Studies Confirm, Free People are Happier

TDB's picture

Via The Daily Bell

If you don’t feel free, chances are you don’t feel happy either.

Both of these words, free and happy, are pretty loose in their official definitions. Scientific studies have used various metrics to measure happiness; self-reporting, brain waves, psychological evaluations, and family member surveys. As for freedom, the studies mainly use the self-reported metric, how free a person feels.

When people feel less restrained by outside forces, when people feel that their life is their own to do as they please, they are happier.

Even when holding income, sex, education, race, religion, politics, and family status constant, we find that people who felt free were about 18 percentage points more likely than others to say that they were very happy.

Even people who think that the government should be less involved in daily life are happier than people who think society needs more rules. And it might be tempting to chalk this up to people who are poor feeling unhappy, regardless of freedom. It makes sense to think they would want the government to intervene in order to make them more wealthy, and thus happier.

But when you look at countries overall, you still find that freer countries are happier countries.

…in 1990, at the end of the Communist era, one cross-country survey found that 41 percent of Americans said that they were very happy—contrasted with just 14 percent of East Germans, 6 percent of Russians and Czechs, and 2 percent of Latvians. Of course, regimes behind the Iron Curtain were not just economically unfree; they were politically unfree as well.

Of course, this could also just point to the fact that the freer the country, the more prosperous the people. So you could say that being prosperous makes you happy. Except this would prove that free economies deliver more prosperity. So no matter how you slice it, more freedom means more happiness–even if prosperity is a necessary step in between.

But another study found that even prosperity might not matter as much as freedom when it comes to happiness.

Swiss economists Bruno Frey and Alois Stutzer made this point convincingly in the 1990s, comparing happiness levels across various Swiss cantons, which vary dramatically in how much political participation they afford their citizens. Cantons that allowed citizens more direct democratic rights, as well as meetings with leaders to discuss political and financial matters, proved significantly happier than cantons where political access was more restricted.

Now there may very well be some very special people, who even in a prison cell would still mentally “feel free.” But for most of us, factors of our environment come into play as much as our mental attitude.

But then we get to the chicken or the egg thing. If you don’t feel free, is it because of your environment? Or does your environment not feel free because of your mentality? Either way, you can fix this. You can either change your environment, or you can change your attitude. But it takes recognizing the root of the issue.

If you don’t feel free, and it is making you unhappy, you should start getting specific. Identify exactly what is making you feel unfree. Not “government” but “high taxes or illegal marijuana.” You can legally set up your finances to drastically cut your tax rate. And you can move to a place where marijuana is legal.

And don’t say “society” makes you feel unfree. Is it watching the news or scrolling facebook? Stop. Living in a city with a country heart? Move. Is it Sunday dinner with terrible relatives? You’re under no obligation, although the choices they force on you may be tough. Still, it is their choice how to react. You have the ability to make yourself free of things that keep you constrained.

Let’s address the claim that people who have too many choices are less happy.

Some studies have found that when given too many options, people get freedom overload, and are more anxious, finding it harder to make any choice at all. In one instance, two sample booths were set up to sell jam. One gave away 24 samples, and that one attracted more tasters. Another booth gave away 6 samples, and even though fewer people stopped to try the jam, they actually sold more.

The idea is that people are attracted to freedom, but in the end, it makes them stagnate and shut down with an overload of choice.

But there are a couple factors to consider.

One is that people are naturally constrained by their circumstances to some extent. Maybe you are technically free to do anything you want. But at any one point in your life, there are really only a few choices to be made.

It gets overwhelming to think, I could move anywhere I want, start a business or get a job, find a lover or play the single life, or hike the Appalachian Trail and write a book. That train of thought makes it seem like there are too many choices. You may choose to stay in a situation that doesn’t make you happy because you have no idea what choice of the infinite possibilities will actually make you happier.

But you don’t really have that many choices right now. Do you want to move, or do you like where you are? That is only two choices.

If you choose to move, that clearly opens up more choices. You say, where should I move? Is every square inch of the earth truly an option? No. You should be able to identify why you want to move. Then you simply need to make another series of small choices that are not overwhelming when you take them one at a time. Warm or cold? City or country? Coastal or inland?

Second, most people are naturally constrained by their own unique morality. Some people adopt moralities from religion or spirituality, and some people create their own. It doesn’t really matter, there are some things you will be willing to do, and some things you definitely will not. You probably don’t truly have a choice between becoming a doctor, lawyer, teacher, meth dealer, or pimp. Some of those options probably don’t align with your morals–like becoming a lawyer.

When you break things down to a step by step process of where you are going from here, the choices for what to do with life become much less overwhelming. It is great to have a 5 or even 10-year plan, but things are going to change. Most choices don’t require a steadfast decision in the present. Your smaller choices in the present will instead present new opportunities to choose from later.

And if you have some general philosophy or morality that you live by, certain choices are off the table altogether.

So by if you limit your own choices, you may very well be happier. But if someone else limits your choices for you, you are likely to feel less free, and thus be unhappy.

But again, don’t let the feeling of being unfree convince you that you are actually unfree. If you aren’t convinced that you have this much control over your own life, start by reading the 1973 classic, How I found Freedom in an Unfree World, by Harry Browne.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
NumbersUsa's picture

FREEDOM FROM THE JEW SUPREMACISTS

-We're taught Jews are the worst persecuted people in history. They are in fact the most relentlous persecutors.

-We're taught 'cause of their persecution, Jews fight for the underdog, the marginalized, the silent voices. Jews have done more than anyone to stifle public discussion and debate and kill free speech.

-We're taught Jews are behind freedom of religion. They're all for mocking and demonizing Christianity (and Islam) only to make Holocaust religion worshiped across the world.

-We're taught Hitler was the devil, yet Jewish Bolshevism, alone, and Stalin's terror, alone, murdered 10 times more than Hitler, regardless if you believe the worst of Hitler or not.

-We're taught Jews are honest and humble and were innocent victims in the world wars. Jews secretly made deals with Balfour and Hitler (Transfer Agreement), who probably didn't know of Balfour agreement, declared war on Germany in 1933 (their words in NY papers), destroyed the Germany economy, and have perpetuated the worst lies and hate in the last century, like Germans making soap, lamps, mattresses out of human parts, and the 6m gassed can not even be established by their markers, and will probably be seen for the hoax it was in less than a decade.

-We are told, you can't blame every Jew, but no tribe is so organized and so cohesive, so willing to jump to take offense, so willing to defend anyone in the tribe, so willing to proclaim their actions to destroy Europe, just like they did Germany.. only to deny it once they're are successful.

-They pretend to not want war or genocide, but are most violent, aggressive and murderous to their neighbors. They plans for a Greater Israel are well know. Well many turn the other way, many are realizing their true plans for a greater Israel.

-We're taught today's Israel is Israel of the Bible... they're God's chosen. They're not. Jacob (Israel) had 12 sons, not one son. There is nothing prophetic about today's Israel!

-We're taught, well they're just smarter and better than the rest of us. I believe very much of the success is due to their intrigue, and ill-gotten influence. When Rothschilds can convince our treasonous leaders that private banks should print money from nothing, only to lend back to the nations (who should be printing their own money), the source of the endless wealth is no longer mysterious. When you have trillions at your disposal, creating and lionizing your "stars" must be very very easy.

And when you control the media, film, finance, education, etc, either through direct ownership and influence, or the 100s of interest groups and suasion, bribery and and threats, it must be even easier.

You stupid Americans when will the jew supremacist yoke be removed.

redmudhooch's picture

More importantly:

People will do whatever it takes to escape misery, to find happiness and freedom.

Up to and including, eliminating the cause of the misery and enslavement.

JailBanksters's picture

So the people in Iraq, Libya, Syria must be ecstatic then

Saratoga's picture

When we are "FREE" from banks and their usuary we then be free....and you can toss in the system of money as well.

TeethVillage88s's picture

Ignorance is Bliss

- Candide, by Voltaire

amadeus39's picture

Not true. Not true. Not true.

 

amadeus39's picture

Yeah, if someone is free to blow your head off, might want to give up some freedom for a little law and order. Come on folks , the alt left has convinced you that freedom is the only game in town. Utter nonsense. Americans are so far from free they can't recall what real freedom is.  I'm sick and tired of this "freedom" bullshit. How about a little consideration for others and a liitle less "freedom" for your greedy selves.  

 

jin187's picture

Law and order has never stopped heads from getting blown off. It's more about sending in people to clean up the mess, and find out who did it, rather than prevention. We wouldn't have millions of people in prison otherwise. Law enforcement only gives the illusion of prevention to make people feel safe.

Hell, I've lost track of how many times someone has gotten shot right in front of my house, and the police don't show up until 15 minutes later. Then of course they have to shut down all the streets and alleys, pretending to look for the guys that they know damn well are already 5 miles away.

fulliautomatix's picture

Isn't the pursuit of happiness a thing? I seem to recall it mentioned in an important document, something about a goal of a republic or something.

nmewn's picture

Yeah and I don't recall anything about forcing the "young & healthy" to do something they wouldn't ordinarily do. 

Apparently that has something to do with..."democracy" or so I'm told ;-)

amadeus39's picture

The pursuit of happiness is over-rated. Try doing something nice for someone else and happiness will happen. It is not a goal.

 

One of these is not like the others..'s picture

Respect, for that observation. I have suffered from the misery that comes when nothing (but nothing) you try to change your own situation for the better will work. I found that taking "if I can't fucking help myself then I'll find some other sod who I can help and count that as a win instead" approach didn't solve any of my problems immediately, but did give me some respite and a sense of empowerment which was better than the other feelings. Even helping ungrateful people is better than wallowing in your own misery I found.

jin187's picture

The pursuit of happiness isn't overrated. It's the pursuit of stuff, thinking having the most stuff brings happiness.

techpriest's picture

Also, they were saying that you had the right to pursue happiness. It was not a guarantee that you would actually *be* happy.

GreatUncle's picture

Free people don't tend to want to hang, guillotine or decapitate their leaders neither.

TeethVillage88s's picture

What are the Organs of State Propaganda?

mtanimal's picture

It took a study to figure this out?

Serious.Lee's picture

Paraphrasing John Fowles (book, "The Aristos '"):

"People would rather live in a free, unfair world than a fair, unfree one."

That, despite the best efforts of all the usual suspects; e.g., socialists, communists, marxists, statists, pseudo-"capitalists," the mainstream media, bankers, Hollywood, the truly deplorable basket of dual citizens, and many more.

Yars Revenge's picture

America: number one in incarceration and also number one in the use of antidepressants.

Coincidence?

evildimensions's picture

This is precisely why I became a Buddhist.

Buddhist prayer: May all beings be free. May all beings be at peace. May all beings be happy.

techpriest's picture

More specifically, within Christianity there is an acceptance that people cannot be everything you want them to be, so you let go of the notion that they can, or must, be. In most relationships this is a necessity, though my Buddhist in-laws arrive at the conclusion in a different way.

Seeing Red's picture

My father used to say:  "Money doesn't buy happiness, but it does buy freedom."

TeethVillage88s's picture

Wasn't there a big study that showed the more "Educated" you were or Women were...

THEN the less happy they(you) were(are).

techpriest's picture

Its called "confounding variables."

When you have to chance of going beyond your current situation/position, you learn to be content with what you have.

When rising up is a possibility, some people will not be content with what they have, and will instead want to rise as high as they can go.

Education is a corollary for this - the more education you get, the more you see how big the world is, and how small you are. Not many people can handle that fact.

jin187's picture

Ignorance is bliss. Just ask all the people that support Obamacare.

FIAT CON's picture

Dont we know this already from free range chickens...and just pure logic! dah.

amadeus39's picture

It has never been determined that free range chickens are happy. If they ever become aware, like us, that they will die, they might not be happy...free range or not.

 

purplelama's picture

You never raised chickens.

Crazy Or Not's picture

Everyone is usually drawn to one of the main  "General Drivers" motivators like:

Achievement
Power
Money
Status
Relationship

After that its one's Life Circumstances that vary in influence as we grow older/settle down/get divorced etc etc
(and also I guess if we've experienced a more free range life than the other guy).

jin187's picture

The sad thing is that all of those drivers result in nothing. You can't take it with you when you die, and at best, some of that might get your name remembered for a generation or three, until your descendants squander whatever you've built. As long as there's death, life is a zero sum game, unless you're doing some truly monumental work that changes the course of humanity itself.

In other words, if you're not the next Hitler or Einstein, you're better off just doing what makes you happy.

amadeus39's picture

The saying "You can't take it with you when you die." is a useless canard. Why state the obvious. We want it now. Could care less (yeah, I know, "couldn't) No person cares about anything after death.

 

Common_Law's picture

They could just be more ignorant not more free.