• Econophile
    03/18/2010 - 13:42
    We think that China is an indestructible economic juggernaut but its economy is very fragile and it is sitting on a property bubble which will burst. What China does in response has major implications for their economy and the rest of the world. This is the third part of a three-part series on this topic: The Consequences.
  • Reggie Middleton
    03/18/2010 - 07:54
    The Greek saga continues, exactly as was anticipated. For all of those who don't regularly read me, this is really not about Greece but about the start of either default or significant depression throughout a large swath of the Eurozone. Greece is the firestarter and it looks as if we are starting to burn...

Greece Implements Pension Reforms

Leo Kolivakis's picture




Submitted by Leo Kolivakis, publisher of Pension Pulse.

John Hadoulis of AFP reports that Greece hikes pension age, calls for bonus cuts:

Greece's government on Tuesday unveiled a hike in the average retirement age and called on striking civil servants to accept bonus cuts to pull the country out of an unprecedented financial crisis.

 

Labour Minister Andreas Loverdos said men and women will retire at 63 on average in a bid to save Greece's cash-strapped pensions system, as other ministers met for a second day to finalise the country's new tax policy.

"There will be a two-year increase of the limits on the average rate of retirement... namely 63 years on average for men and women by 2015," Labour Minister Andreas Loverdos told reporters after a ministry meeting.

 

"We are changing the pensions system in order to keep it alive," he said.

The maximum retirement rate is currently 65 for men and 60 for women, and Greece is under pressure by the European Union to bridge the gap.

 

The minister also pledged to bring an end to voluntary retirement schemes that have cost the cash-strapped state dearly.

 

The pension reform is part of a cost-cutting plan by Greece's hard-pressed Socialist government which is struggling to slash a debt mountain expected to hit over 290 billion euros (396 billion dollars) this year.

 

Loverdos is trying to save 4.5 billion euros (six billion euros) this year from a social budget burdened by years of mismanaged spending by social funds on medicine and hospital bills.

 

Greece's main private sector union GSEE is staging a nationwide strike on February 24 in opposition to the pension reform. Thousands of civil servants targeted for bonus cuts are holding another one-day strike on Wednesday.

 

GSEE chairman Yiannis Panagopoulos on Tuesday said the minister's statements were "vague" as they made no reference to the maximum age of retirement.

"When the government presents its full proposals in a bill, we will discuss them and fight to improve them if necessary," he told private Flash Radio.

 

But he welcomed the scrapping of voluntary retirement schemes, saying it was "provocative to have miners crawling into holes at the age of 65 and to see other categories retiring after 25 years of work."

 

The government is trying to prevent this month's industrial action from undermining efforts to jumpstart the recession-mired economy.

 

The cabinet is meeting for a second day Tuesday to finalise a tax overhaul aimed at netting around five billion euros this year and help plug a budget deficit that hit over 30 billion euros in 2009.

 

Greek Prime Minister George Papandreou late Monday asked civil servants to accept bonus cuts saying they "must be the first to set an example."

 

Wednesday's civil servant strike will paralyse ministries, local administration and tax offices. Air traffic controllers are also joining the protest.

 

Greece's 12.7-percent deficit is beyond EU limits of three percent of output for eurozone members, and it suffered a triple downgrade of its sovereign debt in December.

 

Despite assurances from the European Union and the European Central Bank, markets suspect that the government will not be able to enforce the painful reforms promised.

 

Socialist cadres are already expressing misgivings about the plan according to press reports, but a majority of Greeks appear to support the government.

 

The European Commission last month rubber-stamped a three-year Greek crisis plan presented by the government.

 

But the European Union executive arm also placed Greece under a permanent system of monitoring -- a first for the EU -- and rapped Athens over faulty budgetary data tabled by the previous conservative government ousted in October.

Greece doesn't have a choice but to implement pension reforms. And pension tension isn't a problem unique to Greece. Here in Canada, former Nortel employees will face big cuts to pensions, health care, disability coverage and other benefits later this year under a $57-million deal with the insolvent company.

In the UK, the BBC reports that according to the the Pension Protection Fund (PPF), the deficit in final salary pension schemes in the private sector hit £52bn in January, up from £33bn in December.

In New Jersey, legislation requiring public workers to assume a portion of their health benefits costs and providing relief to the beleaguered state pension system has been introduced:

The package of bills introduced Monday follows vows by new Democratic leaders in the state Senate to revisit pension reform recommendations made four years ago but mostly ignored.

 

"Unless we take action now, New Jersey's pension system will implode, leaving thousands of rank and file workers penniless in retirement," Senate President Steve Sweeney said during a news conference on pension reforms two weeks ago.

One bill requires state, local and school district workers to contribute at least 1.5 percent of their salary toward their health care costs. Another caps at $15,000 the amount of unused sick time that can be cashed in at retirement.

 

A third bill repeals the 9 percent pension benefit increase put in place in 2001 by changing the way pensions are calculated. The last bill in the package requires the state to make its annual payment to the pension system, not skip it or short it, as has been the custom in recent years.

 

No figures were immediately available on the potential savings.

 

Most of the proposals would affect new hires, not those already in the pension system. However, the measure requiring public workers to contribute toward their health care costs would take effect when their current contract expires.

 

The pension system is underfunded by about $34 billion and is in danger of becoming insolvent unless fixes are made.

As you read this comment, remember that what's happening in Greece is emblematic of what's plaguing most developed countries, albeit in varying degrees. Pension woes are not going away, will get worse over the next decade, and will undoubtedly require tough choices and compromises ahead by all stakeholders.

4.666665
Your rating: None Average: 4.7 (3 votes)



by Anonymous
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 09:10
#223123

Surely differential pension ages is sexist under european human rights legislation anyway. Some guy should sue.

by Catullus
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 09:12
#223130

I'm afraid this is going to end in violence. 

by Anonymous
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 09:33
#223159

Agreed.

Civil war.

Man the lifeboats....

by Rainman
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 09:19
#223140

And no story on the Pension Holocaust is complete without mention of CalPers.

In the past 10 years, the State's annual payout into CalPers has gone from $ 159 million to over $ 3.5 billion. State revenues are up just 26 % in that period. That amount doesn't even include the city, county and municipality growth in annual liability ( many are falling way behind on their payments due to CalPers ).

Every day there are editorials in local CA newspapers SCREAMING for electeds to craft solutions to the looming public pension disaster.

by Daedal
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 09:50
#223173

So Pensions, public and private, and Social Security are underfunded. Meanwhile debt loads are still obsenely high.  This means stocks will go up, right?

by Miles Kendig
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 09:39
#223162

If a contracted bonus is held as valid for bankrupt AIG then state committed retirement programs are at a minimum equally, if not superior to any such claims from "private enterprise" operating under state sponsorship.  Keep your commitments or the cops and firefighters may not show up when you call.

by Daedal
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 09:44
#223165

Time to load up on Smith & Wesson.

by Miles Kendig
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 10:27
#223223

And support your local volunteer fire company...

by Anonymous
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 10:08
#223197

What are "cops?"

Don't be a fool, there is no enforcement in finance. Finance is the business of choice for the mafia (spare the the rebuttals on market legitimacy from the panzy trader's perspectives).

I thought there was intelligence on this forum, but all it is is a bunch of weak citizens spouting on about nothing while their governments steam-roller every foundation in what's left of the States of Corporate America.

Bonuses for failure - yeah that sure seems legitimate.

by Miles Kendig
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 10:31
#223219

Cops, just like firefighters go where they are sent.  I would hope that a citizen who desires to avail themselves of the shield of anonymity would understand the basic precepts of governance as it is presently applied. The leaders of American government used the 9-11 attacks as a means of reducing the footprint of law enforcement within the area of financial terrorism, where the real money is made in order to turn the immense capabilities of national technical means against their own citizens. Where have you been, besides hiding behind the mask of anonymity?

Returning to this effort by Leo I am sure that there are many within the Greek civil service and the society that either they serve or whom many believe have grown accustomed to the idea that society is there to serve them with the concept that it is upon their shoulders that the government is calling for sacrifices.  I suspect that the Greek civil service will call upon a greater distribution of pain to those that are best able to shoulder it.  Those that have profited handsomely at the opportunities Greek society has offered many.  Most notably, those who are held above national concerns and prerogatives, or even international propriety who now actively trade national and indeed regional fiscal demise for fun and profit.

A fat bonus payday for "success" - Sure seems appropriate to me...

by Anonymous
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 09:53
#223176

Leo you are a coward.

Until this system is reformed it will fail again and again, exactly as it is designed.

Instead of being a trader/thief why don't you act like an American and quit promoting the theft in the name of "trading"

by Anonymous
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 09:57
#223182

Until the current system of lobbyists and corporate thieves is a pile of bloody corpses there is no end in sight. If you think along the lines of a happier ending you are the spineless problem and don't deserve to be called an American.

Vote out the bums and take your states and nation back you Wall Street wannabe's (pussies)!

Torch it to the ground before someone else does where you end up with not even the ashes.

by Anonymous
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 09:59
#223186

?????????? ???? !!!

by Anonymous
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 10:03
#223195

Shouldn't they also raise taxes?

by Anonymous
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 10:09
#223198

Didn't Argentina implement pension reform a few years ago?

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/11/20/AR2008112003812.html

...unexpectedly...

by SWRichmond
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 10:16
#223201

Why is it when a government is reneging on promises it made to its citizens, or is about to change a system to fuck the taxpayers even more, they call it "reform"?  Why don't they call it what it is?

 

"Greece reneges on promises it should never have made, skull-fucks citizens".

by Anonymous
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 10:21
#223212

>>>>Here in Canada, former Nortel employees will face big cuts to pensions, health care, disability coverage and other benefits later this year under a $57-million deal with the insolvent company.<<<<<

Yes Leo but another $200 million of my tax dollars are going in to the Pension Guaranty Fund to help Nortel emplyees. So billions went to the auto workers, $85 million to teachers and now $200 million to help pensioners from a private company that has gone broke. Any money going to rest of us with our own retirement funds?
This is just political crap buying votes at the expense of tax payers in my opinion.

by Captain Willard
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 10:32
#223234

Leo is doing a very valuable service to us highlighting this issue. The massive coming crisis in pension schemes is going to create enormous social tension all over. In fact, it may be the issue that finally slows runaway government spending and breaks California. Or more likely, it will catalyze a Federal bailout of the states.

It may also have the collateral effect of raising awareness among taxpayers as to exactly how badly they have been screwed in this crisis. Many are unemployed with dwindling benefits whilst policemen retire on huge pensions. This will enrage older voters. Recent polls show that young people would rather have easy government jobs than take private-sector risks. It all crushes the spirit of enterprise.

I predict much more anger.

by guidoamm
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 10:35
#223239

The reforms are needed. But that's not the problem.

As austerity is pushed onto the people and as the shenanigans of the power elite keep cropping up, a whole bunch of people are going to be very unhappy; and if they are hungry and homeless to boot, then yes, that is a likely recipe for revolution...

I know it, you know it too and so do some of our leaders.

Before that happens, they'll plunge us into a world war. Been done before. Absolutely no reason why it should not be done again.

Western politicians are not about to admit that they are no more righteous than your garden variety Mugabe. So war it is I am afraid.

by Anonymous
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 10:51
#223258

Greece is the word.

by Leo Kolivakis
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 10:56
#223271

Those of you who want to track the US and global pension tsunami more closely, should visit Jack Dean's excellent site:

http://www.pensiontsunami.com/

by Anonymous
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 11:25
#223337

Are you still bullish on stocks? If so, I'm curious as to why. Another solid article.

by A Man without Q...
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 11:58
#223397

It's all part of the great wealth illusion.  We over estimate our assets and underestimate our liabilities.  In this case the illustration of the affluence of western societies is the fabulous pensions we can offer to our workers, but the problem is that an unfunded pension is nothing more than a Ponzi scheme, reliant upon the payments of later members to fund the obligations to the earlier ones.  As we face the reality of an aging population (both fewer youth and longer living elderly) the day of reckoning is approaching.

Our societies are not productive enough to cover these generous entitlements, but people have lived and worked on the assumption this would be due them, so some people are going to be very disappointed, to say the least.

by Crime of the Century
on Tue, 02/09/2010 - 22:17
#224422

It's strange that people would think the Federal Gov't would bail out states who don't require their employees to contribute to medical plans (Federal employees do) and who struggle attempting to cap saleable sick hours (Federal employees may carry/sell no more than 240 hrs of annual leave - zero sick time is saleable). Until the states adopt the more stringent benefits scheme of the Federal Gov't, they shouldn't look to it as Bond Bailsman.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.