Charlie Munger Slams HFT: "They Are Like Rats In A Granary"

Tyler Durden's picture

None other than status-quo-hugger Berkshire Hathaway's Charlie Munger took aim at the scourge of HFT this morning; blasting high-frequency traders as "the functional equivalent of letting rats into a granary," and exclaims "it does the rest of civilization no good at all." Buffett reminds that HFT is "not a liquidity provider, " explaining that while it does produce volume, that is not the same as liquidity; and while the Oracle opines (incorrectly) that the small investor has never had it so good, Munger is quick to point out that the money HFT makes does not come from heaven and in fact it is the small investor who is hurt by the fact that large investors (who mostly act on small investors' behalf) are severely impacted. Even the usually abstinent Bill Gates remarks upon HFT as "adding no value.. because when the liquidity is needed, it isn't there." Munger sums it up: "I don't like it."



Buffett added, "It's not a liquidity provider. It may create more volume but that's not the same as being a liquidity provider,"

In addition, "To the extent that it is front running, I think society has generally been against front running for good reasons... Here they've gained an advantage by figuring out how the system worked and getting there first and that adds nothing to economic activity."

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
CPL's picture

And they've eaten all the grain for a coming winter.  Nobody wins, everyone loses something.

Sudden Debt's picture

That's why the crickets should tax the ants more and also impose a fairness cut on their supplies

Stackers's picture

So says King Rat himself.

MontgomeryScott's picture

Buffett and Munger are just pissed because they didn't think of doing it first.

Pure Evil's picture

I don't get it.

HFT is the moral equivalent of Federal and State governments.

They front run your paycheck every week while telling you they provide services.

You would think these state apparatchiks would be all for it.

Oh, I get it, they don't like it cause the HFT rats are also infesting their granaries.

Guess they don't like to pay out more than anyone else.

boogerbently's picture

It's unanimous, HFT's suck.


jbvtme's picture

says the fox guarding the hen house

Soul Glow's picture

"They are like rats with gold sewn into their colons."

- Charlie "Cockface" Munger

Vampyroteuthis infernalis's picture

Well Mr. Munger, I suggest you suck it up!

Four chan's picture

who woke this guy up 10 years after the fact? go back to sleep charles.

Vampyroteuthis infernalis's picture

Well Mr. Munger, I suggest you suck it up!

imapopulistnow's picture

Buffet, Munger and Gates are three very wise and rational men.  They also are three very honest individuals.  

My only criticism is that Buffet and Gates are too diplomatic and subtle when discussing progressive policies and views that keep the economy from growing and creating jobs.  

But I suppose this is why they are successful and why I am posting on a blog site.

boogerbently's picture


What does Gates know about business or Buffet/Munger know about investing ?

venturen's picture

Buffet is a Goldman enabler and whore!!!

Itchy and Scratchy's picture

Nominated for comment of the month! Well done!

Canadian Dirtlump's picture

NO kidding. THere is a disturbing amount of satanic horsepower on that panel.

U4 eee aaa's picture


I had that same thought

Pinto Currency's picture

But the Fed and other cb's blowing bubbles for decades is okay.


Ignatius's picture

Talk about anything but their bailouts.

I just flushed a munger minutes ago.

Greenskeeper_Carl's picture

It's cute when guys like him jump on board with this kind of stuff. As if they weren't entirely dependent o the rigged system. I went to the Florida campaign for liberty a little but ago, and they had a warren Buffett guy there, pushing the warren Buffett term limits plan. Couldn't even take the guy seriously because he was there at the behest of the biggest corporate welfare queen on the planet, mr TARP himself. These guys act like they want to change things, when in reality they are entirely dependent on the status quo.

LawsofPhysics's picture

Apparently you have never had the pleasure of tasting a brazed rodent...

CPL's picture

I wish I could say I haven't but it taste's fine depending on the street meat vendor and where you are in the world.

Greenskeeper_Carl's picture

I probably have too. There is no telling what kind of 'meat' they were using in shwarma alley in Bahrain. It was quite tasty though.

Herodotus's picture

Rats loose in a granary...reminds me of the opening scene in one of those famous Third Reich propaganda films that they show on the History Channel with rats scurring about between the bags of grain... I wonder if that was the image that old Charlie had in his mind from the 1930's?


Sudden Debt's picture

these kids are our future... I wonder how they would adress a problem like HFT robbing...

ps: those are national speaker winners...


Sudden Debt's picture

ehe... those are students who had to take on 150K of student debt each to arrive there...

The 2014 Cross Examination Debate Association's national championship was held at Indiana University. The all African American female team from Towson University defeated the all African American male team from the University of Oklahoma. Though this may be a first for African American women, it is not a real win for women or African Americans, but a loss for collegiate debate specifically and America in general. I am not sure what the winners won, but it certainly wasn't a debate. However, to be fair to the participants, the quality of collegiate debate began to deteriorate long before 2014. All white teams won prior championships using a similar fast-talking style. However from what I can tell, in the past the fast talk, what little could actually be understood, was at least related to the topic supposedly being debated. This farce would be funny if it wasn't so sad. However it does provide a shocking example as to why America is a nation in decline.

Chief Wonder Bread's picture

That is way scarier than what's happening in Ukraine imho.

espirit's picture

Lowering the bar has advantages for the oligarchs.

Chief Wonder Bread's picture

Jesus H Christ. I'm gonna shoot myself in the head.

Snidley Whipsnae's picture

Sudden Debt... I listened to the 'debate' on a FS link. I could not determine how the winners were selected... Unless it was the greatest number of times one particular word, allowed to be used only by one ethnic group, was used during the 'debate'. 

After listening to the debate twice I didn't have a clue what the hell they were debating.

Thats probably a good thing.

Ralph Spoilsport's picture

Multiculturalism in action. Here's an example of where this crap comes from:

"The Process of Cultural Competence in the Delivery of
Healthcare Services
(Campinha-Bacote, 1998a) is a model
that views cultural competence as the ongoing process in
which the health care provider continuously strives to achieve
the ability to effectively work within the cultural context of
the client (individual, family, community). This model
requires health care providers to see themselves as
becoming culturally competent rather than already being culturally
competent. This process involves the integration of cultural
awareness, cultural knowledge, cultural skill, cultural
encounters, and cultural desire."

Snidley Whipsnae's picture

"This model
requires health care providers to see themselves as
becoming culturally competent rather than already being culturally
competent. This process involves the integration of cultural
awareness, cultural knowledge, cultural skill, cultural
encounters, and cultural desire."

Ralph... I am not an anatomy whiz but always thought that the anatomical make up of all humans, regardless of ethnicity, were very similar if not identical.

Where did I go wrong?

Ralph Spoilsport's picture

It's all about the money as well as telling health care workers they better tow the multicultural line when dealing with patients. The verbal diarrhea of Josepha Campinha-Bacote  is inflicted upon nursing students and doctors as required reading. Students have to purchase her study "tools" to take exams. You have to give her credit for realizing that she can peddle her wares better by using the word "cultural" as many times as possible.

Snidley Whipsnae's picture


I can see where I went awry. All the time I have been thinking in terms of health care being the goal to keep all the people as healthy as possible.

I didn't realize that a different set of health procedures would be needed for green people than for purple people and that Dr.s and nurses better damn well know it and act accordingly.

In hindsight it's so obvious that an ingrown toenail for a green person would need completely different treatment than the same ailment for a purple person.

Thanks for getting me current on how fubar the entire system has become.

Poster above is correct... this is scarier than Ukraine situation.

Ralph Spoilsport's picture

On a lighter note, here's one of her cheerleaders who is so competent that she can't spell competent correctly in the title to the article she got paid to put up.

Snidley Whipsnae's picture

"She spends much of her time consulting for the Department of Health and Human Services on HRSA grants, working with universities to make sure concepts such as ethnopharmacology are integrated into the curricula."

Busy lady that has carved out a niche for herself with HRSA grants and other troughs. You're right, her cheerleader needs spell check. lol ... She will probably soon be head of NIH or something similar.

btw... Once I was looking at various university endowment funds and Case Western Reserve popped up as the leader (most money). At the time I had not heard of CWReserveU. They do a good job of staying below the radar.

NotAMathWhiz's picture

These kinds of things make me wonder about the future for 'The Onion'.

Boxed Merlot's picture

these kids are our future...


Not mine. 

Absolutely incredible.  And that's to be celebrated?  I was taught the louder and faster one spoke, the less credible the information.  Not only that, but their repetition even lacked the necessary cadence to allow the use of their words to function as possible jingoes.  (I must confess, I only lasted for less than a minute)

This is not to say the 3 blind mice being interviewed on CNBC are any more credible by speaking in more "civil" tones.


Whatever happened to purpose and reason?



Greenskeeper_Carl's picture

Ya that's how I was taught too. Resorting to telling and talking really fast pretty much means you lost. And they didn't even mention restricting the presidents war powers that I noticed. Just talked about 'racism', which is funny. Read schiffs article on about these people, and these so called debates. This is sad if this is the future of this country, but I'm afraid it is. Giving minority children special treatment just because they are minorities is giving them a license to underachieve.

LawsofPhysics's picture

This is an age old problem for us, damn rodents.  Do what others have done in the past.  Should the granaries get emptied, eat the fucking rats...

meh, same as it ever was.

TeamDepends's picture

A little salt, a little honey........magic!

james.connolly's picture

Buffet's WIFE MUNGER speak's my gawd she is butt ugly ... I have been hearing about her for years, but never seen her ugly face.

Poster bitch for Steve Job's 1984 she is .. :(

Fuh Querada's picture

So Berkshire doesn't do HFT themselves ? Hardly credible. Probably sour grapes after they fucked it up.

james.connolly's picture

Munger/Buffet dont' DO "HFT" they just own it, and apology that only a Unicorn could feel comfy about.


nmewn's picture

The Trouble with Tribbles.

csmith's picture

Scotty:  They called the Enterprise a garbage skow!

Kirk: And that's when you hit the Klingons?

Scotty:  Why no! I'm man enough to take a little insult!


kridkrid's picture

"Front running banker bailouts is OK, because we were the ones front running... HFT front running is bad because...???" I guess I'll assume buffet didn't have any skin in this game.

SheepDog-One's picture

'The small investor has never had it so good'....well yea that's the illusion, just wait until the small investor is trapped like rats in a burning granary.

thatthingcanfly's picture

General: "You told us Windows 98 would be faster, and with better access to the Internet!"

Bill Gates: "It is faster, over 8 billion..."

General pulls gun: BANG!