EU Court: Hungary Guilty of Human Rights Violations, Court Orders Sovereign Nation to Pay Refugees Fines for Unlawful Detainment

The_Real_Fly's picture

Back in the 13th century, Hungary was at the front lines of the Golden Horde's invasion into Europe. It is widely believed that their transformative defensive tactics of building walled cities helped fend off the Mongolians -- saving the rest of Europe from an eventual Mongolian occupation.

Fast forward to today, there is a similar invasion taking place, this time from the middle east. To defend the people of Hungary, the country has set up transit zones in order to properly vet migrants -- before releasing them.

Hungary's PM, Viktor Orban, is on record saying he didn't want more muslim refugees in Hungary -- explaining how the muslim invasion represented a tangible threat to Christian dominated Europe.

In a speech given a little more than a year ago, Orban laid out his grievances -- calling the EU the 'enemies of freedom.'

In a referendum vote in late 2016, 98% of Hungarians voted against EU migrant quotas. PM Orban said “Hungary voted to keep its freedom, its right to decide who we want to live together with, and we decided that we won’t give this right to Brussels. We can be proud that Hungarian people were the first to be given the right to express their opinion on Brussels politics."

Establishing the fact that Orban and the EU were at an impasse, we're now led to the European Court of Human Rights at Strasbourg, France -- who just ruled that Hungary violated the human rights of two migrants who filed suit. Moreover, they ordered Hungary to pay them, mind you, 10,000 euros a piece PLUS another 8,705 euros to cover their fucking expenses.

What did the court say Hungary did?

The 'unlawfully' kept the two men in the transit zone -- a place designated by Hungary to properly process and vet migrants entering their nation. In other words, the EU court found Hungary guilty of unlawfully defending their border from invaders.

Source: Reuters
Two Bangladeshi citizens, Ilias Ilias and Ali Ahmed, filed a suit against Hungary in September 2015, shortly after the government put up a fence on its southern borders and created two transit zones for asylum seekers in a bid to curb the number of migrants arriving via the Balkans.
The two men sought to be released from the transit zone and asked for their expulsion to Serbia be halted.
The court ruled that their detention in the transit zone was unlawful under the European Convention of Human Rights, but there was "no violation of the convention in respect of the conditions of detention at the transit zone."
The Strasbourg court ruling is subject to appeal. The government was not immediately available for comment.

Going forward, some hope this decision will force Hungary into abandoning the idea of minding a border -- freely permitting migrants to come to and fro Europe whenever they like.

"This judgment is particularly relevant now in Hungary because the Strasbourg court has found that detaining asylum seekers in the transit zone without any formal procedure and access to judicial remedy is unlawful," Marta Pardavi, co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee, which represented the migrants' case in the court.
"This already ongoing practice of unlawful detention in the transit zone is exactly what the Hungarian newly adopted law foresees for every asylum seeker, so it's clear: the new law is against the European Convention on Human Rights."

Earlier this month, the Hungarian parliament approved the automatic detainment of all migrants into the transit zone.
"Those readying for the journey do not want to live according to our ways and culture, but according to their own - only with a European quality of life," said PM Orban.

Content originally generated at

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
tuetenueggel's picture

Dear mr. Orban,

pls ignore the stupid sentence of this court.

There are only idiots sitting and telling sovereign states what to do ?

Fuck them an throw them out of your country. Close all borders and please keep them closed. This will save Europe a 2 nd time from those wild muslim hordes of goat -  and donkeyfuckers.

wanderer9641's picture

The EU can piss off.

SMC's picture

EU "membership" is a curse.

Hungary may be the next one out the door - good for them.

tuetenueggel's picture

If that will happen, I´ll at once will ask them to give the right to live there to me.

I´m so fed up with this EU-Idiots and the Berlin morons who destroy my homeland.

hendrik1730's picture

A "formal procedure" and access to judicial support can be fixed in 1 hour : each asylumseeker now sitting in a transit zone is given a fill-out form with questions and gets a waiting list number ( that constitutes a "formal procedure" ). And allocate 1 lawyer ( state funded ) per transit zone, taking his time to go through all answers and proofs of "being in danger" in their homeland. Next number please, there are only 5689 asylumseekers waiting before you. Impatient? Go elsewhere, Problem solved.

Fireman's picture

Good for Hungary, a nation and people that knows all too well the stench of totalitarian filth steaming from the dung hill in Natostan sewer Brussels "seat" of the Pedophile Politburo that is turning the EUSSR into a muslim s#ithole. Today Geert Wilders shows Europeons the way out of this insanity.



tuetenueggel's picture

I hope thet Dutch people won´t let him stand in rain withour umbrella.

Geert god with you.

TheVoicesInYourHead's picture

Hungary, you dont need the EU.

For the sake of your ancient culture, get out of the EU asap.

LoveTruth's picture

EU is good, but not under Merkel and Holande. If they continue to destroy the Christian nature of  EU, EU will fall apart. 

LoveTruth's picture

Well, if the majority of the people think the EU is no good, so be it. I thougt it was good for Europeans to travel freely in Europe, but seems there are other things I do not know about. If it is not good for the majority, it should be broken up.



tuetenueggel's picture

Maybe you are payed by the Brussels morons. You don´t know what about you´re writing. Nonsens. Brussels are thiefs, pedofile criminals and bigmouthsmallbrainers.

None of them was elected by anybody. 55.000 lazy stupid officials are telling 500 Million people what to do ? Fuck them all.

prymythirdeye's picture

You clearly have no clue what you are talking about.  Thanks for trolling.

PrivetHedge's picture

No part of the EU is good.

Before the EU Europs wa a diverse, happy and prosperous area.

Today it's bankrupt, broken and unhappy.

SmittyinLA's picture

Hungary should not appeal but ignore the EU "kangaroo courts", appealing gives them credibility, Hungary needs to reject the EU human rights court and force those that push invasion into their courts, then bend them over like Turk courts would.

Flankspeed60's picture

EXACTLY EXACTLY EXACTLY! Appealing pays deference to them - ignoring them robs them of their power. Trump should do EXACTLY the same thing to the rogue federal courts here in the States. If rogue federal judges want to make new laws in clear violation of the Constitution, let them also try to enforce 'em. I would go to war with the bastards - start by cutting the lights and heat to rogue fed courthouses as a budget-cutting measure.

shovelhead's picture

Oh look, it's a lawyer from European Court of Human Rights at Strasbourg coming to collect his clients money...

What do you have for him Mr. Orban?

Gee, I really don't think that would fit without an awful lot of work.

oncemore's picture

Yes, Organ kicked out IMF and WB. Closed th3ir shops in Budapest.

Am not surprised.


truthseeker47's picture

This HAS to be a BIG TELL to all the other nations that still want to be their own nations: Get the F out of EU asap.

SquadronVBF94's picture

Organ will no doubt tell the EU court exact?Y where they can put their ruling. I'd like!E to see them in force it. The EU s faded with a "March of the Sovereigns" fleeing the yoke of tyranny  o different than happened when the Soviet Union collapsed.

bardot63's picture

I think Wilders just got a big boost in the Dutch vote tomorrow............and LaPen in France, and 5-Star in Italy.  Bad timing for the EU to remind citizens they are being fucked over. 

tuetenueggel's picture

I´m afraid not.

People are to lazy and uninformed.

They still are praying, we are ok. If armageddonwill come, it won´t hit me.........

GreatUncle's picture

If it does not hit the news then makes no difference and we have seen the concept of free speech is dead with the current MSM refusing to acknowledge anything but what their masters tell them.

bitterwolf's picture

well there is this liitle matter of the Hungarian Army......EU can issue proclamations and ruling until it chokes on them.....

mtanimal's picture

Tell the EU court to piss off. 98% of Hungarians voted to keep these people out, but foreign elitists want to override them and force them to commit ethnic suicide. They need to exit the EU ASAP.

Teshuvah's picture

Yes.  How do you spell it?  Hungexit?

bardot63's picture

It's time to dust off those old rifles hidden in European haylofts.... 

tuetenueggel's picture

They long ago have been cleaned, oiled and are almost as new.

We knew what was comming. Brussels is a lot more evil than Hitler was. Hitler told all the world i´ll et the world on fire.

Brussels said we bring freedom, wealth and kindness.  The only country after 1945 which didn´t fuck Germoney was Russia. We should be very grateful to mr. Putin.

fbazzrea's picture

Hungary is one of the few nations in the world without a Rothschild-owned central bank. of course, they're guilty... pay, pay, pay!

cheech_wizard's picture

First Brexit... now Hungarexit? Hexit?

Standard Disclaimer: Last one out is the bagholder...

atthelake's picture

At some point, a nation will be fed up and declare war on Europe when they should declare war on Soros, Rothschild, etc.

How many guns in Hungary?

tuetenueggel's picture

nuff. more than necessary.

SoDamnMad's picture

Wrong question. How many guns in Europe?  Think partisans. Partisans sniping in Strasbourg, sniping in Germany, Sweden, Finland, Netherlands AND of course in Hungary.

steelrules's picture

Vlad can fix the gun shortage in a heart beat.

honest injun's picture

Hungary, admit the invaders but have firing squads at the gates.  I don't think it would take more than a few bullets to cause the invaders to decide to go elsewhere. 

tuetenueggel's picture

after first 500 have an additional asshole, its over.

East Indian's picture

Sovereignty is dead. 

steelrules's picture

I have insight into this as my heritage is Hungarian, Every Hungarian knows the nations history. The history of how 3 seas once washed Hungary's shores and how the county was hacked into the tiny land locked country it is today, by the Treaty of Trianon. No Hungarian will willingly give up this last little piece land, not to Islam and not to Brussels.

Every Hungarian knows this history and is proud of how Hungarians fought the Muslim Hoards for 600 years and how the Danude river ran red with hungarian blood, how the soil it self is so good for crops because of the Hungarian blood spilled on it. 

Even the Flag it's self Red White Green, "Red is our blood, White are our souls, Green are our Fields"

Hungarians were the front lines in the defense of Europe from around 1050 to 1526 

Old Doctor's picture

I too have a part Hungarian ancestry. My Grandmother emigrated legally from Szeged. But all her people were from Transylvania. She was a tough nut to crack. I would not be surprised if Hungary is the first country to kick Brussels in the balls. And rightfully. President Orban should issue an arrest warrant for the Hungarian traitor Soros. Imagine that little Hungary, the country that so many often made fun of now stands taller and prouder than France. The scarcity of Rothechilds must encourage clear thinking.

steelrules's picture

Kindered, My father came to Canada in 56 from Cegléd during the revolution, and my mother from the Hungarian speaking part of Romania. 

I have a theory about Soros, he hates all western countries because of what they did to Hungary twice, first in Trianon then again in 1956, the west was promising to help the Hungarians throw off the Soviets but they didn't lift a finger. Just my theory of why Soros hates the west.

tuetenueggel's picture

Soros ( György ) is a jew and hates most himself.

Al Armed's picture

No, Soros is a Jew who, as a 14-yr-old collaborated in Hungary helping Nazis confiscate Jewish property. My guess is he believes he will redeem himself if he's the one to destroy Christiandom. Of course, there's always this:

When thou comest nigh unto a city to fight against it, then proclaim peace unto it. And it shall be, if it make thee answer of peace, and open unto thee, then it shall be, that all the people that is found therein shall be tributaries unto thee, and they shall serve thee. And if it will make no peace with thee, but will make war against thee, then thou shalt besiege it: And when the LORD thy God hath delivered it into thine hands, thou shalt smite every male thereof with the edge of the sword: But the women, and the little ones, and the cattle, and all that is in the city, even all the spoil thereof, shalt thou take unto thyself; and thou shalt eat the spoil of thine enemies, which the LORD thy God hath given thee.

Deuteronomy 20:11


Grandad Grumps's picture

Giving them all a free train ticket to Brussels would be worth it.


Confiscating any George Soros owned property and allowing them to live on it.

artichoke's picture

Given that Europe is going to hell with all these Muslims, why does Hungary need to stay in?   Just make the Visegrad-4 their primary association.  I hope Trump would make a treaty with the V-4 trading bloc or its countries individually.

HermanVanCuckold's picture

They should leave the EU, but they have been benefitting from large European Union subsidies for quite some time and being the cheap option for outsourcing within the EU. More money is spent per citizen on Hungary than any other country. If I was a German or French, I would argue since they are taking my money so they should take my immigrants too.

What a mess...

Rufus Temblor's picture

How do you say "fuck you" in Hungarian? I guess the EU will find out soon enough.

tuetenueggel's picture

I don´t say fuck you to EU I´ll simply fuck them when they arrive on scene.