Paying Down The Debt Is Now Almost Mathematically Impossible

Tyler Durden's picture

Submitted by Simon Black via Sovereign Man blog,

Exactly 199 years ago, in 1815, a “temporary” committee was established in the US Senate called the Committee on Finance and Uniform National Currency.

It was set up to address economic issues and the debt accrued by the US government after the War of 1812.

Of course, because there’s nothing more permanent than a temporary government measure, the committee became a permanent one after just one year.

It soon expanded its role from raising tariffs to having influence over taxation, banking, currency, and appropriations.

In subsequent wars, notably the American Civil War, the Committee was quick to use its powers and introduced the union’s first income tax. They also detached the dollar from gold to help fund the war.

This was all an indication of things to come.

Over the subsequent decades there was a sustained push to finally establish the country’s central bank that will control money and credit, as well as institute a permanent income tax to feed the expanding aspirations of government.

They succeeded in 1913 when the Federal Reserve Act was passed and the 16th Amendment ratified, binding the country in the shackles of central banking and taxation of income.

Over the century that followed, the US has gone from being the biggest creditor in the world to its biggest debtor.

Decades of expanding government programs, waste, endless and costly wars, etc. have racked up such an enormous pile of debt that it has become almost impossible to pay it down.

A lot of folks don’t realize that, since the end of World War II, the US government’s total tax revenue has been almost constant at roughly 17% of GDP.

In other words, even though the actual tax rates themselves rise and fall, the government’s ‘slice’ of the economic pie is almost always the same - 17%.

I’ve worked out a mathematical model which shows that, even with absurd assumptions (7%+ GDP growth for years at a time, low interest rates, etc.), it is simply not feasible for the US government to ‘grow’ its way out.

Default has become the only option. And that could mean a number of things.

They could default on their creditors (other governments like China who loaned money to the US government). But this would spark a global financial and banking crisis.

 

They could default on the Federal Reserve, which owns trillions of dollars of US debt. But this would create an epic currency crisis for the US dollar.

 

They could also default on their obligations to their citizens—primarily to future beneficiaries of Social Security (who collectively own trillions of dollars of US debt).

 

Or they could choose to default on their obligations to every human being alive who holds US dollars… and engineer rampant inflation.

None of these is a good option. And simply put, the US government has reached a point of no return.

I aim to demonstrate this to you in today’s video podcast episode. It’s a very sobering realization.

Join me to see it for yourself:

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
dbTX's picture

The Rubicon has been crossed.

1000yrdstare's picture

I wish I could erase my debt by burning down my neighborhood....next up, WAR! kiddies...

ACP's picture

Confiscating all the money bankers stole the last 6 years would pay down well over half the national debt.

Bastiat's picture

Cancelling the debt held by the Fed would take care of the rest.

max2205's picture

But I am sure EBT WOULD GROW

NoDebt's picture

Paying down the debt became mathematically impossible when the first dollar was borrowed under our pure fiat system.  Don't confuse the point at which the problem becomes acute with the point at which the problem actually started.

Groundhog Day's picture

But what about all the natural resources the US Gov owns.  thats got to be worth 100's of trillions.  I'm sure GS can figure out a way to do a LBO so they don't defualt and heaven forbid can't tap the international credit markets

Stackers's picture

Anyone who even talks about paying down the national debt has no idea how our money system works. To pay off debt is to decrease the money supply. In other words TRUE deflation and not the CPI nonsense deflation that central bankers track. To contract the money supply by $17 trillion would send commerce and the econmy into a frozen death pit.

I am more equal than others's picture

 

 

Let's just print the money to pay the debt off.  I recommend 8 - $10 Trillion Dollar - notes.  It will get the presses ready for hyper-inflation.  It was good enough for Germany, dam-it, it is good enough for US.

Publicus's picture

There is no need to pay off the debt, it's just a bunch of digits in a computer, and we have control of the computer.

aminorex's picture

Simon post your spreadsheet!

 

mjcOH1's picture

When we print the first trillion dollar bill, the Kenyan's picture should go on it.   It's only fair.   I'll wait 2 years, buy a 55g drum of them on ebay for an ounce of silver, and wipe my ass with them for the next 10 years.  

Xibalba's picture

more likely, they pay off the federal debt with them and pass the expense onto us with a 99% tax of everything

CH1's picture

pass the expense onto us with a 99% tax of everything

And the sheep will obediently line up to pay!

mjcOH1's picture

"more likely, they pay off the federal debt with them and pass the expense onto us with a 99% tax of everything"

By the time those suckers hit the street....and they will hit the street......there'll be 12 more zeros on the national debt.   And a Kenyan will get you a loaf of bread .... at least for  6 months.

SilverIsKing's picture

It will get you a loaf of bread for sure but don't forget that each loaf will come with a free obamaphone.

Gaius Frakkin' Baltar's picture

"...Almost..."

Hahaha... and I've almost grown angel wings.

Debt-Is-Not-Money's picture

Do what Captain Kirk always did: Pull the plug!

ejmoosa's picture

Nor do I have any moral obligation to pay this debt.  

Those that pruchased this debt have made some seriously bad investments-just like they did during the real estate bubble.

IRC162's picture

Jus' unplug da mothafucka 

Leopold B. Scotch's picture

Stackers says "To contract the money supply by $17 trillion would send commerce and the econmy into a frozen death pit."

Fallacy!

As the debt would be paid down -- Instead of endlessly debasing the currenc, harming existing holders' purchasing power as fresh printing divorced those holders of wealth and redirected it to those who get to play with the fresh minted first (Blood Sucking Squid, et al), each unit of currency would regain wealth as old currency was contracted as debt was retired.   The  only difference between $ 0.75 bluejeans of the 1905 sears roebuck catelog and today is a century of Fed policy.  As debt retired, pennys would again gain relevance and those who actual earned their money the old fashioned way ( by exchanging value for value using currency as a medium) would find their purchasing power / wealth again protected from the bankster-looters.

Sure, with our systme as structured, we'd have to eventually de-tach the dollar fromm government debt, orwe'd be forced to consider an alternative currency -- perhaps gold and notes, like the days where this country lauched to unprecedented wealth. 

But before that'd happen, we'd need to also restore a lot of our lost liberty.  NeoConns and Progressives have too many wars to fight, most of which involves what's fundamentally a war on your right to say "no thanks" / Liberty.

Groundhog Day's picture

But what about all the natural resources the US Gov owns.  thats got to be worth 100's of trillions.  I'm sure GS can figure out a way to do a LBO so they don't defualt and heaven forbid can't tap the international credit markets

cynicalskeptic's picture

And WHO buys all those resources? - the holders of all the $US created out of thin air over he past decade... you'll have the bankers - and foreign holders of US debt converting their otherwise worthless oaoer nto TANGIBLE HARD ASSETS while the US taxpayer and citizen sees the little left in the US looted.....  Look at Russia after the collapse of the Soviet Union - the country was bought up by the oligarchs at rock bottom pirces.

The rich end up owning EVERYTHING either way.......   with rampant inflation the holdes of $US convert their paper holdoings into tangible assets sa well - only at MUCH higher prices.  Better to pay 10x the price and get somethign tangible instead of getting stuck with worthless paper...

cynicalskeptic's picture

And WHO buys all those resources? - the holders of all the $US created out of thin air over he past decade... you'll have the bankers - and foreign holders of US debt converting their otherwise worthless oaoer nto TANGIBLE HARD ASSETS while the US taxpayer and citizen sees the little left in the US looted.....  Look at Russia after the collapse of the Soviet Union - the country was bought up by the oligarchs at rock bottom pirces.

The rich end up owning EVERYTHING either way.......   with rampant inflation the holdes of $US convert their paper holdoings into tangible assets sa well - only at MUCH higher prices.  Better to pay 10x the price and get somethign tangible instead of getting stuck with worthless paper...

shovelhead's picture

Psstt.

Wanna buy some shares in a well connected solar company?

Solyndra.

Spread the word.

Agstacker's picture

United States National Parks, for sale, cheap!

Stoploss's picture

Good post Simon.

1801, look at 1801.

Banks and govt are the same thing. Two wings of the same butterfly.

photonsoflight's picture

Not butterfly, think vulture.

Antifaschistische's picture

I guess they didn't have spreadsheets then......yah, does it really take a spreadsheet to figure out our debt is long past the point of no return.

Compwiz4u's picture

Indeed. The currency did not exist to pay back the interest on that first dollar, so more borrowing and debt was needed.

Derivatives were then used to continue the system but it is all crumbling now as the parabolic increase in debt reached its zenith.

The central banks are just trying to slow it down and hide it as best as possible.

Jack Daniels Esq's picture

Granted - so we cancel the $18T debt, clawback all Wall St profits, jail them, reboot America - which is what we should have done before TBTF Barry emigrated to America

ebworthen's picture

Bastiat said: 

"Cancelling the debt held by the Fed would take care of the rest."

Agreed.  However, judging by the bailouts and the newly crammed Crony-Bus bill - they will default on obligations to citizens first, banks dead last.

The U.S. Government is "Of the Banks, By the Banks, For the Banks", and of course the corporations and insurance companies who the Supine Court deemed "individuals".

This means taxpaying citizens are the fatted calf's of the plantation owners.

ajax's picture

 

 

"This means taxpaying citizens are the fatted calf's of the plantation owners."

Tax paying citizens may well be fat but their wallets certainly are not.

(By the way: 'calves' is plural for calf, my father was a dairy farmer ...)

ebworthen's picture

You are correct, thank you, "calves" is the correct plural form for fatted calf.

No doubt there are bankers rubbing their hands over the marbled fat in 401K's/IRA's and the Gold teeth of pensioners.

SilverIsKing's picture

But if you cut a calf in half, you'll have two halves but not two calves.

Phil Free's picture

You can say that again.

 

Fast, three times ...

PAPA ROACH's picture

Cyrpess levy weekend cometh to the USA. The left has always wanted to 'redistribute wealth'. So have the Treasury send survival kits to its bankers, set a $400 daily limit on gold, and let the "one-time wealth tax on accounts over $100k", commence. How's that math work out?

Hohum's picture

Right wants to redistribute wealth, too.  Just differently.

cynicalskeptic's picture

The right lets corporate America pay NOTHING on billions of profits......

truth is that BOTH parties are the servants of wealth - a false dichotomy exists only to preserve the illusion of choice - thow the bastards out in alternate elections but NEVER get a REAL alternative to either.

fastpilot's picture

"The right lets corporate America pay NOTHING on billions of profits......"

I think only a thief could object to that.  Corporations don't really exist.  They can't make a profit.  Only when the money goes into someone's hand does it become a profit to be taxed--the once it is actually earned by a real person.  It becomes taxable again when someone earns it and it becomes their income to be taxed.  Why lefty's are such fans of double taxation, I've no idea.

Oh.  Wait.  I know why.

 

They're theives.

stewie's picture

"Paying down" the debt was never a goal.  Really, think about it.  You can issue an almost unlimited amout of debt at near zero interest, why would you want to pay it down with real production, EVER!?  I sure wouldn't.  Much better to squeeze that lemon for as long as you can then switch to lime when the world is sick to death of lemon juice. 

Alex DeLarge's picture

I will drink a pan galactic gargle blaster to this!

Mepaulus's picture

Maybe the Bilderburgers were discussing switching to lime (digital currency) and just how bitter it should taste. 

SilverIsKing's picture

I order my Bilderburgers very well done. Charred beyond recognition.