This page has been archived and commenting is disabled.
Only A Few Years Left Until The Nikkei Hits Dylan Grice's Price Target Of 63,000,000
Back in May 2011, long before the second and far more disastrous reign of Abe, and even longer before Japan unleashed the most insane episode of Banzainomics, pardon QE11 (or thereabouts), we predicted what the BOJ would do up to and including its recent QE tack-on to its ludicrous debt monetization program in "Japan Resumes Hyprintspeed Part 1: A Look At The BOJ's Current, And Future, Quantitative Easing." Specifically we said:
... as the past 30 years have shown, the country at this point has no other choice but to take the same toxic medicine which merely removes the symptoms briefly, while making the underlying problems far worse. Also, with the Fed threatening to end QE2 in precisely two months, someone out there has to be dumping hundreds of billions in infinitely dilutable 1 and 0s into primary dealer prop desks.
Since then we have had not only Operation Twist and QE3, but also the most aggressive central bank monetary expansion in modern history in Japan also known as Abenomics. And, in fact, when the BOJ's QE 11 (or thereabouts) proved to be too weak, Kuroda unleashed even more of the same, further solidifying the conclusion: for Japan at this point, it's game over.
But even before our forecast of Japan's endgame, one strategist was laying out precisely what would happen in Japan with uncanny accuracy, if a few years early. That person is, of course, SocGen's Dylan Grice.
And since he has been right until now, here is how we forecasts Abe's doomed experiment will end, and why the Nikkei hitting 63,000,000 in 11 years is anything but the Hollywood ending Abe is looking for.
From Dylan Grice, formerly of SocGen
Nikkei 63,000,000? A cheap way to buy Japanese inflation risk (15/10/2010)
Japan is no Zimbabwe. Neither was Israel, yet from 1972 to 1987 its inflation averaged nearly 85%. As its CPI rose nearly 10,000 times, its stock market rose by a factor of 6,500 … Regular readers know that I don’t generally make forecasts, but that every now and then I do go out on a limb. This is one of those occasions. Mapping Israel’s experience onto Japan would take the Nikkei from its current 9,600 to 63,000,000. This is our 15-year price target.
- Despite the Japanese government paying a mere 1.5% on its bonds, interest payments amount to a hair-raising 27% of tax revenues. Including rolled government bills (which Japan’s MoF defines as debt service) takes the share to an eyebrow-singeing 57% (see chart below).
- Any meaningful repricing of Japanese sovereign risk would push yields to a level the government would be unable to pay. Moreover, since the domestic financial system is loaded up to the eyeballs with JGBs (first chart inside), a crisis of confidence there would soon transmit itself beyond the public sector.
- So the path of least political resistance will presumably be to keep yields at levels which the Japanese government can afford to pay, and to stabilise JGBs at levels which won’t blow up the financial system. This will involve the BoJ buying any/all bonds the market can no longer absorb, probably under the intellectual camouflage of "a quantitative easing program" aimed at breaking Japan’s deflationary psychology. Economists might applaud such a step as finally showing the BoJ was ‚getting serious about Japan’s problems?. In fact, it will be the opening chapter of a long period of inflation instability.
It is often pointed out that in Japan’s aging population there is no constituency for inflation, which is why there is insufficient pressure on the BoJ to monetise. However, the same demographic dynamic ensures there is no political constituency for reductions in health expenditures. Yet Japan’s tax revenues currently don’t even cover debt service and social security, persistent and growing fiscal burdens. Therefore, once the BoJ is forced into monetisation of government deficits, even if only with the initial intention of stabilising government finances in the short term, it will prove difficult to stop. When it becomes the largest holder and most regular buyer of JGBs, Japan will be on its inflationary trajectory.
It is said that where democracies are developed and institutions robust, hyperinflations don’t take hold. In the 1970s, for example, while developed economies exhibited a degree of the political breakdown that usually fosters high inflation, their experience was relatively mild in comparison to the more pathological inflations seen in politically malfunctioning economies such as Zimbabwe or Weimar Germany. Problematic 1970s inflation in the developed economies was controlled before it became too problematic … except in Israel, which saw its problematic 1970s inflation explode into a hyperinflationary 500% by the mid 1980s.
Think about that for a moment. Japan is an advanced economy, a developed democracy and certainly no Zimbabwe. But Israel was all of those things too. It simply found itself politically committed to a level of expenditure – military and social – which it couldn’t fund. Instead of taking the politically unpalatable course of cutting that expenditure, it resorted to the tried-and-tested tactic of buying time with printed money. Between 1972 and 1987 Israel’s CPI rose by a factor of nearly 10,000. Inflation averaged around 84% and peaked at an annualised 500% in early 1985.
In real terms equity prices fell (chart above), failing to keep pace with the rise in the CPI. But in nominal terms they exploded rising by a factor of around 6,500 over the period, in keeping with experiences of nominal share indices in Argentina, Brazil or Weimar Germany during their inflationary crises. A couple of clients have told me they think the trigger for a forced BoJ monetisation of the government’s balance sheet can only occur when Japan starts running current account deficits, pointing out that sovereign defaults have only occurred in current account deficit economies. So long as Japan maintains its current account surplus it will be safe. But I’m still not convinced why this must necessarily be the case just because it has been in the past. Current account deficits would be critical for government funding if the swing government bond investors were from overseas, which they nearly always are. But in Japan today they’re not. The households effectively are. Why should the current account deficit even be relevant to what is effectively an internal issue?
Reinhart and Rogoff say that one of the tell-tale early signs that governments are struggling to maintain market confidence is when debt maturities decline. This is what is happening in Japan today. And the BoJ announced last week (to loud acclaim) that it was going to adopt a more Anglo-Saxon style of quantitative easing. The process is arguably underway. My concern is that once the door to QE has been passed through, it slams shut behind.
The truth is we can’t know when this will happen. We suspect only that the writing is on the wall, and the further out we look, the bigger and bolder that writing becomes. But if Japan was to follow a similar trajectory to Israel’s, the Nikkei would trade at around 63,000,000 (63 million) by 2025. How much do you think 15y 40,000 strike call options would cost? I’m not sure either (though I’m sure I could get interested parties a quote), but call options are generally cheap, and ‚melt-up? calls especially so, and I’d be surprised if you couldn’t buy that risk for a few basis points a year. Is there a cheaper way to hedge Japan’s coming inflation?
- 12362 reads
- Printer-friendly version
- Send to friend
- advertisements -






How many eggs will that get you?
lots & lots of gooseggs
DOW 50,000 doesn't look so crazy any more.
The Germans used to burn their fiat currency to cook and keep warm
Gold at $1.50 / ounce with phys delivery in 800 years look about right too.
If this game is still going in 15 years I'm going to stab myself in the face with a soldering iron
If this game is still going on in 3 years, I'm going to stab myself in the throat with a soldering iron or a nail gun
If this game is still going on in 3 years, I'm going to stab myself in the throat with a soldering iron or a nail gun
save yourself and stab a bankster in the face. ;-)
If this game is still going in 15 years I'm going to stab myself in the face with a soldering iron
Does your mother sew?
SEW DAT!!
I respect the position but this game has been going on for centuries. Japan is on its way out and so are selected members of the EEC.
Some other Western powers are probably going to hold on by a thread. They will restore confidence and kick the can down the road for a while.
Ultimately this game always ends the same way though. Japan is going to be a fantastic first-hand learning experience of the stupid shit that governments do when the sov. debt game of musical chairs comes to a halt. Take note folks. No two crises in recent memory are exactly alike, but the principles remain the same, based on the nature of the crisis itself.
PS: I do not see Japan lasting until 2016.
a hot one, right?
Once the genie of inflation is out, and given Japan's debt to GDP of 240%, there is no way to put it back. Into how many countries will this hyperinflation bleed into?
If you are Japanese, it is insane not to have at least 5% of your portfolio in gold and silver
If I lived in Japan today, I'd allocate 80% of my portfolio into gold and silver. Especially after last Friday's kamikaze move. NOTHING else will hold up once the economy starts hyperinflating. You can't even buy property there and expect a decent return, since practically zero immigration occurs with an aging culture.
If I lived in Japan today, I'd move :-)
and miss all the fun becoming a human glow stick? Just think about much fun you would be at raves
Only if it scored me free triple stack pokiballs and the DJ promised to play Summer Calling by Andain on loop for 3 hours :-)
The older generation is committing seppuku while the younger generation is expected to observe and repeat. How do the youngsters feel about that? They aren't producing offspring for their parents to enjoy because they hate their existence in stagflation which soon will hyperAbe into a mushroom cloud.
Peter Boockvar recommended Japanese to buy all the gold they can.
People still don't get it, but they will. All this is about is a 1 world central bank and currency, and they're so far down the line they can do that this week if they choose.
No way there will be one central bank and currency. The saying that "there's no honour among thieves" will keep things fragmented globally for generations.
Unless i lived in japan why would i care to "hedge Japan’s coming inflation"?
Hmm something leaking?
https://www.tradingview.com/x/wPG4IVKu/
Where can I buy some Nikkei?
wheelbarrows back in vogue?
When I was a kid and played Monopoly, I always kinda wondered about the pieces [shoe, banker hat, racing car, battleship]... But then 'WHEELBARROW'? WTF?
Monopoly came out in 1933.
Anyway ~ Later in life I figured it out.
"Japan is an advanced economy, a developed democracy and certainly no Zimbabwe. But Israel was all of those things too."
yeah, well neither (was) exporting powerhouse.
I just don't see Japan doing policy in a vacuum ... ie: other exporting not responding to japan's move.
what country responds first (and how) to Halloween currency massacre?
Inflate or Die. In the end it still dies.
On a long enough timeline inflate or die.
Kuroda and Abe better get to work on designing some Quintillion yen coins(Quadrillion will be so passe')... That's a lot of zero's to cram on the front of anything...Those coins will probably be stamped from recycled milk cartons in 15 years.
Very off topic, but in the spirit of the "lend and extend" based DC US economy, comes this:
"As subsidies fade, AT&T adds 30-month smartphone installment plan"
http://www.cnet.com/news/at-t-adds-30-month-smartphone-installment-plan/
It's sub-prime smartphones.
An American, not US subject.
"If you like, we can transfer this smartphone contract to your kids, and then grand kids."
Neither was Israel, yet from 1972 to 1987 its inflation averaged nearly 85%. As its CPI rose nearly 10,000 times, its stock market rose by a factor of 6,500
See. The bankers have no problem screwing over Jews as well. All you raycisss need to stop with the Jewish banker conspiracy. They aren't evil because they are Jewish, they're evil because they are bankers :-)
Why 15 years? Why not 25 and Nikkei 100,000,000 what the hell. Darts and dart boards. It used to be that something that could not go on forever, stopped.
I guess it's what? Different this time?
Surprise! It won't be hyperinflation. It'll be biflation just as it has been since the financial crisis and in Japan since the bubble burst in '90. Headline CPI will rise only modestly as demand circles the drain. Think about that for a moment: rising prices with falling demand? A double whammy vice grip that will keep the economy on its knees. Falling wages, spending, savings with rising costs will take care of that. Until only billionaires are off the bread lines, because they own the bread company.
So, buy Nikkei?
Remember what Putin said...
"play time is over"
A lot of jawboning on all sides. Putin is a shrewd guy, but he's still a politician, don't take everything he says at face value.
Here are some facts that few seem to know:
1. Japan Post Holdings is the largest financial institution in the world ($3.8 trillion). This is about 40% of total U S bank deposits. Most of their assets are in JGB's. 2. GPIF is the largest retirement fund in the world and they currently own mostly JGB's but are in the process of shifting to 40% JGB's and the balance in foreign bonds, stocks, domestic stocks, Corporate bonds, REITS and ETF's. 3. Japanese banks hold deposits more than double the United States (over $20 trillion) and some 31.7%* of those assets are in JGB's. Insurance companies are large and have over half their assets in JGB's*. 4. The deficit in Japan has been running some 50% of total spending They are borrowing all the money to run the government if you leave out social security and interest. The Sales Tax increase may get them down to borrowing 45%. 5. Interest uses up 27%* of total government revenues. Inflation equals higher interest rates sometime. The only exit on this path is a ruined currency and hyper inflation. 6. The central bank is printing some 960 trillion ($870 B) yen per year at the new rate. Do you want to hold onto these new yen. * per Dylan Grice's article
The fact is that Japan has wasted the wealth and savings of an industrious and frugal people trying to follow Keynesian advice to stimulate their economy and it did not work. QE has been on and off since 2001 and it is now QE 8, 9 or 10. Abenomics was a hail mary pass trying the ultimate experiment that has greatly increased Japan's risks. If they are successful with 2% inflation, interest will likely be 3% and 75% of government revenue will then be absorbed with interest. This is exactly the wrong direction to solve their problems. The finances are bad enough but it is the demographics that seals their fate.
Zimbabwe US Federal Reserve and Asian style. Get out of Yen.