This page has been archived and commenting is disabled.

First Official Complaint Filed To DOJ-Anti Trust Over JPM's Role In Silver Manipulation Case

Tyler Durden's picture


Someone had to do it. So we applaud Jason Hommel of Silver Stock Report for submitting the first official complaint to the United States Department of Justice over the recent revalations of unprecedented manipulation and fraud in the silver (and gold) market.

Citizen Complaint Center
Antitrust Division
950 Pennsylvania Ave., NW
Room 3322
Washington, DC 20530

Re: Reporting Antitrust Concerns

Step 1: Fully Describe Your Concern

1.  What are the names of companies, individuals, or organizations that are involved?

CFTC, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, is withholding the
names, with the excuse given that they cannot reveal the names, because
of statute. But, a statute, which may violate other laws, is no excuse
for obstruction of justice, dereliction of duty, misprison of fraud, or
conspiracy to defraud the United States. 

The COMEX, owned by
the CME Group, also has the data on who is primarily involved, as the
antitrust violaters trade on their exchange.

JPMorgan Chase & Co. has
been named by thousands of writers in the private sector, all over the
internet, based on the reports of the BIS, the Bank of International
Settlements and the OCC, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency
at the US Treasury, that they manipulate the precious metals markets by
fraudulently selling metal that does not exist.  This Bank report
indicates that JPMorgan Chase & Co. is heavily involved, far more than any other, in derivatives, exceeding $72 trillion. 

JPMorgan Chase & Co.
270 Park Avenue
New York, NY 10017


How do you believe they have violated the federal antitrust laws? (For
details on federal antitrust laws, see Antitrust Laws and You.)

RE:  Sherman Antitrust Act
This Act expresses our national commitment to a free market economy
in which competition free from private and governmental restraints
leads to the best results for consumers. This Act outlaws all
contracts, combinations, and conspiracies that unreasonably restrain
interstate and foreign trade. This includes agreements among
competitors to fix prices, rig bids, and allocate customers, which are punishable as criminal felonies.

JPMorgan Chase & Co. holds
a large, concentrated, short position in silver futures contracts at
the COMEX that allows them to unreasonably fix prices for silver lower
than they should be, which resulted in widespread shortages of retail
bullion, and 1000 oz. silver bars, over several months in 2008, at
which time, I became a bullion dealer to help relieve the shortages
caused by this price manipulation.  I had to wait up to 5 weeks for
delivery of 1000 oz. bars from one of the world's largest wholesale
suppliers at the time.

It has been estimated that JPMorgan Chase & Co. has
held up to, and over, 90% of the commercial short interest in silver
futures contracts, essentially dumping silver on the market, silver
that does not exist, in an attempt to contain, thwart, suppress, and
manipulate the price of silver lower than it should be, and otherwise
would be.

RE:  The Sherman Act also makes it a crime to
monopolize any part of interstate commerce. An unlawful monopoly exists
when only one firm controls the market for a product or service, and it
has obtained that market power, not because its product or service is superior to others, but by suppressing competition with anticompetitive conduct.

silver prices are monopolized by this price manipulation that takes
place at the COMEX, and also in the London market, which is even more
heavily leveraged due to excessive selling of silver on paper that does
not exist in the real world.  Their primary product, "silver on paper"
is clearly inferior to real silver, in that the key difference is that
real silver does not depend upon the financial solvency of JPMorgan Chase & Co. for its value; and paper silver will lose all value if JPMorgan Chase & Co. goes
bankrupt.  Competition for real silver as an asset is suppressed by
their choice to sell paper silver at a discount to the costs of
delivering real physical silver, which must include shipping,
manufacturing, and mining costs.  Other popular forms of silver for
investment, such as 100 oz. bars, and 10 oz. bars, and 1 oz. rounds
also include manufacturing costs, which are also not included in their
"paper silver" investment products, such as the ETF, SLV, futures
contracts at COMEX, options on futures contracts at COMEX, and the
standard LBMA "unsecured bullion accounts".

RE: The Clayton Act
    This Act is a civil statute (carrying no criminal penalties) that prohibits mergers or acquisitions that are likely to lessen competition. Under this Act, the government challenges those mergers that careful economic analysis shows are likely to increase prices to consumers.
All persons considering a merger or acquisition above a certain size
must notify both the Antitrust Division and the Federal Trade
Commission. The Act also prohibits other business practices that may harm competition under certain circumstances.

The Clayton Act was likely violated when JPMorgan Chase & Co. acquired Bear Stearns, and inherited their short position in silver, giving JPMorgan Chase & Co. even
more control over silver market prices, due to their even larger and
more concentrated short position.  "Higher prices for consumers" is a
result if the consumers are silver investors, and if they lose the
value of their silver, and thus, have to pay relatively higher prices
for everything else in the economy as a result.

The Department of Justice also often uses other laws to fight illegal activities, including laws that
prohibit false statements to federal agencies, perjury, obstruction of
justice, conspiracies to defraud the United States and mail and wire

BIS, the Bank of International Settlements indicates that the notional
value of "other precious metals" (silver) in the "over the counter"
category increased to $203 billion by June of 2009.

the entire world's annual production of silver, at about 600 million
oz., at $17/oz., is barely $10 billion, which is a mere 1/20th of the
amount owed in these bullion accounts, which are dominated by JP
Morgan.  But the $203 billion of mostly silver, is 12 billion ounces of
silver, which is 24 times world annual production, and perhaps 100 to
160 times the actual supply of physical silver held in London for
delivery against such accounts, which may be as little as 75 million
ounces or less.

JPMorgan Chase & Co. is
also the custodian of the ETF, SLV, which is supposed to have up to 300
million ounces held by JP Morgan, which is also likely not there.

JPMorgan Chase & Co. is
thus likely engaged in a Ponzi scheme of selling silver to clients,
without actually purchasing the real physical silver in the
marketplace, which is a totally fraudulent and illegal activity.

JPMorgan Chase & Co. is likely engaged in sending false brokerage statements to account holders of unsecured bullion accounts, and thus, is likely engaged in both mail fraud and wire fraud. 

JPMorgan Chase & Co. is likely engaged in defrauding the United States Government
by manipulating silver prices low, by selling excessive amounts of
"paper silver", which creates the false illusion of abundance of
silver, which creates the illusion of a false sense of availability of
silver, which is likely needed by the Department of Defense for the
national security of the United States, as silver is vital and
necessary element for the defense industry.


Can you give examples of the conduct that you believe violates the
antitrust laws? If so, please provide as much detail as possible.

Yes.  Andrew Maguire, a silver trader, who knows the silver traders who work for JPMorgan Chase & Co., testified to GATA, and to the CFTC in the recent hearing on March 25th, 2010. 

A London trader walks the CFTC through a silver manipulation in advance
By: Bill Murphy, Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee

provides detailed, blow by blow acts of price manipulation, giving
specifics, in real time, through emails to the CFTC about the
manipulation in progress.  His report is highly detailed.


What is the product or service affected by this conduct? Where is the
product manufactured or sold, or where is the service provided?

question.  The product is silver.  Real silver is sold through
approximately 4000 coin shops nationwide in the USA.  A low,
manipulated price, hurts and suppresses the business volumes of those
businesses.  Even more directly, a low silver price hurts the worldwide
industry of silver mining.  Most silver, about 75% is produced as a
by-product of copper, lead, and zinc mining.  And many primary silver
mines produce gold, copper, lead, and zinc as by-products.  Thus, a low
silver price that suppresses silver mining also restricts the supplies
of gold, copper, lead, and zinc, which leads to higher prices for all
of those other commodities than would otherwise be the case.  The world
could have more abundant, and thus cheaper, gold, copper, lead, and
zinc, which are desperately needed for the continued industrialization
of the entire world, if it were not for the silver price suppression
manipulation scheme in progress.

is primarily produced in North and South America, so this is a direct
assault on a large section of the world's economy, which is, of course,
a much smaller industry as a result.


5.  Who are the major competitors that sell the product or provide the service?

largest refiner of silver in the world is likely Penoles of Mexico, who
may refine about 70 million ounces of silver per year, over 10% of the
world's supply.  The second largest source is likely the Cannington
silver mine owned by BHP Billiton, which produces about 30-40 million
ounces of silver per year.  The largest silver refiner in the USA is
Johnson-Matthey, who also might have been engaged in illegal allocation
of 100 oz. silver bars back in 2008, as their primary retailer had a
wait list of over 2 months for delivery in 2008 as a result of their
complicit actions in the price fixing scheme.  They refused to allocate
silver to the highest bidder at the time.  At that time, I helped
pioneer the development of a silver auction website, with the owner of, who created, which sold over 10,000 oz.
of silver per day to the highest bidder for a few days during a time of
a national and worldwide silver shortage that resulted from the illegal
price fixing.


6.  What is your role in the situation in question?

very good question.  I invested in silver, starting in 1998.  I have
been advocating silver as an investment since then, as can be seen at, which also has an email newsletter that reaches
out to 80,000 readers.  The price manipulation has negatively impacted
the success of my own investment choice, and the investments of
hundreds of thousands of other people around the world.  I have been
working to expose this manipulation since 2002, as I wrote, and spent
over $500,000 to publicize, articles such as:

The Moral Failures of the Paper Longs Jan 22, 2003
CFTC Response to Silver Problem Jan 14, 2003
People Talking About $32,567/oz Jan 10, 2003
Letter To Authorities of Silver Markets Jan 6, 2003
Why no talk of $32,567/oz ? Jan 2, 2003
Refuting Myths about Gold Oct 28, 2002
Controlling Gold with Paper June 10, 2002
Impending Gold Futures Default May 29, 2002

7.  Who is harmed by the alleged violations? How are they harmed?

As I have said, silver investors who need to sell their silver for their retirement are primarily the ones harmed.  But also, silver mining is suppressed,
which hurts companies working to develop technology to explore for
silver.  It hurts engineers and builder who develop mines.  It hurts
and restricts the production of silver byproducts, which raises the
prices for gold, copper, zinc, and lead, which restricts industrial development worldwide

But primarily, it will catastrophically hurt holders of American dollars in the future,
as they are currently being lulled into a false sense of security about
the false and fraudulent value of US Dollars, or more accurately,
Federal Reserve Notes, which stand to lose value rapidly as the fraud
of selling silver that does not exist gets exposed.

the silver fraud is a small part of the Ponzi Scheme on which rests the
much larger Ponzi scheme of the US Dollar itself, a $14-16 Trillion
fraud, and also, the much larger US Bond market, which may exceed
$30-40 trillion.  Further, the $70 Trillion "interest rate derivative"
fraud is also supported by silver price manipulation. 
Inflation-indexed bonds are also sold as a competing investment to
silver, and so, by hurting the silver price, or by making the silver
price seem dangerously volatile by way of direct price manipulation, JPMorgan Chase & Co. supports its entire mountain of paper investment products, which it clearly dominates in world trade.

silver price suppression scheme, and the resulting failure of paper
money, and the resulting collapse of commerce and world trade risks
sending the entire world into a severe depression that risks famine on
a world scale unlike what has ever been seen before in world history,
and could therefore cause the direct deaths of anywhere up to a third of all humans on earth, or even more.

pause now, and reflect on that for a moment.  You may wish to consider
and ask yourself if you want that on your conscience, or if you want to
be blamed for that, by God himself, in the eternal reckoning that must
come due for all men, if you decide to do nothing to stop the fraud on
progress, that could potentially cause so much devastation.


For more information, please see the following articles, or excerpts:

The Silver Boom Is Coming!
by Richard Daughty
April 6, 2010

Key Excerpt:
Nielson, writing in the James Cook Market Update newsletter, who says
that because silver kills the bacteria that causes body odor, “the use
of silver in sportswear has exploded into one of the largest single
applications of silver. This one usage already consumes more than 1,200
TONS of silver per year.”

1200 tonnes x 32,151 oz./tonne = 38,581,200 oz.


Silver Short Squeeze Could Be Imminent
April 3, 2010

Key Excerpt:
believes the precious metals markets are currently being artificially
suppressed by paper gold and silver that doesn't physically exist. At
last week's CFTC hearings, Jeffrey Christian of the CPM Group admitted
that banks have leveraged their physical bullion by 100 to 1. This
means for every 100 ounces of paper gold/silver that trade, there could
be as little as 1 ounce of physical gold/silver in the vaults backing
it. However, Mr. Christian sees no problem with this because he says
"it has been persistently that way for decades" and there are "any
number of mechanisms allowing for cash settlements".


Kingdom Economics Blog: Biggest Fraud in History Exposed
FED and JP Morgan Chase appear to be manipulating Gold/Silver Market

Key Excerpt:
does this mean for the future price of gold and silver? Now that this
fraud on the market has been exposed for what it is -- traders will
eventually call the bluff of the manipulators and expose their naked
short position. This could mean that the manipulators will need to find
physical gold and/or silver to cover their position. And with these
metals now being in short supply (relative to demand) we could see the
PRICE of silver and gold increase dramatically in the next few months.
Silver is currently at $17.97/ounce and gold is $1128.80.

would not be surprised to see silver exceed $25 by the end of 2010 and
gold exceed $1500. And this may be just the start of the increases in
price for these metals. What we have today is psychological money and
it moves globally with the emotions of traders. Prices are artificial
(imaginary) and the market is very volatile and emotional today. Except
some ‘fireworks’ in the silver/gold markets in the near future. See
this web site for more details on this issue:


Will fraud lift gold prices to $10,000/ounce?
April 03, 2010$10000ounce-27107-3-1.html

Key Excerpt:
fact, there is no gold left in this world if all the Gold ETFs ask for
physical delivery. And, if that happens only god knows what will be the
gold prices in the coming months — $10000 per ounce? Maybe, even more.
Because, price of a commodity which is not available at all can go up
to any level due to the sheer fact that it is not there in the market.

read about the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) hearing last
week about a London whistle-blower who had explained to the CFTC how JP
Morgan Chase has been manipulating/capping precious metal prices. In a
shocking parallel to the inaction by the US Securities and Exchange
Commission (SEC) after receiving warnings from Harry Markopolos about
the Madoff ponzi, the CFTC has apparently been sitting on the
information on gold cartels.

you visit the websites of GATA and CFTC this week? If you do, you can
see a lot of articles and responses from investors who have been keenly
watching the developments in bullion market.


Gold, Silver, the CFTC & Conspiracy Theories
April 2, 2010

Key Excerpt:
if you read the Wall Street Journal, you’ll never know what happened at
the hearing and whether the CFTC paid any attention to them, but, if
you look elsewhere, you’ll read about all kinds of interesting
developments during and after the meeting.

Here’s a partial list:

GATA’s evidence of silver and gold manipulation at CFTC hearing – Mineweb
CFTC Gets Facts of Bullion Manipulation – Numismaster
JP Morgan Chase Caught Manipulating Gold & Silver Market – Firedog Lake
Whistleblower Speaks Out On JP Morgan Market Manipulation – Jesse’s Cafe
Former Goldman Analyst Confirms LMBA Gold Market Is “Paper Gold” Ponzi – Zero Hedge
Whistleblower in Silver Manipulation Struck by Hit and Run Car In London – Jesse’s Cafe
King World Interview with Andrew Maguire the Silver Market ‘Whistleblower’ – Jesse’s Cafe
King Interview With GATA On The Biggest Gold Manipulation Story Disclosed – Zero Hedge


Perhaps we all ought to submit this story to ?

again, they are about as likely to expose this story as the Russian
media was about to expose communism in government.  What's ironic is
that pravda is more likely to cover this story than the mainstream US



- advertisements -

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Fri, 04/09/2010 - 01:20 | 292679 Number 156
Number 156's picture

That will go nowhere fast.

Btw, all you gold bugs out there who are holding gold on paper, sell your paper NOW.

If you want to wait for delivery of real gold, you may already be too late.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 18:03 | 292869 swamp
swamp's picture

Ass kicking complaint.

It needs to go world wide viral like the GATA CFTC video.

If, like you say, it goes nowhere (in terms of DOJ action) then the conspiracy of JP MOrgan (and Goldman Sachs — too big to fail crappers) with government is further cemented while outright corruption is exposed and faith in the USA and USD erodes at a faster pace.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 08:44 | 292919 john_connor
john_connor's picture

156, you beat me to the punch.  Anyone who is holding PM's in paper ETF's or funds should demand delivery or sell NOW, like today.  It would be very ironic if you were right all along except that paper shares were just a part of the fiat bonfire.

Sell the paper, buy physical, and set up security measures around your home as needed. 

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 18:20 | 293771 Number 156
Number 156's picture

Fiat indeed, and who can afford to find out the hard way that the paper belongs on a roll next to the toilet seat.

Dump GLD and SLV ETFs, like right now and get PHYSICAL.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 16:59 | 293647 dlmaniac
dlmaniac's picture

Hats off to Mr. Homme.


Fri, 04/09/2010 - 01:22 | 292685 Nolsgrad
Nolsgrad's picture

long silver vs. gold here. gonna decimate all you gold bugs.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 01:25 | 292687 Number 156
Number 156's picture

You better have physical silver though. We'll be wiping our asses with the paper.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 01:34 | 292691 Nolsgrad
Nolsgrad's picture

all physical, bring it!

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 11:26 | 293215 Missing_Link
Missing_Link's picture

Mithril, bitches!

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 01:52 | 292704 Spitzer
Spitzer's picture

Bullshit, silver has too much industrail use, gold will do better in a depression.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:21 | 292726 CitizenPete
CitizenPete's picture

I thought we were in a depression?  How's that Au bullion a tastin?  like "Chikin"?

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:55 | 292887 duo
duo's picture

FRNs don't taste very good at all, but at least they have fiber.


1 oz copper coins could be our future $1-2 bill

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:34 | 292871 swamp
swamp's picture

I know what you mean in terms of pure monetary value, however, gold will be too expensive to use even in fractions of one ounce for small time items, availability will be narrow, and silver is a good "poor man's gold" substitute (sorry silver lovers).

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 10:38 | 293120 FEDbuster
FEDbuster's picture

Even at current levels ($1150) the value of gold is too high for most barter transactions.  How often do you go out an spend $1150. on a single transaction?  Siver at about $18. makes more sense for barter, better yet pre 1964 coins like a quarter is worth about $3. now.  Nickels are worth more than five cents (save your nickels).

The gold:silver ratio should tighten in the next few years, with silver prices rising faster than gold on a percentage basis.  Once the silver fraud and manipulation is well known, silver should take off.  David Morgan says that once silver breaks through the $25. level, it could go to $50.+ very quickly.

When gold goes to $2K+ and silver is $50+, the world is going to be screwed up much worse than today.  Now is the time to really prepare for that.  A good place to start is .  Hang on tight this rollercoaster ride is just getting started.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 09:27 | 292985 Marzen
Marzen's picture

how better? I find comments like this funny.

Anyways...physical on Both Silver and Gold!!!!

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 10:53 | 293149 Hulk
Hulk's picture

Same here. Most of us "goldbugs"

are "silverbugs " too

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 01:27 | 292688 mattco
mattco's picture

Someone just wasted a few hours of their time. You get an "A" for effort but a "F" for thinking that anyone at the USJD will read it. Also realize that JPM is basically an arm of the Fed and are most likely doing their work for them. But it was fun to read. Thanks.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:09 | 292715 digalert
digalert's picture

Isn't Obamas man Holder the top justice guy? yep

We know where this is going...

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 04:40 | 292814 gratefultraveller
gratefultraveller's picture

Well, as Karl Denninger once remarked about his activity, this is not necessarily about obtaining any results immediately, but rather to document the ongoing fraud *on the record* to make sure none of the involved can later claim that they were not aware of it, in case there should ever be a serious investigation.

As an efficient official investigation would presume the existence of a functioning society, I am not too optimistic about the chances of this ever to happen, though.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:35 | 292870 MarketTruth
MarketTruth's picture

So exactly how many official complaints has Denninger filed? With his whining and chart 'proof' almost daily and whatnot, you'd think he would have filed at least 50 official complaints by now.

So how many has Denninger filed... or is he all talk and no action?

The again it seems he has no belief in hard currency or the obvious and constant proof of manipulation so justice may be served his way one day. Sometimes even the obvious proof blinds people who want to protect the currupt system they hold too dear to their heart.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:37 | 292872 swamp
swamp's picture

The complaint sets the facts, the groundwork, the exposure to the world, and beautifully sets up DOJ as corrupt if they fail to act. It reveals the magnitude of the paper game and is GREAT information for all investors. Look at those numbers!!! whooooo hoooooo

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 11:07 | 293173 umop episdn
umop episdn's picture

Yes. The fact that this complaint was filed will be considered newsworthy, just not by the LameStreamMedia that most 'Merkins are likely to read/watch. The LSM doesn't control the whole world...and the whole world needs to keep accepting the Feral Reserve Notes or the Ponzi scheme starts to blow up. Just a matter of time, in my opinion...

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 01:39 | 292695 LeBalance
LeBalance's picture

All pissing in the wind gets you is wet and needing a bath.

But pissing in the wind in court costs you untold time and money as well.

Play the chess game, realise the course, and walk away.  Change the channel and don't play their illusion.

LOL, like you have a chance in front of JPM's judge and JPM's law? /ouch!!!/

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 08:54 | 292935 ToNYC
ToNYC's picture

Whining about court costs, changing the channel, walking away,fear of the time spent before corrupted judges; this is not the courage our founding patriots demonstrated when they took the time out from their busy lives to show up in Lexington and Concord on April 19, 1775

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 01:51 | 292703 Segestan
Segestan's picture

Ya Jason deserves an big applaud for at least setting an documented legal example of metals fraud. Now the real fraud will begin... by the denial of justice.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 01:56 | 292707 Blackpearl
Blackpearl's picture

That's what I call a worthless noble cause......



Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:02 | 292712 Rick64
Rick64's picture

I understand the cynicism, but at least he is doing something which might turn into sombody else stepping up. If the momentum gathers speed it might become something they can't ignore.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:53 | 292742 Cookie
Cookie's picture


Fri, 04/09/2010 - 06:40 | 292853 Rusty_Shackleford
Rusty_Shackleford's picture

Well said.


I think he did a nice job. 


Kudos to you Jason.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:41 | 292877 swamp
swamp's picture

Other world players must be salivating at this information.

People thought GATA was fringe too, and look at the impact Murphy's testimony has had already in just one week — all without "official" government action. 


Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:09 | 292716 TroyMcClureRIP
TroyMcClureRIP's picture

What are some of the best channels to utilize to buy physical gold? 



Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:12 | 292719 Shameful
Shameful's picture

Tulving is the best for price and shipping, big minimum orders.  CNI and APMEX are both good too.  Have used all 3 and been happy.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:32 | 292730 TroyMcClureRIP
TroyMcClureRIP's picture


Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:38 | 292875 MarketTruth
MarketTruth's picture

Have been at this for MANY years....

#1 Tulving (high min to buy, best deal and fast delivery)

#2 Gainesville Coin (best price lower mins, fast delivery)

#3 CNI or Apmex (slower delivery, higher spreads yet they do deliver)

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 10:39 | 293128 Pure Evil
Pure Evil's picture

Great tips from both of ya!

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:10 | 292717 JX
JX's picture


Kinda wish GATA would've done this first. 


Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:17 | 292718 CitizenPete
CitizenPete's picture

Who would have ever guessed that Jason Hommel would have been the first to officially file?    he he he 

That durn "mightier than the sword" pen agin!   Outside the Matrix in the real world, the landless peasants would open a Sams' Club size case of Whoop-ass on someone.  

I crashed a lecture by Harvey Silverglate at Case Western Law School this week. He lectured on his book, "Three Felonies a Day: How the Feds Target the Innocent. " and he gave examples how the Justice Department "fills the gap" in broadly drafted statutes to obtain any desired result.  "Show me the man, and I will give you the crime."  About halfway through the lecture I came to the realization that one could never store enough ammunition for personal protection from the strong men of our owners -- then decided one would really need a personal squadron of attack helicopters to have half a chance of defending themselves.

I'll bet JPM is just a shakin in their Amedeo Testonis.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:53 | 292740 3ringmike
3ringmike's picture

nobody gets out of this shit house alive

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:38 | 292874 Absinthe Minded
Absinthe Minded's picture

I hope this guy drives an armored car for his commuter.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:54 | 292743 xPat
xPat's picture

GATA's incompetence has been mind-boggling, and it's frustrating to see yet another well-meaning but completely mis-placed effort to do the right thing that will only distract attention from what's important.

Folks, here's what's important:

  • CFTC has a comment period on COMEX position limits open right now, and they appear (just maybe) to actually be listening.
  • JPM has a massive concentrated short in silver futures (Ted Butler's research)
  • Andrew Maguire claims to have compelling evidence that JPM is consciously and intentionally using that short to manipulate the market.

That's really big stuff. What the investment community needs to do is stay focused on what's important. But instead GATA insists on taking Jeff Christian's testimony completely out of context, and using it to form largely baseless allegations of "the fraud of the century" on the LBMA.

What's important is to stay focused on how to effect real change.

CFTC has no regulatory jurisdiction over LBMA. They do have jurisdiction over COMEX. We need to pressure CFTC to take meaningful action within the scope of their authority. That's the opportunity before us right now (comment period still open) and that's where we need to focus our energy.

I'm not saying there's no scandal on the LBMA. There very well may be, although Jeff Christian's testimony in the CFTC hearing certainly doesn't "admit" any such thing in the way the incompetents at GATA keep alleging. But my point is, save LBMA for another day. Thanks to GATA and Eric King, way too many people are confusing way too many issues and writing in to CFTC about "fractional reserve scandals" and "fraud in the London market". Those are not within the scope of CFTC's jurisdiction, and are therefore irrelevant even if true.

All this nonsense about "illegally selling contracts on the COMEX when they don't own the metal" is nonsense. The COMEX is a derivative market and there's nothing wrong with selling what you don't own there. It's legal. But we have strong and compelling evidence that something very illegal is going on, and that CFTC should act to correct (JPM concentrated short being used for price manipulation before major economic data releases). We need to stay focused on that and keep the LBMA conspiracy theories and related GATA rhetoric out of the process.

Please, google "ted butler a time to act" and read Ted's excellent piece also emphasizing the importance of staying focused on what CFTC actually has authority to regulate. That piece also contains instructions on adding your own comments to the public comment process, and a sample letter for reference.

IMHO, Eric King and yes, even Tyler Durden should be ashamed of themselves for their role in helping GATA's incompetent leadership to distract everyone's attention from the solid, irrefutable evidence in favor of theory, which although it might eventually be proven true, isn't relevant to the regulatory opportunity now before us.



Fri, 04/09/2010 - 04:20 | 292808 Riley Wilde
Riley Wilde's picture

+1 Well said.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:41 | 292878 MarketTruth
MarketTruth's picture

Agreed, and the LMBA is deeply corrupt and will NEVER change. Look at where the Rothschild/etc do their dirty work and what they own. So the LMBA will never change, yet demanding physical delivery means eventually the shelves will be empty.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:45 | 292881 swamp
swamp's picture

Focus on the fact that CFTC works for the too big to fail, not you, they have no interest in you, at all, never did never will.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 08:48 | 292923 knukles
knukles's picture

Tired of hearing about selling that which one doesn't own on derivatives markets.  That's a fundamental underlying premise, a necessity for the whole marketplace to function.  The hedger, by definition requires the offsetting spec. 
And if the market is to be broad, deep and liquid, there will, by definition be significant over purchases and sales versus the underlying commodity supply. 


That is NOT to say that there are not attempts at malfeasance and manipulation.  Evidence (real, proven, not debated, suspected, etc.) the Hunt Brothers attempt to squeeze the silver futures market some eons ago. 

But that a derivatives market has out standings Many Multiples of the underlying is of no consequence in and of itself.  That's one of the fundamental premises behind Clearing Corporations.   
Not to mention that each short and long in the futures arena posts not ony initial, but Variation Margin.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 09:50 | 293015 Sabremesh
Sabremesh's picture

It should be added that although Andrew Maguire has been described as a "whistleblower", this is not technically correct. Maguire is not a JP Morgan employee and therefore has no first-hand experience of JPM's market rigging activities. Although I have no doubt this manipulation is occurring,  a JPM metal traders conversation with Maguire is no more than hearsay, and wouldn't be admissible in court.

This was a big story, make no mistake, but it would have been much bigger if an actual JPM trader had come forward to blow the whistle.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 02:54 | 292744 sweet ebony diamond
sweet ebony diamond's picture

it's great.

for the historical records.

just like the ZH website.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 03:08 | 292751 xPat
xPat's picture

Forgot to mention...

GATA keeps trying to make a big deal about how Jeff Christian "admitted" in his testimony that the LBMA (that's the PHYSICAL market in London) is "leveraged" 100:1 by paper over real gold. GATA and Eric King would like you to believe that this is "the biggest fraud in history" and that selling something you don't have - as they allege Jeff Christian to have admitted is the case 99% of the time on the LBMA - is fraudulent default.

Wow! Them's some pretty darned incriminating words, and anyone who listened to the GATA round table interview by Eric King would certainly be expected to come away outraged that 99% of what's being sold on the physical market really has no physical gold behind it. And Jeff Christian even admitted it! That Bastard!!!

Unless, that is, you listened to what Jeff Chritian actually said, as opposed to the nonsense GATA is claiming he said. You don't have to take my word for it. Go to the CFTC website, bring up the official video of the hearing, and go to the 5:32 mark, where Christian makes the now-infamous "100 to 1 statement".

All he really says is that the term "physical market" is something of a mis-nomer, because a lot of people in the industry use the words "physical market" to refer not only to the real physical market (LBMA), but collectively to LBMA plus OTC derivatives, and other stuff. He goes on to say that when you consider that collection of markets including both the actual physical market and the derivative markets, perhaps as much as 100 times as much gold is traded than really exists in physical metal.

There's no scandal or great revelation in Christian's testimony, folks. I'm not saying there is no fraud on LBMA - there probably is. But as noted in my earlier post, this is not the time to make a case about LBMA. It's time to focus on what CFTC has authority to regulate, and that's position limits on COMEX Gold and Silver contracts.


Fri, 04/09/2010 - 04:22 | 292809 Riley Wilde
Riley Wilde's picture

+1 Again.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 06:52 | 292856 tip e. canoe
tip e. canoe's picture

imho, always thought that GATA, while its intentions are noble, is its own worst enemy.  it definitely serves a purpose and should be respected for its diligence & perservance, but perhaps it's time for it to pass the baton to someone with a little more saavy for strategy.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:59 | 292888 Al Gorerhythm
Al Gorerhythm's picture

How many hundreds of billion naked short has the OTC grown to, in the gold and silver markets as reported by the BIS? Where were you screaming about this  and central bank dumping of gold for the last 10 years? Where is your track record of sacrifice of your time and money as well as attacks upon you credibility and body personally.

Fine, focus on your US centric, market oversight buffons, but don't make excuses for fuck ups like Christian who have been disparaging any hint of market manipulation since GATA was formed. They have endured enough vitriol from these turds over the years, without having to get labeled as incompetents by some wanna be. Let them have their day. It's been a long time coming. Congratulations to Bill and team for getting us to where we are, and fuck you for trying to besmirch them for their achievement, using semantics to justify your points. What are you, a fucking troll?

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 10:07 | 293064 Hephasteus
Hephasteus's picture

"What are you, a fucking troll?"

Repeat after me. Fuck al-CIA-duh.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 11:51 | 293264 xPat
xPat's picture

It's so disappointing to encounter immature, unprofessional attitudes here at ZH.

My esteemed colleage A. Gorerythm, I'm not going to stoop to the level of returning your personal insults and foul language. If you wish to engage me in a polite intellectual discourse on this subject, I'm keen to consider your views and share my own. But I'm not going to take you seriously if you continue with the sophomoric personal insults.

I never endorsed Jeff Christian or his views - he's not my favorite guy either. All I did was to factually observe that GATA has twisted his words in a way that defies logic and reason, and I expressed my opinion that GATA is doing more to hurt its own cause than to advance it.

I also never said that I had great confidence in CFTC. Quite to the contrary, I am very skeptical of their sincerity in looking at this problem with a real desire to affect change. But for right or wrong, the opportunity now before us is to influence CFTC to take action in regulating impropriety on the COMEX, and I'll give them the benefit of the doubt because to write them off as useless only guarantees an outcome with no improvement. A watchdog organization representing the interests of the non-iBank investor is desperately needed here, but I for one am of the opinion that GATA has done an horrific job of fulfilling that need. Incidentally, I sent all of my criticism to them directly via e-mail (I don't like to criticize others without giving them the courtesy of knowing who I am and what I'm saying), but have yet to receive the courtesy of a reply. Ditto for Eric King.

As I said previously, I don't doubt that there is plenty wrong in the land of LBMA. All I said is that making a big deal of it now when focus on the matter at hand is more important bespeaks incompetence on the part of the folks at GATA.

I welcome your counter-arguments, but ask that you try to participate in this discussion on a more adult level than your last post.



Fri, 04/09/2010 - 21:54 | 293728 Al Gorerhythm
Al Gorerhythm's picture

Bullshit Xpat,

"Let's focus on the job at hand with the CFTC", is not exclusively what you said.

So, it's OK for you to sling barbs such as "GATA being mind-bogglingly incompetent", hedging your attack with underhanded slime-speak, using redirection strategy with a backhanded compliment with them being "Well meaning but misdirected". This, in your opening sentence and then you claim "professionalism" as your high ground, to label name callers as a lower common denominator in this discussion. This from you, despite their success in revealing the fractional nature of the LBMA, supported by their release of evidence from the first whistle blower in the history of CFTC "investigations". You use the same false sincerity with your reply to me "My esteemed AG, I not going to stoop to your level blah, blah, blah", ipso facto I am a crude commoner. You'd be right there. I am when necessary but a least I'm up front and don't need decoding.

You cavalierly dismiss or ignore the testimony of Christian, when he states that the comments of Adrian Douglas of GATA re the fractional reserve nature of the PHYSICAL market in London, was correct. That says it all re your own (professional, phttt) assertions and misinterpretation of clear evidence given at the CFTC hearing. You are a "Brutus" friend and your approach smacks of underlying motive. 

My last post was the bourbon talking so let me rephrase for clarity. Kiss my hairy ass you sanctimonious wanker. Your point proven, happy now?

Sat, 04/10/2010 - 10:59 | 294536 Hephasteus
Hephasteus's picture

Well xPat how'd that molding public opinion work out for ya?

Sat, 04/10/2010 - 20:12 | 294689 tip e. canoe
tip e. canoe's picture

know what, you're right algoryrhythm, it's easy to be critical from the peanut gallery.  i join you in junking my original comment.

still think xPat, spook or no spook, is making a subtle point worth considering.  when dealing with masters at manipulating hearts & minds, one must be able to skillfully outfox the foxes if one is attempting to dismantle the psychological edifice, especially one that is made from the bedrock of civilizations. 

there is no question that gold (and silver to a lesser extent) has had a grip on human societies since the beginning of what is called history.   maybe this pull is due to something beyond the logical arguments on the surface of things?

e.g. the egyptians & the sumerians had no idea how much gold was available in the earth, yet they still treasured it as divine.  ever wonder why that is?

Sat, 04/10/2010 - 20:13 | 295013 tip e. canoe
tip e. canoe's picture

goddess bless the edit function

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 04:29 | 292811 nathan1234
nathan1234's picture

I think it would be best for all those who wish for delivery to do so at the next settlement.

This may be the last chance to get your physical gold and or silver. The rest will be closed out by squaring up.

The LBMA and the Comex are just gambling dens and the money power dictates the so called price of gold and silver.

Asians believe in physical possession. I also do not understand how anyone can trust the government who can hand over trillions to the Treasury and Fed and not say to whom the money has been given. Congress and the Senate are in cahoots.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 05:47 | 292834 Gordon_Gekko
Gordon_Gekko's picture

Will fraud lift gold prices to $10,000/ounce?

More like $100,000 /ounce.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 05:48 | 292836 Gordon_Gekko
Gordon_Gekko's picture


Fri, 04/09/2010 - 06:19 | 292847 Instant Karma
Instant Karma's picture

I, for one, would like to thank J.P. Morgan for keeping silver not only affordable, but inexpensive, for ordinary Americans.

Given that American currency is, like most currency, not worth the paper it is printed on, I find it comforting that I, as an American, a Citizen of a country with untold TRILLIONS of dollars in outstanding debt and TRILLIONS more in unfunded obligations, can still produce a $20 dollar bill and buy an ounce of silver.

Gold has already appreciated to the point that a mere ounce requires 12 $100 bills. Obviously, we need to bring $1000 bills back into circulation. Perhaps with Bernanke's or Obama's picture on them.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 06:35 | 292852 TooBearish
TooBearish's picture

Thank you xPat for getting to the point - it is not illegal to sell what you don't own in the derivatives markets - COLLUSIVE trading which JPM, GS, DB and others have been engaging in for years is illegal and the CFTC should be held accountable for non-enforcement.

Tyler - your reporting continues to outstrip not only the MSM but anything on the web, outstanding reporting, much appreciated.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 10:10 | 293070 tmosley
tmosley's picture

Selling short is fine, but you should have to be able to borrow the metal with which to do so.  Otherwise its fraud, no matter which way you slice it.  It reduces the market into a casino.  If that's what they want to do, then fine, but they should be abhorred by the greater investing community for such actions, and only their actual physical orders should be counted toward the prevailing spot price.  Let them play their own little games within their closed arena, but don't let pretend orders and pretend sales affect actual movement of physical metal.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:12 | 292862 plocequ1
plocequ1's picture

Very impressive Letterhead.. Market goes up

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 07:45 | 292880 unwashedmass
unwashedmass's picture


i'm waiting for the class action suit to be filed. its sort of surprising one hasn't found its way to the courts. its been two weeks, and.....attornies in class actions get 1/3 plus costs of any award. so, someone could end up a billionaire.

maybe...given the "accidents" that seem to befall people who get in JPM's way, they are having a hard time finding a plaintiff willing to be named.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 08:14 | 292899 Monday1929
Monday1929's picture

Can you give any examples of those who have had accidents? I am hoping to help put Jamie Dimon in prison.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 08:16 | 292903 unwashedmass
unwashedmass's picture

google Andrew Maguire and read all about the hit and run "accident" that almost took him and his wife out the day after the CTFC hearings.

odd coincidence, eh?

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 08:24 | 292891 TruthHunter
TruthHunter's picture

"LOL, like you have a chance in front of JPM's judge and JPM's

law? /ouch!!!/"

Then we'll have to resort to JP Morgan's gun, which

is like Karl Marx's Capitalist Rope!

Seriously, what are the consequences for the market?

 Most won't/can't take delivery so I am expecting

unprecedented cashing out.  Thats' bearish for paper

Gold.  So where is real Bullion market instead of the Casino

or Pocket Change Dealers??

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 08:11 | 292897 SilverIsKing
SilverIsKing's picture

Kudos to Jason for doing this.  Regardless of whether anyone believes that it will get results, it's an important step and for that, Jason should be applauded.

It's also incumbent upon all of us to do what we can to publicize this issue as well as Jason's complaint to hopefully bring the issue into the light of day and force the DOJ's hand to act.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 08:28 | 292908 roadcaptain
roadcaptain's picture

Futile - last time there was a silver squeeze

the CFTC issued a liquidation only trading rule for

long enough to bail out JPM and a few others

who were on the wrong end of the trade.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 08:29 | 292910 saladbarbeef
saladbarbeef's picture

For my money, the Mogambo Guru should have been the first to file the complaint.  THAT would have been quite impressive reading.  


We're freaking doomed!



Fri, 04/09/2010 - 08:58 | 292942 cossack55
cossack55's picture

Gold is the currency of kings

silver is the currency of gentlemen

barter is the currency of peasents

debt is the currency of slaves

       The Richest Man in Babylon


Fri, 04/09/2010 - 08:59 | 292944 justbuygold
justbuygold's picture

Conrgatulations to Jason for this letter.  Someone has to be first .  While one letter may not get much notice, it will prokove other letters and hopefully momentum will ick up where one day they suddenly have thousands of letters.  Here is to hoping...

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 09:20 | 292968 jory
jory's picture

Jason is a JOKE

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 09:43 | 293009 Johnny Dangereaux
Johnny Dangereaux's picture

Wow you guys are on a first name basis, and you call him what? 

Jeez jory, jamie "DB" dimon tell you to say that?

I know Jason carries personal protection. Maybe he'll have a chance to pick off the inevitable hit and run driver he's going to meet soon!

Hommel has his own PM production mint...yeah, what a joke.....

Sat, 04/10/2010 - 00:52 | 294262 RockyRacoon
RockyRacoon's picture

Uh, I was wondering when someone would point out the weirdness of Mr. Hommel.  I had to unsubscribe to his email newsletter.  The Jesus rants, bible quotes, and his stance on Obama's birth certificate really turned me off.  No problem with views, we all have them, but mixing economics with religion ain't the route to take.  If he could have stayed on the topic of silver I would have hung in there.  The stench got pretty bad toward the end.  I would have liked to have seen someone with a bit shinier tin-foil hat to do the lawsuit.  Mr. Hommel is not the guy to take the lead in this.  Sorry to be the one to put a down note on the whole affair.   He's brave, yes, but a little too kooky for the task.  I'm with Gordon and all the others here who say that you'd better get your physical metal pretty soon -- or miss the boat.  If TS does not HTF, then all the better.  But it's nice to sleep at night.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 09:26 | 292982 Pladizow
Pladizow's picture

I think many are missing the point of filing this suit.

Perhaps it is pointless to fight JPM but as awareness spreads, you will not need to figfht them.

As more and more push for physical delivery JPM will be in trouble.

China, Russia, India and the educated buyers will ultimately trump JPM.

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 12:43 | 293392 Zerozen
Zerozen's picture, is that a vagina in your avatar?

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 11:26 | 293214 silver surfer
silver surfer's picture

Sorry but paper claims on paper fraud is hopeless, taking physical delivery is the only way to rince out the banksters

Fri, 04/09/2010 - 11:46 | 293263 SaulA
SaulA's picture

They said it on the internets, so it must be true.  What a sophmoric filing.  It will end up in the trash at the DoJ where it belongs.

Sat, 04/10/2010 - 00:54 | 294266 Grand Supercycle
Grand Supercycle's picture


DOW / SP500 daily chart gives bullish signals as of Friday 9 April.  Weekly chart still trends up but continues to warn of an overextended bear market rally.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!