• Steve H. Hanke
    05/04/2016 - 08:00
    Authored by Steve H. Hanke of The Johns Hopkins University. Follow him on Twitter @Steve_Hanke. A few weeks ago, the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) sprang a surprise. It announced that a...

Shinzo Abe And The Three Magic Arrows

Tyler Durden's picture


Submitted by Andy Sirkis via The Ludwig von Mises Institute,

Despite claims to the contrary in the mass media, Japan’s economy is continuing to suffer mightily under the leadership of Prime Minister Abe Shinzo. Abe is from a famous family and he’s a convincing talker, so he was able to bamboozle people into believing that he could make Japan prosper with his three arrows. These metaphorical arrows stand for “monetary stimulus,” “fiscal stimulus,” and “structural reform.”

When Abe was elected using his “three arrows” symbolism to attract votes, I thought the Japanese people were beginning to believe in magic. Perhaps they were gullible or a little lazy in thinking or thought they would receive “free stuff” from Abe. No matter, Abe became Prime Minister in December 2012 and shot off his arrows.

With his “monetary stimulus” arrow, Abe arm-twisted the central bank into doubling the money supply in just a few months time. I could just imagine Abe rubbing his palms together and fiendishly muttering “We’re going to be rich, rich, RICH!” All that the central bank had to do was type a few numbers into their computers to make this happen. Naturally, the newly created money was distributed to politically powerful banks.

How did all of this money creation affect the common people? Despite claims that Japan has less than 2 percent inflation, I can assure you that the prices of many goods, especially imported goods like energy, have increased dramatically since the monetary stimulus arrow was fired. Wages, on the other hand, have remained depressed. With higher expenses to pay, Japanese people can’t afford other goods they would like to buy and businesses can’t afford to raise wages, hire, or expand. Only Abe’s bankster friends have profited from this scheme by speculating in the stock market with the counterfeited money that had been credited to their accounts with the central bank computer.

Japanese people are mostly smart enough to realize that typing numbers into a computer can’t make an economy strong, yet they just haven’t figured out that Abe’s monetary stimulus is nothing but a sneaky counterfeiting scheme.

At the same time as the monetary stimulus arrow doubled the money supply, Abe and his gang used their fiscal stimulus arrow to enormously increase spending on government works projects. Unlike capitalists who at least try to invest productive enterprises, the government allocates money based on pull and other political considerations. Wasting money on things like a new sewer system in Kiev, replacing the perfectly good Olympic stadium with an expensive new Olympic stadium, and handing out plum contracts for highways to nowhere will never generate a profit. Government investment is more like consumption, often creating a 100-percent loss.

These money-losing projects weigh heavily on the people. After all, they will have to pay for this waste in the form of higher taxes and higher debt service. Even if by some miracle the fiscal spending created a profit, the money wouldn’t be distributed to the taxpayer. Heads you lose, tails you lose.

Most Japanese people are smart enough to realize that investing in things that lose money can’t make an economy strong, yet they just haven’t figured out that Abe’s fiscal stimulus is nothing but a sneaky scheme to enrich his well-connected friends. After nearly twenty-five years and fifteen rounds of fiscal stimulus spending, you’d have to be totally bamboozled to still be a believer in this failed Keynesian claptrap.

To pay for his “fiscal stimulus” arrow Abe decided to raise taxes and take the money he needed by force. He raised car taxes and income taxes and he raised sales taxes by 60 percent, but he also announced plans to raise sales taxes by 100 percent. He is considering increasing taxes on married people and poor people. With each tax increase and threat of further tax increases, the economy has weakened further.

And what of Abe’s third arrow, “structural reform”? No one knows what this political slogan actually means. It sounds like some modern day form of Soviet era Glasnost, but there’s been no significant deregulation or loosening of government controls that have long stifled the Japanese economy. We do know that Abe has spent a great deal of effort making enemies with the neighbors. Effectively, Abe’s aggressiveness in foreign affairs is the real third arrow.

Abe has severely damaged relations between the peaceful and industrious Japanese people and their business trading partners in the neighboring countries of China, Russia, and South Korea. Business deals such as the effort to build a gas pipeline between Japan and Russia have been scrapped. Profitable trading in South Korea and especially China has been crushed by Abe’s undiplomatic actions. Via his confrontation with China and sanctioning of Russia, Abe has recklessly followed the dictates of the warmongering US government, all to the detriment of the Japanese people.

Abe’s arrows have been praised in the media by the economically ignorant, the politically motivated, and those who believe prosperity is parceled out by some all powerful shaman. However, the arrows, seen in the harsh light of reality, turn out to be counterfeiting schemes, “investing” in money losing ventures, taking money from the productive, and squabbling with the neighbors. These counterproductive political actions won’t ever result in a stronger economy and have instead left the Japanese people with a crushing debt and tax burden. Don’t get taken in by the hogwash you read in mainstream media propaganda pieces.

Abe’s policies are complete and utter failures.

Your rating: None

- advertisements -

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Sat, 06/28/2014 - 21:50 | 4906311 Mike in Tokyo Rogers
Mike in Tokyo Rogers's picture

Before this nonsense started out, gasoline at the stand was selling for ¥138 per liter (about $5.21 per gallon USD). Yesterday I filled up the tank at the discount place and it was ¥159 per liter ($6.01 per gallon USD)... I think that's about a 13% increase.

By the way, some stands were selling gasoline for ¥167 per liter ($6.31 per gallon USD).

The cracks have begun to appear. To say that, "Abe’s policies are complete and utter failures" is an understatement.

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 22:35 | 4906379 remain calm
remain calm's picture

they are fucked

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 00:18 | 4906511 knukles
knukles's picture

Three arrows; Excessive monetary stimulus, excessive fiscal stimulus and a buncha sophist bullshit thrown in for the Sound and Light Kabuki Theater.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 01:00 | 4906543 El Oregonian
El Oregonian's picture

Look at my held up hand... I had three magic arrows and the first two didn't work... So... um, now I have just one arrow left, and it is my middle arrow... and that's the one you'll be getting...

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 01:16 | 4906560 wee-weed up
wee-weed up's picture



Abe’s policies are complete and utter failures.

Yep, but more importantly...

Obozo’s policies are complete and utter failures.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 06:21 | 4906717 Top Gear
Top Gear's picture

Mortimer Duke: Do you really believe I would have a *nigger* run our family business, Randolph?

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 07:21 | 4906752 stoneworker
stoneworker's picture

Do not mistaken racists for realists...this is the realist playground.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 08:08 | 4906781 RSDallas
RSDallas's picture

Top,  you are obviously an ignorant pig and most definitely part of the problem.


Sun, 06/29/2014 - 10:58 | 4906979 Ben Ghazi
Ben Ghazi's picture

Abenomics is shooting arrows at deflation.


Deflation is shooting AR-15 rounds at Abenomics.

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 22:43 | 4906393 nmewn
nmewn's picture

Six bucks a gallon?...hmmm.

Ah yes, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, UAE and tadah!...Iraq.


Hat tip to Ned ;-)

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 08:49 | 4906836 SuperRay
SuperRay's picture

If the people in japan wake up, they'll tie Abe to one of the 2600 exposed fuel rods at Fukushima. One can only hope.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 00:00 | 4906489 Reptil
Reptil's picture

When I read this, I found it odd. A casino law to stimulate tourism?
Does he want to change Japan into Las Vegas?
Who are these tourists? Who runs the casinos?


Sun, 06/29/2014 - 00:36 | 4906520 Wild Theories
Wild Theories's picture

The tourists would be:

the Chinese... no, they have money, but they hate Abe's Japan now

the Koreans... no, they have money, but they hate Abe too

the Russians... no, their oligarchs have money, but Japan isn't offering them any business right now

the European... no, they are both bankrupt and have casinos closer to home

the Americans... well, the American tourist might visit, but they have enough debts already to gamble even more, and they also have casinos at home

so that only leaves...

the JAPANESE: why yes, gamble away what you money you have left trying to get lucky, why not

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 04:12 | 4906647 Reptil
Reptil's picture

exactly. and since the gambling japanese are already covered, that leaves no one.
maybe its purpose is to tax the Yakuza?

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 07:24 | 4906756 stoneworker
stoneworker's picture

They could just invest that money instead of gambling with it....20 000 Dow or bust.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 04:15 | 4906653 random999
random999's picture

Dont only blame it on abe. Japan was heading towards that situation no matter what. You cant escape gravity.

Good for the japanese anyways, hopefully they can get rid of their fiat at the same time as their economy collapses to start from scratch with a sustainable and free peoples monetary system.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 04:37 | 4906665 Cast Iron Skillet
Cast Iron Skillet's picture

$6.31 / gallon? how do they get away with such cheap gas? I pay about $8.50 / gallon in Germany.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 08:56 | 4906840 saveandsound
saveandsound's picture

Same in Switzerland.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 11:27 | 4907036 Svendblaaskaeg
Svendblaaskaeg's picture

Same in Denmark

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 19:35 | 4908171 Bunga Bunga
Sat, 06/28/2014 - 21:51 | 4906315 suteibu
suteibu's picture

"Most Japanese people are smart enough..."

A large part of the education Japanese children receive in government schools is importance of respecting authority.  After many generations since the end of the feudal era, this has become part of their culture.  Japanese are extremely smart and they know what is going on.  They just don't know how to complain about it.  Look, if they could only make ineffective protests over the corruption surrounding Fukushima (before and after), what would you expect.

As for China and Russia, America admittedly runs Japanese foreign policy.  As for South Korea, America also runs SK foreign policy.  Oh, and Abe is an idiot nearly on par with America's own idiot.

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 22:12 | 4906353 r00t61
r00t61's picture

In the States, we have the expression, "the squeaky wheel gets the grease."

In Japan, contrastingly, they have the expression, "the nail that sticks up gets hammered down."  (Deru kui wa utareru).

Japanese culture (and most Asian cultures, really) are authoritarian and patriarchical - this stems from historical Confucian teachings on obedience.  Like the Matrix, most Westerners can't really appreciate or understand just how authoritarian and patriarchical Asian cultures are from reading a book.  They have to experience it for themselves.

If you were a Japanese everyman, and you ran around, telling your neighbors to make some noise because of your corrupt government and steadily eroding quality of life, you'd likely be shunned, ridiculed, ostracized, ignored, and worse.  You'd be considered guilty of disrupting societal harmony and lack of patriotism.

By the way, Shinzo Abe is a Japanese neo-con.  They want Article 9 abolished, they want the Senkakku Islands now, and they never met a war they didn't like, especially when others do the fighting and the killing and the dying for them.  In this they are much like American neo-cons.

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 22:18 | 4906366 suteibu
suteibu's picture

They do complain about...but only to their friends.  Then they all sit and stew about it, much like Americans, and do little or nothing about it (the internet, as a safe place to vent frustration, is a boon for authority).  There was a time in Japan when people took to the streets, assassinated people and generally brought these issues to the fore.  No longer.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 00:53 | 4906537 disabledvet
disabledvet's picture


Whatever happened to the teenage mutant ninja turtles anyways? And who came up with that idea too...cuz it was real good.

Again...no expert (see comment below)...but to say Japan has some issues with nuclear stuff is like saying Abraham Lincoln had a problem making sure the job got done.

They'll have no problem venting their spleen when the time comes.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 14:47 | 4907493 Reptil
Reptil's picture

A man set himself on fire today, to protest the "self-defence" policy of the Abe government:


"But I was more surprised to see some tweets (like this, and this, and this) accusing this man of carrying out an act of "terrorism" - setting himself on fire and thus endangering others on a busy street, when freedom of speech and universal suffrage are guaranteed [by the Constitution]."

Everything is upside down.

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 23:47 | 4906477 john39
john39's picture

Have you ever seen Chinese riot? Pretty intense once it starts.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 00:56 | 4906532 Wild Theories
Wild Theories's picture

They are also pretty common in the provinces.

Chinese riot a lot more often than people in the west think, but they are equally quick to disperse as soon as they get something out of it. They are a practical bunch, the Chinese.


Conversely, whenever a Chinese riot comes to light to the western media, people fawn and swoon and swear it's going to be the 'downfall of the communist government', but it's actually pretty standard fair to them and don't carry much politics.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 00:39 | 4906525 Curiously_Crazy
Curiously_Crazy's picture

"If you were a Japanese everyman, and you ran around, telling your neighbors to make some noise because of your corrupt government and steadily eroding quality of life, you'd likely be shunned, ridiculed, ostracized, ignored, and worse.  You'd be considered guilty of disrupting societal harmony and lack of patriotism."

Sounds exactly like the rest of the west to me ;) (Yep I do understand your point btw - just having a bit of a fun)

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 01:38 | 4906575 wee-weed up
wee-weed up's picture

you'd likely be shunned, ridiculed, ostracized, ignored, and worse.

Sounds like what the US MSM does to you if you criticise the Obozo Admin.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 07:28 | 4906763 stoneworker
stoneworker's picture

They just delete your comments since they are big believers in freedom of speech...but not in the freedom of other people to hear you.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 01:28 | 4906566 Non Passaran
Non Passaran's picture

Mostly in order, except I don't know WTF is that part about the Senkakus supposed to mean.

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 22:04 | 4906339 NOZZLE
NOZZLE's picture

Shitzo Abe is about as qualified torun a country as William Agee and his little blondie blow job queen Mary were qualified to run Bendix

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 00:18 | 4906507 knukles
knukles's picture

Damn, Nozzle
Good memory.  That sure dates us.

BTW, I think my neighbor has a Shitzo dog?

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 06:32 | 4906726 Headbanger
Headbanger's picture

Oh that fucking asshole!


Sat, 06/28/2014 - 22:06 | 4906345 Reaper
Reaper's picture

There's no free lunch, no free money printing, no costless tax increases, no costless foreign belligerency, and no costless king or prime minister. But, the gullible as always hope, but in the end must pay the piper.

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 22:17 | 4906364 yogibear
yogibear's picture

Abe's kamikaze economic policy, a US Federal Reserve production.

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 22:26 | 4906374 moneybots
moneybots's picture

"Abe’s policies are complete and utter failures."


Abe's policies are the U.S. policies- which are complete and utter failures.

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 22:29 | 4906377 shinobi-7
shinobi-7's picture

Better policies would not have worked anyway. Japan is too far down the drain. Since in Japan, as in the West, the politics of illusions has taken over why not keep it going a while longer? Japan has a more resilient society, it won't be the first domino to fall. Now that the market, i.e. the thermometer of the economy, is broken, they can keep the illusion on, buying all the JGBs, then propping up the stocks. If the economy fails, it will be either because the Chinese bubble popped or the US recovery didn't materialize. Even better: Both! This will get us to 2015. After that, who cares?

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 23:01 | 4906415 eddiebe
eddiebe's picture

Abe like many of our leaders is just another whore for the banking elite. And remember, Japan is still an occupied country. Abe does what he's told to do.

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 23:11 | 4906438 Caviar Emptor
Caviar Emptor's picture

Abe will be remembered as one of the fathers of biflation. Prices spiral, wages tank

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 23:36 | 4906464 wavegenius
Sat, 06/28/2014 - 23:40 | 4906470 Peter Pan
Peter Pan's picture

Sooner or later the reality is going to have to set in and Japan will have to be known as the land of the setting sun.

Overpopulated, under-resourced, aged, indebted and over governed. All the ingredients for an economic Fukushima.

Sat, 06/28/2014 - 23:45 | 4906475 Arthur
Arthur's picture

maybe all true, maybe not.  Some citaions to factual sources would be useful.


Despite claims that Japan has less than 2 percent inflation, I can assure you that the prices of many goods, especially imported goods like energy, have increased dramaticallysince the monetary stimulus arrow was fired. Wages, on the other hand, have remained depressed. Perhaps - or out of thin air.  Source buddy

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 01:33 | 4906569 Non Passaran
Non Passaran's picture

It's common knowledge for fucks sake, just read few recent articles on Japan posted here on ZH.
And bugger off with that bold formatting crap. There's nothing insightful or important about your comment that entitles it to prominence :-)

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 03:59 | 4906646 Aussiekiwi
Aussiekiwi's picture

lol, classic response :-)

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 00:06 | 4906497 Joebloinvestor
Joebloinvestor's picture



Should have been "magic beans".

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 00:15 | 4906506 Otto Zitte
Otto Zitte's picture

Shinzo is CFR. he's a whore. Everything he says publicly is bullshit. 

Fuck you Shinzo-whore.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 00:29 | 4906518 world_debt_slave
world_debt_slave's picture

Japanese culture "it can't be helped"

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 00:38 | 4906522 Rathmullan
Rathmullan's picture

xenophobia and an aging demographic are a bad mix. Japan is destined to become a museum before the end of this century.

Sun, 06/29/2014 - 01:29 | 4906568 SmittyinLA
SmittyinLA's picture

They don't fear foreigners, they just like themselves, look at the wonders mexican growth has done for America and its bottom line.

Their demographics aren't a problem, unlike India or China,  a stable or shrinking population is a good thing, you don't have to constantly  invest (debt) in additional new water,sewer energy, housing school supplies........unless you poison a wide swath of the country with radiation, a declining population actually benefits society and frees up resources.

Imagine moving out of a 400 sq ft apartment into a 1200 sq ft apartment and having your rent cut in half, horrible huh?

Imagine the horror of petroleum imports dropping every year while the hydro is constant or increased with new dams every year.

Imagine having more surplus food to export every year, these horrors all come with declining populations.

As far as caring for the elderly, most care for themselves and work till they're dead, they got 87 year olds working rice fields and a thousand other jobs, not because they have to but because they enjoy hard work, and many self off themselves when they no longer can work.

They do have a Goldman Sachs problem with spending on stupid shit, easy to fix unlike Mexican invasion, which is unfixable. Japan's problem is America, and taking our monetary marching orders spend spend spend.

I guarantee if we go to war with Russia they jump ship and form an alliance, then start collecting on their US assets.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!