Does S&P's Top-Ticking Incompetence Mean It Is Time To Short Credit?

Tyler Durden's picture

Today's Bloomberg has a good article on how S&P: that most reliable lagging market counterindicator has thrown in the towel, and is upgrading anything that moves. "Ford Motor Co., the world’s most profitable automaker, and San Jose, California-based EBay Inc. were upgraded by S&P along with 756 others, compared with 722 downgrades, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. In 2009, S&P slashed corporate debt grades more than three times as often as it raised them, the data show." The article continues: "S&P boosted grades for non-financial issuers 1.5 times as often as it cut them, while Moody’s Investors Service made 1.9 upgrades in those sectors for each downgrade, the ratings companies said." In other words, the crisis is all over according to S&P. Luckily, we all know one thing that the ratings agencies apparently don't: that when it comes to top or bottom ticking the market, there is nobody even in the same ballpark as these two business model relics (both of which only downgraded Ireland after the country became insolvent). Which is why, as the chart below, courtesy of Andrew Yorks, demonstrates, the time to go balls to the wall short credit is now.

Note the uncanny capability of S&P's upgrade/downgrade ratio to be the be the best leading indicator of inflection points in corporate bond returns.

The chart above is all one needs to keep in mind when reading the rest of Bloomberg's article.

About half of non-financial companies upgraded by S&P were rated in the B range and 16 percent were in the CCC or CC tiers, according to a Dec. 15 report from the New York-based firm.

The default rate for speculative-grade borrowers fell to 3.4 percent last month from more than 11 percent a year earlier. It may decline to 2.4 percent by September 2011, S&P said. Moody’s estimated this month that defaults may fall from November’s 3.5 percent rate to 2.1 percent next year.

Investment-grade spreads have contracted 23 basis points to 167 from 190 at the end of 2009, according to the Bank of America Merrill Lynch U.S. Corporate Master index. Companies will find it more difficult to improve their creditworthiness after cutting costs and taking advantage of investor demand for their debt to extend maturities, Diane Vazza, head of global fixed income at S&P, said in the report.

“We expect only modest revenue growth in 2011 and that margins will be flat to slightly down,” wrote Vazza, who didn’t return a telephone call seeking elaboration. “To this end, we would expect upgrades to slow in 2011 but downgrades to remain muted.”

Moody’s increased corporate debt ratings 742 times across all industries and cut them 847 times, Bloomberg data show. The downgrades include 97 rankings on hybrid securities issued by BB&T Corp., Fifth Third Bancorp and 30 other banks on Feb. 17, Bloomberg data show.

Bondholders may suffer in 2011 as cash-laden companies start tapping their war chests to expand, said John Hawley, a money manager in Des Moines, Iowa who helps oversee $22 billion of investment-grade bonds for Aviva Investors North America.

“If you just look at it from a balance sheet perspective, we’d think we’re pretty close to the top and would not expect it to get better from here,” Hawley said.

EBay, the largest e-commerce marketplace, was raised to A from A- by S&P on March 2. Moody’s followed on Aug. 19, boosting EBay to an equivalent A2. The change followed the company’s “good resilience during the challenging economic environment over the past eighteen months,” Moody’s said in a statement.

Ford’s unsecured debt rating was raised three times by Moody’s in 2011, to Ba3 from Caa1. The Dearborn, Michigan-based automaker, the second-biggest issuer of high-yield corporate bonds this year after Ally Financial Inc., sold $4.5 billion of debt through its Ford Motor Credit Co. unit at yields showing investors were betting it would be upgraded to investment grade.

Bottom line: if Moody's deplorable history of top-ticking the market every single time is any indication, it is high time to go short credit.

h/t @andrewyorks

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
MeTarzanUjane's picture

Yea sure short anything that moves, except metals, right? RIGHT ALICE?!

I get my trading inspirations from Bloomberg

JohnG's picture

Please read the first bullet point and reconsider if you should post here again.

jeff montanye's picture

thanks.  never read it before.  moves me to mention why i use my real name (perhaps foolishly).  until i retired for the third time, i hope for keeps, i always felt oppressed by employers or employers to be regarding outside expression of opinion.  now, not so much.  it's like skinny dipping, a bit: scary but liberating.

bigredmachine's picture

Lighten up, and Bang Da Hoe, Bitch

johnnymustardseed's picture

Tonight the JP Morgue will beat down the PM's. They think Asia is a market that they can control.... Me thinks the Bloomberg is smoking the hoochie dingus  

emsolý's picture

When of course everyone knows Bang What's-his-name controls Asia, not the JP Morgue...

Sudden Debt's picture

shorting now is still to expensive. Better wait till after 1 jan. when all puts drop a few cents. A week won't matter.

On the other hand, I'm shorting nothing!

I'm going to liquidate my last shares and options and warrants before Friday and keep the cash.

This whole trading thing these last few years have almost given me a ulcer! I'm going to quit it for about 6 months.

PigsOnTheWing's picture

This would all make so much more sense if S&P and Moody's were US government agencies headed by Mike Brown.

hugovanderbubble's picture

Very interesting asset idea, thx for sharing

gwar5's picture

The rating agencies are run by Bernie Madoff relatives

RunningMan's picture

Would be interesting to see this chart going even further back, and against the S&P index. I always got the impression that ratings always went up, although on further reflection, the ratings just usually sit at (unrealistically) high levels, relative to true risk. Thus, the weighting of action to downgrade, versus upgrade. 

One thing this does tell us is that the ratings agencies are declaring this crisis over by and large, if the comparison to the last technical recession plays out in a similar fashion.

M.B. Drapier's picture

So does this mean that the Irish economy and banks are about to rocket back? I'm guessing 'no'.

PD Quig's picture

Maybe S&P and Moody's think that we think that they think that we think that they think that we think things are getting better. All you need to do is plug this into your model. And then follow the trend, tighten stops, and shut out all the noise that has kept people from making money over the past two years.

"Buy the fucking dip you fucking idiot," gets the award for the best advice since March 9, 2009