Currencies: QE2's Done, European Debt Crisis To Take Center Stage

asiablues's picture

By Dian L. Chu, Economic Forecasts & Opinions

Over the past month or so, world`s focus, currency markets in particular, has been centered mainly on the U.S. over QE2, the November elections, and the Job`s Report. As such, there have been some interesting headlines coming out of Europe that went quietly under the radar as Wall Street became infatuated with their own bullish sentiment.

Now, with QE2 and mid-term election pretty much behind us, guess where the market’s attention will shift to next?

The euro, which has been strengthening across the board for a while, was noticeably weaker last week considering the bullish sentiment, which really bolsters the European currency during ebullient US and world market breakout moves to the upside.

Trichet’s Telegraph

There were also telltale clues from the press conference of ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet last Thursday after ECB’s decision to leave interest rates unchanged. The press conference was filled with numerous questions regarding the record high Irish bond spread, and the ever widening bond spread of the other highly indebted EU members--Greece, Spain and Portugal.

That basically telegraphed the European debt crisis will start to take center stage once again.

Spread at Euro Life Time High

Sure enough, on Monday, the Portuguese and Irish government bond spread hit their highest in the euro's lifetime with Irish 10-year bond and the German Bund widened to 557 basis points while the Portuguese 10-year versus the Bund expanded to 450 bps. (see Bond Yield Chart)

In fact, the bond interest rate of Ireland, Portugal and Spain, have been rising ever since German Chancellor Angela Merkel said any future EU bailouts is expected to come with new rules requiring bondholders to absorb some losses, which was further elaborated by German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble in a an interview with Der Spiegel.

Ireland & Portugal - The New Center of Crisis

Meanwhile, Greek bond had a little rally after the election poll, but that does not alter its ominous overall debt picture. Nevertheless, Greece is pretty much old news, and now it’s Ireland's and Portugal's turn to take a beating from the widespread investors skepticism.

Market players expect Portugal to issue up to 1.25 billion euros of five and ten-year bonds this week, while Ireland says it has sufficient cash until mid-2011 (such reassurance to bond buyers) and plans to resume bond auctions in January. 

But with ECB seemingly the only major buyer of European bonds in recent weeks, and at such high yield levels, investors pretty much bet on both countries will eventually join Greece for a bailout by the EU and International Monetary Fund (IMF).

Head of the Debt Class

Of course, fresh deficit figures from Eurostat last month only add to the pessimism. According to Eurostat, Ireland’s budget deficit was the highest among EU members at 14.4 percent of GDP last year, ahead of Spain at 11.1 percent and Portugal at 9.3 percent. (By the way, the UK came in second to Ireland with a deficit of 11.4 percent of GDP.)

Debt Projection – Bad

The more eye-popping news is that Irish deficit is set to rise to an unprecedented 32 percent this year—a modern European record-- due to the one-off costs associated with the bank bailout.

The situation seems so dire that in an article in the Irish Times, the "Dr. Doom" of Ireland--University College Dublin economics Professor Morgan Kelly--concluded that

"We [Ireland] are no longer a sovereign nation in any meaningful sense of that term. From here on, for better or worse, we can only rely on the kindness of strangers."

The debt projection is even more depressing for Portugal and other EU peripheries (See Debt Projection Chart), whereas the UK debt outlook is not that rosy either.

Growth Forecast - Worse

While the US is depressed over its 9.6% unemployment rate, just imagine Spain`s 20.5% unemployment rate, not to mention the slower growth prospects (see Growth Forecast Chart) due to the implementation of numerous Austerity programs throughout European Union member states.

Something Bullish About The Dollar

In short, analysts may be inclined to be bearish on the US dollar due to Mr. Bernanke`s QE2 campaign. However, the European Union and namely the Euro currency may be much worse off than the US dollar, considering the US can actually still finance its debt at much lower rates right now.

Furthermore, the US only has ONE country to manage, whereas the European Union has 27 member states with 16 utilizing the Euro as a single currency, with the high powered Germany at one end of the fiscally responsible spectrum, and lowly Greece and Ireland at the other end.  The GDP comparison chart here also bears a similar message. 

Euro To Retrace

After the initial reaction regarding QE2 where the euro approached 1.43 on the Eeuro/Dollar currency cross, it is now hovering just above 1.38. It seems very likely that euro could break through the 1.38 level this or next week, and head much lower to around 1.35 over the next month on European debt concerns, which will be back on the front burner as markets focus away from the US and back on Europe. 

The comparison is not a favorable one from a currency evaluation standpoint. What you have is a contest where you are trying to find the proverbial dog with the least flees on it, and at these levels, I am not sure the euro is the winner in this currency contest.

Remember, just this summer the euro was trading at 1.18 against the dollar, it has come a long way in a short time, and is probably due for a correction lower to the 1.30-1.35 range over the next 6 months. (See Euro Technical Chart)

Dian L. Chu, Nov. 8, 2010

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
paragshah12's picture

The need for Greece and other European economies to slash government spending is not some artificial imposition by the IMF or the European Union. Once investors decide that a country living beyond its means will have a hard time meeting its debt obligations, spending cuts become a reality of arithmetic.

Canucklehead's picture

QE2 is a chambered round aiming at the heart of international currency manipulation.  If the Europeans want to bail on their currency and find safety in the US dollar, so be it.  Expect QE2 to be implemented "with vigour".  Where will the exchange rate end?  Europe will be out of bullets long before the US breaks a sweat.

If China wants to "stimuate" the Yen by using the same British infrastructure that used to buy US financial instruments, expect Japan to call on the US for QE2 help, along with the Japanese equivalent of QE2.

If you are China, who are you going to call?  A dropping US dollar and Japanese Yen will cause significant domestic hardship.  It has been said that 60% of a typical Chinese pay packet goes for food.  Can the Chinese Oligarchs convince the Chinese population that they should go to financial/economic/physical war with the West?  What happens to the Oligarchs's manufacturing assets?  Do they move them inshore in the search for cheaper operating costs?  What happens to the value of the coastal infrastructure?  What about transportation costs?

I see Chinese comments today simply as steam escaping from the teapot.  Will we see a Chinese version of the tea party rise up?

robobbob's picture

"US is depressed over its 9.6% unemployment rate, just imagine Spain`s 20.5%"

Is that with or without everyones' version of the invisible U6 being counted?

apple, meet orange

Traianus Augustus's picture

The European debt crisis is a non-issue.  China will move in on each of the individual EU countries and replay their same strategy from the Greece crisis.  Go in and buy up tangible assets first.  Then buy up the govt debt using US$'s.  China has already told Portugal they are there to help.  Pretty masterful actually.  They get out of holding US$'s and buy up most of Europe. 

Rogerwilco's picture

Who needs credibility when the golden nectar of liquidity can rain down from the heavens? Rejoice, the Millennium is here!

moofph's picture

"probably due for a correction lower to the 1.30-1.35 range"

...hmnnn...something tells me it should be a bit lower than that...although i agree with most of your synopsis asianblues, it is and has been rather difficult to calculate reality these question is when the euro was trading at 1.18 against the dollar, what made it rise?...ahh, yes, sometimes the numbers appear "like magic."

asiablues's picture

Click to enlarge the euro chart. 1.18 levels back in May/June when Greek debt crisis erupted and EU, ECB, IMF et al took their time to put together and approve the bailout package.  Euro rose afterwards on Greek bailout, shaky U.S. econ, and last but not least, QE2. 

moofph's picture

...yes, i do recall...and i was being a bit facetious...there appears to be this view that the bailout served as a coordinated event, a necessary reaction, yet the drop to 1.18 was not coordinated? to me, the drop appeared as a necessary reaction...but for whom? what is to gain from the drop?...yes, yes, down conspiracy lane, i know.

reactions to data can be mislead when the cause of the data is ignored, in my opinion.

Central Wanker's picture

An interesting story about ECB's ability to exit its "stealth stimulus program".

"Ireland, whose banks borrowed 83 billion euros ($115.5 billion) from the ECB in September -- 38 percent more than a month earlier -- has seen its bonds slide for 10 consecutive days."

ECB alone is keeping Ireland alive with its liquidity program. Spain and Portugal will share Ireland's fate in a near future. How much of ECB's credibility is left then?

Orly's picture

I just worry that when we are all supposed to refocus on European debt, that we don't.  Everybody and their barber is expecting it, so it probably won't happen that way.


deez nutz's picture

While the US is depressed over its 9.6% unemployment rate, just imagine Spain`s 20.5% unemployment rate

U.S. TOTAL unemployment upward of 18 -20%.