Savings Rate Plunges To Lowest In One Year As US Consumer Once Again Tapped Out

Tyler Durden's picture

Today's personal income and spending report for the month of September was just the latest datapoint confirming that the US consumer is once again massively cash-strapped and is eating, literally, into their savings. While Personal Income rose at the expected pace of 0.4%, Spending in the last month came well above expectations of 0.6%, printing at 0.8%, which meant that on a net basis Consumers, always hopeful, outspent themselves by a margin of 0.4%. This meant that the savings rate declined from 3.7% in August to a tiny 3.3% in September. This was the lowest Savings print in 2012, and higher only compared to last November's 3.2%, which in turn was the lowest print since the start of the second great depression. In other words, overeager consumers saw their nominal incomes increase... and decided to outspend said rise at double the rate of increase! At this pace, by the time Thanksgiving rolls out, US consumers will have no savings at all left to tap and living will be strictly a month to month activity.

But wait, it gets worse. As the second chart below shows, the real story was that of the Real, not Nominal, Disposable Income, adjusted for the cost of living, which declined for the second consecutive month, and shows that the peak this year took place in July, having declined consistently ever since. In other words, even real incomes are now consistently declining, spending aside.

Based on this data, the US consumer is tapped out, has hit peak earnings power, and is looking at a holiday season where spending is expected to ramp up drastically with empty bank accounts and maxed out credit cards. But at least "housing has bottomed."

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Shizzmoney's picture


I really don't understand how these fucking people are "confident" about the economy.  I guess they are only asking employed and well paid white people.

GetZeeGold's picture



CD or gold. Savings account or gold.


Hold on....I'm thinking about it.

CPL's picture

Silver and gold are about to get unmanipulated.


With all the casuals and their Algo's and HFT's offline we might have an honest trade happening over the next couple of days.  Go figure, awful storm keeps all the assholes offline.

Translator's picture

Black folks just want a welfare check from Obama, right?

CrimsonAvenger's picture

Don't forget Obama phone. Keep Obama in president, you know?

GetZeeGold's picture



Let's hope so....unless you want to deal with all the screaming freakin crying girls running loose without birth control.


asteroids's picture

Don't worry about putting gas in your car or paying your mortgage, Obama's got you covered:


DosZap's picture

Black folks just want a welfare check from Obama, right?

There are tons of white/ hispanic trash that are exactly the same trust me I know some.

This has been the Obowells plan from day one, get as many on the free dole as possible,get em addicted to free shit, and after two stints at 99 weeks, you lose the WANT to support yourself, and work.You lose desire, and hope, and get the lazy ass.

PLUS, the Avg Fed workers income is 35% above the Natl Average...........35%...............think about it.

Plus there are no jobs worth a damn, unless you have specific skill sets.

Good morning and welcome to Wal Murt.

vinayjha's picture

Don't Ben is ready with his helicopter. I am waiting for the day his helicopter crashes with stock market.


jeff314's picture

fuck you bernanke

Translator's picture

but but but the O'Bowel administration just reported consumer confidence at 5 year highs.......



What HASN'T Obama lied about?

rbg81's picture

This is not a surprise.  Food continues to go up bigtime.  Healthcare premiums & copays are going up.   Tuition goes up 6% per year.  Utilities, cell phone and cable service always goes up, never down.  Mortgages may be cheap, but property taxes continue to rise.  Gas bounces around between $3.75 to $4.00.  Incomes remain flat.  So going into debt is the only way to survive for 80% of the country.

odatruf's picture

Might be nice if people tried going without some iShit before going into so much debt. Here is a good acid test before you pull out your Visa / Mastercard: if your grandparents did need it to get by, neither do you. If you still one want anyway, you better be paying cash.

gmak's picture

Change "Obama lied about?" to "any Presidential Administration (ever) lied about?"

Translator's picture




I am too big of a lying coward to admit that Obama has lied about everything!




toady's picture


Everyone knows obama lies about everything.

And romney lies so much he can't keep track of them. I don't know how many times I've seen him be pro/anti war, pro/anti bailout pro/anti abortion.... he's pro/anti anything depending on the crowd, just like obama.

Ron Paul 2012!

gtb's picture

Obama is in a league of his own.  I defy anyone to name one thing about which the SOB has told the truth.  A real brain teaser, heh?

toady's picture

I won't be dragged into defending that bastard.

I'm just saying i've rarely seen someone as obviously two-faced as romney.

We've all seen them, they tell you one thing then argue against it at a meeting, tell your wife one thing and your girlfriend another, leaving you stuck in the middle.

Damn it! I told myself I wouldn't let myself be dragged into this shit!

Ron Paul 2012!

DosZap's picture

 I defy anyone to name one thing about which the SOB has told the truth.  A real brain teaser, heh?


Got ya one!, he promised to Fundamentally Change America,he damn sure has kept that promise.

Brown Shirts and all.

Buckaroo Banzai's picture

Let's be clear: Romney is a flip-flopper and a waffler, not a liar.

Obama doesn't waffle, he either just flat-out lies, or covers up the truth, or both.

toady's picture

I'm not so sure.. I think romney is just spinning, spinning, spinning, hoping to get just the right amount of confusion. It's a subtle way to lie, but it's still lying.

obama appears to believe his lies, so that can be confusing too.

What's really an awful lie is the media buying it all, hook, line & sinker.

alstry's picture

SAVINGS?  What a ridiculous concept.

In modern economic systems, savings is simply loaning non specific debts of others to banks....and the banks are bankrupt. When our systems are failing, it is the system that is paramount.  Anyone holding gold on the systemic failure of the Titanic simply became an anchor.

For Thousands Of Years People Benefited From Trading The Production Of Themselves And Others

Innovative Technology Is Now Efficiently Replacing The Need For Humans To Traditionally Produce


There is ZERO HEDGE when we all milking each others' debts and the world is bankrupt in the

Today we learn the world does not need millions of people needlessly walking around meaningless jobs on Wall Street unsustainably consuming resources.  In fairness to NY, it is far more sustainable than most of the worthless suburbs around America.

GCT's picture

Look out all we now have Alstry here.  He is better then MDB!  This should be fun.  Be warned Alstry ZH is a fight club and will most likely not want to read about your social credit or another name for the welfare system!

ZeroAvatar's picture

alstry's hoping he can funnel some viewers over to his website in order to cash in google clicks.


1.  See alstry comment


2. Downvote (red arrow)


3.  Scroll to next comment


So easy a caveman can do it!

Meatballs's picture

Broke Bitchezzz!


Temporalist's picture

It's a Kleptocrat Tsunami!  Clear the beaches!  Every taxpayer prepare!

LongSoupLine's picture

don't worry, that's what credit is for...


i mean, what's the worst that can happen?

oh, wait...nevermind.

BrigstockBoy's picture

"Hey, we're losing all our damn money, and Christmas is around the corner, and I ain't gonna have no money to buy my son the G.I. Joe with the kung-fu grip!"

max2205's picture

SantaBama has a shiny new cell phone just for you

odatruf's picture

hasn't been toys that cool in years...

max2205's picture

Why are futures trading!?

Another big move for equities to gap to Wed most likely.

pods's picture

Didn't earning power peak in the 70's?

Now 2 incomes are lower than 1 in the 70s.


Frastric's picture

If we can get to 0% savings in the next few months then we can have one last hurrah...

And party likes it 2012!

Long-John-Silver's picture

Saving Dollars is stupid. Converting your Dollars to Gold and Silver and saving that is smart.

Bruce's picture

Real income declining due to QE (read DM, or debt monetization)-induced inflation, plus a dearth of jobs that pay a decent wage. Food and gas prices up for anyone eating or driving.  Healthcare costs soon to be up even more under Obamacare.  Real wages down.  The Fed may temporarily goose the markets (supposed "wealth effect"), but it has been shown to be insignificant (Hoisington Investment Mgmnt. Q3 Review and Outlook must read here: ).  So small/no boost from QE/DM, and resulting inflation spike soon follows.  Next phase further recession.  The Fed is inept and useless.  The result is intuitively obvious to the most casual observer: econ. contraction soon to follow.  Rinse and repeat.

madcows's picture

Inflation is the Fed's goal.  It's the only way out of debt.  By making the dollar worth less, the debt's are easier to pay off.

But, the Fedtards don't understand that there are different types of inflation.  Debt devaluation through inflation only works if the people have money to burn... that is, the type of inflation where there are too many dollars chasing too few items.

These Fedtards are doing the exact wrong type of inflation.  They are destroying the value of the dollar by buying bonds, etc.... but the money isn't going into circulation.  Thus, they are driving up inflation without the people ever touching the paper.  Essential goods become more expensive.  The people buy fewer and fewer non-essentials.  GDP continues to sputter.  The Fed gooses more.  Essentials continue to climb.  The people go on welfare or EBT or SSDI.

This is bad inflationary policy.  If inflation is the root out, at least give the money to the people to spend.  But, of course, this isn't the desire of the Fed.  They keep the dollars, and make money with it.  They keep the banks gorging on low interest debt.  They keep the government going on fiat dollars.  Destroy the Fed.  They are the real cause of this mess.


grid-b-gone's picture

Before 2008, people spent maybe 10% of their income on things they didn't need, often didn't even want.

Mall shoppers shopped out of habit. Timeshares, magazine subscriptions barely or never read, long-term RV, ATV, or jet ski payments that were rarely used and may have required storage fees. When not buying out of habit, we'd eat out of habit.

Even still today, we have billions of dollars worth of clothes in closets with tags still hanging, guns never fired sitting in cabinets, books never cracked open, and DVDs and board games still in cellophane.

This is the string on which the Fed pushes. The richest society in the history of man, with its huge, post-war generation peaking, has discovered it was working for trinkets, sitting in production-maxing cubicles like caged laying chickens, singularly pursuing more for the sake of growth at the expense of precious time.

In the physical world, growth naturally leads to maturity, eating leads to expelling, inhaling leads to exhaling, hightide leads to lowtide, apogee leads to perigee, and inflation leads to flacidity.

Push that string until it looks like the snake river. Push that theoretical model as far beyond the laws of nature as you wish, even to the extent of pushing the currency into extinction. Natural forces will fix it all, eventually.

Taffy Lewis's picture

Aw c'mon people, Bloomberg news says it's "a sign the biggest part of the economy was picking up as the quarter drew to a close". Green shoots.

adsanalytics's picture

The chart of Income - Spending just took a dive south (after the jump) into a clearly unsustainable situation. Another poor sign is that personal income is largely driven by government transfers rather than wage growth.

lolmao500's picture

And now just imagine the saving rate in October and November after Sandy wipes out the east coast...

LawsofPhysics's picture

Yes, but think of the taxable income that will be generated by the rebuilding. < sarc off >  Paul Krugman likes broken windows....


Robslob's picture


Merry this pace forget Thanksgiving or Christmas...!

Yellowhoard's picture

So what that the world is spiraling into WWIII.

So what that race relations have never been worse.

So what that peoples savings are being gutted.

So what that we are becoming a flat out police state.

Obama has a sweet jump shot. He single handedly killed OBL.

Obama/Biden 2012! Let's finish the job!

madcows's picture

Government malfeasance and corporate kleptocracy are coming home to roost.  I sure am glad we bailed out the banks and unions.  I'll sleep well knowing they are well fed and warm with my dollars in their pockets.

virgilcaine's picture

Hello..The Currency needs to be worth something for incentive to SAVE..= epic fed fail (2) The last thing the Fed wants is a bunch of frugal Savers.. go out and spend sheeple!

Being Free's picture

the US consumer is once again massively cash-strapped and is eating, literally, into their savings

and of course as the savings decline the earned interest on the savings is taking a massive hit, plummeting from 0.04 to 0.03 Bernanks/mo.

Oh the humanity!

yrbmegr's picture

Why should consumers have the money?  It does nobody any good in the hands of consumers.

virgilcaine's picture

"dipping into their savings" ie.. going into credit card debt. Only in the bernanks fantasy world is this savings. They are broke u beared bufoon!

Seasmoke's picture

I had well over 30k "saved" until they slashed my available credit balances below 5K