This page has been archived and commenting is disabled.
Top NSA Official Who Created the Global Surveillance System: Fire the U.S. Intelligence Agencies … Hire Anonymous, Instead
William Binney is the high-level NSA executive who created the agency’s mass surveillance program for digital information. A 32-year NSA veteran widely regarded as a “legend” within the agency, Binney was the senior technical director within the agency and supervised thousands of NSA employees.
Binney sent Washington’s Blog an article from Monday showing that a member of the cyber collective Anonymous tipped off Texas police to the imminent shootings by Muslim extremists.
Binney comments:
This is the objective of intelligence agencies that I worked in – predict intentions and capabilities in advance. I agree with my VIPS [i.e. Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity] associates, hire Anonymous and fire the bums we got including the intelligence committees and the FISC [U.S. Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court].
After all, when was the last time our “intelligence community” predicted anything like this in advance????
Binney and other top NSA whistleblowers have previously explained that the intelligence agencies should have stopped 9/11, the Boston Marathon bombing, the Paris shootings and other terrorist attacks. But corruption prevented them from stopping the attacks.
Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity – a group composed of former high-level military and intelligence officials – recently called for independent intelligence analysis to keep our country safe.
- advertisements -


called for independent intelligence analysis
Cool.
Next question: who decides which are the independent people do take over such a task?
The fences are there to keep us in.
Liberty is a demand. Tyranny is submission.
The farmer protects us from the wolves, but who protects us from the farmer.
It wasn't in the news but Hillary Clinton was inaugurated as the 45th President in their secret bunker ten miles from Washington. Operation Jade Helm has commenced, which is a continuation of the red-blue state war, or the Federal government versus the people, which began under Wm Clinton in 1992. The first two sorties were at Ruby Ridge and Waco Texas, and they were followed by a counter attack at Ok City.
Clinton Two remains their best choice to continue the New Cold War, government versus the people. Bush Three might represent a truce of sorts, in the states, but it would also imply a shifting of this Cold War with more conventional objectives, Russia and China. Bush Two was the Manchurian president, and Bush Three would continue that policy.
The new currency war with China is heating up, this is hardly a time to be accomodative. Clinton Two serves to bridge the gap between wealthy and educated voters, and greater government control of the population, domestic and global. The red states are hotbeds of seditious activities, the Posse Commitatus, and so on. Their real power is only a slight blip on the radar, their symbolic value is huge. The working difference between Bush Three and Clinton Two is that Bush Three draws a great deal of support from these red states, and he would allow them to operate as they do currently (a largely symbolic refutation of the growing Federal power, and resistance to that power, because welfare and entitlements are just as active in middle American micro economics, as they are in NY City.)
Bush Three would overlook prosecuting the new Cold War against these people, just as Obama made a policy of overlooking prosecution of illegals along our southern border. The New Cold War would have been against traditional targets such as Cuba. Obama would have never opened the door with Cuba unless he knew Clinton Two was going to be elected to continue that policy, and shift the Cold War to the homeland.
They print money, and they can print votes.
Now its easy to disregard a few red neck secessionists, but remember what was said about the same thing during the Reich in Germany, first they came for the Gypsies, but I wasn't a Gypsy. It's a slippery slope and Clinton Two wants to give us all a big push. Jade Helm is the kick start to her administration, it will be far bigger than Ruby Ridge and Waco. The ulitmate goal is the furtherance of the Federal governments control over your lives, albiet with a carrot (entitlements) and a stick. A real stick, but don't worry it's not meant for you.
It's still possible they may change their minds, the people who decide these things.. The new market crash cycle is not built on technical trickery, its built on the change of regime in Washington. The players always get nervous while they secretly choose who they want to represent them, and so they pull a few chips off the table until they know which way the bet is going. By appointing Clinton Two early they may be able to avoid a ruffling of the markets, or the crash could come a year early, if the powers to be can't come to agreement.
Allowing a few Texas rednecks who put on an art show desecrating the Prophet is hardly a priority to the Federal government, who would just as soon whack these peckerheads themselves, allowing the perps to get off a few shots makes their job easier, all the way around. Another successful operation.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KLhgkbkSnoM
No comment needed.
Sometimes I read part of a comment that appears be fairly intelligently written but then I come across a reference to Martial Law, except it's spelled as "Marshall Law"...
No big deal, but that's the point when I always find myself skipping on down the page scanning for another clever remark or persuasive opinion.
... not just the comments, but the articles as well. ZH used to be able to spell check before the site was plastered with advertisements and pop-ups.
Even a Dave Stockman article incorrectly used the word "loose" when the intended word was "lose".
It is a little disappointed and makes me wonder who is actually running the site now in comparison to who was running it before.
It is a little disappointed ?
lol
You had best check yourself before criticizing others.
I'll second that motion.
Go home spelling Nazi. We are human and make mistakes.
but but, will Anonymous perpetrate the necessary false flag attacks? i really havent seen enough to guarantee their loyalty to America.
Wonderful posting, GW, as usual but even more superlative this time!
One must suppose that Palantir wasn't up to snuff, they way they fingered that day trader who was constantly complaining about HFT (strobing and spoofing, etc.) frauds being perpetrated, and was indicted by the SEC/DOJ/CIA/NSA/DIA/UYA (that would be Up Your Anus group), etc.
Evidently, Palantir wasn't covering this.
Loved that NY Times article on them, whereby the "journalists" and "reporters" at the New Whore Times evidently neglected to mention that Peter Thiel's Palantir received their CIA funding because Thiel sits on the board of the American Friends of Bilderberg, Inc., with David Rockefeller, Henry Kissinger and Richard Perle (Perle introducing Thiel to Adm. Poindexter who steered the CIA funding his way).
Next the article brags on Palantir getting their first private sector client, JPMorgan Chase?
Chase Bank? David Rockefeller's bank? Who could possibly have foreseen . . . .
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/01/business/unlocking-secrets-if-not-its-own-value.html?_r=0
Yeah, Good Point! We really haven't been seeing the kind of a body count one might expect from terrorist's that are loyally dedicated to their cause. "Boston", and "Sandy Hook" were not very convincing at all... They had that "made for TV" sort of "drama", no?
These latest Productions of terrorRus.gov have been pretty lame when compared to Real Terrorism from the past. I remember the drama of the 1972 tragedy at the Munich Olympics. It was truly Horrifying; it was Real!
I seriously doubt that Anonymous wants anything to do with that kind of carnage!
Anonymous are notoriously Communist/Socialist/Statist/Zionsts, if they were on "our side" they'd publish all the criminal communications between our elected and appointed officials and the judiciary, including Lois Lerner, Corzine, Madoff and of course Jamie Gorelick, Jeff Epstein
BTW anytime to publicize an event with Gert Wilders or anti criminal invasion or anti Islam you are gonna get attacked by the left and they will have state protection
They don't have the same limitless resources of the NSA/CIA/DIA/NRO/NGA you stooopid shit!
http://www.wsj.com/articles/appeals-court-rules-nsa-phone-program-not-au...
A superior competent federal civil service was a fantasy of the Progressive movement in the nineteenth century. The government would use exams to select the best and brightest and then give them life tenure, as opposed to the prior appointment of political hacks, continually changing with each new President.
Power corrupts. Entrance exams are manipulated. Even the best from exams is corrupted by the power of life tenure. With the spoils system, the voters could throw the bums out.
Greater intelligence or honesty is the greater enemy of entrenched incompetents. They took away our freedom to vote the bums out.
I think you are talking about the nature of Power and Government,Monarchies, and Clerics.
I don't want to downplay what your wrote at all. I would add that the people from the Military that hold positions in the Government know how to play power games and strategize on how to hold power as well.
Funny in an odd way, Carter was Navy, Bill Clinton is said to be CIA through his Rhodes Scholarship, and Obama is linked to the CIA as well, BUT the Military notoriously don't like them. I can see Clinton & Obama are Lawyers and did not run businesses this may account for the total corporate Coup on the USA.
But Anyway. Every Government has people with Strategies on how to Rule and Hold on to Power.
- The holy See certainly knows how to hold power
- USSR knew how to hold power
- European Monarchs knew how to hold power
- Revolutionary China knows how to hold power
I guess you are pointing out Thuggish Behavior and Brutality should be Eschewed by all in the USA. Lawyers use these techniques learned for Court. They put on Emotions, Anger, Rage, outrage, Condemnation, Judgement, Patriarchy, ETC. Lawyers see it as an Argument. Maybe Military People do to. It is about "Winning". It is called Rhetoric I think or they also use Ad Hominem Attacks to the 'man".
Fellow ZHers, please consider adding something like the following to your email signature:
WARNING: You are participating in electronic communication at your own risk. The National Security Agency in collaboration with other government agencies and private enterprises are recording, analyzing and storing your communications. Constitutionally aware patriots who regret assisting in the creation and operation of these data collection programs have raised their voices to warn that this information is used by various government agencies to achieve political objectives. In addition, information retained from your digital communications may be provided to foreign governments and/or private companies without your knowledge by various federal agencies. The result may be termination of employment, coercion, indefinite detention or execution.
Anonymous is comprised of NSA spooks, Binney. Not only is the NSA finished along with America, but Anonymous is finished too. In fact, the entire 'intelligence' community in the Western World has already had its best before date expire. Clearly, when the principle architect comes out of the woodwork to claim failure you know the claim is strategically placed. Did Binney suddenly find religion or is his conscience keeping him awake at night? We can scrap any notion of ethics or morality because anyone that worked for the National Security Agency has neither. Like the Central Intelligence Agency, the National Security Agency is a board certified criminal organization that set out with the mandate to manipulate what Americans read and think on a daily basis.
NOTE: "Truth" is NOT part of their mandate so they can manage the lies, half truths, and outright bullshit propaganda, motherfuckers!!
Geez, this must be the day of the Retarded Commenters.
Yes, 'information' is the guarded secret that all the Agencies like to keep to themselves. That's the great weakness in all of this not counting the billions wasted.
Max Mermelstein a big time coke smuggler from the 1980s made the same point when he spoke in front of one of those DC committes (he was in witness protection).
He said that Customs don't share with the DEA who don't share with the FBI who don't share with the local cops and so on. Made his job a lot easier. I doubt it's any different these days whether Coke or terrorism.
If you like true crime and the coke business get his book, The Man Who Made it Snow, it's a great read.
Yes, that lack of "sharing" gong was beaten relentlessly just after the 911 theater, if I recall. People testifying that the lack of sharing was the problem. They had a turnkey solution...ready to roll...just sign the line which is dotted.
That's why the awesome Patriot Act was sooooo important, right?Had to tear down those "walls" to get all agencies on the same page, right? Play nice.
That worked out well. Enter "Fusion Centers", your statist one stop shop for all dirt and blackmail. Now all agencies may drink from the fountain freely.
Without cause or warrant.
To protect us, of course.
he's got the whole country wired and he's still singing the blues.
but like most ami projects it never works like they say it will work.
poor control freak
I can remember back in the day when very few had a clue of deep state shenanigans when i would have heated debates regarding the trustworthiness of the folks running the zoo.
Their argument always ended with ' at least you have free speech here '
We've come a long way since in that case when the ventriloquists dummies ( police ) are knocking on some teenager's door regarding some insult he typed on twitter.
You have UK politicians being protected by public servants for heinous crimes against minors.
You have the jobless/poor being removed from cities to make way for private housing interests.
You have whistleblowers being incarcerated as an example not to follow in their footsteps
ETC ETC ETC ETC ETC ETC
This current shower of shit sitting in the corridors of power in the USSA, UK, Brussels are ON A PAR WITH IS. If you're NOT aware of that then i'm afraid you're future is not too bright.
AND STILL/YET
For some folks on Z?H the recognisable enemy is the looter, just as for .gov the scapegoat for libor rigging is the asian living in his dad's basement in London.
MAYBE WE ALL DESERVE EACH OTHER
In het systeem 'Leven en Laten Leven' is de rol van het IMF uitgespeeld, omdat 'landen niet meer met elkaar concureren, maar samenwerken'.
http://www.volkskrant.nl/dossier-4-uur-nieuwsbreak/lilianne-ploumen-we-m...
=== Macht van IMF is gebaseerd op SCHULD-papier ===
The IMF system is based on Special Drawing Rights, or ‘SDR’s’ in short which is considered to be an IMF reserve asset. The IMF itself defines an SDR as a ‘potential claim on the freely usable currency reserves of member countries’. The SDR’s were originally based on the value of gold, but this was later converted to a basket of the Euro, Japanese Yen, the US Dollar and the British Pound which were considered to be the main reserve currencies of the world.
Just a few weeks ago, China has hinted to the IMF it would like to see the Chinese Yuan being included in the basket of foreign currencies. This isn’t an unrealistic claim as China has become one of the world’s economic powerhouses. It’s extremely important to note the next IMF meeting to discuss the basket of currencies included in the SDR system is scheduled for the end of this year (the previous meeting was in 2011, so China doesn’t get a lot of chances to be included).
===
Het (Paradigma)Conflict tussen de Europese Commissie en het IMF gaat niet zozeer over 'het faillissement van Griekenland', maar over het script van de 3e SpinozaGolf. Nu zelfs ZeroHedge weet dat het een kwestie van tijd is dat het SCHULD=H00P-principe wordt ingeruild voor het GELD=ZUURSTOF-paradigma, moet ook het personeel van hotel GradjA worden ingelicht.
http://www.volkskrant.nl/buitenland/harde-eisen-imf-frustreren-akkoord-o...
EU-ambtenaar: "De verdeeldheid tussen Griekenland en de instituties is vele malen groter dan die tussen de instituties onderling".
Eurogroepvoorzitter Dijsselbloem weet dat 'die instituties' de 3e SpinozaGolf niet gaan overleven en dus gaven de Commissie, het IMF en de ECB ieder een aparte verklaring uit dat ze alle drie hetzelfde doel nastreven: een financieel gezond Griekenland. Dit kan natuurlijk het snelste door gewoon het DAB-systeem in te voeren, maar dit plan willen de regeringen van de eurozone doodzwijgen.
http://www.volkskrant.nl/buitenland/jemen-vraagt-veiligheidsraad-om-inze...
Op dit moment denkt netwerk WitteGejT nog steeds dat door luchtaanvallen op Houthi-rebellen in Jemen het systeem 'Liegen om te Leven' kan worden gered. Dit is uiteraard tot mislukken gedoemd, omdat de inspiratiebron van netwerk @SuperWil niet de psychosegelovige CONTrACTEN met het IMF betreft.
De VredeVrijheidDirect-beweging heeft het voor elkaar dat Rusland 'de MH17-wrakstukken beziet' als het signaal dat Klaveren niet meer troef is.
http://www.volkskrant.nl/binnenland/wrakstukken-van-mh17-in-russisch-mus...
Het is al eerder gezegd dat de 3e SpinozaGolf veel problemen geeft voor landen die niet door de VN zijn ingewijd in de blauwdruk van het systeem 'Leven en Laten Leven'. Dat zelfs in de VN de ContactPersoon van 'de Heilige Stoel' niet heeft gewaarheiddeeld met de ContactPersoon van 'het Witte Huis' was al wel door het personeel van hotel GradjA voorzien. Politici mogen nu hun achterban inlichten, waarom ze niet al eerder hadden ingezet op het systeem 'Leven en Laten Leven'. Het mondiale financiële systeem moet flink op de schop en dat kan rechtvaardig gebeuren, indien men (te starten met het IMF?!?!?) het GELD=ZUURSTOF-paradigma gaat hanteren. De omvang van de slechte leningen op de balans van banken in de eurozone is gestegen tot 900 miljard euro en de 'problematiek rondom Griekenland' is een mooi moment om het DAB-systeem uit te rollen.
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-04-15/negative-interest#comment-5997844
Het presidium in Nederland loopt volgens netwerk WitteGejT voor op de kennisniveau in netwerk Juncker of het Europees Parlement. Dit konden de hersenen van Hans Jansen niet meer verwerken en dus was een hersenbloeding zijn deel. In het DAB-systeem is de kamervoorzitter en de vice-president van de @RaadvanState dezelfde (rechts)persoon. Op die manier heeft het collectief bewustzijn van Nederland ook meteen toegang tot het geweten van netwerk @0ranjePapegaaY. De rol van Koningin Máxima was om minister Dijsselbloem uit de wind te houden en wat hij eerder 'complex en het gaat gewoon niet lukken' heeft genoemd, is nu aan de orde. Chris Buijink van de Nederlandse Vereniging van Banken (NVB) wil overigens dat Folkert Fennema de rol van KlaverenHeer gaat spelen.
Doordat de ECB mag discrimineren waar de 'gratis geldgroei' naar toe mag zijn "de spanningen in het financiële systeem sterk toegenomen". Dit kan veranderen, wanneer president Jim Yong Kim van de Wereldbank Groep en de Haagse burgemeester Jozias van Aartsen gaan speculeren hoe 'de cybertop' de verschillende ministers, staatssecretarissen, topambtenaren, ambassadeurs en andere gasten hebben doordrongen dat de ABSOLUTE WAARHEID niet te verkrachten is.
De parlementariër Ilja Ponomariov van Rusland verblijft nu in de Verenigde Staten en zegt niets te weten wat Snowden tegen Poutin heeft verteld.
http://nos.nl/artikel/2029037-doema-berooft-kritisch-lid-van-immuniteit....
NieuweBoer: "Ondernemingen mogen in de toekomst niet meer garant staan voor leningen aan private equitybedrijven, als op die manier de eigen overname wordt betaald."
http://www.mintpressnews.com/keeping-the-republic/205248/#comment-201087...
De internationale geldschieters van Griekenland hebben terecht het vermoeden dat 'op maandag 11 mei 2015' het gesprek van de ministers van Financiën in de eurozone niet zozeer gaan over 'het failliet van Griekenland', maar hoe de Europese Commissie, de Europese Centrale Bank en het Internationaal Monetair Fonds de bevolking van Griekenland kan bewegen tot 'vreedzaam waarheiddelen'. Dus iets anders dan wat in Syrië aan de gang is.
http://www.volkskrant.nl/dossier-burgeroorlog-in-syrie/assad-schroeft-st...
Gerucht gaat dat de multimiljardair Warren Buffett (84) wel een rol in de 'Parodie op de Waarheid' wil spelen.
http://www.ad.nl/ad/nl/1013/Buitenland/article/detail/4003352/2015/05/06...
Guus:
Mit flib flob zoomy floob oms im izzaroo sniff chomp chomp slur zoot scmole. Zebly nim-nim umpt em ak ak ak. Smill? Ixolitomnu zeeb ooop all waquil.
Om zoool flib flob aklu greem oon gribble? "Shite, what incomprehsible gibberish is this?" Aaaal ooom zip grooble flem! Abrillo drigs mep ooble ooble.
Prenfig am zoopla! lech im der griblle chip noshing frurble krep. Grinchly klepru ach der noople shimmer? Im het lipo ampere. Loout prish mer heeble frommitz
ach meerillopede zoopla izzaroo! Zepper, zepper, zepper...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukDs7wScLUI
Good idea. Smart moral individuals certainly have the force of existence behind them and a large government without any possiblity of morality and dedication to existence can only be destructive and against existence. The answer of who should be in control is easy, should an entity that is attempting to honor non-existence be in control or one that honors existence. In any case the end result will be the same. Time assures that.
This is a moral question. The definition of moral hazard. Binney was their wiz because he showed these raping hordes the lowest edge of a higher form of intelligence, which they then used to rape everyone, soviet style. Fuck you Binney. You and Bill Gates. Has any one person done more, through their narrow minded pursuit and subsequent demonstrative psychopathic lack of true empathy to bring about the global police state?
If you know PI, save it for your own.
Binney created the system to AUTOMATICALLY ENCRYPT everyone's identity. It could only be decrypted upon a JUDGE's ORDER. He did that to protect our Constitutional rights.
But the NSA flipped it so that NO ONE's info was encrypted ... i.e. mass surveillance. This was when the police state ramped up.
Binney tried to stop it ... but couldn't.
Binney has also publicly apologized for his role in creating surveillance. But remember, when he created it, he had no idea the fascists would take over and turn in on Americans without any warrant, and implement his system after stripping out the privacy-protecting automatic encryption.
His system required a real judge to order it be decrypted as to a specific individual...
GW i believe Oppenheimer tried to stop the nuclear bomb but is this any excuse? Did he ever naively consider that it would be used for the good of mankind?
Surely you study all the pros and cons especially when you have ample evidence that the guys pulling the strings have sociopathic traits.
Anyone who believes that the legal system is going to be our saviour must be deluded. Just like Barry they are useful tools.
That said, probably would have surfaced under someone else's watch but i'm afraid this is a classic example of the tail wagging the dog.
Can you cite any particular cases where anyone has been falsely accused or arrested because of the NSA data collection? - Me neither; however, it is still a gross abuse of power and infringes on the clause of search and seisure.
I'm guessing a few judges and congresscritters have been blackmailed -- just a guess based on depraved power dynamics and game theory.
Golly. You don't suppose Justice Roberts may have been encouraged to rule in favor of BammyCare, far out of norm, due to something such as this?
Blackmail is illegal! Heavens. That's just nuts.
Nah. I'm sure his child's adoption was done strictly on the up and up.
Unless it wasn't and they used that to lean on his ass.
Or not.
Who knows. But I'd say your guess was a good one.
"It could only be decrypted upon a JUDGE's ORDER."
and
"He did that to protect our Constitutional rights."
Those two are very conflicting statements. If he gave a flying fuck about any Constitutional rights, the crooked-ass judges would pound sand. You can't pretend to give a shit, and leave a backdoor the size of a schoolbus for the statists to use.
Binney left himself tangled up in his own paradox.
Binney and other top NSA whistleblowers have previously explained that the intelligence agencies should have stopped 9/11, the Boston Marathon bombing, the Paris shootings and other terrorist attacks. But corruption prevented them from stopping the attacks.
Yes, they could have stopped them...because they planned them.
Last week I told my wife that with Jade Helm we can look for three false flags:
1) ISIS will attack various places in various cities throughout North America. ISIS Sympathizers will also attack places. The purpose of ISIS sympathizers is so the criminals in control can institute Marshall Law and gun confiscation. After all, if sympathizers are american citizens that can't be easily separated from other americans then, well, they'll just have to confiscate everyone's guns for national security.
Interesting how less that one week later the very first ISIS related strike in the US happened in Texas by sympathizer american citizens. Texas, the epicenter of Jade Helm. FBI said they had been "monitoring" these guys for 8 years (like the boston bombing). So why did they allow them to buy AK47s? Why allow them to go through with it? And it happened because of a cartoon drawing of Mohammed (like Charlie Hebdo).
2) Iran will bomb Isreal
3) Russia will nuke major cities in America, starting with New York. Why are the NFL, the Fed, Bernanke, and Geitner all relocating from NY to Chicago?
It's all theatre. The world is just a stage. We're screwed. Time to open that rare vintage.
Forget Anonymous. This is easy. Very predictable.
Speaking of Boston - I try now and again to see wtf happened to "Jeff baumann". I still try to get people to look at that shite and tell me it looks real. I especially like gettIng medical ppl to look at it. The last I remember -"Jeff" had over $1M in his charity donation account.
Here's some good info http://www.boilingfrogspost.com/2015/05/05/disinfowars-with-tom-secker-a... Brassards not Baumann crisis actors snapped nevertheless
old man finger spasms...did this lke fourteen times so far...........
old man finger spasms...did this lke fourteen times so far...........
"3) Russia will nuke major cities in America, starting with New York. Why are the NFL, the Fed, Bernanke, and Geitner all relocating from NY to Chicago"
Looking forward to it. Clean the shit out. You can't make omelets without breaking some eggs.
Hopefuly, DC will be a close seond to NY.
All false flags. Orders prevented them from disclosing the ops.
You are travelling through Yemen on the Slik Road.
You are approaching a fork in the road. One way will lead you home, the other will lead you into a den of vipers who will eat you, and follow your heat all the way back to 1901 and eat ever relative you ever had.
You do not know which way to go.
At this crossroads is a house, where twin brothers live. FRENCH twin brothers. One always tells the truth. The other always lies. If you knock on the door to ask which way you should go, one of them will answer. You have no way of knowing which brother you are speaking with.
You may only ask one question. Get over it, it's a children's puzzle. There is no bifurcating this one. Shit or git off my porch.
What one question will you ask of the wiz, to find your way home?
Can you both please lead me to the vipers?
One will say yes, the other no and go the same way. One because he's telling the truth, the other because he lied.
--If I asked you if this was the path to the den of vipers, would you say yes?--
OR --Si je vous demandais si cela était le chemin vers le repaire de vipères, voulez-vous dire oui? --
Wiz, I thought feeling my breath was the way home, but walking alongside, or alongwith, seems to be home.
Or, what would the other man say is the right path?
The question is: would your brother give the same answer?
The liar has to say yes. The truth teller has to say no.
Really just a different phrasing of your question-same logic.
The intelligence apparatus no longer protects us from terrorism
The public safety apparatus no longer protects public safety
The military apparatus no longer defends us
The political apparatus no longer governs for the public good
The economic apparatus no longer strengthens our economy
The educational apparatus no longer teaches our children what they need to be successful
The healthcare apparatus no longer makes us healthier
The agricultual apparatus no longer nourishes us