This page has been archived and commenting is disabled.

The Stimulus Monkeys Are Screeching And The Central Banks Are Pushing On A String

Tyler Durden's picture




 

Submitted by David Stockman via Contra Corner blog,

Have you been at the zoo when the monkeys start rattling their cages and screeching in unison? That about sums up the last 24 hours since the euro zone’s December CPI printed at negative 0.2% versus prior year. Within minutes of the release, brokerage house “economists” were out in force caterwauling that $1 trillion of ECB bond purchases were now in the bag, meaning that gamblers who had ridden the Italian 10-year bond, among other peripheral junk, all the way down from 7.5% to 1.72% would have another bountiful payday.

Then, just to make sure, the rather vague reference in the Fed’s 2pm meeting notes about headwinds emanating from economic weakness in Europe was spun shortly thereafter by the Fed’s PR firm, Hilsenramp & Blackstone, as an explicit instruction to Draghi et. al. to crank up the printing presses to full throttle.

But then about 8pm came the screech that ignited the robo-traders to another 300 Dow point buy-the-dip-rip. The screecher was Charles Evans, who has spent the last 24 years in the central banking cage at the Chicago Fed—–that is, after having been trained previously in the intricacies of global money and capital markets as an assistant professor of economics at the University of South Carolina.

Never mind the upbeat picture of macroeconomic success painted in the meeting notes, said he. To actually allow money market rates to rise from the zero bound, where they have been pinned by the Fed’s big fat thumb for 73 months now, would  be a “catastrophe” he averred.  Or as one wag noted at that moment,

SPHs are up 17.30 as we write because uber dove and Chicago Fed Prez Evans said the Fed ‘should not rush to hike rates’ and hiking rates would be a ‘catastrophe.’ Algos went berserk and bought SPHs. Ergo, Evans pulled a ‘Bullard’ last night.

A “Bullard” indeed. Since Evans has a vote this year and Bullard doesn’t it is evident that the monkeys are interchangeable. But how else could you describe the babble and gibberish that emanates from the world’s central bankers and the casino economists, strategists and touts who amplify it?

There is overwhelming evidence that the rampant money printing of the past decade or two has done nothing to generate sustainable growth in mainstream living standards and real wealth. Yet the monkeys keep rattling the cage, promising and demanding more ZIRP(and now N-ZIRP) and more fraudulent purchase of government debt with fiat credit congered by their printing presses.

Consider some striking proof of failure. Presumably, the welfare state mecca comprising the EU-19, for example, needs at least some growth in industrial production to sustain the massive state spending, redistribution and borrowing of its member nations. But behold, there has been no net increase in industrial production since 2001.

Eurozone Industrial Production

quick view chart

Now, fourteen years of going net nowhere can’t be due to want of applying the recipe de jour. Rather than stringency, the euro zone experienced a heaping big serving of monetary expansion and inflation during this same period. Even taken at face value, the balance sheet of the ECB is 2.6X its size in 2004——at a time when EU-19 industrial production was exactly at today’s level.

So the central bank balance sheet grew at a 10.5% CAGR over the last decade, while industrial production expanded at a 0.0% CAGR. Double digit annual money printing is not enough?

Historical Data Chart

Well, actually, not even 15% annual money printing was sufficient to lift European industrial production off the flat-line. The truth of the matter is that the ECB balance sheet has not actually retracted at all from its euro 3.1 trillion peak in 2012. The trillion euro difference is just parked off balance sheet in hedge funds and the trading accounts of trend-following European banks who took Draghi’s “whatever it takes” ukase as a bankable commitment.

Why not rent out your balance sheet to the ECB in order to make enormous windfall gains on the soaring bonds of the bankrupt peripherals? And then to complete this larcenous romp, fund the bonds with zero cost deposits mandated from Frankfurt, while keeping your trigger finger on the “sell” button for the day when Draghi is forced to make good?

Stated differently, that’s what all the screeching was about yesterday. It was just a proclamation that the balance sheet of the ECB is actually $3.5 trillion at today’s FX rate, and that the balance sheet renters were much obliged for the negative CPI print.

Likewise, it can’t be said that the euro zone’s flat-lining industrial production was caused by “low-flation”, let alone negative inflation. In fact, the EU’s harmonized CPI index printed at 88.58 in January 2000 and stood at 117.7 in December 2014. That computes out to exactly a 1.9% CAGR. You can’t get any closer to the ECB’s arbitrary 2.0% inflation target than that, yet where’s the beef? Why hasn’t the elixir of prodigious money printing and ample inflation resulted in any net growth in euro zone industrial output at all?

Eurozone Harmonized CPI

quick view chart

Actually, the real picture is much worse. Nearly every EU-19 country has lower industrial production today than it did in the year 2000 except Germany; and much of the latter’s gain was due to the explosion of engineered machinery and other high-value exports to China’s building boom. Current industrial production in France, for example, is still 12% below its turn of the century level. In the case of Italy, production is down by 24%.

There is a reason for Europe’s economic stagnation, of course, and it has nothing to due with insufficient money printing enthusiasm at the ECB. The culprit is “peak debt” and the relentless expansion of the state’s barriers to enterprise, investment and growth.

In the case of the former, the graph below needs no elaboration. During the two decades ending in 2012, and especially upon the arrival of the single currency in 1999, and what in effect became German interest rates all across the continent, the euro zone private sector went on a borrowing binge. Bank loans to the private sector  soared by 3.5X during the period, growing at a 7.0% CAGR for twenty years running.

What has happened since the peak two years ago is self-evident. Europe ran out of credit-worthy borrowers——even at bank rates floating a few points above LIBOR at zero. In short, households and businesses in Europe are already in debt up to their eyeballs, or, at least, to the limits of their income carrying capacity.

Additional money printing at the ECB will therefore accomplish nothing more than what the fast money speculators and their compatriots in the halls of government intend. Namely, that the public debt will be fraudulently sequestered in the ECB’s vaults, while the gamblers collect handsome windfall gains on the securities they rented in the repo market.

Historical Data Chart

Even as private sector spending and investment was capped by peak debt, and therefore constrained to levels supportable by current income and cash flow, the state sector was piling on additional baggage. Namely, as the euro zone countries have desperately tried to rein-in their soaring public debt, they have resorted to heavy tax increases, taking the tax burden to an all-time high of nearly 47% of GDP.

Eurozone Tax Share Of GDP (%)

quick view chart

And yet it is a virtual certainty that future tax rates will rise even more owing to the fact that the public debt ratio exploded upwards during the same period. Is it not surprising, therefore, that already debt-saturated households and business are not eager to take on even more debt. The ECB money printers are not only pushing on a string; they’re being completely thwarted by a rising fiscal burden that has crushed business enterprise and labor incentives across much of the continent.

Eurozone Public Debt As % Of GDP

quick view chart

Nor is the ECB the only money printing central bank pushing on a string. The Federal Reserve has been engaged in the same futile undertaking since the financial crisis of 2008. The fact is, there is no magic economic process by which central bank monetary policy is transmitted to the private sector. Its all about credit expansion, and the boost to spending that happens on a one-time basis while balance sheets are being levered-up.

But that’s over and done in the US, and most of the DM for that matter. In the case of US households, the only growth in debt has been for student loans and sub-prime auto borrowers. We already know where the latter will end-up—-with a surge of business for the repo man.

Moreover, the explosion of student loans to nearly $1.2 trillion was never really about lending in the first place; it was about lifetime debt servitude. Not surprisingly, on that portion of student debt that is actually in repayment  status, the default rate is already north of 30% and rising rapidly.

The real story about household debt is conveyed in the chart below.  “Peak debt” was reached in 2008 when total household credit outstanding reached nearly 220% of wage and salary income—or nearly 2.5X its historic and sustainable ratio prior to the 1980s.  Since the financial crisis, debt ratios have been slowly falling, but still have a long way to go.

Consequently, the US household sector is now on its own. That is, its spending rate is now constrained by the tepid rate of income growth; the Keynesian parlor trick of credit inflation is over and done.

Household Leverage Ratio - Click to enlarge

Household Leverage Ratio – Click to enlarge

Likewise, the credit channel of monetary policy transmission is also no longer operative in the business sector. Too be sure, total business credit outstanding (corporate and non-corporate) has soared by nearly 30% from the pre-crisis peak, rising from $11 trillion in 2007 to $14 trillion at present.

But the overwhelming share of that surge has gone into financial engineering, not productive asset investment. And that is directly the result of the Fed’s 75 month long spree of ZIRP and massive balance sheet expansion. These ruinous policies have caused a veritable explosion of risk asset inflation, while at the same time herding  investors into a desperate scramble for yield.

Not surprisingly, with the S&P 500 at 3X is post-crisis low, the return to the C-suite from stock buybacks, M&A and leveraged buyouts has dramatically outpaced gains from capital investment and R&D. These investments are being shunned for a logical reason. Namely, they must compete over the longer haul in a world that is universally saturated with excess capacity and malinvestments owing to the central bank financial repression and false pricing of capital markets over the last decade and one-half.

Indeed, even the modest level of CapEx posted in the US since the 2007 peak amounts to less than meets the eye. As shown in the chart below, the total increase in CapEx and R&D for the S&P 500  over the past six years was a modest $180 billion or less than 4% at an annual rate. But fully half of that gain—-$90 billion—- was accounted for by gains in the energy sector, and especially the shale patch.

Aside from the energy anomaly, which was driven by the $100/bbl. China bubble and an orgy of cheap junk debt issuance, the growth rate for investment spending in the rest of the economy has been a negligible 2.5% per annum. That’s right. After accounting for inflation, non-energy sector investment has been less than 1% annually.

energy sector capex rd

Needless to remind, since 2007 the Fed’s balance sheet has exploded by 5X—from $900 billion to $4.5 trillion. And what does all that ZIRP and QE have to show for it?  Well, a false boom in the shale batch owing to artificially expensive oil and inordinately cheap junk debt that is now fracturing violently; miniscule growth in non-energy business investment despite an eruption of ultra-cheap corporate debt; and a household sector that remains pinned down by peak debt.

Now that’s pushing on a string!

Its also the opposite of the Keynesian promise of “escape velocity” and “decoupling” in the USA. Take the fudge out of the phony Q3 GDP gain of 5%, and set aside the one-time run-up of sub-prime driven auto sales, and this is what you have.

Real GDP ex-autos expanded at a 2.3% rate during the four quarters ending in Q3 2014. That’s the same rate as for the year ending in Q3 2013, and actually below the 2.4% rate recorded for the four quarters ended in Q3 2012.

There has been no growth acceleration or escape velocity. The US economy is inching forward on its own capitalist hind legs. The Fed’s massive pushing on a string is only generating another giant financial bubble, as was evident in today’s rip by the day traders and robo machines.

Yet when the Fed’s bubble bursts again for the third time this century, the main street economy will be sent sprawling once more. Indeed, pushing on a monetary string is not only futile; it’s also ruinous in its ultimate effect.

Yes, what we are now hearing is the screeching of monkeys rattling their cages. And their awful clatter is not likely to abate any time soon.

 

- advertisements -

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:01 | 5649098 Bear
Bear's picture

Hey ... when something is working ... keep doing it ... just like heroin ... what could go wrong?

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:06 | 5649113 cossack55
cossack55's picture

Can't wait till they start flingin' pooh.

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:09 | 5649123 Aaaarghh
Aaaarghh's picture

Test ebola on the fuckers, that'll shut em up

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:16 | 5649136 NidStyles
NidStyles's picture

Of course they would demand MOAR. They know they have the western world by the goat hairs after decades of creating vast ghettos filled with barely sentient apes. The western people will submit to their demands or they will unleash conflagration from the ghettos. Ferguson was merely a demonstration of the mob that they can release on the small business people and property "renters". (let's be honest; if you're paying property taxes, you don't really own that land) 

 

These are the same tactics and stretegies used by the social engineers in Europe during the 1930's. The Marxist wet dream is a mob under their control, that they can use as a virtual weapon without putting any of the "party" members at risk.

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:50 | 5649241 ZH Snob
ZH Snob's picture

c'mon, yellen, we're jonesin'!

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 20:09 | 5649694 Hail Spode
Hail Spode's picture

It IS working, for those close to the printing presses.  The article assumes the ruling elites WANT sustained recovery.  What I assume they want is what they are getting- buying up the world with funny money for pennies on the dollar as everyone far away from their largesse goes under.

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:04 | 5649107 Sizzurp
Sizzurp's picture

NFL has become WWE

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:06 | 5649117 cossack55
cossack55's picture

Just more obvious now

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 18:41 | 5649402 Bossman1967
Bossman1967's picture

Been that way since 1989 when brett favre threw away 30 pts in last 2 min of game to loose the spread but still win game by 4 pts. Like the fed now all rigged. Enjoy the production called the USSA as it wont be long

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:09 | 5649122 Aaaarghh
Aaaarghh's picture

.

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:19 | 5649152 WTFUD
WTFUD's picture

Main Street, never did care for this term. A more suitable name would be Serf street and the bottom line is ' we'll accept what we're given '

Is it ANY FUCKING wonder that  ' BankCorp ' is so contemptuos of serf street?

The shit that went down in the cartoon office and the jewish deli should be 'app'nin' in .gov the enablers and BanCorp's plush offices and for certain in the breeding ground , that is, ivy schools where recruitment of the next decade's wave of TERRORISM is nurtured to be thrown onto the next generation of SHEEP.

Smash it ALL.

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:26 | 5649172 Duc888
Duc888's picture

 

 

"There is overwhelming evidence that the rampant money printing of the past decade or two has done nothing to generate sustainable growth in mainstream living standards and real wealth."

 

A bit of an understatement. Debt is not wealth, at least not for the werker beez..

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:28 | 5649177 NoWayJose
NoWayJose's picture

Stimulus monkeys have nothing to fear as long as the monkey regulators "See no evil, hear no evil, and speak no evil".

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:29 | 5649181 wmbz
wmbz's picture

Central banksters may be a bunch of howling monkeys, but one thing is certain.

Capt.  Jack Yellen is not going to roll into the office tomorrow and say, hey gang I was reading Ludwig Von Mises over the weekend and you know what? I beleve that he was on to something. Let's give that angle a try!

Not going to f---ing happen!

Un-Fed = FUBAR!

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:31 | 5649187 adonisdemilo
adonisdemilo's picture

Getting close to lift off,

Time to go long ropes and lamp posts ?

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:46 | 5649224 El Vaquero
El Vaquero's picture

Not yet.  The sheep need to get fucked good and hard at least once more, or supply chains need to break. 

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 18:43 | 5649407 August
August's picture

I'm not sure if the Anglosphere populations will ever rebel as long as they are only receiving one more good, hard fucking by their elite (middle-class continentals will at least strike/riot).

 However, when the supply chains fail, not only are all bets off, but all the tables are turned over, and the casino's on fire.

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 19:06 | 5649467 Bossman1967
Bossman1967's picture

We sheep already fucked and my ass hurts tell them 1 percenters to take it out

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 19:42 | 5649582 El Vaquero
El Vaquero's picture

They're using lube right now.  Wait until the next downturn.  They'll throw sand in the lube and make it a contest to see who can pump the hardest.  Any of them who don't participate will have to file for BK.  It's what happens in a parasitic system.

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:49 | 5649237 MontgomeryScott
MontgomeryScott's picture

Qui bono?

Ownership of property is SO 'passe'. Independent industrial production is SO 'last century'.

The monkeys have been given two buttons to push. One will deposit food in the bowl, and the other one Cocaine. Germany is the only nation in the Eurozone to 'post a profit' because it's making machinery for COSCO to use to enslave mankind. FUCK. It's all fiat currency, and; once again, QUI BONO?

The mantra is "Never let a GOOD crisis go to waste". Problem-Reaction-Solution.

The bankers will come to the aid of everyone, of course.

LOOK! UP IN THE SKY! It's a BIRD! It's a PLANE! NO, it's Q-E MAN!

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:49 | 5649238 Dr_Snooz
Dr_Snooz's picture

Good analysis. Thanks!

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 17:57 | 5649270 buzzsaw99
buzzsaw99's picture

to bet against moar is to get your face ripped off

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 19:31 | 5649541 Last of the Mid...
Last of the Middle Class's picture

pushing on a string sucking on the right penis. Whatever. They want absolute and total economic destruction before their derivatives go tits up.

Sun, 01/11/2015 - 20:48 | 5649805 yogibear
yogibear's picture

LOL, even with all the QE money velocity keeps dropping.

Mon, 01/12/2015 - 20:09 | 5653496 MEFOBILLS
MEFOBILLS's picture

Nowhere does Stockman explain how pushing on string works.  Banks can make all the loans they want at zero percent, and if there are no takers, then no new banker credit will enter the money supply.

No new loans, no new money to offset the drain.  The drain is current money already earmarked for destruction into debt instruments.  When you pay your loan off, your former bank credit disappears into the ledger, so there is always a drain on money supply.

The bottom loop of the economy, where the middle class lives, is under continual drain pressure.  The drain pressure is higher than it should be because of the housing bubble.  So, people went into debt and pledged to pay out of the future.  The future, which is now, does not have money available to pay the past bubble debts. Bottom loop is also under heavy drain pressure as interest payments vector away and into finance and then percolate upward to the 1 percenters.

Instead of marking debt instruments to market, which means haircutting; said debt instruments were propped up in an asset push.  QE money chases after MBS and Bonds.  Buying MBS rewards those who created the housing bubble i.e. TBTF banks.  In other words, MBS and other debts that Fed aimed their credit fire hose at, those debts were propped up.  If money chases something then its price goes up as supply exceeds demand.

QE buying of bonds helps the capital market, and then helps banks who hold TBills and the like in their reserve channels.  Bond prices held high with QE also makes interest rates low, thus pushing the housing bubble as an asset class yet again.

Virtually all private bank credit that comes into being is related to FIRE sector.  It is real estate that is pledged to double entry ledger, and insurance backs this up.  Both of these gambits are bets against the future, yet the future must drain ever faster due to exponential claims of the debt instruments.

Real estate then must bubble to create enough credit, to then fund today's U.S. economy, and world economy.

This private bank credit then takes rents on an asset class to create money that everybody uses.  

The system is totally flawed  and needs to be junked.  

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!