This page has been archived and commenting is disabled.
The Economic Wall Dead Ahead Is Hidden Behind False Signs Of "Recovery"
Submitted by David Stockman via Contra Corner blog,
This morning I had left the TV mistakenly tuned to CNBC with the sound on - and unavoidably caught another bullish strategist jawing about the US economy’s awesome strength. This one was peddling as exhibit #1 the recent surge in C&I loans, arguing that it is a sure sign that business is gearing up for a post-winter boom.
It turns out that the $1.8 trillion of C&I loans outstanding at the end of February, in fact, were up by 14% since January 2014. But then again, when are they going to find a guest which wasn’t born yesterday. That is to say, an analyst who is capable of looking at the historic context in which the latest data points are anchored, the quality of the numbers at issue and the deeper implications of the indicators.
In this case, like most of the blizzard of bullish factoids spewed out each day on bubble vision, the purported business lending boom is not all that. The upward blip during the last 13 months was from a level which had first been reached way back in October 2008. In other words, it had taken 63 months to dig out of the deep crater that had resulted from the liquidation of the mountains of bad debt that existed on the eve of the financial crisis.

Next consider the quality and content of the purported “surge” in business lending. The skunk in the woodpile is patently obvious in the graph below.
The “surge” is almost entirely due to financial engineering and LBOs. In fact, virtually all of the growth in business lending during the past two years is due to a dramatic rise in leveraged loans from the deal business. Thus, overall C&I loans are up a modest $220 billion since October 2008, but 100% of that gain is accounted for by the 37% rise in leveraged loans outstanding since 2008.

Needless to say, even a quick peak under the hood results in just the opposite conclusion to that offered by CNBC’s bull peddler of the day. Back in some dusty economic textbook a few decades ago, it might have plausibly been argued that rising C&I loans were evidence of business expansion and a rising requirement to fund working capital and plant and equipment.
But after two decades of central bank financial repression and grotesque mis-pricing of debt, we now have an irrational scramble for yield which is actually attracting funds into anti-growth, anti-jobs and capital destroying deployments—-the opposite of the historic implication of rising business lending.
The fact is the LBOs and leveraged recaps which utilize this booming leveraged loan market invariably involve the strip-mining of cash out of enterprises in order to pay debt service, not the acquisition of new productive capital. Stated differently, this is Wall Street driven lending that arises not because businesses need funding for productive assets, but because speculators, money managers and banks desperately need “yield” in their portfolios.
Accordingly, the proceeds from such loans are more or less put to happenstance use—-and invariably end up as dividends and fees to the private equity shareholders of the leveraged borrowers.
The graph below provides the smoking gun evidence that the recent upturn in reported C&I loans is yield driven. To wit, the recently surging volume of leveraged loans was being taken down by a recrudescence of the CLO market (collateralized loan obligations).
After being essentially shutdown during the financial crisis and for several quarters thereafter, CLO issuance has come roaring back. This was especially the case after mid-2012 when the Fed’s monster QE programs drove treasury and investment grade yields toward the zero bound.
The truth of the matter is that in an honest free market, financial engineering contraptions like CLOs would not even exist. These are essentially “pop-up” funds that appear out the bowels of Wall Street when the Fed’s serial financial bubbles reach an advanced stage. They involve issuing debt to buy debt with some internal fund-level leverage thrown in to top-up the returns.
Stated differently, CLOs are just another financial arbitrage play in which the fast money scalps a cut out of pointless financial churning. These CLO funds are essentially artifacts of financial technology that provide no value added to the economy; and, when the inevitable main street downturn arrives, they disappear as fast as they came in a hail of write-offs and investor losses.
The only thing CLOs actually add to the financial system is instability. In fact, CLOs embody the very worst kind of liquidity and maturity mismatch. The underlying whole loans are hard to sell and have 5-7 years terms. By contrast, CLO debt is sold by Wall Street in a “bespoke” market. That is, the yield parched investors who get suckered into buying these securities are free to sell them at will——but invariably into a dealer market which “gaps” massively downward when the panic starts.
So rather than looking at the financing input into the main street economy, it would be far more sensible to look at the output. Namely, the rate of investment in new productive assets that will support productivity and output growth in the future.
Needless to say, there is none. The massive distortion and deformation of financial markets fostered by the Fed is encouraging the liquidation of American business, not its expansion. As shown below, after accounting for the depreciation of assets in current production, real net investment in American business has not even yet recovered to its 1999 level.
So the real story is not about business investment growth but about financial engineering. In that regard, the Wall Street claim that American business is healthier than ever before and is sitting on mountains of cash just waiting to be put to work is rank nonsense.
Yes, non-financial business have generated about $500 billion in additional cash since the financial crisis. But, on the margin, that was all borrowed money—since total credit market debt outstanding is up by nearly $2 trillion during the same seven-year period. Overall, the net debt of American business is at its highest level in history.
One of these days, even the Wall Street bulls are going to be compelled to look under the hood of their happy time numbers. The story above is only a mild example of what they will find.
- 14704 reads
- Printer-friendly version
- Send to friend
- advertisements -




Silly Stockman. During the mania phase no one looks at the facts. All that does is cloud your bubble vision and stay you hand from doubling down once again.
<Let's see, you stay on 17 and hit 16....right? Wait, I think maybe you split doubles and buy the fucking dip....right?>
So, when does World War III start, to allow Homeland Security to round up all the dissidents here?
Fortunately, DHS is a bunch of incompetent retards. If their "HULK SMASH!" mentality doesn't get the desired results, they will not know what to do.
Unfortunately, they will learn - with you paying their tuition.
That's why it's called
"Prop up can ya" - aka propaganda.
The progressive elite will not let a crash happen under Dear Leader.
Second or third term?
They may not be able to prevent it...
If a crash happens and nobody reports it does a bear still poop in the woods?
I'm guessing that we are stuck with the current "DicktatorInChief" & any different ExecutiveOrderSelectee will be contingent on whether they can keep the delusion alive till the "DickTator" could be sworn in; I do not think so. Then again; I did not think it was possible for this long, but the printing presses have motivated the "perceived" enemies to act; ie AIIB.
Cold Water Stockman throws another bucket on a CNBC pumptard.
See what happens when you look under the carpet
I wonder what Yellen & Co. think or mutter to themselves when they read stuff like this...? I guess the fact that we have been under 6% unemployment for quite some time, yet rates have yet to rise sorta answers that.
Been watching CNBC since Ron Insana acutally had hair and Mark was still around, gold was around 500 bucks and climbing and they were pissing on it. Today, Its just good background noise that makes me feel like im a psuedo financier. Now they have these GOOBER blathering idiots, pretty blondes- Its insulting to watch, knowing whats going on behind the scenes Everyone has abandoned them. Erin, Maria et al its funny.
I think the major tell about CNBC is that they are owned by GE whose CEO is Jeffrey Immelt the JOBS CZAR for Barrack, go figure. No confict of interest there. Fuckers...
Yeah it is all corruption all the time.
- Here is a Boondoggle, Get a Contract for Security Equipment or Defense Equipment and you are sure to make millions off the Taxpayer and Endless Drunken Spending Congress, Fear Porn apparently sells
- 'Homeland Security' renews quest for national license plate tracking system... (This is going to make someone Millions in Profit as highways will be riddled with Readers)(and watch they award the whole national system to one Manufacture instead of a dozen small businesses)
Agree, we (private sector) lost, they (fed gov) won. For now!
Side note: one of my sons CIA guy with trained sniffing La bomba dog. When Deployed to Irag and Afghan. Told me he knocks down 40k a month !!!!! WTF? Ive seen private vs gov job paycheck comparisons, its redunkculous.
.GOOD GAWD !!! So we have that IRS chick still getting a paycheck... oh fuck me, nevermind..
Raiding is done for plunder.
Amazing you can put up with it. It's bad enough on real news days, such as jobs report or Fed annoncements - for a max of 30 mins.
p.s. GE is no longer the majority owner of CNBC!
If I had a choice of Stockman or Cashin? I'd take Stockman without queston.
One thing about Art though. He's gonna make the SNB pay for fucking with him!
I think the SNB is about to get caught on the wrong side of some trades next week. Art might just be able to get some payback. :-)
The SNB, and other un~named entites are skating on thin ice, with respect to their sell-side practices.
It's pretty obvious that(dark pool) corporates and micro sovereign entities are massively hedged, vs $usd. When those hedges are forced to cover, all hell will break loose as the spot market reprices risk, and these clowns get caught on the wrong side of the trade.
Long Ag & Au.
That's the problem with ZIRP! Everyone thinks they can "over ~risk" instead of being prudent hedgers... Traders misconstrue the cost of money.
Dude the Wall Street bulls are the central banks and they've got plenty more where that came from. Last time I checked infinity was a lot more than what you have showing there David.
Most concentrate on the debt as a problem. I focus on the printed-theft that underlies the debt, and what will happen once those fiat-debts cannot be serviced any longer.
The Zionist banksters' fiat-debts capture more and more of the real wealth of the economy in their clutches as service to those fiat-debts. As the economy inevitably collapses, the Zionist banksters also capture and gather to themselves the underlying collateral.
The real crisis is theft, not debt.
The banksters need to repay us.
Guillotines lower debt burdens.
The market works until it doesn't. When that day comes (likely soon), there will be blood in the streets as there is no country on Earth that can dig us out of the hole we have prepared for ourselves.
Any politician who references the financial collapse as a thing of the past is either lying or a fool as that was only a dress rehersal for what is to come. If you deny this truth, you simply haven't been paying attention.
Tyler, thank you for leading those who would see the truth to it.