Comey Slams NY Times' Fake News On Russia Probe: "Story Was Almost Entirely Wrong"

Tyler Durden's picture

For those of you who continue to consume anonymously-sourced news from the likes of CNN, NYT, WAPO, etc, as pure fact and a perfect substitute for actual, unbiased journalism, while blindly ignoring the overwhelming evidence which continues to suggest these outlets are simply pushing a sensationalized narrative aimed at bringing down an administration of which they disapprove, please consider Comey's testimony from earlier today in which he describes a February NY Times story, which alleged numerous contacts between Trump associates and Russia, as "almost entirely wrong"

Cotton:  "On February 14 the New York Times published a story, the headline of which was "Trump Campaign Aides Had Repeated Contacts With Russian Intelligence." 


You were asked earlier whether that was an inaccurate statement and you said you said 'in the main.'  Would it be fair to characterize the story as 'almost entirely wrong?'"


Comey:  "Yes."


For those who missed it, we covered the original New York Times article in a post entitled "NYTimes Reports Trump Aides' "Repeated Contact" With Russian Intel Officials, Admits No Collusion Discovered."

Meanwhile, in earlier testimony with Senator Risch, Comey further explained why anonymously sourced stories can often be pure "nonsense."

Risch:  "So the American people can understand this, that report by the New York Times was not true, is that a fair statement?"


Comey:  "In the main it was not true.  And, again, all of you know this, maybe the American people do not, the challenge, and I'm not picking on reporters, about writing stories about classified information is, the people talking about it often don't really know what's going on and those of us who actually know what's going on are not talking about it. 


And we don't call the press to say 'hey, you got that thing wrong about his sensitive topic.'"


"I mentioned to the chairman the nonsense around what influenced me to make the July 5th Statement.  Nonsense, but I can't go explaining why it's nonsense."


Of course, just like with CNN's story yesterday, we're certain that the New York Times will promptly retract their erroneous reporting and offer an apology to their readers for the unfortunate mistake...not that it matters much because the story has already reached millions of readers and inflicted the damage for which it was intended.

* * *

For those who missed it, Comey's opening statement also outed another anonymously-sourced 'fake news' article pushed by CNN.  Here was our post on the topic from yesterday:

Back on May 9th, the White House released the letter that President Trump sent to former FBI Director James Comey informing him that he'd been relieved of his duties at the FBI.  Within that letter, Trump awkwardly inserted a sentence thanking Comey for informing him "on three separate occasions, that I am not under investigation."  Here's the full sentence (full post here):

"While I greatly appreciate you informing me, on three separate occasions, that I am not under investigation, I nevertheless concur with the judgement of the Department of Justice that you are not able to effectively lead the Bureau."

Not surprisingly, this statement set off alarm bells at CNN and other MSM outlets because, if true, it would put a real damper on their "Trump colluded with Russian hackers to stage a coup" narrative. Therefore, those outlets set out on a mission to 'prove' that Comey never made those statements and that, by definition, Trump clearly lied about his past interactions with the former FBI Director. 

And not long after setting out on that mission, courtesy of those infamous 'anonymous sources', CNN and ABC struck gold when they confirmed that "FBI Director James Comey is reportedly set to testify he never told President Donald Trump that he was not under investigation."  Here is a summary of CNN's reporting from their primary echo chamber, HuffPo:

"Former FBI Director James Comey is reportedly set to testify he never told President Donald Trump that he was not under investigation in connection with Russian interference in the 2016 election, according to CNN and ABC News."

And here is the original CNN reporting:



"Trump has made a blanket claim that Comey told him multiple times that he was not under investigation."


"But one source said Comey is expected to explain to senators that those were much more nuanced conversations from which Trump concluded that he was not under investigation.  Another source hinted that the President may have misunderstood the exact meaning of Comey's words, especially regarding the FBI's ongoing counterintelligence investigation."

Unfortunately, CNN's 'anonymous sources' seem to have been 'mistaken' on this one.  And while we have no doubts, generally, about the integrity of CNN and/or their anonymous sources, Comey's direct testimony released just a while ago seems to confirm exactly what Trump said in his original May 9th letter and exactly the opposite what CNN subsequently reported. 

In fact, here are precisely three instances (ironic, right?), directly from Comey's testimony, in which he personally told President Trump he was not under investigation:

1.  January 6th Meeting at Trump Tower:

"In that context, prior to the January 6 meeting, I discussed with the FBI’s leadership team whether I should be prepared to assure President-Elect Trump that we were not investigating him personally. That was true; we did not have an open counter-intelligence case on him. We agreed I should do so if circumstances warranted. During our one-on-one meeting at Trump Tower, based on President Elect Trump’s reaction to the briefing and without him directly asking the question, I offered that assurance."


2.  January 27th Dinner at White House:

"During the dinner, the President returned to the salacious material I had briefed him about on January 6, and, as he had done previously, expressed his disgust for the allegations and strongly denied them. He said he was considering ordering me to investigate the alleged incident to prove it didn’t happen. I replied that he should give that careful thought because it might create a narrative that we were investigating him personally, which we weren’t, and because it was very difficult to prove a negative. He said he would think about it and asked me to think about it."


3.  March 30 Phone Call:

"I explained that we had briefed the leadership of Congress on exactly which individuals we were investigating and that we had told those Congressional leaders that we were not personally investigating President Trump. I reminded him I had previously told him that."

Of course, we're 'absolutely positive' that everything else CNN has learned and reported from their anonymous sources, regarding Trump and his Russian collusion, is completely accurate and reflect nothing but the highest levels of journalistic integrity.  As such, we are quite confident that CNN will promptly retract their erroneous reporting and offer an apology to their readers for the unfortunate mistake.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Erek's picture

Well raise my rent. I never suspected.

Publicus's picture


Looney's picture


Comey loves Coca-Cola Zero® bottled in Flint, Michigan, along with Slightly Salted Lead Chips®.  ;-)


sixsigma cygnusatratus's picture

It's hillarious.  Here in the U.S., everyone I know that is on the left watches Fox because they want to know what the other side is thinking.  Outside of the U.S., everyone watches CNN because they want to know what Americans are thinking.  

This is so messed up.

hedgeless_horseman's picture


Fuck the New York Times.

I am really looking forward to hearing Robert's talk next week in Marfa.

Media: Robert Gore, Breaking alternative media's dependency on the MSM

If you are still deciding "weather" or not to get out of The City and come to Marfa, next week, then check out the amazing weather forecast for the First ZeroHedge Symposium and Live Fight Club.

  • THU, JUN 15, Sunny, High 91° and Low 61° 0% Chance of Rain, Wind SE 11 mph, 31% Humidity
  • FRI, JUN 16, Sunny, High 92° and Low 61°0% Chance of Rain, Wind SE 13 mph, 32% Humidity
  • SAT, JUN 17, Sunny, High 89° and Low 61°0% Chance of Rain, Wind SE 11 mph, 27% Humidity
  • SUN, JUN 18, Sunny, High 88° and Low 61°0% Chance of Rain, Wind SE 11 mph, 29% Humidity
Croesus's picture

Good, throw the MSM's "credibility" into the trash where it belongs.

Serves these morons right.

Art Van_Delay's picture

Comey switched to "cover own ass" mode

After the weekend all will be forgotten.

The real problem is those deep state obama operatives still embedded in DC.

How The Globalist Establishment Gained Worldwide Supremacy's picture

Now with Comey out of the way, let's focus on Cankles.


Bigly's picture

Have a great time. I wish I could go but have major conflicts.

If you upload some of it please let us know.



hedgeless_horseman's picture


If you upload some of it please let us know.

I may wear a GoPro for the Seth Rich Memorial Ranch Water Drinking Contest.  

Ranch Water

  • 2 ounces Tequila
  • Lime wedge
  • Topo Chico, 12 oz. ice cold and in the bottle

Open Topo Chico. Drink off about 2 ounces.

Top with Tequila.

Squeeze and stuff the lime in the bottle.


Su nombre era Seth Rich.

yogibear's picture

Doesn't Paul Krugman reside at the NYT? Should rename it the  Lefty Times.

NoDebt's picture

As I'm (barely) tuning into this laughable "testimony" by Comey the one thing that keeps going through my heads is:  THIS GUY NEVER SHOULD HAVE BEEN FBI DIRECTOR.  What a clueless, spineless little weasel.  He's all over the map.  Why is he even TRYING to balance his duties against pleasing various people?  And how the fuck does this guy think he can read everyone's "INTENT"?  Hillary didn't intend to cause harm, and Trump intended to fire him if he didn't lay off the Flynn investigation?  How the fuck does this guy read everyone's mind so accurately but get themselves this twisted up?  

By the way, Dow's up 40.  And really, that's what we all care about.


Richard Whitney's picture

Agreed. Can you imagine J. Edgar Hoover giving this testimony?

NoDebt's picture

No, sir, I most certainly can not.


Dead Indiana Sky's picture

Self mental mutilation, that's what you're doing.  No way I could stand 30 seconds of it.  Think I might tune in to Scott Pelley tonight though, and enjoy the spin.

MadHatt's picture

Im outside the US... I dont watch CNN or Fox for news.

Neither of those two are sources for infromation. 

N19's picture

If one outside of U.S. is allowed to chime in, I'm precisely watching CNN, from France, _especially_ to see how they can try to spin that like it's a comey-win/trump-lose situation.

(hint: they're not winning :) )

Made my day.

williambanzai7's picture

The only people watching it outside the US ar US embassy staff.

sixsigma cygnusatratus's picture

Airports and restrooms too, right?

Bernie Madolf's picture

NYT. Is the Gartman of MSM

Carlos Slim must be so proud of his investment

Go F yourself Carlos you slimy POS

Publicus's picture


Joe Cool's picture

Enough of this Comey shit...Won't even be a footnote in a month....Or sooner I hope

Bill of Rights's picture

Isn't it funny how these clowns are now all labeling  " Fake " News  yet allow Fake economic reports to continue. The eight year Obama rein was one giant BS fest.

nmewn's picture

Just think,  in the not so distant future the Fake Nuuuz will be crowing about the fully employed economy to those standing in bread line's. 

Forward Soviet!!!  ;-)

Al Huxley's picture

I think they're doing that already - the future is now!

Tejano's picture

No bread lines. One of the reasons we have SNAP - no need for tiresome Depression Era bread lines.

blown income's picture

Ignorant  sheep , lazy blacks, whites etc belive what the TV said , that's what the black at work said and the lazy fat white secretary too..I know better and just laugh under my breath. ...





Bigly's picture


Son of Loki's picture

And no one is sued for blatant defamation and outright lies.


Sad day in America.

MrBoompi's picture

They passed a law legalizing the pushing of lies and propaganda on the people for Christ sake.  And we're supposed to be shocked, dismayed, or upset when we discover this is exactly what they've done?

Doubleguns's picture

Well your supposed to at least feint shock, dismay and being upset. 


I am shocked I tell you.....shocked. 

Black Forest's picture

Would it be fair to characterize the story that the Earth is a flat disk populated by dems as almost entirely wrong?



Al Gophilia's picture

Do the math. Where's the curve? Fuck the Dems and fuck the GOP. WHERE'S MY COUNTRY, TRUMP.AND TEAM?  DELIVER IT AS PROMISED. THANKS.

Canoe in the Desert's picture

Fun watching the major news networks make a complete train wreck of their reputation.



Erek's picture

Bozos? Don't you mean "Bezos"?

Al Gophilia's picture

I have no doubts about CNN's integrity as well. They have none.

aliens is here's picture

I hope Trump has a long term memory and remembers what NYT, CNN, Bezo Post and other MSM did to him over this fake Russian story.

Iconoclast421's picture

By "repeated contact with Russian Officials", they meant that they shared the same sun rays, only 10-12 hours apart.

Mr. Crisp's picture

The same people who insisted that Benghazi was caused by a youtube video are now insisting that the the election was thrown by the Russians.

They're relentless liars, motivated by politics, politics, politics.

shimmy's picture

Damn, the libtard media must be pretty pissed off with Comey refuting some of their bullshit and also indicating the bullshit with Lynch and the Clinton campaign and not being the smoking gun against Trump like they were hoping he'd be. Guess they'll go back to slamming Comey.

rosiescenario's picture

It seems pretty safe to say that anything a democrat or their mouth pieces say is most likely a lie. They must be fairly stupid to actually think the public has not figured this out.

ClickNLook's picture

Do you mean that GOPs are all George Washingtons?

francis scott falseflag's picture


                              "In Anything Goes We Trust."          


"Mr Speaker, I ask unanimous consent that a delegation from Congress travel

to find and meet with Caligula and offer him the Presidency of the United States."  


Speaker:   "Hearing no objection, it is so ordered."

Miss Expectations's picture

"I fired my FBI director the day before Vince Foster was found dead."  Bill Clinton


Richard Whitney's picture

Technically, it was WJC. Actually, it was HRC.