The "World's Most Bearish Hedge Fund" Crushed It In 2015

Tyler Durden's picture

The name of $2.8 billion Horseman Capital is familiar to regular readers for two main reasons: not only has the fund, which some have called the "most bearish in the world", generated tremendous returns ever since inception except for a 25% drop in 2009 (after returning 31% during the cataclysmic 2008), but more notably, it has been net short - and quite bearish on - stocks ever since 2012. In that period it has consistently generated low double-digit returns, a feat virtually none of its competitors have managed to replicate. In fact, its performance has put it in the top percentile of all hedge funds in recent years.

And, according to its December letter, Horseman not only crushed it in both December and 2015, but knocked it out of the ballpark.  Here's why:

It's hardly new to Horseman, which has been "crushing it" for four years in a row, and not surprisingly, 2015 was its best year since 2008.

What is most amazing is that as noted above, Horseman has been bearish since 2012 while outperforming most hedge funds and as of this moment is net short by a whopping -68%, which could certifiably put it in the running for the title of the "world's most bearish hedge fund."

Here is how Horseman made a killing in December:

This month the gains came from the short portfolio, in particular from oil and oil transportation, EM financials and automobile sectors. The short exposure to real estate and the long portfolio incurred modest losses.

What was the fund most bearish on? Pretty much everything, but a few sectors in particular:

Furthermore, Horseman seems to have an unusually bearish bias toward Mexico and especially Pemex and the Mexican auto sector. Here's why:

In Latin America, the poor performances of the Argentinian and Brazilian economies are regularly making the headlines in the press, while the economy of Mexico tends to be perceived in better shape, less reliant on commodity prices and benefiting from being closer to the growing US economy. However, the Mexican economy is heavily reliant on the automobile and oil sectors, which respectively accounted for 21.6% and 10.6% of its exports in 2014.


The country runs a 2% current account deficit and a 3.19% budget deficit. The budget deficit does not take into account the losses from its national oil company Petroleos Mexicanos (Pemex), which is used by the government as a financing vehicle to finance about 30% of its budget. The company said that in the third quarter of 2015, taxes and royalties accounted to 232% of its operating results. It reported a $9.9bn net loss, its 12th consecutive quarterly loss. As a result, for 2016, the company expects to borrow $21bn, increasing outstanding debt to more than $100bn.


In November of last year, the government used an average oil price of $50 per barrel for its 2016 budget. However, since then, oil prices collapsed to $32. Including Pemex’s losses and using the Q3 quarterly results, Mexico’s budget deficit is more likely to be around 6% of GDP, a level similar to Brazil’s current official number.


In the automobile sector Mexico has overtaken Japan as the second largest source of U.S. auto imports. Mexican made vehicles account for 11% of cars and trucks sold to the U.S. The Mexican Automobile Industry Association estimated that more than 70% of the cars and light trucks headed to the US in 2015. Over the past 5 years, US purchases of cars have been largely driven by a boom in auto loans, which in our opinion is about to end.


The Mexican government has introduced structural reforms in the hope of encouraging new entrants to challenge monopolies. However, in our opinion, these reforms will take years to pay dividends, while in the short term the economy will have to adjust to low oil prices and a likely downturn in automobile demand. The fund maintains a short exposure to the Mexican peso versus the US dollar of approximately 25%.

We expect the "short Mexico" trade to become quite popular in the coming weeks.

Finally, here is the monthly essay by Russell Clark, Horseman's CIO, which as always is a delightful read and this time has a Star Wars theme.

Yellen Skywalker inched down the corridor. There was barely any light, but the force guided her steps. Soon she felt the presence of her father, Deflation Vader. His voice rasped out a greeting.


“I have been expecting you. I can feel that the force is strong with you. Good. The Emperor has foreseen that your powers would grow, and that you would become our ally. It is time for you to join me and restore order to the universe!”


“You are wrong Vader – I would never go to dark side!”


“Ha ha ha – dark side – what dark side? Did Obi-Wan Ben Bernanke never tell you the true nature of the force?”


“What true nature?” asks a troubled Yellen.


“The force is all around us, and seeks harmony and balance. It is neither light nor dark, but cyclical. Mountains must have valleys. Light must create shadow. Action and reaction, this is all that life is. Your belief in the light side of the force, and the need for you to strenuously push it on all things, to create inflation in all things, is touching, but quite misguided.”


Vader continued “Low interest rates and debt creation in particular is an object that is neither inherently inflationary nor deflationary, but only becomes a tool of the light or the dark side if it moves out of balance, or harmony. You see my jedi, debt accumulation is inflationary when taken on and deflationary when paid back. The longer you push your light side of the force, the stronger the dark side becomes! You have in fact been my greatest ally!” Vader let out a bellowing laugh.


“Search your feelings Yellen, you know that I speak the truth”. Yellen knew the words Vader spoke were true. Despite monumental efforts, the light side had only generated minor inflation, even with previously unheard interest rates and even with their new monetary techniques. She thought back to the day her mentor Obi-Wan Ben Bernanke disappeared off to some far flung colony – his parting words as he passed responsibility for the light side to Yellen were cryptic – “Whatever you do, do not do anything sensible”. But Yellen knew she faced a dilemma, if she continued to fight the dark side she only made it stronger, and the ultimate move to harmony more difficult. Or should she succumb now, and hope that dark side influence would not destroy too much. In her heart, she made her decision.


“You are right father, I can see that. What must I do?”


“Why my child, you must do nothing, just cease to fight the dark side, and it shall restore harmony to the universe as surely as a rising tide destroys footprints in the sand. Come, let us watch”


Vader and Yellen moved over to an observation window. From the view she could see the dancing constellations that made up the financial universe. Many shone as brightly as they could. Record employment, record car sales, all-time highs in the stock market. Yellen let go of the light side of the force. Almost instantaneously, the Transport star system began to darken and disappear. The high yield nebula went into super nova and slowly began to darken. And then nothing. But as Yellen watched all the bright constellations began to darken ever so slightly. And Yellen could feel a tremor from a billion traders’ hearts, as fear began to replace greed in their hearts. She wondered what she had done, as she stood next to Vader, and watched the lights go out.

Clarke's parting words: "Your fund remains long bonds, short equities."

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
The Merovingian's picture

Yeah, but what about Gartman? /s

Plunge Protection's picture

He's -1000% in his virtual portfolio

TheDanimal's picture

So, when these guys go short bonds, if the bubble hasn't popped yet, that would be a good time to go all in short bonds?

Arnold's picture

I do not believe you deserve the Guy Fawkes mask yet,..

You ask silly and unanswerable questions.

TheDanimal's picture

I take that as a compliment since I am attempting to raise the quality of the discourse and expand my mind.

Arnold's picture

With all the homework I do, I allow my self only the fact that I can recognize pure shit when I see it.

. . . _ _ _ . . .'s picture

"I do not believe you deserve the Guy Fawkes mask..."

That is so not in the spirit of Anonymous. V, perhaps.

Yen Cross's picture

 Good for them. An ounce of prevention, is worth a pound of cure.

 Those returns were/are inline with reality, based on all that sloshing fiat churning central bank balance sheets.

 Don't get me started on the bond markets<><><

squid's picture

The time to get in with these guys was 2010.

They will get crushed when th market turns in 2-3 years OR when the market eventually stops falling and goes sideways for a decade or two....think NIKKIE.


Buy gold and bury it.


Everyone with a MBA should be rounded up for re-education......these tuckers have destroyed the world.



Jstanley011's picture

Nice fable. Capitalism isn't quite so dramatic however.

Protecting overcapacity and underwriting failed ventures via bailouts and mis-priced money misalocates capital and labor that would otherwise be available for shifts to new enterprises and for more competent players to take over existing ones.

"Market exposure" causes "creative destruction," but the words of the latter are in the wrong order. First you go broke, then you figure out how to do better. Get a bankster bonus or borrow funny money to do stock buybacks with a view to cashing out before the bill comes due, enabled by Congress and the Fed, and you don't. Simple as that.

"Almost instantaneously, the Transport star system began to darken and disappear."

Long horse carts?

Yen Cross's picture

  Anyone that trades " Capital Destruction" is  pretty kool in my book.

DipshitMiddleClassWhiteKid's picture

spoken like a true currency trader


liquidty is our hedge!

Yen Cross's picture

 There's an old adage... Currency and Bond Traders see shit long before it happens.


AGuy's picture

[Rolling Star Wars "Empire" Theme music]

[Screen scroll Text]:In the not so distant economy, in the near future..


[Emperor Obamatine, followed by Darth Yellen causally walks into the scene]

Luke horseman: Your empire days are over. Sooner all your markets will tank!

Emperor: You underestimate the power of the darkside, We are quite safe from your insignificant Rebellious friends.

Luke horseman: You'r overconfidence is your weakness!

Emperor: Your faith in your Bearish Friends is yours!

[Darth Yellen steps close to his Emperor side]

Emperor:  Come, boy, see for yourself. From here, you will witness the final destruction of all your shorts and the end of your insignificant rebellion.

Emperor: As you can see, my young apprentice, your friends have failed. Now witness the firepower of this fully ARMED and OPERATIONAL Central Bank battlestation!

[Yellen signals to fire off QE-forever]

[In an instance, Rebel Ships heavily laided with shorted equities begin to explode as the Federal Reserve Bank fires its Primary Weapon: QE]

[HedgeFund manager Akbar, aboard Rebel flag ship] Its a Trap!

[Rebel alliance is rounded up by the Fed troopers sending to prison to attempted to undermind the stability of the Empire]


"Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the mouth' --Mike Tyson


Urban Roman's picture

Horseman? Not our Hedgeless Horseman I presume?

DeadCatBouncer's picture

One Horseman of the Apocalypse riding high on the corpses of those who die.

yogibear's picture

Gartman started this rally.

Jim Bulltard, of the St Louis Fed, pushed it further.

hedgiex's picture

Cool Horesemen. Have been late (only early 2015) than awake to track them. They are pretty wily so do not take their bond bit literally.