From Marin Katusa Of Casey Research
It’s Time To Invest In Coal
Coal prices are surging ahead even as most other commodities pull
back, spurred on by expectations that metallurgical and thermal coal
production will again fail to meet rising global demand this year. The
result? Record profits for major coal producers like Xstrata, a surge in
acquisitions from coal-hungry India, Chinese electricity shortages, and
a raging carbon tax debate in Australia amid record investments in that
country’s coal-heavy mining sector.
price spikes in the second half of 2008, which were completely
unsustainable and disappeared rapidly in the recession, distort the
picture. So instead, imagine the above graph without those peaks. What
you get is an almost sustained ascent in the spot prices of thermal and
metallurgical coal over the last four years. Metallurgical coal, which
is used to make steel and is also known as coking coal, has almost
doubled in price, climbing from just above US$80 per ton in mid-2007 to
more than US$160 per ton today. Thermal coal, which is burned to
generate electricity, has risen from the US$45 per ton range to almost
US$80 per ton.
There are a couple of countries that really take
notice when coal prices start to rock. Australia is the world’s biggest
coal exporter and relies on thermal coal for 80% of its electricity.
China mines more coal than any other country in the world but still
imports more to support its power and steel-making needs – the country
mines and burns more than three billion tons of the black stuff
annually. And India – where the economy is growing at 8% annually – is
facing multimillion ton coal shortages even as it works to halve a 14%
peak power deficit within two years.
Let’s start with Australia, a
country embroiled in a debate over newly introduced carbon taxes. Those
taxes are set to come online in mid-2012, ahead of a cap-and-trade
system that could begin as early as 2015. Proponents say the tax is
necessary to force a coal-reliant country to move toward cleaner
energies. However, the tax has drawn widespread criticism from the
nation’s huge coal industry. Australia supplies 19% of the world’s
thermal coal and 59% of its coking coal; these industries are worth A$18
million and A$40 million, respectively (2009 numbers). With coal prices
expected to keep rising for the next few years at least, Australian
coal miners had big expansion plans. Instead, if the carbon tax goes
ahead, the industry says it will have to close mines, meaning major tax
and job losses for the nation. Opponents of the tax also say it will
make Australia’s own energy more expensive and less reliable.
argument against the tax is that reducing Australia’s coal output could
in fact increase global carbon emissions, because power stations in
China and India would simply use dirtier coal to fill the gap.
Australia’s thermal coal is perhaps the best in the world, with high
energy content and few impurities. Thermal coal from Indonesia has only
70% of the energy value of Australian thermal coal, which means that
much more coal would have to be mined, processed, and shipped.
the context of this very current, heated debate – the Australian
coalition government is set to meet this weekend to hammer out the
details of the tax – a new report from the Australian Bureau of
Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences shows that planned
investments in the country’s mining sector have soared to a record
A$173.5 billion. The figure represents development plans for 94
projects, including 35 mineral projects, 35 energy projects, 20
infrastructure projects, and four processing projects. The Bureau
estimates A$55.5 billion in mining-industry expenditures in the current
A fair chunk of these investments will come from coal
companies, which have money to spend because the current coal prices are
providing record profits. Xstrata, the world’s largest exporter of
thermal coal, is expected to report an 83% gain in net income this year,
according to a Bloomberg compilation of analysts’
expectations. Another good example comes from Arch Coal (N.ACI), which
recently tendered a $3.4 billion offer for International Coal Group
(N.ICO) aimed at creating Australia’s second largest metallurgical coal
China is another major coal producer, but there the
issue is coal shortages. The country’s economy is steaming ahead at a
10% growth rate, and that kind of development requires a lot of steel.
This year alone, China is facing a shortfall of 56 million tonnes of
metallurgical coal – the country is expected to produce 513 million
tonnes, but consumption will reach 569 million tonnes. The Asian giant
imported 47 million tonnes in 2010, helped by a 278% increase in imports
from Mongolia. And even though domestic coking coal production is
expected to increase by 80 million tonnes per year by 2015, China’s
latest estimates predict a 100-million-tonne annual shortfall in coking
coal by 2015.
It is not just coking coal that China needs.
Shortfalls in thermal coal supplies are the main culprit in an expected
30-million kW summer power deficit. And the problem is exacerbated by
the fact that the country’s electricity pricing system has not kept up
with coal price increases. Plants sell electricity to the State Grid
Corp. of China (SGCC) at a set price, and SGCC then resells to
consumers. But the set price has not kept pace with coal prices. As
such, coal-fired generators lose money for every ton of coal they burn,
which is not exactly an incentive to produce more power. Over the past
three years, China’s top five state-owned power generating plants have
lost some 60 billion yuan, while SGCC posted a 40-billion-yuan profit
last year alone.
China is expecting to face its worst power
shortage in years this summer. Widespread droughts, which have decimated
the country’s hydropower capacities, are not helping. As many as 20
provinces and territories have already been put on power rationing,
including the country’s industrial heartland. Some 44 major industries
in Zhejiang (a manufacturing hub near Shanghai) have been told to limit
consumption or face prohibitive tariffs. The story is much the same in
Guangdong, south China’s manufacturing hub. And producing more coal is
not an option – the government has acknowledged that China is near its
peak coal production capacity.
To continue on a familiar theme,
India is also facing an acute coal shortage. In April, for example, the
nation imported 32 million tonnes of thermal coal against a total
requirement of 36.9 million tonnes. At the end of March, 26 of India’s
thermal power stations reported having only critical stocks of coal,
including ten stations with fewer than four days’ worth of fuel. On
Monday, the prime minister convened an emergency meeting to discuss the
coal shortages, which are expected to total 112 million tonnes over the
next 12 months.
India has been working to address the coal void
for some time now. Indian firms have been scouring the globe for coal
assets, and the effort has secured several major deals: Indian
conglomerate Adani is set to buy the 25-million-tonne-per-year coal
export terminal as Abbot Point in Queensland, only a year after buying
the Galilee coal project in Australia for $2.7 billion; Indian trader
Knowledge Infrastructure signed a joint venture deal with Indonesian
miner PT OSO International to develop thermal coal mines in Kalimantan;
and three Indian firms are among those shortlisted to buy Australian
coal explorer Bandanna Energy, a deal expected to top $1 billion.
India, which produces 80% of the country’s coal, is not going to be
left out of the shopping spree. A few months ago, the company set aside
$1.2 billion for overseas buys, specifically in Australia, Indonesia,
and the U.S. And it has the money – net income for the first quarter
totaled $931 million and full-year profits were up 13%. Shares in Coal
India started trading Nov. 4 after the government raised $3.2 billion by
selling a 10% stake, in the country’s largest public offering to date.
story could go on, discussing other coal-needy countries like Japan,
South Korea, Germany, and so on, but perhaps the point has been made.
Global production is maxed out with respect to existing infrastructure,
so increases from here can only occur as quickly as new mines, rail
lines, and ports can be built. Coal prices have been climbing steadily,
based on real supply constraints, and most industry watchers agree that
they will hold their ground or continue to climb for the next few years.
Those countries with coal should count their blessings.