This page has been archived and commenting is disabled.
Goldman Warns "VIX Seems Low", Significantly Underpricing Economic Uncertainty
"The options market seems to either be anticipating an inflection higher in the economic data, no rate hike, or an extreme lack of catalysts between now and year-end," according to Goldman Sachs' Krag Gregory. With VIX trading with a 13 handle, Gregroy warns, it is notably under-priced relative a 19 handle more in line with economic and policy uncertainty. The potential for volatility to swing higher seems more likely.
The VIX landed at 14.2 on November 2nd, back down to its average closing level during the low volatility years of 2013 and 2014.
That seems low to us given recent weakness in the U.S. economic data and a potential rate hike in December. The options market seems to either be anticipating an inflection higher in the economic data, no rate hike, or an extreme lack of catalysts between now and year-end.
Argument for higher volatility: Uncertainty surrounding a mediocre economy + FOMC reaction function; GDP of 1.5% and ISM @ 50 are more consistent with a 19 VIX
Our VIX model uses economic inputs to estimate trend VIX levels over time. With the ISM, consumer spending and unemployment data that we have in hand, our models would suggest baseline VIX levels of 19, not 14 and change. Reverse engineering our model we estimate that a 14 VIX is more consistent with an ISM new orders level above 60 (ISM high 50’s) given no change in consumer spending or the unemployment rate.
The U.S. options market may be expecting economic stabilization, or a lower likelihood of a December rate hike given an ISM at 50.1.
Volatility: Less room for error with ISM @ 50 and GDP is 1.5% rather than 3%
GDP is 1.5% and ISM at 50.1: In our 2015 Volatility Forecast (January 20, 2015), we showed that the FOMC has tended to hike rates when the economy is on solid footing. U.S. real GDP growth has been 3% or higher during the quarter of the initial hike and the ISM averaged 57.6 the month of the hike and a robust 57 one- to three-months after a hike over the last three rate cycles. While the VIX is already pricing in an ISM level in the high 50's and the FED has put a December hike back on the table, the economy is well below where we were at the beginning of past hikes. The advance number for real GDP was +1.5% in Q3 and the ISM stands at 50.1. That gives us a lot less cushion than in past cycles.
Implications: Modest U.S. and global growth may imply that U.S. market volatility (much like the FOMC) will be a lot more data dependent.
The economy and the FOMC reaction function will be the key into year-end. Our point is that the potential for volatility to swing higher seems more likely when we are (1) at low VIX levels, (2) the economy is mediocre, and (3) the market is navigating the ramifications of a potential December rate hike.
Bottom line: a VIX back at 2013-2014 levels seems low if a December rate hike really is in play. In terms of timing, it may be natural for volatility to take a breather after the intense market swings experienced in August-September, an earnings season, and three highly scrutinized central bank meetings (FOMC, ECB, BOJ). We would take advantage of lower option prices to implement direction views.
Source: Goldman Sachs
»
- 280 reads
- Printer-friendly version
- Send to friend
- advertisements -
So now we're worrying about LOW VIX?!? Doesn't stop does it?
Bull trap complete. Time for bull blood to flow like rivers, Most obvious bull trap in history.
Spoken like a true short who is about to get his face ripped off!
thief - noun \thef\
: a person who steals something
plural thieves \thevz\
Full Definition of THIEF
:one that steals especially stealthily or secretly; also : one who commits theft or larceny
Common Synonyms: Goldman Sachs.
FUCK THEM AND THEIR ILK!
Let me guess you believe in the tooth fairy as well?
Not seeing it Carpenter. The only index that could potentially have a big dump is the Russel - seems to be lagging. Perhaps this is what's holding everything from going to nosebleed measures. I'd like to believe a reversal is in the offing. But, I'm seeing nothing but blue skies for the bulls.
The gold man may be on to something for once,todays vix action was "curious" . parties seem to be buying protection,reloaded on UVXY myself. something smells..
That smell is your money burning up!
There was this.. from a month ago.
Goldman: VIX In Midst of Historic IndecisionVIX will fluctuate.
nailed it.
I'm guessing they got caught a little too long...
With the algos going crazy this past week, pretty hard to feel confident one way or the other.
http://pebblewriter.com/cl-algo-madness/
They know that the NY FED is responsible for the VIX rigging/suppression. They decide when the VIX moves up or down.
WHAT happened to Goldman lately?
Did they take a reality pill?
I could swear that someone at the top of Goldman - is trying to tell the truth. Big image change?
YEAH the VIX is way underpriced, Goldman folks.
You know why. It's not another conspiracy theory. It's those stupid HFT's. They profit off small moves in volatility. That's their game. So they eat up a lot of movement on the VIX curve, Which means .. the VIX ain't really the VIX, until the market jumps big time.
GS is selling VIX calls to whomever thinks their linear VIX "model" seems legit.
Enjoy.
Why does Goldman even bother to pretend.
Economic uncertainty has absolutely nothing to do with price.
The VIX, as with Precious Metals prices, is manipulated like silly putty in the hands of a five year old!
Do not try and bend the VIX, that's impossible. Instead, only try to realize the truth...there is no VIX . Then you will see it is not the VIX that bends, it is only yourself."