Former Bridgewater-ite (which we hear is not doing that hot lately) Rick Bookstaber, who was recently appointed at the SEC in some risk management capacity, comes out with a truly amusing rant on why gold is in a bubble, and, not just that, but that "we all know gold is in a bubble." Ignore the fact that all multi-billionaire hedge fund managers have been loading up, all relevant and semi-relevant pundits have been claiming that gold is gradually becoming the one alternative to fiat debasement which has recently become a global phenomenon, and ignore that even with the dollar going up, gold has defended its 1,100 an ounce price quite successfully. Bookstaber compiles vivid imagery upon even more vivid imagery, and goes as far as comparing the quest for gold with the pursuit of hookers "Even if a guy is just after sex, he at least has the decency to act like there is some substance behind his interest. But with gold, no one seems even to
care about giving a justification, other than “gold has been a store of
value throughout 5,000 years of monetary history”. No one? Dear Mr. Bookstaber, feel free to peruse the following thoughts by Eric Sprott, Dylan Grice, Hugh Hendry, David Rosenberg, Fred Hickey, Jim Grant, David Einhorn and last but not least, Goldman Sachs, on some contrarian opinions to your prevailing dogma. And speaking of unconflicted advance warning vis-a-vis ponzi bubbles, where was your current employer cautioning the general population about the dot com bubble? Or the housing/credit bubble? Or the Madoff ponzi? Or the current Great Currency Deflation Bubble? Perhaps you can expend your time and energy on the real source of soon-to-be unparalleled wealth loss instead of focusing on the fringe "tin foil"-hatted gold community which nobody takes seriously anyway (except India of course which just incidentally bought 200 tons of gold north of $1,000).
From the SEC-member's blog:
This represents my personal opinion, not the views of the SEC or its staff.
I am not going to spend time here talking about how the price of
gold is off-the-wall, that it is not just a bubble in the making, but a
bubble waiting to burst. I don’t want to waste your time on that
point.We all know it is a bubble.
George Soros has said “The ultimate asset bubble is gold”. Many of
the top asset managers, such as Tudor and Paulson, are piling on; Paul
Tudor Jones recently said gold “has its time and place, and now is that
time.” The banks are echoing this view with their research. Goldman has
a research piece that looks for gold to approach $1,400 in the next
year. The more ebullient Charles Morris of HSBC has said, “I absolutely
believe it’s heading into a bubble, but that’s why you buy it. ” He,
along with a number of other professional and otherwise rational
managers, looks for gold to move as high as $5,000 an ounce.
More interesting than this almost universal agreement is what that agreement tells us about the dynamics of the market.
The Naked Bubble
Usually the markets have the
courtesy of giving cover for bubbles. We adorn the bubbles with some
justification. Even if a guy is just after sex, he at least has the
decency to act like there is some substance behind his interest. For
the Internet bubble, it was that fundamental analysis based on the
brick and mortar world did not bear relevance in the New Paradigm. For
the Nikkei bubble, it was that the crazy P/E ratios were not
considering one subtlety or another in the Japanese accounting system.
But with gold, no one seems even
to care about giving a justification, other than “gold has been a store
of value throughout 5,000 years of monetary history”. Which is fine as
far as it goes, but that doesn’t say anything about what the price of
that store of value should be.
Pump and Dump
Given that “hedge fund” and “highly secretive” are usually said in
the same breath, don’t you get suspicious when so many of the top
managers are so vocally out there about their gold investments? And
when their positions are structured in a way that make them open to
view? Paulson and Soros have huge positions in gold ETFs. We know that,
because if you buy ETFs, they show up in your 13-F filing. Granted,
with an equity investment you can’t help putting that information out
into the market, but with an asset there are plenty of ways to take the
position without signaling it.
That they are taking a highly
visible route to their positions suggests the game that is being played
is one of leading the herd. The 13-F reports positions with a big lag,
so no one will notice if they quietly slip out the side door while the
party is still hopping. And how about when the view is backed up by
none other than Goldman Sachs? Will they let everyone know when they
think it has gone too far before they get out. Or before they go short?
Maybe they already have.
Herds, crowds, mobs, and the Top Ten
And yet, we follow the herd, as we have countless times in the
past. Herding is a timeless and universal market behavior, but one that
seems less than rational. It is broader than markets; think of the Top
Ten phenomenon. We feel better if a lot of other people think that our
favorite artist or actor is The Best. We like a song better if we know
a lot of other people are liking it as well. Thus our love affair with
lists. Magazines featuring the Ten Sexiest, the Five Best, the 100
Whatever are all best sellers, even if the list is the product of a
story meeting between an editor and five reporters.
Herding can be explained as an
artifact of what was rational behavior in earlier times, when we were
running around as hunter gatherers. Back then, mob and herding behavior
made sense. Mob behavior if attacking a competitive group or killing a
large animal; herding behavior if protecting against predators or
uprooting to a new location. Whatever it was that got started, you
could be pretty sure there was safety in having a crowd on hand to
The very notion of mobs and herds evokes a certain spontaneity. But
with the gold bubble, we are moving on to a concept of herding by
appointment. Everyone seems to be happy in agreeing that this is a
bubble, and we are all going to participate in this bubble in a
rational, genteel way. We have all decided that this is going to be a
number one hit, a Top Ten. Though we might want to ask who is leading
this herd, because my bet is they will be stepping aside and cheering
us over the cliff.