This page has been archived and commenting is disabled.
Guest Post: CFNAI: Not Seeing The Growth Economists' Predict
Via Lance Roberts of Street Talk Live,
In a post by my friend Cullen Roche at PragCap he pointed out that many economists are suggesting that the second estimate of Q3 GDP, which showed an initial estimate of 2.0% annualized growth, will be revised sharply upward to 2.8%. This 2.8% bump in annualized growth comes on the heels of a very sluggish Q2 growth rate of 1.3%. If Cullen's observations of economic growth in the third quarter is correct it suggests much more than just a mild pickup in the economic underpinnings of personal consumption expenditures, private investment, government spending and net exports but rather something much more material. This would be welcome news for the millions of individuals on extended unemployment gains as such a surge in economic activity will be reflected by increasing employment as businesses gear up to meet increasing demand.
The problem is that the surge in demand isn't materializing at the manufacturing level. For example, it is worth remembering that ex-government defense spending, which jumped $30 billion after being flat in the previous two quarters, the growth rate in initial Q3 estimate would be 1.3% rather than 2.0%. Therefore, that jump in defense spending, which requires manufacturing, should be showing a bump in new orders for manufactured products. Furthermore, if personal consumption expenditures and private investment (i.e. residential construction) are improving then, likewise, there should be improvement in the overall manufacturing makeup as components are required for assembly.
Unfortunately, that has yet to be the case.
The most recent release of the Chicago Fed National Activity Index (CFNAI), which is a broad measure of 85 subcomponents, declined to a -.56 in October after improving sharply from a -1.13 in August to 0.00 in September. The chart below shows the index versus its 6-month average.
More importantly the diffusion index also deteriorated from -0.14 in September to -0.32 in October which is the lowest level since July 2009. The difference, of course, is that in 2009 the index was rising as the economy was surging due to massive fiscal stimulus. That is not the case now.
Yes, this is just one measure, albeit a very broad one, of economic activity and it is also posting October numbers very late in the month of November. So, what about other manufacturing indexes - surely those are showing improvement, right?
Maybe not? The Dallas Fed Reserve just released their regional manufacturing survey for November which dropped from 1.8 in October to -2.8 in November. Furthermore, the future activity component plunged from 16.8 to -5.3. As a reminder the Dallas Fed region is one of the strongest economic regions in the country (Texas) and if there was a pickup in economic activity occurring it should be showing up.
The chart below, as discussed many times before, is the STA economic composite index which is comprised of the CFNAI, ISM, Chicago PMI, several Fed regions and the NFIB Small Business Index. This is an extremely broad economic composite index which should be seeing incremental pickups in economic activity. Unfortunately, that is not the case as the index declined from 28.68 to 27.73 in October. I have smoothed the data using a 6-month average which shows the overall trend more clearly.
Maybe it is in the housing market? Many economists have been pointing to the resurgence in real estate related activity as a potential catalyst for continued economic expansion. The problems with this thesis are several. First, the majority of the gains seen in housing starts in recent months have come from seasonal adjustments rather than actual activity. This was shown in detail in our previous report on housing activity but most recently seen in the October report where it was reported that on a seasonally adjusted basis new home starts surged from 863,000 to 894,000 whereas the non-seasonally adjusted data saw just 100 new homes started as the number rose to 77,900 from 77,800 in October.
Secondly, the activity has been primarily in the rental unit space, as David Rosenberg points out:
"All the gains were in the volatile multi-family segment which soared 11.9% to a 300k annualized unit pace, the highest since July 2008 (the month that Fannie and Freddie blew up). In July, just a short three months ago, apartment starts were sitting at 222k units. That is a mind numbing 233% annual rate of increase in that time frame. Whatever demand for rentals looks like - and I am sure it remains strong - it can't possibly match that."
The problem with all of this is that while looking at annualized data is interesting it is the non-seasonally adjusted data that builders are looking at when making hiring decisions. This is why there has been NO increase in the employment of residential construction workers at this point.
Lastly, while it is very true that housing and economic recovery go hand-in-hand, it is important to remember that the residential construction story makes up just a little more than 2% of economy and just 0.1% of the equity market. Therefore, even if the resurgence in housing activity is real, and sustainable, its impact on the overall economic recovery will remain somewhat subdued.
Headwinds Growing
My friend Doug Short does an excellent job in tracking the primary economic components each month as shown in the chart/table below. The month-over-month data has begun to show signs of deterioration as of late which doesn't support the idea of a sharp rebound in economic activity in recent months.
The point here is that if the expectations of the majority of economists are correct then we should be seeing activity filtering into the system. Yet, what we are currently witnessing, from a broad measure of indicators, is deterioration in forward outlooks. This has been witnessed not only in the manufacturing reports, such as the CFNAI and Dallas Fed Region surveys where forward expectations were sharply reduced, but also in many of the corporate earnings and guidance's this quarter.
Cullen is correct that the economy is not currently in a recession and Doug's work confirms the same. However, as I stated last week, what is important is where the trend of the data is going.
"...with economic growth currently in a declining trend, earnings deteriorating as the Eurozone slips back into recession, and employment and wages likely to be negatively impacted - that optimistic forecast will be revised lower. Furthermore, the raft of bailout and stimulus programs, enacted during the first two years of the current Administration, are now fading out of the system. The lack of further stimulative support, combined with rising taxes in 2013, will impede economic growth further."
The headwinds to economic growth are gaining strength as the tailwinds from stimulus related support programs fade. Increasing tax rates, implementation of ObamaCare, increased regulations and Eurozone related weakness on exports all drag on future economic growth. Later this week we will get the second estimate of 3rd quarter GDP which will give us some clues about the real direction and strength of the economy. While I sincerely hope that the majority of economists are correct in their assumptions - I have a nagging suspicion that we might be disappointed with the actual number.
»
- 7117 reads
- Printer-friendly version
- Send to friend
- advertisements -
Infinite Growth... Finite Planet = FAIL
Well what do they expect? There is no time for people to work when they are busy collecting money by going to college.
I thought the obama phone website got taken down after that video but it seems to be back up. http://obamaphone.net/ It makes my heart warm to think I'm not limiting someone's communication to what they can afford. After all, Michelle Obama doesn't limit her vacations to what she can afford. What a great example she sets!
Holy shit. Kitco showing gold down $34 and silver down $2.33. Did the world just end?
No. The end of the world is scheduled for 12/21/12. That's a Friday. After that, please consult the Jehovah Witnesses for the next scheduled end of the world.
FUBAR --------
I am long bullshit.
29 Nov 2012 8:30 AM ET. We'll know soon...not that this estimate means all that much.
FORWARD!
SOVIET!
Get yer own gig!
If we just adjust the seasonal adjustments, all the numbers will look great.
We are not in a recession? Got news for the delusional: we never left the last one, unless of course you really believe all those gubmint numbers; well do ya punk?
always with the negative waves... [/oddball]
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KuStsFW4EmQ&feature=fvwrel
...why don't you say something righteous and hopeful for a change? [/sarc.]
And we'd have seen that middling growth too if weren't for that pesky Hurricane Sandy! Damn you Sandy!!
With inflation at 8% and GDP at 2% looks like negative growth.
More like just Inflation standard.
Hussman (aka Mary f-ing Poppins) would be happy with this article. Hussman also noted the CFNAI contradicts the notion of recovery.
many economists are suggesting ...will be revised sharply upward to
What? Were they phds? Who listens to economists?
Eddie Bauer North Face Jackets for men
The collection of Eddie Bauer North Face Fleece Clearance for men gives many different classy jackets all of which might be designed with high quality leather-based, fantastic lining elements, and therefore are designed with high-quality and workmanship. Decide on form among several models such as blazers, car coats, and Trip jackets all of which are existing developments and major from the line designs for men. The selection of jackets obtainable with the assortment of Eddie Bauer North Face Jackets for men are made to final and so are priced affordably.
A person with the most favored jackets in the collection of Eddie Bauer north face jackets on sale for men is definitely the Suede Blazer. What's good about this individual coat is always that it can be washable suede making it possible for for your good deal of versatility and lower servicing. The well-known Eddie Bauer washable suede blazer is fashioned with high quality leather, a vented back, enhanced fitting shoulder and leading polyester lining. This can be essential have jacket for your male on the go and also a top choice in the assortment of Eddie Bauer North Face Jackets for men. Offered in java or tan the fashionable jacket retails for about $200.00.
The Leather-based Journeyman Jacket is yet another with the top rated style possibilities from among the many assortment of Eddie Bauer North Face Jackets for men. This unique jacket can be a famed preference by aviators and remains a prime decide on among the men on the lookout for a top quality leather-based jacket. Comprised of high quality leather-based using a polyester lining, the up to date styled jacket functions zip front closure, slit pockets, and it is accessible in both tan or java. This really is a great alternative of jackets notably for anyone who is updating your wardrobe. The trendy jacket through the selection of Eddie Bauer North Face Jackets for men retails for approximately $249.00.
In the event you require a coat which you can have on each day and however wish to make a fashion declaration a leading decide from your 2012 collection of Eddie Bauer North Face Jackets for men is the Leather-based Vehicle Coat. This can be a superb jacket that is definitely nicely produced, handsome seeking and surely built for any guy. It has a rugged fashionable look whilst nonetheless getting dressy ample to pair with your favored slacks. The Eddie Bauer Leather Car or truck Coat is made out of superior quality leather-based and characteristics a Thinsulate lining which is obtainable in tan or java. The fashionable coat from Eddie Bauer [NorthFace Govles Sale http://www.pandajackets.com/shop-equipment-northface-govles-sale-c-24_25...] for men retails for about $299.00 from Eddie Bauer.