This page has been archived and commenting is disabled.
Citi Identifies Contagion "Trigger Point" For More ECB QE
Greece’s historic referendum is in the books and confusion now reigns in Europe and in stock and bond markets across the globe. Put simply, no one — not the politicians, not the analysts, not the traders — has any idea what happens next because there simply is no precedent for a voter-supported exit from the EMU.
While markets, as a rule, hate uncertainty, the environment on Monday is more than uncertain. This is a case of outright confusion and until there’s at least some degree of clarity on whether i) debt restructuring will form the backbone of a renegotiated deal between Athens and Brussels, and ii) whether the ECB intends to allow Greek banks to reopen this week, the “market” (so that’s the algos and whatever carbon-based lifeforms are still crawling around out there) can’t even begin to decide which uncertain future it should fear. Is near-term contagion risk triggered by a Greek banking sector meltdown the problem or is the real issue that a negotiated restructuring of Greece’s debt will alleviate the short-term crisis but make it more likely that the entire drama will repeat itself with Spain and Portugal? No one knows and so at least for the next 48 hours, the only thing to fear, so to speak, is fear itself.
Once the market has a better idea about whether it should fear a near-term, Lehman-style meltdown or a longer-term reimagining of the entire European project, periphery spreads (not to mention EU equities) will begin to price in the uncertainty and at that point the ECB’s contagion fighting “tools” (outlined here earlier today) will be put to the test. Citi has more on the above and on the “trigger” point for ECB intervention.
* * *
Big picture thoughts
The myopic focus on contagion here should not hide the long term implications of events now unfolding, with one negative for periphery being that Greece has already set a bad precedent (as far periphery bonds are concerned) where reform/austerity is put directly to a plebiscite.
If Greece comes to the table and agrees on a new bailout avoiding default and Grexit, the implications are that the Euro region is indeed robust, but that will only be evident many months into any new bailout.
Default inside the Euro area by Greece, but no Grexit, is not positive for periphery risk primarily because forces from the political extremes would see this as somehow favorable, despite the economic pain. That is, it is not just Grexit, that delivers risk of political contagion.
Finally, if Greece does exit the Euro, investors will have learned that markets cannot break the Euro but democracy can. That adds risk premium for periphery medium term given that (a) the absence of large contagion limits the motivations for a political integration response and (b) because a debt overhang with political fatigue in Europe, will not necessarily be a unique Greek experience in the next recession.
Next steps – and watching the 20th July bond redemption
Euro area leaders have called Summit for Tuesday ahead of which a Eurogroup meeting will take place. We do not expect significant concessions on debt haircuts or the conditionality of the programme. That means, with Greek banks likely to face closure, markets will focus on whether the 20th July €3.5bn bond redemption to the ECB is a default event.
How do bonds trade?
The most important feature of the periphery trade around the Greek crisis is the relative calm in how markets have traded. This is related to two factors. Firstly, Greece looks more of an exception than a template in respect of both politics and economics. Secondly, the ECB is signaling that it is ready to provide a firewall. For instance, the statement last weekend, noted that
“The Governing Council is closely monitoring the situation in financial markets and the potential implications for the monetary policy stance and for the balance of risks to price stability in the euro area. The Governing Council is determined to use all the instruments available within its mandate”.
Benoit Cœuré then repeated this message and noted the latest ruling by the European Court of Justice highlighted the “need for the ECB to have some room for manoeuvre” in the choice of its instruments in order to fulfil its mandate.
He followed this up this weekend, by saying the ECB is ready to take additional measures to support the eurozone at a "time of uncertainty". He added that "In the current circumstances of great uncertainty in Europe and the world, the ECB has been clear that if we need to do more we will do more. Our will to act in this matter should not be doubted".
That sounds very much like ‘whatever it takes’ remark and in this respect we have little doubt that the ECB will act either through more QE (if economic sentiment is hurt) or perhaps through more targeted purchases of periphery paper.
It is not known whether any periphery specific purchases will be centralized risk or via the balance sheets of the NCBs – but for now we doubt this matters because we do not think the ECB will fail to make its mark if it decided to act.
The common view of the ECB is that they are slow and meek. The slowness to respond to disinflation is correct but when the ECB acts it can typically surprise in its size and aggression – as with QE itself.
We would begin to doubt the ECB firewall only if the ECB interventions were any combination of collateral moves or OMT, where the latter would be seen as a policy error given the need for MOUs to activate. That would add a new political crisis and is probably why the ECB is signaling that it is looking at its monetary policy stance – a string hint that asset purchase is on the radar.
Periphery levels: 3% in 10y BTP to price ECB intervention risk
As we wrote recently, our central view is that periphery contagion is limited by the ECB signaling effect, but should markets fret, and ECB action becomes necessary then we think the markets will price ECB action well before highly stressed levels.
If we for instance take it view of the monetary policy stance impact seriously then market moves that take real yields to levels that persisted before the ECB started easing policy (negative rates started in Jun 2014) may be a trigger point.
Markets would anticipate ECB action on a move of near 50bp in real 10y BTP yields and this is consistent with 10y nominal BTP nearer 3%.
* * *
Note that Citi has effectively ruled out two of the ECB's contagion fighting tools as not credible. Anything that requires an MOU or isn't conducive to unilateral activation and implementation will make the market "doubt the firewall." In other words: it's more QE or nothing, and at least according to Citi, the threshold is pre-June 2014 Italian spreads.
At that point — i.e. at the point when Goldman's conspiract theory stunner finally comes true and PSPP is expaned in order to "fight contagion" — the only remaining question will be how long it takes for ECB purchases to suck so much liquidity from the market that all non-central bank buyers begin to demand higher yields to compenstate them for the liquidity risk. When that happens, the ECB will officially join the Riksbank in what will be an ever growing pool of central banks who, having reached the monetezation endgame, will either admit defeat or go to Defcon 1, the monetary paradrop.
»
- 15412 reads
- Printer-friendly version
- Send to friend
- advertisements -
CITI identifies Contagion Trigger Point: Our own PRECIOUS METALS DERIVATIVES BOOK
++++
Primary detonator: When the lightbulb goes on over the heads of Boobus-Americanus, that what was normal, sound and secure, is no longer.
..."Note that Citi has effectively ruled out two of the ECB's contagion fighting tools as not credible. Anything that requires an MOU or isn't conducive to unilateral activation and implementation will make the market "doubt the firewall." ... "
... I wonder if precious metals were Citi's only lapdog in this fight ... let me see ... Citi's owned by: Abu Dhabi >>> http://www.democracynow.org/2007/11/29/abu_dhabi_becomes_largest_citigroup_shareholder; Prince Al Waleed >>> http://www.americanbankingnews.com/2010/04/20/citigroups-nyse-c-largest-shareholder-strongly-supports-pandit/; & US taxpayers >>> http://swampland.time.com/2009/02/27/a-sign-of-whats-to-come/
... perhaps, Citi's one of ECB's mouthpieces hiding in the shadows used to "identify" the supposed trigger point ... to greek the greeks ...
A nation of sheep will be led by wolves...
http://galeinnes.blogspot.com/2015/06/the-great-government-heist.html
Kid in the pic coulda been me in 1966.
Bazooka shot a wicked airball that would be illegal nowadays.
Fuck the Banksters.
LOL, had one- greatest gift ever...
I wonder if a real one will take out an MRAP.
http://foxtrotalpha.jalopnik.com/a-school-district-bought-an-18-ton-mrap...
As visions dance in your head of Assistant Principal Bone gleefully peering out the top hatch, ready to crush any truant that dares to step in his way, San Diego Unified School District Police Chief Ruben Littlejohn said that all of the weapons have been removed, really, an enormous MRAP is about protecting the kids, and making them feel good, according to local radio station KPBS:
When ex-Goldman people work everywhere is it really a suprise things always go how Goldman want?
Any excuse... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lx4poQw1mZo
Tsk, no where has the Greeks talked about a Grexit. The only people talking about it are the ECB and their lapdogs.......
It’s like “slacking” at a job you HATE…
you don’t QUIT, they have to FIRE you!
"not the politicians, not the analysts, not the traders — has any idea what happens next because there simply is no precedent for a voter-supported exit from the EMU"
Sounds like fun
QE is cover ("we tried") for the biggest financial crimes in history.
Dig deep. The answers are buried very deep.
"QE" just means your plans to "pay me/screw you" have failed and you have now reached the point where "pay me" isn't even working.
"The good news is there is no hope for recovery under QE" so the ECB still at least has that going for them.
Hence "why Greece should go first."
Simply no longer become a "country" per se but let others "define you" as you print trillions in euro under the auspices of "free trade."
Buy yourself a pet lizard and equip said lizard with a nice diamond necklace...appear at various social functions of your choosing..."make a good show" as it were.
If you can't baffle them with bullshit, offer the slaves free money from the sky.
It won't cost a penny, well unless you buy goods and services. Central Banking needs to hit the 2% GDP mark. If they feel the bench mark is compromised, print more money to inflate false hopes.
Comedical to say the least. It won't be long until the population executes them. Obama can take away our guns, we'll just start using the new laser technology.
:p
Should markets fret
Must never have THAT, people can get no treatment if sick and the poor and pensioners starve and die, but the market fretting, that can NOT happen is the banksters mantra
Love the picture. When we were kids we had all kinds of rifles and stuff. We were free. It was a good life.
My guess is it's either an old picture or one not taken in the US: note the inexcusable lack of helmet, safety goggles, hearing protection, gloves or body armor.
+it wasn't a video game.
We stopped being "free" about 1861 and possibly earlier.
Good point. Read Howard Zinn's "A People's History of the United States", to clarify anyone's thinking.
The Greek tragedy is just a smoke screen to to what ECB and other banksters wanted to do all along. Blowing bubbles and without acknowledging the fact nothing can be understood no ZIRP, NIRP or QE and infinitum. We need to know what bubblology is all about.
Bubblology 101;
Bubbles are credit expansion/contraction, government policy driven monetary intervention cycles well described in "Money Masters" which now are completely divorced from economic cycle, which is stuck in US in depression levels over thirty years now. In other words boom and bust cycles are only fueled now through credit policy into specific market tradable assets selected and ordered by policy makers.
The world central banking system is trying to moderate bubbles’ deflation or collapses through creation bubbles in another asset class just to maintain values of collateral from the initial bubbles. For example if you overpaid for your house and prices are falling and you cannot sell without massive loss, windfall from another bubble is able to cover your mortgage, losses and/or margin requirements, so you hope and wait for better times.
And so you go from one bubble to another and this relates all abstract paper assets and derivatives including, debt, oil and gold etc. Hence, crash may occur only when CBs run out of bubbly and no more bubbles could be created otherwise party will go on while more and more weaker rats in this rat race are being eliminated via attrition and slide into socio-economic margins like most of us even if we do not know it yet, we are next.
Such practice, in essence denying basic tenet of capitalism namely capital re-production and recycling into productive assets, which is in the first place is labor, was and is widely implemented over last 30 years by world ruling elites and now even in China rendering population obsolete in grand scheme of illustrious progress of civilization.
The real economy is dead so its real economic cycle that included revolving commodity and labor investment assets, recycled in and out economy a classical capitalistic re-production cycle. This type of process is dead and buried.
There is no revitalization of labor power as well as commodity demand due to collapse of labor income and collapse of asset or commodities prices controlled by vast majority of population subjected to deadly deflation spiral due to removal of money from circulation among ordinary people a devastating process, getting stronger and more intense as bubbles become bigger and more numerous.
The only thing that keeps us from massive unrest, hunger and ultimately extinction now is money supply from government social programs such pensions, SS, social welfare, technical/scientific funding, military or security/police non-productive funding which ironically fuel spiral of debt needed to keep it blowing.
It’s like on Titanic, party was going on as usual while in lower decks people were slowly drowning. I hope that there would be not enough boats for all those murderous and gluttonous oligarchs when water reaches their noses.
Simplified take on QE and market liquidity can be found at:
https://contrarianopinion.wordpress.com/2015/01/28/liquidity-of-blood-sw...
Ok, nationalize the banks. Restore the Drachma and negotiate with Russia and China on an exchange rate. Begin lending to small businesses.
Then jail the bankers or use firing squad whatever is the course in Greece for treason.