SS Trust Fund - "We lost $1.1 Trillion last year!"

Bruce Krasting's picture
Yes, that is a correct headline. In its annual report to Congress last
week SS acknowledged that its condition had sharply deteriorated in
2010. This sentence from the report is all you really need to know about
what the status is:

The open group unfunded obligation over the 75-year projection period has increased from $5.4 trillion (present discounted value as of January 1, 2010) to $6.5 trillion (present discounted value as of January 1, 2011).

Note that this is a present value calculation. The total unfunded
obligation has grown by a cool $1.1 trillion in just a year. In other
words, if we had to shore up the TF to the level that it was just a year
ago the USA would have to write a check for $1.1 T. The unfunded status
was a disaster a year ago at $5.6T, it got worse by 20% during 2010.
The cost of “fixing” SS goes up as a result. To put things in balance
one of these two extremes are now required:

For the combined OASDI Trust Funds to remain solvent, the payroll tax rate could be increased an immediate and permanent 2.15%, (or) scheduled benefits could be reduced by an immediate and permanent 13.8%.

If you think this a ho-hum result, think again. If benefits get cut
across the board by 14% we will have many seniors who will fall into a
hole. An increase in payroll taxes of 2.15% is simply not going to
happen anytime soon. There is no support in Congress for an increase
like that. It would mean that taxes on all workers/employers would have
to go up by $110b in the first year and rise every year thereafter. This
would be a very regressive tax increase that hurts lower end workers
the hardest. For 2011 there is already a payroll tax holiday of 2%. If
the required increases take place in 2012 it would mean a 3.2% reduction
in wages. Kiss the economy goodbye under that scenario.

I underlined the TF’s use of the words immediate and permanent as this language highlights the fact there can be no delaying on the fixes necessary at SS. One thing that you can take to the bank is that nothing will happen with SS in 2011 or 2012.
This is a problem that will simmer for at least another 24 months. This
delay will prove to be very costly for all involved. Both the required
tax increases and/or the required cutbacks will be much larger than

The NPV of the unfunded liabilities at SS are now growing by at least
$100b a month. One would think that this massive cost would spur some
response in D.C. Don’t count on it. As a result, SS is going to come off the rails in about two years.