Guest Post: Silver Is Getting Too Popular… Right?

Tyler Durden's picture

Submitted by Jeff Clark of Casey Research

Silver Is Getting Too Popular… Right?

It’s no secret that the silver market is red hot. As I write, silver American Eagles and Canadian Maple Leafs are sold out
at their respective mints. Buying in India has gone through the roof,
especially noteworthy among a people with a strong historical preference
for gold. Demand in China continues unabated. Silver stocks have
screamed upward.

So, as an investor looking to maximize my profit,
I have a natural question: is the silver trade getting too crowded,
meaning we’re near the top? Have the masses finally joined the party
such that we should consider exiting? After all, it’s not a profit until
you take it, and you definitely want to sell near the top.

are several ways to measure how crowded the silver market might be. I
prefer to look strictly at the big picture and not get caught up in the
weeds. This means I’m looking for signs of market exhaustion or the
masses rushing in. Nothing says “peak” more than an investment everyone
is buying.

So how crowded are silver investments right now? Let’s first look at the ETFs.


$35 silver, all exchange-traded funds backed by the metal amount to
$20.7 billion. You can see how this compares to some popular stocks. All
silver ETFs combined are less than a quarter of the market cap of
McDonald’s. They’re about 10% of GE, a company that still hasn’t
recovered from the ’08 meltdown. Exxon Mobil is more than 20 times
bigger. And this isn’t even apples-to-apples, as I’m comparing the
entire silver ETF market to a few individual stocks.

This is even
more interesting when you consider that it’s the ETFs where most of the
public – especially those that are new to the market – first invest in
silver. So while the metal has doubled in the past seven months, total
investment in the funds is still far beneath many popular blue-chip

Okay, maybe all this money is instead going into silver
mining stocks. How does the market cap of the silver industry compare to
other industries?


you fetch your magnifying glass, I’ll tell you thatthe market cap of
the silver industry is $73.1 billion. It barely registers when compared
to a number of other industries I picked mostly at random. The dying
newspaper industry is over 26 times bigger. Drug manufacturers are 213
times larger. Heck, even the gold market is 19 times greater. And here’s
the fun one: the market cap of the entire silver market, with all its
record-setting prices and stock-screaming highs, represents just
one-third of one percent of the oil and gas industry.

To be fair,
there are a number of sectors that are smaller than silver. Radio
broadcasters ($43.2B), video stores ($10.9B), and sporting goods stores
($2.5B) have puny market caps, too. But then again, who's buying DVDs or
baseball mitts to protect their wealth from a coming inflation?

Silver hardly resembles the picture of an investment that is too crowded.

I’m not saying one should rush to buy silver right now. After all, it has
doubled in seven months. Unless this is the beginning of the mania,
prudence would certainly be called for at this juncture. The price will
always ebb and flow in a bull market, and an ebb is overdue. 

question, of course, is from what price level it occurs. What if a
correction doesn’t ensue until, say, a month from now, and the price
falls back to… where it is now? I remember some articles in January that
insisted silver would fall to as low as $22, and, well, they’re still
waiting and have in the meantime missed out on some huge gains. For
silver to fall back to $22 now would require a 40% drop; not impossible,
but I wouldn’t hold my breath.

Fixating on market timing takes
your focus off the ultimate goal. In my opinion, instead of worrying
about what will happen next week or even next month, focus on how many
ounces you have, and then buy at regular intervals until you reach your
desired allocation. This has the added benefit of smoothing out your
cost basis. And don’t forget to buy more as your assets and income

This is a market where you'll want to be well ahead of
the pack. Someday in the not-too-distant future, average investors will
be tripping over themselves to join in. That will make the market caps
of our silver investments look more like some of the others in the
charts above. And that will do wonderful things to our portfolio.