Euro Plunges On Dovish Trichet Comments, Says ECB Has Credibility Because Hiked First (What Does That Leave For The Chairsatan?)

Tyler Durden's picture

Trichet says:

  • CPI rates likely to stay above 2% in coming months
  • Risks on economy from Japan disaster
  • Geopolitical tensions pose growth risks
  • Paramount that rise in HICP inflation does not lead to second-round effects
  • Risks to medium term inflation outlook are on upside
  • Inflation expectations must remain firmly anchored
  • Monetary analysis indicates underlying pace of monetary expansion picking up but moderate
  • Confirm banks have continued to expand lending to private sector
  • Governments need to achieve their fiscal consolidation targets in 2011

Most importantly: he says nothing about a June hike which was largely "priced in" by the Wall Street lemmingraty.

From the Q&A:

  • Will not comment on the market, but the ECB can delivery price stability in the medium run
  • Can increase rates whenever judge appropriate to do that
  • Incorporate the EURUSD FX rate in the ECB's analysis, have noted that on April 26 Geither said "our policy has been that a strong dollar is in our interests as a country, will never embrace strategy of weakening our currency at the expense of our trading partners"
  • No response on whether the ECB will resume or cut bond purchases
  • Says as to credibility was first Central Bank to increase rates
  • What has changed in inflation picture? Money markets have hit a brick wall: are they improving? - Not changing attitude regarding inflation - continue to monitor developments to upside price stability. Will always do what is necessary to deliver price stability. 
  • Progressively looking at more appropriate function of the money market which is visible in the positioning of the EONIA. If EONIA vol is less pronounced than before it would be good. Liquidity situation of overall banks is normal.
  • W/R/T Portugal will expect that all countries live up to their responsibility.
  • Responds: 'I don't think we have a policy of normalisation'
  • Question of the day: "Do banks that are not raising rates have a credibility problem" FTW
  • Do you think Portugal will be available to come back to market any time? Did not work with Greece. Also, on normalization there are those on the ECB who do use the term. Answer: Not sure who you are alluding to in the governing councel. Must be semantics. On Portugal believe the program contains elements to stabilize the economy.
  • Will ECB need more capital from regional banks? Have no new decision in the pipe.
  • Greek Restructuring is not in the cards.
  • Will EFSF be fully activated regardless of Finnish stance? Why should Finnish taxpayers guarantee funding for portugal? In contribution of Eurobodies must consider that EFSF and EFSM both must contribute one third each of the bailout package. We as governing counsel are calling all countries to be "up to their responsibility in the circusmtance." [sic] 
  • People don't seem to think Irish bailout package is working. Does ECB think it is working? ECB has a plan approved by the international community which is being implement by the government. We share the view that Irish bailout is Credible.The level of commitment by Eurosystem to Ireland has no precedent .
  • What would level of losses be to ECB if there is an event of restructuring? Answer: "It's not a problem" [laughter in the room]
  • Have not bought government bonds for a number of weeks, why? "We are transparent" Does it concern you that you can no longer sterilize your bond purchases? My understanding is that we are back in an episode where market is working better than usual, where banks are asking for less liquidity. [How that is an answer to the question is beyond even sarcasm]

Net result is this, just as predicted earlier:

And the pain continues as of 9:08 am Eastern:

Full prepared comments:

Jean-Claude Trichet, President of the ECB, Vítor Constâncio, Vice-President of the ECB, Helsinki, 5 May 2011

Ladies and gentlemen, the Vice-President and I are very pleased to
welcome you to our press conference here in Helsinki. I would like to
thank Governor Liikanen for his kind hospitality and express our special
gratitude to his staff for the excellent organisation of today’s
meeting of the Governing Council. We will now report on the outcome of
the meeting, which was also attended by Commissioner Rehn.

Based on its regular economic and monetary analyses, the Governing Council decided to keep the
key ECB interest rates unchanged following the 25-basis
point increase on 7 April 2011. The information that has become
available since then confirms our assessment that an adjustment of the
very accommodative monetary policy stance was warranted. We continue to
see upward pressure on overall inflation, mainly owing to energy and
commodity prices. While the monetary analysis indicates that the
underlying pace of monetary expansion is still moderate, monetary
liquidity remains ample and may facilitate the accommodation of price
pressures. Furthermore, recent economic data confirm the positive
underlying momentum of economic activity in the euro area, with
uncertainty continuing to be elevated. All in all, it is essential that
recent price developments do not give rise to broad-based inflationary
pressures. Inflation expectations in the euro area must remain firmly
anchored in line with our aim of maintaining inflation rates below, but
close to, 2% over the medium term. Such anchoring is a prerequisite for
monetary policy to make an ongoing contribution towards supporting
economic growth and job creation in the euro area. With interest rates
across the entire maturity spectrum remaining low and the monetary
policy stance still accommodative, we will continue to monitor very
closely all developments with respect to upside risks to price
stability. Maintaining price stability over the medium term is our
guiding principle, which we apply when assessing new information,
forming our judgements and deciding on any further adjustment of the
accommodative stance of monetary policy.

As stated on previous occasions, the provision of liquidity and the
allotment modes for refinancing operations will also be adjusted when
appropriate, taking into account the fact that all the non-standard
measures taken during the period of acute financial market tensions are,
by construction, temporary in nature.

Let me now explain our assessment in greater detail, starting with the
economic analysis. Following the 0.3%
quarter-on-quarter increase in euro area real GDP in the fourth quarter
of 2010, recent statistical releases and survey-based indicators point
towards a continued positive underlying momentum of economic activity in
the euro area during the first quarter of 2011 and at the beginning of
the second quarter. Looking ahead, euro area exports should be supported
by the ongoing expansion in the world economy. At the same time, taking
into account the high level of business confidence in the euro area,
private sector domestic demand should contribute increasingly to
economic growth, benefiting from the accommodative monetary policy
stance and the measures adopted to improve the functioning of the
financial system. However, activity is expected to continue to be
dampened somewhat by the process of balance sheet adjustment in various
sectors.

In the Governing Council’s assessment, the risks to this economic
outlook remain broadly balanced in an environment of elevated
uncertainty. On the one hand, global trade may continue to grow more
rapidly than expected, thereby supporting euro area exports. Moreover,
strong business confidence could provide more support to domestic
economic activity in the euro area than currently expected. On the other
hand, downside risks relate to the ongoing tensions in some segments of
the financial markets that may potentially spill over to the euro area
real economy. Downside risks also relate to further increases in energy
prices, particularly in view of ongoing geopolitical tensions in North
Africa and the Middle East, and to protectionist pressures and the
possibility of a disorderly correction of global imbalances. Finally,
there are still potential risks stemming from the economic impact on the
euro area and elsewhere of the natural and nuclear disasters in Japan.

With regard to price developments, euro area annual HICP inflation
was 2.8% in April according to Eurostat’s flash estimate, after 2.7% in
March. The increase in inflation rates during the first four months of
2011 largely reflects higher commodity prices. Looking ahead, inflation
rates are likely to stay clearly above 2% over the coming months. Upward
pressure on inflation, mainly from energy and commodity prices, is also
discernible in the earlier stages of the production process. It is of
paramount importance that the rise in HICP inflation does not translate
into second-round effects in price and wage-setting behaviour and lead
to broad-based inflationary pressures. Inflation expectations must
remain firmly anchored in line with the Governing Council’s aim of
maintaining inflation rates below, but close to, 2% over the medium
term.

Risks to the medium-term outlook for price developments remain on the
upside. They relate, in particular, to higher than assumed increases in
energy prices, not least on account of the ongoing political tensions
in North Africa and the Middle East. More generally, strong economic
growth in emerging markets, supported by ample liquidity at the global
level, may further fuel commodity price rises. Moreover, increases in
indirect taxes and administered prices may be greater than currently
assumed, owing to the need for fiscal consolidation in the coming years.
Finally, risks also relate to stronger than expected domestic price
pressures in the context of the ongoing recovery in activity.

Turning to the
monetary analysis, the annual growth rate of M3
increased to 2.3% in March 2011, from 2.1% in February. Looking through
the recent volatility in broad money growth caused by special factors,
M3 growth has continued to edge up over recent months. The annual growth
rate of loans to the private sector remained broadly unchanged at 2.5%
in March, after 2.6% in February. Overall, the underlying pace of
monetary expansion is gradually picking up, but it remains moderate. At
the same time, monetary liquidity accumulated prior to the period of
financial market tensions remains ample and may facilitate the
accommodation of price pressures in the euro area.

Looking at M3 components, the annual growth rate of M1 remained
broadly unchanged in March, while that of other short-term deposits
increased. The development partly reflects the gradual increase in the
remuneration of these deposits over recent months. At the same time, the
steep yield curve implies a dampening impact on overall M3 growth, as
it reduces the attractiveness of monetary assets compared with more
highly remunerated longer-term instruments outside M3.

On the counterpart side, there has been a further slight
strengthening in the growth of loans to non-financial corporations,
which rose to 0.8% in March, after 0.6% in February. The growth of loans
to households was 3.4% in March, compared with 3.0% in February.
Looking through short-term volatility, the latest data confirm a
continued gradual strengthening in the annual growth of lending to the
non-financial private sector.

The overall size of bank balance sheets has remained broadly
unchanged over the past few months, notwithstanding some volatility. It
is important that banks continue to expand the provision of credit to
the private sector in an environment of increasing demand. To address
this challenge, where necessary, it is essential for banks to retain
earnings, to turn to the market to strengthen further their capital
bases or to take full advantage of government support measures for
recapitalisation. In particular, banks that currently have limited
access to market financing urgently need to increase their capital and
their efficiency.

To sum up, based on its regular economic and monetary analyses, the
Governing Council decided to keep the key ECB interest rates unchanged
following the 25-basis point increase on 7 April 2011. The information
that has become available since then confirms our assessment that an
adjustment of the very accommodative monetary policy stance was
warranted. We continue to see upward pressure on overall inflation,
mainly owing to energy and commodity prices. A
cross-check with the signals coming from our monetary
analysis indicates that, while the underlying pace of monetary expansion
is still moderate, monetary liquidity remains ample and may facilitate
the accommodation of price pressures. Furthermore, recent economic data
confirm the positive underlying momentum of economic activity in the
euro area, with uncertainty continuing to be elevated. All in all, it is
essential that recent price developments do not give rise to
broad-based inflationary pressures. Inflation expectations in the euro
area must remain firmly anchored in line with our aim of maintaining
inflation rates below, but close to, 2% over the medium term. Such
anchoring is a prerequisite for monetary policy to make an ongoing
contribution towards supporting economic growth and job creation in the
euro area. With interest rates across the entire maturity spectrum
remaining low and the monetary policy stance still accommodative, we
will continue to monitor very closely all developments with respect to
upside risks to price stability. Maintaining price stability over the
medium term is our guiding principle, which we apply when assessing new
information, forming our judgements and deciding on any further
adjustment of the accommodative stance of monetary policy.

Turning to
fiscal policies, current information points to uneven
developments in countries’ adherence to the agreed fiscal consolidation
plans. There is a risk that, in some countries, fiscal balances may fall
behind the targets agreed by the ECOFIN Council for the necessary and
timely correction of excessive deficits. It is essential that all
governments meet the fiscal balance targets for 2011 that they have
announced. Where necessary, additional corrective measures must be
implemented swiftly to ensure progress in achieving fiscal
sustainability. The implementation of credible policies is crucial in
view of ongoing financial market pressures.

At the same time, it is of the utmost importance that substantial and far-reaching
structural reforms be implemented urgently in the euro
area in order to strengthen its growth potential, competitiveness and
flexibility. In particular, countries which have high fiscal and
external deficits or which are suffering from a loss of competitiveness
should embark on comprehensive economic reforms. In the case of product
markets, policies that enhance competition and innovation should, in
particular, be further pursued to speed up restructuring and to bring
about improvements in productivity. Regarding the labour market, the
priority must be to enhance wage flexibility and incentives to work, and
to remove labour market rigidities.

The Governing Council, in line with the ECB’s opinion of 17 February
2011 on the six legislative proposals on economic governance, urges the
ECOFIN Council, the European Parliament and the European Commission to
agree, in the context of their “trialogue”, on more stringent
requirements, more automaticity in the procedures and a clearer focus on
the most vulnerable countries with losses in competitiveness.

Finally, the Governing Council welcomes the economic and financial
adjustment programme which was agreed by the Portuguese government
following the successful conclusion of the negotiations with the
European Commission, in liaison with the ECB, and the International
Monetary Fund.

The programme contains the necessary elements to bring about a
sustainable stabilisation of the Portuguese economy. It addresses in a
decisive manner the economic and financial causes underlying current
market concerns and will thereby contribute to restoring confidence and
safeguarding financial stability in the euro area.

The Governing Council welcomes the commitment of the Portuguese
public authorities to take all the necessary measures to achieve the
objectives of the programme. It considers very important the broad
political support for the adjustment programme, which enhances the
overall credibility of the programme.

We are now at your disposal for questions.