Paul Craig Roberts Warns "Revolutions Are Bloody, But So Is Doing Nothing"

Tyler Durden's picture

Authored by Paul Craig Roberts,

Graeme MacQueen, a university professor in Canada, calls attention to the American left’s inability to exercise imagination with regard to the reports of the Warren Commission and the 9/11 Commission. A collection of individuals and publications, somehow regarded as leftwing, has proven to be active agents for the conspiratorial state against true dissent.

Most peculiar and disturbing is the tendency of left activists and leaders to join with state intelligence agencies in using the term “conspiracy theory” to dismiss those who raise questions about official state narratives.


There seems to be little awareness among these left critics of the history of the term. They seem not to realize that they are employing a propaganda expression, the function of which is to discourage people from looking beneath the surface of political events, especially political events in which elements of their own government might have played a hidden and unsavoury role.

The United States no longer has a leftwing, and neither does Europe, Greece least of all, a country whose “leftwing” government has agreed that Greece’s creditors can loot and plunder the Greek people and the public assets of Greece in behalf of the One Percent. The British Labour Party is as rightwing as the Conservatives, and the French socialist party is more rightwing and much more acceptant of American overlordship than General Charles De Gaulle.

In Germany the electorate has put in place as Chancellor of Germany a US puppet who represents Washington, not the German people. And she will continue to represent Washington, even if it means war with Russia.

The leftwing, once a force that attempted to hold governments accountable, has merged with the American Empire. The American “left” has now joined with the military/security complex to deep-six the prospect of detente with Russia. As Counterpunch's John Feffer writes,

It has all the hallmarks of a compelling thriller.


A U.S. president willing to put his reputation on the line in the interests of peace and prosperity prepares to reach out to Russia. The Kremlin shows some cautious interest. But before the president can propose anything substantial, his opponents do everything possible to derail his efforts.


Worse, this “deep state” of operatives within government — and political actors on the outside — leverages a full range of false accusations to smother the administration in the fog of scandal.

The American leftwing has joined with the neocons, the presstitute media, and the military/security complex in a common agreement that anyone who favors better relations with Russia is a Russian agent or a dupe of Vladimir Putin.

And if you know enough to doubt the Warren Commission and 9/11 Commission reports, you are a conspiracy kook and are put on Harvard’s list of purveyors of “fake news.” Everyone who does not agree with the Establishment’s line is “fake news.” And this is in a “democracy with free speech.” What a joke America has become!

In other words, the “left” has accepted the neoconservative line that those who advocate peace with Russia, other than on US imposed terms, are traitors to America, including the President of the United States. Harvard University now has a PropOrNot type of list of suspect websites. All who favor normal relations with Russia are on the list.

We have reached the point that even for Harvard University, no dissent from hating Russia is possible. This leaves war as the only option.

Are you ready to die for the military/security complex’s enormous budget?

That is all you will be dying for.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
junction's picture

So we all go to hell in a handbasket.

lexxus's picture
lexxus (not verified) junction Mar 16, 2017 8:32 PM

W Bush: "Dad, what's a neocon?"
HW Bush: "You want names or description?"
W: "Description."
HW: "Israel."

Mano-A-Mano's picture
Mano-A-Mano (not verified) lexxus Mar 16, 2017 8:33 PM

All the hell that the Middle East is going through is because of that shitty country.

lexxus's picture
lexxus (not verified) Mano-A-Mano Mar 16, 2017 8:34 PM

Even the problem in Ukraine is payback for Putin helping Syria.

Mano-A-Mano's picture
Mano-A-Mano (not verified) lexxus Mar 16, 2017 8:36 PM

Bolshevik Revolution: The Jewish Bolsheviks, who took over the Russian government in the 1910s, killed 66 million Christians, including 200,000 members of the Christian clergy, and destroyed 40,000 churches.

World War 1: Britain was losing the war against Germany. The Zionists stepped in and bribed President Wilson to get the US into the war to help them. In return, the Jews asked the British Empire to deed them Palestine to create Israel. Their wish was granted in the form of the Balfour Declaration of 1917, which cost the world 18 million dead.

World War 2: The Zionists fomented that war (just like they’re doing today with Iran and other countries in the Middle East), so that European Jews could feel threatened. The deception worked as European Jews fled in droves to Palestine and took over the homes of Palestinians, who were evicted at gunpoint and then either massacred or driven out of their land into neighboring Arab countries. With enough Jews on the ground, Israel was created in 1948 at a cost of 80 million dead.

World War On Terror: Jewish neocons, in cahoots with their bought-and-paid-for politicians in the US government, perpetrated their act of terrorism on 9/11. Then they conveniently blamed it on Muslims so as to obtain a green light to destroy the Middle East using the armies of the US and NATO and the terrorist groups they finance, with the ultimate view to creating Greater Israel. So far, the death toll is over 3 million, including Christians.

World War 3: With Russia protecting Syria and Iran from Israel’s Machiavellian design, will the Zionists succeed in bringing the world once again to the brink of disaster to create Greater Israel? If they do, will it instead bring about their downfall?

Apartheid Israel is truly a scourge. A cancer that needs to be dealt with.

“We Jews, we, the destroyers, will remain the destroyers forever.” – Maurice Samuel

Bay of Pigs's picture

Who upvotes this pathetic serial spammer?

Seriously, come on Tyler. Get to work on these threads.

J S Bach's picture

Well put, Mano-A-Mano.  Those snippets of historical fact need to be repeated over and over and over again until enough people realize who the eternal warmongers are in this world.  Of course, Mr. Roberts never correlates all of his villains - the "leftists", "neocons", "presstitute media", "Harvard faculty", etc... - under the unifying umbrella of "jews".  This is the beef I have with him.  He writes well of the core problems... but rarely identifies the core PERPETRATORS.

Tarzan's picture

5 of the first 6 posts from the same guy, talking to himself,  It's pathetic

Cheka_Mate's picture

The ultimate logic of the Israeli-U.S. global war, writes Israeli activist Michel Warschawski of the Alternative Information Center in Jerusalem (July 30, 2006) is the “full ethnicization” of all conflicts, “in which one is not fighting a policy, a government or specific targets, but a ‘threat’ identified with a community” — or, in Israel’s case, with all non-Jewish communities.

frank further's picture

Shitty country my ass.  Shitty US gubmint selling us all down the drain.  Clintons, Bushes, Ostinko and worst of all, congress!

runnymede's picture

Lived in the middle east. It's shitty even without Israel. We just need to pull out, stop supplying weapons and aid and let them figure it out. 

NobodyNowhere's picture

He said Israel only because saying 'Jews' would have been too uncivil?

GUS100CORRINA's picture

lexxus ...

Why are you posting apostate and heretical references from SATANIC writings posted on biblicisminstitute?

Please stop this practice. Tbx

chubbar's picture

We all know that Trump is aware of this, why can't he throw off the yoke? Is he threatened or is he playing a game with the neocons or is he stalling for time? Just can't seem to get my head around how much his plank has changed since he took office. He won't be a shadow of himself in a couple more months at this rate.

Publicus_Reanimated's picture

He's chomping at the bit.  His advisors, I believe, have managed to slow him down.  He's really only getting started, have patience.  Remember, if you cook the frog too quickly it jumps away.

Grandad Grumps's picture

I have no intention of dying for the Luciferians. Fighting them with violence is dying FOR their goal.

me or you's picture

The only way to remove the traitors and dual-citizens who have hijacked US Government is by a REVOLUTION.


*** But Americans would rather die on their knees than fighting for the country.

Mycroft Holmes IV's picture

I think Americans will take action once their quality of life is disrupted suddenly.

What has happened over the past 25 years is a slow bleed of the middle class, coinciding with the implementation of NAFTA and the rise of the WTO (and GHWB's NWO).

Social programs, welfare, and new entitlements (Obamacare - good luck getting rid of it) have been a drug soothing the pain of the blood loss. 

My concern is when things do break down, the people will be blaming each other (as intended) instead of the shadow government (you can see someone besides Trump is pulling the strings of the national narrative). It is the shadow government that the people should blame; starting with Soros - an obvious face of the movement.

It's kind of a concern of mine as I am in Occupied Territory and there are not a lot of people who are prepared for a supply chain breakdown (let alone a major earthquake). 

me or you's picture

It ain't gonna happen. Americans lack of balls and courage.

Mycroft Holmes IV's picture

**typo** should be aren't prepared...

Pooper Popper's picture

No bastard ever won a war by dying for his country. He won it by making some other poor dumb bastard die for his country.

centerline's picture

We past the event horizon some time ago.  Doing nothing now just ensures the damage is more profound.  We all know it.  Lots of other people feel it (but dont want to admit it). 

mvsjcl's picture

And we all know that JW is never insouciant. (Hey, its a PCR article!)

moorewasthebestbond's picture

I'm not sure what the content on this article has to do with it's title, but whatever.


Bloody Revolution?


Most people today wouldn't last a week in the field.

Kprime's picture

"wouldn't last a week", that would cetainly fortify the concept of bloody revolution.

frank further's picture

Interestingly, current thinking is that posting a comment on some website actually is doing something.  Well, it lets off some steam if nothing else.  Every now and then, tho, some folks post actual info and not an uniformed opinion.  Thank y'all.

RedDwarf's picture

I would argue that it is not only doing something, it is doing something important.  It means you are taking part in a global dialogue.  That is how a concensus is formed, and that is necessary before coordinated and meaningful action takes place.  In Ye Olden Times people of political bent would meet in pubs and smoking dens.  Then over time those discussions would nourish the seeds of rebellion.

The two things a dictator always does is ban free speech and disarm the populace.  So yes, taking active and traceable part in the discussion is not only 'doing something', it's 'doing something meaningful', and even potentially dangerous.

TeethVillage88s's picture

This makes sense and is important.

But also

- Institutions like Churches have been involved in controlling people
- MSM are institutions that do control people
- Lobbyists are institutions that corrupt govt
- No Term Limits for National level Parliament or Congress is a corrupt practice

frank further's picture

If only.  Meetings in pubs were face to face didn't involve anonomous names like RedDwarf. 

RedDwarf's picture

Left and Right wing is a false dichotomy.  Authoritarian and Libertarian is the real dichotomy.  Nazis were National Socialists.  Nationalism is a defining aspect of the Right Wing, Socialism is a defining aspect of the Left Wing.  The Nazis were both extremely Right and Left wing at the same time.  This proves that Left and Right are NOT dichotomies of each other.

What we have today is the Authoritarians getting desperate as the Internet is decentralizing information flows and opinion and redpilling too many people.  Populism, Progressivism, and other ideologies are beginning to battle it out without the elites being able to control the narrative nor the leaks.  That is why everything is reorganizing itself politically.  The false dichotomies are being exposed for what they are and the true ones are starting to come out.

Trump and Sanders are not the end of this sea change.  They are the Heralds.  This show is just getting started.

frank further's picture

Apparently, you haven't noticed the orange traitor, undoing the "sea change" with Goldmans and other billionaires taking charge.  Dream on, friend.

RedDwarf's picture

Looks like big picture strategic thinking is not your forte.  Trump doesn't matter at the level I'm talking about.  Even if he totally betrays everything, that he was voted into office to do and betrays the Demos all that will happen is that come next election the Demos will be even more radicalized and even angrier.  What matters is WHY the Demos took a chance on Trump and almost Sanders.  That WHY will not change if Trump betrays the people, in fact it will be strengthened by it.

jaketfs's picture

Your two comments may be the best and most accurate  I have ever read on ZH .Bravo

RedDwarf's picture

Thank you for your kind words.

nmewn's picture

"Are you ready to die for the military/security complex’s enormous budget?"

lol...are you ready to die for the welfare/plantation-state' enormous budget?

How about if we cut both by half? ;-)

me or you's picture

Neither me nor my sons. But I cannot say the same for the bunch of retarded brain-dead cheering the clown in chief everytime his open his big mouth.

* I hope @nmewn you can protect your family too. 

ersatz007's picture

"How about if we cut both by half?"


Thordoom's picture

One thing that the world has learnt from the past is that you can never push Russians to capitulation.What makes this idiots think they know better? Russia isn't France and Russians are not europeans. They are mixture of Europeans slavs, vikings, mongolians. They will better eat snow from Siberia than surrender.They survived Napoleon,Hitler,Stalin and jewish zionist holocaust of 40 million Russians during that asshole raign. They will surely survive us. On the other hand the brutal collaps that US is heading to will be worse than the collaps Russians experienced when USSR fell and most of the Americans won't stand a chance because unlike Russians they never experienced poverty and are unable to even plant anything to survive.

runnymede's picture

Russians are indeed tough SOBs. Yet history has invariably shown eventually someone thinks they are just the ones that will bring them (and their resources) to heel.

Stormtrooper's picture

Paul, ease up on the Scotch!

Son of Captain Nemo's picture


Your finest and quite frankly the last piece you will ever need to write before "DOING NOTHING" bears it's final harvest!

Dump's picture

The Rothschild formula: Create a credible enemy. War is good for MIC business and banks.

US citizens have been led by the nose to fear Russia, for years.

Why: Russian economy is the same size as Australias -

Russia is no threat to the US. Period. 

Get over it and stop letting the MIC rob you blind.