Global Nuclear Update

George Washington's picture

Washington’s Blog


United States: Alabama

While a tornado partially knocked out at the Browns Ferry reactors in Alabama in April, power began to be restored within a month without incident.

United States: Nebraska

The flood waters in the Missouri continue to pose a danger to the Fort Calhoun nuclear plant in Nebraska. As you may know, an
electrical fire at the spent fuel pools at Fort Calhoun temporarily
knocked out power for cooling, and the operator flooded the containment
building
.

So
far, I have seen no evidence of any release of radiation, although
there are a number of worrying factors in the form of a "perfect storm"
which could - in a worst-case scenario - lead to an accident.

The latest updates include:

  • An "event" at the Fort Calhoun plant was reported to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission:

    Facility: FORT CALHOUN
    Notification Date: 06/16/2011
    Notification Time: 14:46 [ET]
    Event Date: 06/16/2011
    Event Time: 12:30 [CDT]

    Event Text: ADDITIONAL PENETRATION IDENTIFIED FOR MITIGATION DURING WALKDOWN

    “Operations
    identified a potential flooding issue in the Intake Structure 1007 ft.
    6 in. level. The area of concern is a the hole in the floor at the
    1007 ft. 6 in. level where the relief valve from FP-1A discharge pipe
    goes through the raw pump bay and discharges into the intake cell.
    There is one penetration of concern. Flooding through this penetration
    could have impacted the ability of the station’s Raw Water (RW) pumps
    to perform their design accident mitigation functions.

    “Efforts are in progress to seal the penetration.

    “This eight-hour notification is being made pursuant to 10 CFR 50.72 (b)(3)(v).”

    The licensee notified the NRC Resident Inspector.

  • WOWT reports:

    [Fort
    Calhoun Nuclear Power Plant's chief nuclear officer, Dave Bannister]
    said for the plant to get to a disaster level, floodwater would have to
    rise three and a half feet above where it stands now.

  • The Kansas City Star notes:

    The endless complexities have made prediction a tough task, said
    Ross Wolford, a hydrologist working long days for the National Weather
    Service in order to try to predict the river’s flow.

    “We
    don’t have, nor does the Corps or anyone else have, a hydraulic model
    of what the [Missouri] river’s going to do,” Wolford said. “There’s a
    lot of art
    in the way we estimate.”

  • The Journal Star points out:

    The
    flood begins higher up, at places like Dark Horse Lake in the
    Bitterroots, [Montana] where another 2 inches of snow fell late this
    week, landing on the 8 feet still on the ground.

    “It’s all
    starting here,” said Jim Brusda with the National Weather Service in
    Great Falls, Mont. “It’s going to flow back down there toward Nebraska”
    ...

    “People who have been here 50 years, 70 years, say they
    haven’t seen anything like this ... And there’s a lot of water to come”
    ...

    And as the snow-fed Missouri crosses Montana, it’s
    collecting record rainfall, too. Some areas received 10 inches in three
    weeks; 3 inches fell on a town in northeast Montana between Thursday
    and Friday.

    The rain is expected to continue through the weekend. An even stronger storm system could surface next week.

  • The Kansas City Star notes the at the Army Corps of Engineers is planning on releasing more water:

    Heavy
    rainfall expected over the Dakotas in coming days, combined with rains
    from the past few weeks, have officials worried they’re running out of
    space in upstream dams, potentially forcing them to release even more
    pent-up water downstream [the Missouri River] …

    One of the Army
    Corps’ biggest tools is the Gavins Point Dam, the last stop for the
    Missouri River in South Dakota, which will blast out a record 150,000
    cubic feet of water per second through at least mid-August.

    Officials
    now think they might have to boost the amount to 160,000 cubic feet,
    saying they’re running out of options to manage all the water upstream.

    “At this point, we have very little flexibility remaining,” Farhat said.

    (the Missouri flows from South Dakota to Nebraska)

  • KTIV reports:

    [I]n
    Pierre, South Dakota, the Army Corps announced it’ll raise releases at
    the Oahe Dam [a second dam] another 10,000 cubic feet per second this
    weekend. That will bring it to 160,000 by Sunday.

    “We are
    transferring flood storage from Oahe and Big Bend to Fort Randall,
    which has more storage available at this time,” said Jody Farhat, chief
    of Water Management, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Northwestern
    Division. “The amount of rain has nearly filled the reservoirs, doing
    away with most of the flexibility we had built into our operations for
    this year,” said Farhat.

United States: Vermont

The State of Vermont has denied relicensing to the Vermont Yankee Nuclear power plant.

But Senator Sanders says that 100% captured Nuclear Regulatory Commission has pressured the Department of Justice to sue the state to allow relicensing, and to side with the nuclear operator instead of the state.

Egypt: Cairo

The Anshas Nuclear Reactor outside of Cairo has leaked small amounts of radioactive water. See this, this and this.

Japan: Monju

The New York Times has a must-read report
on a situation at a reactor hundreds of miles from Fukushima which
hasn't turned into a catastrophe net, but could become a large-scale
disaster:

Three hundred miles southwest of
Fukushima, at a nuclear reactor perched on the slopes of this rustic
peninsula, engineers are engaged in another precarious struggle.

 

The
Monju prototype fast-breeder reactor — a long-troubled national
project — has been in a precarious state of shutdown since a 3.3-ton
device crashed into the reactor’s inner vessel, cutting off access to
the plutonium and uranium fuel rods at its core.

 

Engineers
have tried repeatedly since the accident last August to recover the
device, which appears to have gotten stuck. They will make another
attempt as early as next week.

 

But critics warn that the
recovery process is fraught with dangers because the plant uses large
quantities of liquid sodium, a highly flammable substance, to cool the
nuclear fuel.

 

***

Prefecture and city officials found
that the operator had tampered with video images of the fire to hide
the scale of the disaster. A top manager at the plant recently
committed suicide, on the day that Japan’s atomic energy agency
announced that efforts to recover the device would cost almost $21.9
million. And, like several other reactors, Monju lies on an active
fault.

Japan: Shizuoka

As Japan Times reports:

Chubu
Electric Power Co. said Friday that 43 pipes in a turbine steam
condenser were found to be damaged at the Hamaoka nuclear plant in
Shizuoka Prefecture, after the utility last month probed the leak of
seawater into a reactor at the plant.

 

Two other pipes were found to be deformed, the utility added, without elaborating.

 

On
May 14, some 5 tons of seawater entered the No. 5 reactor at the plant
in the city of Omaezaki, following the discovery of around 400 tons of
seawater in the condenser, which cools steam from the turbine and
turns it into water.

 

The trouble occurred
during work to put the reactor into a state of cold shutdown, according
to Chubu Electric. At that time, about 530 tons of water were flowing
per hour through the recirculation pipe for adjusting the water volume
inside the reactor.

 

***

 

As
the recirculation pipe had a fracture on its welded part near the lid,
water that gushed out of it possibly damaged the pipes, the utility
said.

Japan: Fukushima

As of June 4th, highly radioactive steam was escaping inside reactors at Fukushima:

 

 

As of June 14th, radioactive steam was still escaping into the air:

 

(compare
the amount of steam escaping starting around 1:32 into video with the
amount released starting at around 2:12 into video)

Daily Kos reports:

Japan
is dangerously contaminated by radioactivity over a far larger area
than previously reported by TEPCO and the central government according
to new reports from multiple sources. The prefectural government of
Iwate released new data that shows radioactive contamination of grass exceeds safety standards at a distance of 90 to 125 miles from the damaged Fukushima nuclear power plants.

The
prefectural government found on Tuesday radioactive cesium exceeding
the limit of 300 becquerels per kilogram in grass collected from
pastures in four areas, including Tono and Otsuchi. The areas are
located about 150 to 200 kilometers north of the Fukushima nuclear
power plant.

Science
Magazine reports that Japanese scientists have become so concerned
about the health of their children that they have initiated their own
radiation monitoring program and made their own maps. The results are
shocking.

 

***

 

It shows one wide belt of radiation
reaching 225 kilometers south from the stricken reactors to Tokyo and
another extending to the southwest. Within those belts are localized
hot spots, including an oval that encloses northeast Tokyo and Kashiwa
and neighboring cities in Chiba Prefecture.

 

***

 

A map of citizen measured radiation levels shows radioactivity
is distributed in a complex pattern reflecting the mountainous terrain
and the shifting winds across a broad area of Japan north of Tokyo
which is in the center of the of bottom of the map.


Radiation
limits begin to be exceeded at just above 0.1 microsieverts/ hour
blue. Red is about fifty times the civilian radiation limit at 5.0
microsieverts/hour. Because children are much more sensitive than
adults, these results are a great concern for parents of young children
in potentially affected areas.

I've previously noted that some Japanese tea is contamination with radiation. And now, reports of radioactive tea shipped into other countries are starting to surface.

The journal Nature notes that the governments knew, but covered up, early knowledge about the release of radiation from Fukushima.

American reporter Dahr Jamail reports:

"We
have 20 nuclear cores exposed, the fuel pools have several cores
each, that is 20 times the potential to be released than Chernobyl,"
said Gundersen. "The data I'm seeing shows that we are finding hot
spots further away than we had from Chernobyl, and the amount of
radiation in many of them was the amount that caused areas to be
declared no-man's-land for Chernobyl. We are seeing square kilometres
being found 60 to 70 kilometres away from the reactor. You can't clean
all this up. We still have radioactive wild boar in Germany, 30 years
after Chernobyl."

 

***

 

TEPCO announced that the
accident probably released more radioactive material into the
environment than Chernobyl, making it the worst nuclear accident on
record.

 

Meanwhile, a nuclear waste advisor to the Japanese
government reported that about 966 square kilometres near the power
station - an area roughly 17 times the size of Manhattan - is now
likely uninhabitable.

 

In the US, physician Janette Sherman MD
and epidemiologist Joseph Mangano published an essay shedding light on
a 35 per cent spike in infant mortality in northwest cities that
occurred after the Fukushima meltdown, and may well be the result of
fallout from the stricken nuclear plant.

 

The eight cities
included in the report are San Jose, Berkeley, San Francisco,
Sacramento, Santa Cruz, Portland, Seattle, and Boise, and the time
frame of the report included the ten weeks immediately following the
disaster.

 

"There is and should be concern about younger people
being exposed, and the Japanese government will be giving out radiation
monitors to children," Dr MV Ramana, a physicist with the Programme
on Science and Global Security at Princeton University who specialises
in issues of nuclear safety, told Al Jazeera.

 

***

 

Gundersen points out that far more radiation has been released than has been reported.

 

***

 

According
to Gundersen, the exposed reactors and fuel cores are continuing to
release microns of caesium, strontium, and plutonium isotopes. These
are referred to as "hot particles".

 

"We are discovering hot
particles everywhere in Japan, even in Tokyo," he said. "Scientists are
finding these everywhere. Over the last 90 days these hot particles
have continued to fall and are being deposited in high concentrations. A
lot of people are picking these up in car engine air filters."

 

Radioactive
air filters from cars in Fukushima prefecture and Tokyo are now
common, and Gundersen says his sources are finding radioactive air
filters in the greater Seattle area of the US as well.

 

The hot particles on them can eventually lead to cancer.

 

"These
get stuck in your lungs or GI tract, and they are a constant
irritant," he explained, "One cigarette doesn't get you, but over time
they do. These [hot particles] can cause cancer, but you can't measure
them with a Geiger counter. Clearly people in Fukushima prefecture
have breathed in a large amount of these particles. Clearly the upper
West Coast of the US has people being affected. That area got hit
pretty heavy in April."

 

***

 

Gundersen pointed out that the units are still leaking radiation.

 

"They
are still emitting radioactive gases and an enormous amount of
radioactive liquid," he said. "It will be at least a year before it
stops boiling, and until it stops boiling, it's going to be cranking out
radioactive steam and liquids."

 

Gundersen worries about more earthquake aftershocks, as well as how to cool two of the units.

 

"Unit
four is the most dangerous, it could topple," he said. "After the
earthquake in Sumatra there was an 8.6 [aftershock] about 90 days
later, so we are not out of the woods yet. And you're at a point where,
if that happens, there is no science for this, no one has ever
imagined having hot nuclear fuel lying outside the fuel pool. They've
not figured out how to cool units three and four."

Indeed, a 5.9 earthquake hit 110 kilometers from Fukushima today.

A water decontamination system has been halted after a rapid rise in radiation. Radiation limits were reached in 5 hours, when it wasn’t supposed to happen for a month

As Jamail notes, the long-term prognosis is challenging:

"Units
one through three have nuclear waste on the floor, the melted core,
that has plutonium in it, and that has to be removed from the
environment for hundreds of thousands of years," he said. "Somehow,
robotically, they will have to go in there and manage to put it in a
container and store it for infinity, and that technology doesn't exist.
Nobody knows how to pick up the molten core from the floor, there is
no solution available now for picking that up from the floor."

 

Dr
Sawada says that the creation of nuclear fission generates
radioactive materials for which there is simply no knowledge informing
us how to dispose of the radioactive waste safely.

 

"Until we
know how to safely dispose of the radioactive materials generated by
nuclear plants, we should postpone these activities so as not to cause
further harm to future generations," he explained. "To do otherwise
is simply an immoral act, and that is my belief, both as a scientist
and as a survivor of the Hiroshima atomic bombing."

 

Gundersen believes it will take experts at least ten years to design and implement the plan.

 

"So
ten to 15 years from now maybe we can say the reactors have been
dismantled, and in the meantime you wind up contaminating the water,"
Gundersen said. "We are already seeing Strontium [at] 250 times the
allowable limits in the water table at Fukushima. Contaminated water
tables are incredibly difficult to clean. So I think we will have a
contaminated aquifer in the area of the Fukushima site for a long, long
time to come."

 

Unfortunately, the history of nuclear disasters appears to back Gundersen's assessment.

"With
Three Mile Island and Chernobyl, and now with Fukushima, you can
pinpoint the exact day and time they started," he said, "But they never
end."