted to enrich greedy bankers, and when they are told that this process is necessary to make America prosperous again, no wonder so many citizens have displayed so much anger at “Tea Parties.”
  • Amid all the enthusiasm about soaring stocks and an economic recovery, it is wise to retain one’s perspective about what has happened to investors. Last week, the Bank of America summed up the disappointments of our era for institutional investors. It noted that there were 42 trading days left this year, and the S&P would have to rise 42% to deliver a Zero rate of return for the past decade. By some calculations, on a compounded basis, long Treasurys have outperformed the S&P since the beginning of the Reagan bull market. The problem with those data is that they assume sustained reinvestment of interest at the long end of the curve, but most bond managers would have been below benchmark duration for extended periods, which meant their cash income would have been reduced.

On excess reserves

  • The amount of Cash and Excess Bank Reserves in the US economy is at all-time records, mostly because of Bernanke’s panicky doubling of the Fed’s balance sheet. But this is a construct, not a solidly-based financial reality.
  • Cash was splashed among the B5 to array their balance sheets, which were looking Gandhian in their skinniness. But the B5 re-deposited a huge slug of those funds with the Fed as excess reserves: why go through all the nuisance involved in making loans to individual companies? They also bought up the Treasury curve. These bankers toil not much, but they spin like mad: they keep trying to convince us that they didn’t cause the Crash, and they really deserve their big bonuses.

On the biggest threat with mortgages:

  • All those math and physics PhDs who built the products, and the bankers who distributed them, never thought about a principle in mortgages that dates back to the 14th century and the emergence of Courts of Equity. (That’s where the word “equity” comes from.)
  • Equity was based on the Chancellor’s religious-based concern for welfare of people of the middle- and lower-classes who suffered under the rigors of Common Law.
  • If more US courts decide that those ancient protections for homeowners need to be protected against derivatives, the results for the B5, Fannie and Freddie would be very…..interesting.

On market and portfolio volatility and risk:

  • Zero Cash means big problems for overall construction. Assuming
    that a Fund needs to earn a nominal 7% overall, net of fees and costs,
    then the higher the Cash component, the higher must be the rate of
    return assumptions for the other asset classes. Without tinkering with
    those assumptions, then the higher the Cash component, the higher the
    risk and volatility the portfolio must assume. Such asset classes as
    Junk Bonds, Leveraged Loans, and small Emerging Markets might have to
    be quite big commitments for the Fund to meet its objectives
  • The price of oil in recent months has traded almost in inverse lock-step with the value of the dollar. This isn’t the longer-term adjustment that characterized the 1970s—it’s occurring in real-time. This daily activity mocks the reliance traders used to place on actual data about oil supplies and demands—particularly the weekly data about US supplies of oil and refined products. Many of the metals—notably aluminum—no longer trade primarily based on LME inventory data. They dance to the global risk music of the markets. Stocks trade together globally on a day-to-day basis. Yes, Emerging Markets continue to outperform the S&P, rising more than New York on bullish days, and not falling as hard, on days risk is being unwound.
  • The Barons of the B5 are reporting record trading profi ts, which means, as Nouriel Roubini warns, that systemic risk is increasing, not decreasing. The locus of this new risk has moved from toxic, untraded products whose values are shielded against market pricing to marketable investments of nearly all stripes.

On those "easily forgotten" daily problems like CIT:

  • CIT’s bankruptcy is a synecdoche for Main Street America’s problems. As the largest factoring company, it has been—for many decades—a reliable backstop for small and medium-sized businesses across America. Companies assigned their receivables to CIT, thereby allowing them to continue to sell their output profitably, even to sophisticated giants such as Walmart and Amazon, which are famously successful at boosting their cash flows by delaying their payments to suppliers for months. Their local banks would assist in financing inventories and making loans for capital investment secured by real estate liens and owners’ personal guarantees. CIT is now operating in bankruptcy, but it is hardly in shape to perform its historic functions as demand for factoring rises in response to an economic recovery.

On the outlook for the middle class and small and medium-sized businesses:

  • The realization that the trillion-dollar deficits are destined to continue, even when the economy gets back to sustained growth, frightens the [small and medium sized businesses]. They hear that they will be subject to much higher taxes on “the rich,” and hear that the term “rich” means people who earn more than $500,000 a year. (According to The Wall Street Journal, if the tax rate in 2007 were 100% on Americans earning over $500,000 a year, that would have generated just over a trillion in Treasury receipts.)
  • The 1990-page health care legislation not only has the “millionaire’s taxes” on those earning above $500,000, but imposes high extra taxes on small businesses which do not offer health care to their employees. Doubtless, local bankers will be looking at the effects of these permanent tax increases and mentally marking down their customers’ ability to service their loans in future years

On Gold:

  1. It’s a risk asset, so it’s benefiting from the rush to risk.
  2. Borrowing at Zero to buy something with Zero yield is income-neutral.
  3. It’s the only asset that, based on history, outperforms under both horror stories—Depression and Hyperinflation.
  4. Its upside breakout came at the time of Halloween.
  5. India announced purchase of half the hoard on offer from the IMF, which had been weighing on gold prices, and there are rumors that China will take up the rest. This was the second surprising announcement from India within a fortnight. The other was that the United Arab Emirates had displaced such nations as the US, China and Germany as India’s biggest trading partner in recent months. Apart from tea, and gold in the form of baubles, bangles and beads, what big-ticket exports other than bullion could India be sending to that collection of gold-loving states? It’s no longer exporting rice or sugar.
  6. Statistics from across the world confirm that the economic recovery is gaining steam, so the specter of inflation is moving stealthily from deep in the primeval forest toward the main path. Travelers beware.
  7. Barrick CEO’s statement in London about the continuous decline in new gold mine output, suggesting, “There is a strong case to be made that we are already at ‘peak gold’.’’ The golden rule of commodities has been that the cure for high prices is high prices: when the price of stuff goes up, big new production always follows, and the price goes down. Gold’s price has more than quadrupled, but new-mine production keeps falling. With central banks apparently switching from the sell to the buy side, this may be a new world for the oldest store of value.
  8. All of the above.
  • Is gold overvalued? In terms of a reliable historic indicator, it may depend on how you define a gentleman. The Economist once sought to fi nd a true value of gold with a study showing that, for most of the time since the Middle Ages, an ounce of gold would buy a gentleman’s suit in London. That was not the case on Jermyn Street from 1981 through 2007 even for the less prestigious tailors. With the recent decline in the pound, it is now applicable to the shops located more than two blocks from St. James’s Street. (It hasn’t, we believe, applied at Savile Row since King Edward’s time.)

The outlook:

  1. The root cause of the financial and economic collapse—the demographically driven plunge in real estate prices at a time of serious over-leverage in the housing sector—remains a clear and present danger to banks and other financial institutions.
  2. All the US government’s home mortgage lending institutions are experiencing rising losses, despite the slight uptick in house prices. That barely-observable bounce is due to most drastic price maintenance program in history—taxpayer bailouts of lending institutions, the Fed’s huge subsidy to mortgage rates through purchases of Fannie and Freddie paper, and 10-year notes, and the First-Time Homebuyer Subsidy of $8,000. It took all those trillions to get house prices to rise 4% from their panic lows. Why should investors be confi dent the rally will continue? “Stein’s Law”, which has never been repealed, may be ready to be proved anew: “If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.”
  3. Bernanke will have used up his entire declared quota of purchases of long Treasurys and mortgage-backed paper within a few months. Then what?
  4. Commercial real estate grows sicker each month, as office and condo vacancy rates rise, and more and more regional banks go to the wall.
  5. The biggest contributor to the 3.5% economic growth of the Third Quarter came from the Cash for Clunkers program. That is gone.
  6. The only US auto company to report positive cash fl ow in the Third Quarter—Ford—still struggles with a boom-year-negotiated UAW contract that means its labor costs are much higher than the other members of what used to be known as The Big Three. Since the UAW and Washington effectively own those competitors to Ford, there’s slim chance the union
    will do anything to strengthen Ford: if Ford collapses, so much the better for the union-owned Big Two. Chrysler has no hot new products in the pipeline and an ambiguous management agreement with Fiat. GM is adjusting to a shrunken product base and its finance subsidiary, GMAC, has already received four emergency cash infusions from Washington since the bankruptcy. Hyundai, no friend of the UAW, is the hottest company in US sales. The current noise on Detroit assembly lines could turn out to be a death rattle.
  7. What may have been the most useful consumer economic stimulus—the collapse in gasoline prices—is fast becoming a cherished memory. Gasoline prices have already retraced roughly half their plunge. That most useful of all “tax cuts” is being chipped away, as other taxes at federal, state and local levels face inevitable increases.
  8. Although overall consumer inflation remains near the Zero level, food prices continue to rise relative to other costs, and natural gas prices are no longer at remarkably cheap levels.
  9. And it looks to be a cold winter—atmospherically and otherwise.

Full report:


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Anonymous's picture

yup, everything looks rosy fersure.


qrs521's picture

Women in summer would like to become beautiful. Everything can grab other's eyes is their best friends.Products make them beauty and confident is their favourite. Look in the street,you can see many different types of make up to show women's personality.

Welcome to the shop, the following is our products, free shipping.

Soccer Shoes Cheap Soccer Shoes Nike Soccer Shoes Adidas Soccer Shoes Nike Soccer Shoes sale Adidas Soccer Shoes sale UGG UGGs UGG Boot UGG Boots UGG Boots Sale Cheap UGG Boots UGG Boots Cheap Women UGG boots ugg boots cardy ugg cardy boots Timberland Timberland sale Timberland boots Timberland boots online Timberland on sale New timberland boots UGG UGG boots UGG boots sale UGG boots short Short ugg Short ugg boots Ugg boots tall Nike Air Nike Air Max Nike Air Max Shoes Nike SB Nike Dunk Nike Dunk SB Nike Dunk SB Shoes Nike Shox Nike Shox Shoes Women Bags Women Bags Sale Women Handbags Women Handbags Sale Women New Bags Cheap Bags Cheap Bags On Sale New women bags New women bags sale New women bags sale online Louis Vuitton Handbags Gucci bags Nike Nike Shoes Nike Shoes Sale Nike running Nike running shoes Nike trainers Nike trainers shoes Timberland Timberland boots Timberland boots sale Timberland boot Timberland boot sale Timberland boots cheap Men timberlands MBT MBT Shoes MBT Chapa GTX MBT Men Shoes MBT Women Shoes Discount MBT Shoes LV Handbags Gucci Handbags Chanel Handbags Chloe Handbags D&G Handbags Dior Handbags Fendi Handbags Hermes Handbags Jimmy Choo Bags Marc Jacobs Bags Miu Miu Handbags Mulberry Bags Prada Handbags Versace Handbags Yves Saint Laurent Balenciaga Bags Burberry Handbags LV Handbags Gucci Handbags Chanel Handbags Chloe Handbags D&G Handbags Dior Handbags Fendi Handbags Hermes Handbags Jimmy Choo Bags Marc Jacobs Bags Miu Miu Handbags Mulberry Bags Prada Handbags Versace Handbags Yves Saint Laurent Balenciaga Bags Burberry Handbags

Those who want to become most beautiful in the world should try them. Just ones can make you different. Girls who want to grab your boyfriends's heart is necessary to use them.

sohbetme's picture

I like your ideas and thoughts. While chat and sohbet with my friends talking about it...

spekulatn's picture




MsCreant's picture

Do you have like, dude pom-poms?

. . .'s picture

He wears them on his chest.  His avatar, John Goodman, is endowed with bigger breasts than many women.

D.O.D.'s picture

Ohhh if we could all have the class and depth of insight of MsCreant. Why are you worried about it?  Or is owning your own home and being employed, debt free not turn out as thrilling as you would have hoped?

Let me dumb it down for you, you might be missing my point...

Say something smart, I'm calling you out

this is Fight Club... you Have to fight...

MsCreant's picture

"Nobody fucks with the Jesus."

Is that the problem here? Did I fuck with the Jesus?

For some reason, you have to draw some kind of line in the sand, here, now? You have never spoken to me before and this post, of any post I have ever posted, you gotta have an attitude about?

Or has it been building up for a while and finally, you are all pissed off and you just gotta do something about me, some, as you characterize it, "home owning, debt free, employed, unthrilled with her life," poster?

Yep, I'm a real menace. An obvious threat. I'm sure he could not respond to the comment and needed you to jump in and help. I know he is grateful.

Nah, you just basically told him you think he is a pussy by, "Calling me out."

You are suffering an illusion. Your reactions are yours, not my problem.

Wonder what offends you?

You think I am attacking him? Asking about Pom-poms? Hmmm... ya know, he could just answer me. It might be funny. We might get to know more about him, he says so little.

For the record, I have a cat who is "The Dude," "Mr. Dude," "Dude-a-rino," and "Dude-a-riffic." He is a laid back Tom who is only 8 months old and already 12 pounds and no fat. He very much abides, thank you very much.

Now what is your real problem? It ain't his pom-poms.

Probably lives in this comment: "if we could all have the class and depth of insight of MsCreant."

Whats up?

D.O.D.'s picture

As I suspected... not an intelligent comment in there.  Several leaps in logic, with [lack luster] attempts at back handed ad hominem attacks. 

You could try and pin the tail on me (this is the genral solace of the guilty), but the truth be told, you are the instigator and I am the finisher.  If you honestly don't know who started this, then you really are as dumb as your posts infer. 

If you are looking to back out now, I will let you.  I don't want to embarrass you in front of all your friends, but you should know, I will.  Your call smart guy.  You might want to think about this one; just a word from the wise.

MsCreant's picture

You can say there are leaps in logic, show us.

D.O.D.'s picture

If you don't see them, that is my point, ignant fool.

MsCreant's picture

Ya got nothing. So basically you are going to huff and puff and bloooow my house down.

If you are going to pick a fight, best you believe in the cause. Do you believe in the cause? Or is this going to turn into:

D.O.D.: You're stupid.

MsCreant: No, you're stupid.

D.O.D.: No, you're stupid.

This is turning into a real lame fight club fight. You are correct, I am embarassed.

D.O.D.'s picture

Actually, I tend to be a bit more creative with my insults than stoopid.  You see, I have a grammar level beyond 5th grade.

Again, you are pulling things out of thin air that have nothing to do with the discussion at hand, lending more creed to my accusation; You are tarded.  Don't worry scro, lots'a people are tarded these days. You've got plenty of company... bahhahhahh bahahhahh

MsCreant's picture

"Discussion at hand," there is one?

All I see you doing is calling me names and huffing and puffing. You are not saying anything, this is going nowhere, we are in the land of the absurd. There is no issue, you know it and now you can't back out.

You think I'm ignant, tarded, and? So?

D.O.D.'s picture

The issue at hand is your intelligence.  You have yet to make an intelligent statement in 5 comments.  In fact all of your comments have been designed to deflect from the question of your intelligence.  I wonder why?  You can continue to try and make this out to be about my intelligence, further proving your own ineptitude, or you can make an attempt at an intellectual debate.  The choice is yours.  Oh and the debate is; whether or not you, MsCreant, have the mental capacity to make logical, thought provoking sense.

MsCreant's picture

I posted this: "Do you have like, dude pom-poms?"

You said this:

"Ohhh if we could all have the class and depth of insight of MsCreant. Why are you worried about it?  Or is owning your own home and being employed, debt free not turn out as thrilling as you would have hoped?"

Somewhere in that is the topic of discussion. If you can't talk about the topic you brought up with me, and you want to change the topic to how retarded I am, then that is what you want to type about, type away, free country. But you have already lost simply because you lost the topic. And yeah, each one of these I answer makes me dumber and dumber, you are right about that, because there is nothing going on here at all.

D.O.D.'s picture

You might want to read that post again...

"I will dumb it down for you, you might be missing my point

say something smart, I'm calling you out"

I am still waiting. Do you actually have any idea what you are saying, or do you just grab at random words and hope they make sense?

MsCreant's picture

You win.

Careful there...

Now what?

D.O.D.'s picture

ok, that is smart, I'll give you that...

MsCreant's picture


Non-Zero-Sum game.

Cognitive Dissonance's picture


What the fuck was that? I've never seen anyone have a nervous breakdown in public until now. Steer clear of that one cause the edge is real close. Must be a sleeper cell let loose from the meds that calmed the savage beast.

MsCreant's picture


I think that was an experiment in fight club. He did not like my comment. He called me out. I think it was settled just fine. But I appreciate where you are coming from and thank you for it. If this place is going to use the fight club motif, we need to be free to use the motif. It may actually be an excellent enforcement mechanism for random trolling (which apparently is how some see me and I will adjust my posts now that I know).

Folks are wound tight CD.

D.O.D.'s picture


If you've never experienced someone who is willing to fight for their own dignity, perhaps that is the problem in this country. 

Wait... Are you from Canada? honest...

Cognitive Dissonance's picture

What a fucking ass wipe. Go somewhere else and piss to your hearts content. I had my fill of bullies in first grade and never tolerated them again. A couple of shots to the face sends them running to momma.

My dignity is based upon my own standards and can never be insulted or challenged unless I lower myself and allow it. I don't worry what other people think of me except those I respect. You are not in that category and clearly never will.

Get lost fool.

D.O.D.'s picture

This is where you are way off base CD.  Just because you are a coward doesn't mean those who are willing to stand up for themselves are bullies.  You can ask MsCreant who started this; because it wasn't me.  I simply defended myself. If you really call defending yourself being a bully, then you absolutely have no place telling anyone what to do.  Avoiding the Canada question?  I wonder why?  Panzie...

11b40's picture

A pox on both your houses.  Please take this somewhere else.

D.O.D.'s picture

pox on your house; it seems ad hominem attacks were the weekend flavor.  Don't like 'em, don't use'em...

11b40's picture

A pox on both your houses.  Please take this somewhere else.

D.O.D.'s picture

Sticking with the theme of the post, and as a demonstration as to the level of commitment to my beliefs, I will choose 0.

msjimmied's picture

Newbies wanna be badasses...let it go, you have never displayed bad form, with them, you would have to. Nah, keep it for the deserving. I've always enjoyed your posts.

JR's picture

Gee, this kinda made me homesick for a weekend at home with Mom and Dad.  It’s better than the Bickersons!  Let me know where to tune in next Sunday. It'll probably be syndicated by then... :-)

justrichard's picture

Nothing worse than "lousy logic, tempestuously waged"  -W.F. Buckley

 D.O.D. -- enjoy your posts.  Ms Creant -- not so much.

SRV - ES339's picture

Richard, you enjoyed these posts?

Seems like a pompous bully to me. 

D.O.D.'s picture

Most panzies have that opinion...

SRV - ES339's picture

Sorry... a "spell check" challenged pompous bully

D.O.D.'s picture

I reserve artists' discretion, by right of profession... bitxez...

Anonymous's picture

Allow me to poke my fat long haired head in here
and begin singing innapropriately for a business environment



-64 minus 20 = -84

Math question (answer) cannot be longer than two characters but is currently three characters long.

Here is my two character answer:


Problem Is's picture

MsCreant : "Nobody fucks with the Jesus."

"Eight-year-olds, Dude... He had to go door to door to tell everyone he was a pederast."

jongreen's picture

I h8 sigs - Not lean at all. Then again, neither is commenting on them.

jongreen's picture

Although replacing the word "dude" with "hedge" would be funny for a while.

Stevm30's picture

2010 is going to hurt, bad.

JamesBrrando's picture

raise % rates. kill gold, roast the usd carry traders, crash the  market, strengthen the usd.


i can dream cant i......

Anonymous's picture

And that's why Obama has gone to China.
By mid-next week, we will have a press release saying the Chinese will support the USD through continued purchase of treasuries (a stronger USD is in China's interest and this is a 'supply and demand'driven equation). They could support the USD through some independent mechanism, not sure what.
The USD will reverse and show a gentle, bullish trend. Stocks will begin to decline, but gently. Commodities will continue rising gently because they were over-sold.
USD increasing strength, improves confidence and markets will begin to show break-outs to the upside (recent company results continue to show suprisingly strong returns). There will be a further decrease in the number of people speculating doom and gloom scenarios.

Harbourcity's picture

"USD increasing strength, improves confidence and markets will begin to show break-outs to the upside (recent company results continue to show suprisingly strong returns). There will be a further decrease in the number of people speculating doom and gloom scenarios."

Interest rates will stay low yet the USD won't be the carry trade.  Suddenly, the trillions in debt will miraculously disappear.  Obama will be elected to a second term.

Stay tuned for more rose colored clap trap.



Anonymous's picture

You take the blue pill - the story ends, you wake up in your bed and believe whatever you want to believe.