This page has been archived and commenting is disabled.

The Fed Never Learns - Another Inventory Dump Is Brewing

Tyler Durden's picture




 

Submitted by David Stockman via Contra Corner blog,

The fairy dust peddlers who moonlight as Wall Street economists were out in force yesterday after March retail sales came in with a positive m/m change for the first time since November.  This purportedly confirms that we’re back on track for a big rebound in Q2:

Ian Shepherdson, chief economist at Pantheon Economics, said he expected stronger sales in coming months as the drop in gas prices have built up consumer cash savings.

Now how in the world does he figure that? Total retail sales in March were up a miniscule $5.5 billion or 1.3% over prior year. But then again, gasoline sales were down $10 billion, meaning that consumer spending on everything else was up by $15 billion or 4%. So consumers weren’t hoarding their money or building a cash cushion for some big shopping spree later this spring——-they were just reallocating it like they always do.

Yesterday’s bubble vision jabbering about March retail sales, of course, is just more of the phony baloney “gas tax cut” meme. The 50% cut in world oil prices did not put more income in consumers’ pockets; it just allowed them to spend a tad more on home improvement and restaurants and less on gasoline. But relative price changes and spending reallocations between categories come and go; and besides, this was the “advance” retail report that is going to get revised several more times, anyway.

What might more profitably be asked is this: Has there been any improvement in the tepid rate of retail sales gain since the pre-crisis peak? The answer is no there hasn’t been.

In fact, the March monthly number of $441.4 billion reflected only a 2.1% annual rate of gain since the November 2007 peak. During that same seven year period the CPI was up at a 1.5% rate—-meaning that inflation adjusted retail sales have grown at only 0.6% per annum during the last 7 years.

The graph below which displays inflation adjusted retail sales since the turn of the century explains how Wall Street economists chronically peddle fairy dust. In a word, they focus narrowly on short term rates of change while completely omitting any sense of context. Accordingly, if you are digging out of a deep hole the rate of change can be made to look robust when the trend line is actually quite punk.

That’s exactly the case with retail sales, and the reason for the distortion is crucially important. As shown in the graph, retail sales declined only modestly during the shallow 2001 recession. So seven years after the 2000 peak, inflation-adjusted retail sales had risen at a 2.3% annual rate or nearly 4X the rate posted during the most recent seven year period.

Self-evidently, the difference between the two cycles is that after the 2007 peak, constant dollar retail sales plunged all the way back to the 2001 bottom. So what we have had during most of the current so-called “recovery” is a spot of “born again” sales, not actual trend expansion of retail spending.

In fact, it wasn’t until June 2013—–four years after the NBER declared the Great Recession to have ended—–that real retail sales got back to their pre-crisis peak. Needless to say, when you spend 48 months digging out of a deep hole, it might look like progress if you ignore where you started. But it isn’t.

The reason that the hole was so deep and the recovery so long is crucial to understand. In a word, consumer spending growth during the 2000-2007 recovery cycle was turbocharged by a huge increase in household leverage. It came in the form of the infamous MEW (mortgage equity withdrawal) that both Greenspan and Bernanke thought was a wonderful boost to household spending and GDP growth. In fact, it was a disastrous raid on household balance sheets.

So when housing prices collapsed, the subprime mortgage market shutdown and the home ATM machines went dark, the props were pulled out from under consumer spending. After all, the level of MEW went from upwards of 10% of disposable personal income to zero percent in just a few quarters after the subprime bomb exploded.

More importantly, notwithstanding the Fed’s pegging of interest rates at the zero bound for 75 months and its massive bond buying campaign, including $1.8 trillion of mortgage backed paper, the wizards in the Eccles Building have not been able to restart the home ATM machines. As shown below, US households got in way over their skis in terms of the debt they took on relative to wage and salary income.

So the leverage ratio has been falling from the nosebleed section of history where it topped-out in late 2007. This means that household spending has not gotten a booster shot from leveraging up balance sheets this time around.

Stated differently, the trend rate of real retail sales has been tepid because it is now tethered solely to gains in real incomes. The one-time parlor trick of ratcheting up balance sheet leverage ratios is over and done, as the chart makes starkly apparent.

Household Leverage Ratio - Click to enlarge

Household Leverage Ratio – Click to enlarge

The above graph looks dramatically different than the dishonest pictures peddled by the Wall Street economists. They claim that  consumers are all better now, and ready again to shop until they drop because the ratio of debt service to DPI (disposable personal income) has dropped sharply and is back in historic ranges.

There are only two problems with that ratio—–namely, the numerator and the denominator! The major element of debt service is interest payment, but do these geniuses really think that central banks can hold the monetary system to the zero bound forever without blowing the whole system sky high?

Likewise, 25% of DPI consists of transfer payments including nearly $1 trillion of in-kind Medicare and Medicaid payments on behalf of households.  Well, how much do these highly paid Wall Street prevaricators think poor people and old people actually borrow?  And besides that, have they ever tried to pay a monthly interest charge with their Medicare card?

The fact is, most of household debt is owed by working families and is serviced out of wage and salary income. So not only does the above chart display the proper measure of household leverage, but the denominator—-wage and salary income—-fully explains why retail sales growth has been so tepid during this so-called recovery cycle.

As shown below, during the last seven years wage and salary income has grown at only a 2.2% annual rate, meaning that after inflation it has increased at the same 0.6% rate as real retail sales. And that’s all there is because there’s no incremental kick from higher leverage.

By contrast, during the seven years after the late 2000 peak, wage and sale income grew at a  4.3% annual rate—or by nearly 1.8% per year after inflation. On top that you had further spending power from the home ATM raids.

Needless to say, the ebullient consumer of 2000-2007 is not coming back. They have lost their ATM; they did not get a “gas tax cut”; and the growth rate of real wages has ground decidedly slower.

In short, with the household sector at peak debt, Wall Street economists should be looking to the supply side to understand where the economy is going. Household consumption and so-called aggregate demand is no longer getting a booster shot from sending balance sheets deeper into hock—–so growth has to happen the old fashion way with more work and more productivity.

And there was some pretty chilling evidence out today on the supply side, as well. Namely, that total business sales (manufacturing, wholesale and retail) continued to falter while inventories have kept rising. Specifically, February business sales at $1.313 trillion were essentially flat with January, meaning that Q1 to date is down 2% from the fourth quarter average and 3% from the mid-year 2014 level.

So not only is the US business sector rolling over, it is doing so after only a modest rebound from the deep hole it plunged into during the Great Recession. The February number reported today actually represents just a 1.6% annual gain from the 2007 peak, and hardly any gain at all after inflation.

By contrast, total business sales grew at a 5% annual rate in nominal terms during the seven years after the 2000 peak. Once again, the culprit in this cycle is the deep sales plunge that occurred during the crisis when the excessive inventories built up during the housing boom were violently liquidated. And these excesses were surely attributable to the false bullishness that enveloped the C-suites as the Greenspan/Bernanke bubble inflated to higher and higher levels.

Is that happening again? Why, yes it is!

The monthly rate of business sales in February was actually $16 billion lower than the same month a year ago, while total inventories were up by nearly $60 billion. Consequently, the inventory-to-sales ratio has soared to 1.36—its highest level since October 2008.

So let’s see. Why would corporate management be allowing inventory ratios to soar in the face of what has been the most tepid and inconstant recovery in modern times?

Can you say S&P 500?  At today’s close just shy of 2100, it stands at 3.2X its March 2009 bottom. To be sure, there is no evidence that the main street economy has been “reset” since then or has eluded the headwinds facing it from home and abroad.

What has “reset” in the interim, however, is the strike price of top executives’ stock options. The bullish inventory build, in effect, is the result of the drastically inflated stock quotes and options gains coming from the Wall Street casino.

Needless to say, Janet Yellen thinks the stock market is reasonably valued. So when the next inventory liquidation comes storming into the “incoming” data don’t expect her and her merry band of money printers to have a clue. They never do.

In any event, what happens next is not too hard to figure. Unless you are a Wall Street economist.

 

- advertisements -

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Wed, 04/15/2015 - 19:19 | 5996885 vachon
vachon's picture

These people are just up their self-interested graphs.  Prolly trying to dump Wal-Mart or Sears or Target stock.  Again.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 19:49 | 5996952 CrazyCooter
CrazyCooter's picture

Why do people listen to predictions from people whose profession ends in "-missed".

Regards,

Cooter

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 22:33 | 5997357 Lets Buy The Dip
Lets Buy The Dip's picture

well no one can hit predictions 100% of the time I guess. 

 

3 important Things people are missing about the market.

1) Earnings is not that bad, they revise down, and then beat. Fancy that!

2) Crude is bottoming here, could be whats termed a “W BOTTOM formation” See here => http://www.bit.ly/1fMcakI

3) There are big analysts who keep saying the market is topping, they are saying this so they can get long, while people are selling, and getting caught out yet again and HAD! fancy that as well!!!

 

Do not listen to CNBC, these guys are doing the opposite to you. Yes…..fancy that LOL. :-D

Thu, 04/16/2015 - 07:43 | 5998111 GetZeeGold
GetZeeGold's picture

 

 

These comments will self destuct in 5 seconds.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 22:42 | 5997381 chilli sauce
chilli sauce's picture

I'm making over $7k a month working part time. I kept hearing other people tell me how much money they can make online so I decided to look into it. Well, it was all true and has totally changed my life. This is what I do... www.globe-report.com

Thu, 04/16/2015 - 07:52 | 5998116 GetZeeGold
GetZeeGold's picture

 

 

Bitch please......work more than 29.5 hs/wk.....and you will be assimilated.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 23:20 | 5997518 TheReplacement
TheReplacement's picture

I got it!  Auto Equity Lines of Credit!  That will bring it all back to rah-rah land.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 19:20 | 5996887 kaiserhoff
kaiserhoff's picture

Retail, yaz.

Sun Trust is offering a new credit card with 5% cash back on gas & grocery purchases for one year.  In VA, we can buy wine in almost any grocery or convenience store.  So..., if wine is included, I have a new source of income.   Winning

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 19:28 | 5996899 Snoopy the Economist
Snoopy the Economist's picture

Dave seems to think that the fed has no clue and won't say the truth because he used to be in the club (still in the club?) - truth is they are lying siociopathic parasites.

Thu, 04/16/2015 - 01:40 | 5997793 AGuy
AGuy's picture

"truth is they are lying siociopathic parasites."

While that is definately true, they are also clueless. No point in raising rates when Q1 2015 GDP growth was zero. The Fed tends to make long term plans that are always 2 years obsolete because of economic changes. The Fed continues its plans even though its very obvious that they are doomed to fail. Then when the SHTF, they go into full panic mode and enact extreme policy changes without thinking how to reverse them.

 

 

Thu, 04/16/2015 - 05:30 | 5997987 Snoopy the Economist
Snoopy the Economist's picture

If you think they are clueless then I feel sorry that your mother obviously dropped you on your head as a child. The know EXACTLY what is happening - remember that they see data we don't get to see.

This is all part of the original plan to steal from us.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 19:38 | 5996901 BoPeople
BoPeople's picture

Blah, blah, blah blah, blah blah blah. Ya know I tried to read this shit Dave ... but I could not. It uses to the terminology of the financial sector within the domain of "the financial sector".

In the real world no one gives a damn about terms and processes designed by the clever ones to screw everyone else.

Life, the world and the universe is much simpler than that.

People are either worthy or they are not. At one point my wife thought you were worthy ... even when the FBI called her at her job (the Japanese she worked for at the time got freaked because they thought the FBI might hassle them about insufficient billing) to try to find out if she knew anything about the Carter briefing notes. She remembers the mock debates with Reagan and typing things on 3 X 5 cards but could not tell the FBI where that stuff came from.

Long time ago (like 35 years) ... and we appreciate you ... and your grape farming family from Western Michigan. Please just be good.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 19:39 | 5996929 hungrydweller
hungrydweller's picture

yes but htat's how it has always been.  so why diss on dave now?

Thu, 04/16/2015 - 05:04 | 5997967 BoPeople
BoPeople's picture

The writing does not sound like a mature and reflective Dave, who has seen the inside and turned away from it. That is the Dave we have learned to love an respect.

This particular writing shows a lack of human depth. Sorry, just saying ...

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 19:34 | 5996910 sunny
sunny's picture

Dave, everything you write is true!  Really.  And irrelevant.  The markets keep making all time highs, ignoring any bad news.  We both know that if there was as much as a 5% correction we'd see QE4, 5 and 6 symultaneously.  The markets will go up.  That's all that matters.

Deal.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 20:30 | 5997049 khakuda
khakuda's picture

Yup. Fed wants biggest bubble ever because the last ones have worked out so well.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 19:47 | 5996948 Weaponized Innocense
Weaponized Innocense's picture

There yea go stuff all the channels in all industries that ought to help get us through this fine mess uve gotten us into this time Ollie ~ big grin

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 19:56 | 5996970 adr
adr's picture

Sorry but the numbers in those charts comes from the government so you have to cut whatever is reported in half since 2009 to get near the truth. Sales are seasonally adjusted, inflation adjusted using the wrong inflator, and just plain made up.

If you fill a 15 gallon tank every week you saved about $60 a month with gas dropping to $2.50 a gallon. Around me electric rates jumped 20% this year and up almost 80% in two years running close to $.23 per kWh. Two years ago they were $.13. So if you use 1500 kW per month your electric bill went up $150. Water is up 30% and sewer up 18%. Trash pickup is up 12%.

There was no savings at the gas pump. All the savings there and then some was made up with price increases everywhere else. $3.99 for a dozen eggs, fucking capital A.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 20:29 | 5997045 wains
wains's picture

Right on dude. Your last 3 words summed it up indeed. 

Also, strong dollar my ass. I'm tired of hearing that bs.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 20:29 | 5997046 wains
wains's picture

Right on dude. Your last 3 words summed it up indeed. 

Also, strong dollar my ass. I'm tired of hearing that bs.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 20:29 | 5997047 wains
wains's picture

Right on dude. Your last 3 words summed it up indeed. 

Also, strong dollar my ass. I'm tired of hearing that bs.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 23:02 | 5997308 foghorn leghorn
foghorn leghorn's picture

Everyone is forgetting that we increased our population by importing massive amounts of illegal aliens. Many of them have gone straight into our welfare rolls. At the same time we have been cutting back on pensions and even other retirement income. All of that is misallocated income which is being spent on an economy that is based on bullshit. Any increase in sales has more to do with inflation due to an ever increasing population on some sort of assitance. The old people will soon be forced to join the same assitance rolls the illegals are on right now. This is completely unsunstainable and it is what lead to the fall of the Soviet Union but in a much grander scale.

Wed, 04/15/2015 - 22:20 | 5997321 dreadnaught
dreadnaught's picture

huh-i am still using my 2001 SONY flat CRT Trinitron (Bought Jan 2002) and still going strong-but my DVD player crapped out and now i must by a DVD/BR player-anyway, a Samsung LED ive stettled on and have in my "maybe pile" just dropped $40....no tax or shipping

Thu, 04/16/2015 - 07:54 | 5998118 GetZeeGold
GetZeeGold's picture

 

 

Awesome story.....thanks for that.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!