Europe: Stagnation, Default, Or Devaluation

Tyler Durden's picture

Submitted by Louis & Charles Gave via Evergreen Gavekal,

Last week’s Jackson Hole meeting helped to highlight a simple reality: unlike other parts of the world, the eurozone remains mired in a deflationary bust six years after the 2008 financial crisis. The only official solutions to this bust seem to be a) to print more money and b) to expand government debt. Meanwhile, Europe’s already high (and rising) government debt levels and large budget deficits raise the question whether we should worry about ‘debt thresholds’, past which increasing deficits, and hence growing sovereign debt, no longer add to growth? Such a constraint could come from one of at least two sources:

1) Once the debt level gets high enough, debt service costs (even at very low rates of interest) can eat up so much of the budget that it is impossible to spend new money on anything else. Fortunately, most European countries are not at that point. Take France as an example: at roughly €45bn (or 2.1% of GDP), debt servicing costs are not out of line with its recent past.


2) Perhaps more insidiously, if the sustainability of the debt becomes dependent on low rates—as increasingly it is in countries like France— then the government has a powerful incentive to do everything it can to keep rates low so it can pursue its existing policies without facing the threat of fast-rising debt service costs. If the price of keeping rates low is low nominal GDP growth, then so be it. This is where Japan has been for some years, and could be where France is now heading. Though, worryingly for France, when it comes to the sustainability of debt accumulation, the similarities with Japan may end there.

When looking at an over-indebted borrower the most important questions should always be ‘Who owns the debt?’ and ‘Will the owner prove patient or fickle?’ For example, a family in which a father lends money to his children, will, on a consolidated basis, have no debt. Applying this analogy to Japan, it seems that Japanese savers prefer to buy bonds rather than pay taxes  (government debt is nothing but deferred taxes). As a result, 92% of outstanding Japanese Government Bonds are owned by  the Japanese themselves. Thus, in a pinch, Japan could choose to convert its repayable debt into perpetual bonds yielding, say, 1%. Even better, it could transform its debt into pieces of paper called banknotes, which are really perpetual debt yielding 0% (perhaps this is what Japan is already doing?). Another option would be for Japan to impose inheritance taxes of 80%, and very quickly the government debt would melt away...

Of course, such solutions are not consequence free. Financing governments through debt rather than a functioning tax system tends to be debilitating for economic growth. Over time it favors the rentier above the entrepreneur (since the only way to find buyers for the new debt is for its yield to be higher than the growth rate of corporate profits). As Knut Wicksell conclusively showed, this pushes the economy into stagnation. Still, Japan has proved that such stagnation is compatible with economic stability. But is the Japanese option open to France?

The other alternative to growing debt levels is the path trodden by Argentina, Russia and Greece in recent decades. What unites these bankrupt issuers is that a majority of their debt was owned by foreign savers. Indeed, when a country accumulates too much debt and begins to find the roll-overs a growing challenge, it really has just two options: the first is a total or partial default; the second is a large currency devaluation. The second choice begs the question ‘Who prints the currency in which the debt is labeled?’ When a central bank controls and independently prints the currency, then a default is highly unlikely and devaluation a near certainty (which is what is starting to occur in Japan). If the central bank does not control the currency in which the debt is labeled, then the only solution over time is a partial or total default, especially if interest rates are above the nominal growth rate of the economy (debt trap).

This brings us to Mr. Draghi’s speech at Jackson Hole, in which the European Central Bank (ECB) head argued for more fiscal stimulus and more structural reforms before the ECB does more to help out Europe’s failing economies. But, at this stage, more fiscal stimulus in countries like France and Italy would likely mean much higher budget deficits and debt levels. Given the rollover schedule of the next 18 months, those could prove challenging for the bond market to swallow, unless, of course, the ECB is willing to embark on the same kind of exchange program that the BoJ has embraced in the past 18 months, namely trading 0% interest rate bank notes for government bonds. It is a kind of Catch 22: the ECB wants to see more reform before turning on its printing press; however, reforms without growth are particularly tough to deliver. Incidentally, this was the pattern in Japan for 15 years or so: the Ministry of Finance (MoF) pointed the finger at the Bank of Japan (BoJ) for not printing enough, and the BoJ pointed the finger at the MoF for the slow pace of reform in the Japanese economy. Replace MoF with Bercy, and BoJ with ECB and very little has been ‘lost in translation’.

But as we know, there are key differences between Japan and France; differences which bring us to the following conclusions:

Investors who believe that the ECB will always step in to prevent French spreads from blowing out should probably conclude that France is now heading down the Japanese path: that of an underperforming economy whose technocratic elite has a growing embedded interest in keeping interest rates low (and thus nominal growth low), lest a spike in rates trigger a funding crisis.


Investors who believe that the ECB will not always step in to prevent French spreads from blowing out will have to conclude that a potential debt restructuring lies in France’s future. However, this restructuring is unlikely to happen until the ECB decides to let France go. And the ECB won’t let France go until conditions in Germany (most likely higher inflation) force the ECB’s hand. Hence, this scenario is not a near term concern.

Very clearly, with French Government Bonds (OAT) yields at record lows, and the euro gapping down, the market is acknowledging these conclusions.

Nothing Mr Draghi said in his Jackson Hole speech changed this reality.

At this stage, the path of least resistance is for the eurozone, and especially France, to continue disappointing economically, for the euro to weaken, and for Europe to remain a source of, rather than a destination for, international capital.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Cattender's picture

Europe.. LOL! i hope they are not doing as Piss Poorly as Michigan...

Sudden Debt's picture

Stagnation it will be.
Europeans want to keep things like they are and that's the only effort they'll do.
And there's just to much old money to be protected against inflation.
And after that, there will be a default.
And after that, inflation will hit us in the face like it did so many times before.
And than, we'll get creative.

kaiserhoff's picture

Who says the French aren't creative?

It was Parisian whores who invented lip stick, high heeled shoes, bras, all sorts of pussy shit;)

Clowns on Acid's picture

Hey.. it worked ! Still used today.

yogibear's picture

Isn't Europe becoming the 2nd middle east?

Muslim prayer rugs are big for Europe and the UK.

Germany will be speaking Arabic instead of German. 

The globalist perfect plan. First you flood the country with another culture, then you replace that country's culture with another. The invading culture is subservient to the globalist.

Joebloinvestor's picture

Government debt evidently doesn't mean jackshit in a fiat based economy.

The Europeans are whistling past the graveyard.

RadioactiveRant's picture

Europe is becoming a mix of south Asia and the Middle East. North America is becoming a mix of Africa and South America.

The beauty of multiculturalism. Black power good, white power bad.

moneybots's picture

"The only official solutions to this bust seem to be a) to print more money and b) to expand government debt."


The only official solution to this bust is more bust.

AdvancingTime's picture

Well said! Before the "Bernanke has all the answers" era, many of us criticized Japan for failing to own its problems. Many people thought Japan should face up to the mess it had created and do the right thing. Broadly accepted was the concept that only by letting its zombie banks and industries fail could Japan clean out the system and move forward.

While they claim otherwise, in many ways Bernanke and the Fed have put America on a path that mirrors the same unsuccessful path taken by Japan. A path that avoids real reform and bails out the very people that caused many of our problems.  As we measure the results of the Bernanke policy it seems they may not be much different than those achieved by Japan over the last few decades.

Bernanke endorsed and encouraged Japan to step on the gas and print more money until they lower the value of the yen and force inflation to set them on a path forward. More on the path we are going down in the article below.


nakki's picture

I thought a weak dollar was good for multinational US corporation because 40% profits were from Europe. Strange how the financial mainstream media points that out when the $ is going down but some how the $$ hitting 13 month highs is great for the SPY QQQ DIA and especially the R2K. 

AdvancingTime's picture

It appears the central banks of the world have made the crux of their existence a balancing act. You can almost imagine these bankers standing atop a fence. On one side lays a field of inflation and on the other a deep pit of deflation.

A new round of easing by central banks to combat a slowdown in growth may again be in the cards but do not be surprised if this time it is less successful. The magic of this policy is losing its luster. More on this subject in the article below.