Morning Musings From Art Cashin - The Bubonic Plague And Healthcare Reform

Tyler Durden's picture

Via UBS Financial Services

As Told To….. – I was at an all-day, offsite seminar yesterday so this is not the usual eye-witness account but is based on input from friends. The stock market opened marginally weak but quickly changed to the upside in reaction to a sharp downside move in the dollar.

Some upbeat talk from some airlines about the “return of the passenger” combined with strength in the railroads to take the Transport Index to a new 52 week high. Since the Industrials have not made a new high that sets up a Dow Theory “confirmation” challenge. If the Industrials fail to make a new 52 week high that would set up a negative divergence, hinting a meaningful pullback in stocks.

For much of the early going the Industrials looked like they might have a go at a run toward new highs. Part of the thrust came from a series of rumors that spurred trading in the likes of Fannie, Freddie, AIG and Citi. The rumor that seemed to help them all was a zany thesis that the U.S. might ban shorting of the companies that it had a large stake in. While the rumor seemed whacky and unfounded, a rumor is not responsible for who believes in it. That became evident as buyers surged into the above-named stocks, probably on the theory that a shorting ban could cause a massive short covering rally.

Citi benefitted from a couple of other rumors. Charlie Gasparino reported on Fox that the U.S. government was looking to sell its Citi stake. That might free the company up. The stock spiked 7%. Also helping was the strong demand for some preferred shares the company was issuing.

The rumor driven frenzy in those stocks swelled the volume sharply. Monday looked like the slowest day of year, followed by the highest volume in a month. All thanks to a couple of rumors.

Shortly after 1:00, the rally in the averages seemed to sputter. The initial pull back was small. They regrouped and tried to rally again shortly after 2:00. They failed to get past the earlier high and things started to turn ugly, quickly. Bids evaporated and stocks plunged in a trapdoor selloff. They shot into negative territory.

In the final hour, they circled the wagons and regained plus territory but marginally. Unfortunately, the general volume (away from the four rumor beneficiaries) accelerated on the selloff.

What caused the sudden selloff? They were several theories. First was simply technical. The failure of the S&P to surmount its earlier intra-day high, presented a double top and a failed attempt to break through Januaries highs. That, said the napkin readers, spooked the bulls.

Some friends had another theory. Shortly after 1:00, a Wall Street Journal blog run a story on a speech by a Fed official. Here’s a bit:

For some time now, Federal Reserve officials have been hesitant to put a precise time frame on when they will begin to tighten policy, except to note the action lies well into the future.

But on Monday, one of their chief lieutenants, the man charged with implementing Fed policy, offered a pretty clear take on the likely timing of a move up in interest rates. The official, New York Fed Markets Group chief Brian Sack, has no formal role in setting monetary policy. But his position elevates his importance, and he suggested in a speech some sort of rate tightening will occur by late year.

“The current configuration of yields and asset prices incorporates expectations that short-term interest rates will begin to rise around the end of this year,” Sack told a group of economists in Virginia. “The markets seem prepared for the risks toward tighter policy,” he said, adding a “decent-sized term premium” on longer-dated yields suggests low chances of a “sizable upward shift in yields’ when that tightening comes.
Why is this observation important? Sack’s speech was entitled “Preparing for a Smooth (Eventual) Exit” from the current state of very stimulative monetary policy. If the Fed wants a tranquil exit from its current stance of 0% interest rates and if it thinks market are priced for the move, then it’s reasonable to believe a late-year increase in rates is what policy makers have penciled in.

Sack’s speech also laid out a path for the unwind. He sees the Fed draining reserves on a temporary basis, then raising rates, all the while allowing the $1.7 trillion in mortgage and Treasury assets it will have purchased by end-March to mature. Any active sales will come much later. Importantly, he said the tools to drain reserves temporarily will be in place by midyear, lending additional heft to the idea the Fed can start easing rates up off 0% by year end.

That hinted tightening could come sooner than expected. Some friends claim it caused a lot of buzz and may have contributed to the selloff.

We’ll investigate more today.

Spotty Performance – My ham radio pal passed along the latest sunspot data. For the period from February 25th through March 3rd, the numbers were 30, 26, 26, 13, 36, 39, and 39. Longtime readers will recognize that for the first three days, we had basically two spots per day. Then, we dropped to one spot followed by three days of approximately three spots per day. It’s nice to see the action but we’re still below normal. Despite the recent thaw, remember where you put that sweater.

Consensus – Assaulting January highs. Stay Nimble.

Trivia Corner

Answer - If you spell "Tennis" backward, you find the last three letters spell "Net" - a piece of equipment used in Tennis.

Today's Question - Tomorrow, today will be yesterday and yesterday, today was tomorrow. When tomorrow is yesterday, today will be as close to Sunday as today was when yesterday was tomorrow. What day is it?

And here is why fixing healthcare, whether today or in the middle ages, never works when the government gets involved:


On this day in 1349, in the midst of the infamous Black Plague epidemic, the forces of government, science and academia came together with a plan to save the people. As you recall from earlier episodes, the Black Plague had spread from the eastern Mediterranean throughout most of Europe killing millions over the preceding three years. People searched everywhere for the source of the plague…..a heavenly curse; a burden of immigrants; the result of spices in the food. It was tough to figure however, since whenever they held a conference either the host area caught the plague or the visitors did……..not too many conferences.

Then in the six months preceding this date the death rate leveled off…..or seemed to. So in castles and universities and town halls across Europe, great minds pondered the cause of the plague. And they came pretty close. The collective governmental/academic wisdom was that the source of the Black Plague was fleas - (absolutely correct). So the word went out from town to town across Europe - to stop the plague - kill the fleas -by killing all the dogs. And immediately the slaughter of all dogs began.

But like lots of well-intentioned governmental/academic ideas it was somewhat wide of the mark...and had unexpected consequences. The cause was fleas alright but not dog fleas… was rat fleas. And in the 1300's what was the most effective way to hold down the rat population… guessed it - dogs. So by suggesting that townsfolk kill their dogs, the wise authorities had unwittingly allowed the rat population to flourish and thus a new vicious rash of Black Plague began. Before it was over, three years later, nearly 1 out of 3 people in the world had died of the plague.

To mark this eventful period, take time to review your public servant’s plans for your welfare. Whether taxes or healthcare, they'll work night and day for a solution. It may not be as efficient as the way that they handled social security but - what is? Just remember that these public servants have your best interests at heart. Don't dwell on the DARK AGES. Back in those days the seat of government often was filled with rats, vermin and leeches. Thank goodness those days are over.

(Historic footnote…..Published sources say that with so many people dying, millions of estates had to be settled - result…..the fallout of the plague was a huge growth in....the number of lawyers.)

There were no carts on Wall Street with guys crying "bring out your dead" yesterday. But in mid-afternoon, the stock market looked like it needed a doctor.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
john_connor's picture

Wow, it looks like they will sacrifice the 10 year today just for a little more "juice" profit on March options.  What a bunch of jackals.

theprofromdover's picture

I made it Sunday today, but I haven't time to do this. ssshhh.

(Or today is actually today)

Anonymous's picture


Anonymous's picture

"I hope no one believes this passage, because I can't make any money off of it. Damn Occam's Razor!" - Al Gore

Spotty Performance – My ham radio pal passed along the latest sunspot data. For the period from February 25th through March 3rd, the numbers were 30, 26, 26, 13, 36, 39, and 39. Longtime readers will recognize that for the first three days, we had basically two spots per day. Then, we dropped to one spot followed by three days of approximately three spots per day. It’s nice to see the action but we’re still below normal. Despite the recent thaw, remember where you put that sweater.

IE's picture

Very nice story, Art - short sellers are the mangy dogs of today.

Anonymous's picture

Healthcare or STEALTHcare ?

E pluribus unum's picture

If you had the choise, would you rather have 100,000 shares of Citi or genital herpes? Neither seems to go away

TumblingDice's picture

I think after 1150 to 1200 resisance area its either going down to at least 800 or at least 1600. The next 400 points are going to be decided by what it down from here. My guess is that its going down from here, but I have made no bets as of yet. A euro short squeeze might end up pushing the market higher. 50 points from this point should decide the direction though.

JR's picture

As for rolling out the carts of the dead, it looks as if the government is trying to resuscitate a few battered and near-dead bank customers by administering a bit of financial oxygen, while the banksters weep crocodile tears over their victims.

Bank of America, says Karl Denninger, laments that come summer it can no longer charge 31,200% for a week’s annualized interest charged on an overdraft loan of $5 for that latte you, whoops, debt-swiped when there was no $5 in your account.  Not withstanding that the banking industry "earns" some $1,770,000,000 a year off these little transactions, the bankers’ big heart goes out to its lower income customers because, well, changes like this will "restrict credit" to those who allegedly "need" that credit most.

Says Denninger today, “I will simply observe that nobody ‘needs’ a 31,200% interest rate loan except the bank that has been given license to rob the public blind - literally.”

And adds: “If you were wondering who the Congress and Fed work for, it clearly is not you.

“The open question, and one that I cannot seem to find a reasonable answer to” says Denninger,  “is why we, the people, continue to allow both a Congress and Federal Reserve to sit in control of our government and financial system when they permit and endorse actions that constitute financial rape of such an egregious nature that absolutely everyone can understand it.”

Good question, along with Art Cashin's other "morning musings."

AnonymousMonetarist's picture


That's an original!

Me likey.

Anonymous's picture

It's a trick question because all that flummery about "when tomorrow was yesterday" HAS NOTHING WHATSOEVER TO DO WITH THE ANSWER. That because the "today" the question asks for is a day which is as close to Sunday looking forward as it is looking back. The only day of the week having that property is Sunday itself.

I suspect this was designed as a "cutting through the bullshit" question, and as we know such a skill is absolutely essential in finance, economics, and politics.

Greyzone's picture

Census hiring is starting en masse. This will give a false sense of numbers when the March and April unemployment numbers are issued. The market will likely shoot up on such news but those jobs all end by mid-summer, meaning late summer and fall should see a resurgence in unemployment. So while I don't think there is any factual basis for such a move, I am sort of expecting a sharp swing to the upside in late March or early April, lasting through May/June, brought to you courtesy of Ben "The Pump" Bernanke and Timothy "The Dump" Geithner.

merehuman's picture

Only the criminals are left in the market.

Oh i forgot the dummies and collaborators.

If this is you... ask yourself what kind of world you want to live in, and who do you really want to be?

There is honor, trust and love  or greed power and death .

I find it incomprehensible that any decent soul would trade with the enemy now that we know who it is.

At this point the seeking of profit is killing all of us and our aspirations.

Help stop the crime! Please.

CrazyCooter's picture

I read in a small biz journal once that the only historical equivalent to baby boomers retiring, as defined by "the loss of productive members of society", was the black plauge.

I think they cited a five year time frame though.

Anonymous's picture

No, the loss to society was mostly those over 65 and those under 5. The loss was to landowners as less productive farmland was abandoned to pasture and less productive pasture was abandoned to forest. Income of laboring people went up so far that the governments instituted wage controls to keep the lower classes in their place.
Didn't work.

Anonymous's picture

I have tried to use the captcha several times and it doesn't seem to work. I am going to try and solve it by trial and error.

wkwillis's picture

They didn't know what they were talking about. The plague mortality was higher for the very old and the very young.

The price of labor went sky high. People abandoned their inheirited land rights and moved to the villages after the plague, low value farmland was abandoned to pasture, low value pastureland was abandoned to forest, etc.

mark456's picture

Good linux hosting option package offered by ucvhost which not only provides the best in terms of hosting packages but also believes in truly being there for the customer, 24x7. vps web hosting Moreover , they offer unlimited bandwidth as well as nearly 1GB storage along with database maintenance, email facility along with storage, availability of sub domain and many other important features for a very low price. ucvhost thanks