Did Oil Markets Overreact To The Saudi Purge?

Tyler Durden's picture

Authored by Nick Cunningham via OilPrice.com,

Saudi Arabia’s powerful crown prince led a massive purge over the weekend, ousting around a dozen royal cousins in a bid to consolidate power.

The removal and detentions of so many members of the royal family were ostensibly the outgrowth of an anti-corruption campaign, but the actions put the top security institutions under the control of the king and the crown prince after having been distributed among different family factions for decades. In essence, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman (aka, MBS) has ended decades of tradition and has consolidated power in his own hands, making him the most powerful figure the country has seen in generations.

MBS also removed one of his rivals for the throne, Prince Miteb bin Abdullah, son of the late King Abdullah. Many analysts expect the octogenarian King Salman to abdicate the throne in the coming months, and the ouster of Miteb paves the way for MBS to take over.

The purge also took down the richest Saudi investor, Prince Alwaleed bin Talal, a move that “would be like arresting Warren Buffet or Bill Gates in the United States,” Robert Jordan, former U.S. ambassador to the kingdom, told CNBC.

Favorable interpretations of what is playing out in Riyadh view the actions as a way to push forward with economic reforms. “The new leadership is committed to modernizing the economy and diversifying the economy and addressing the issue of over-reliance on oil,” Khatija Haque, head of Middle East research at Emirates NBD PJSC, told Bloomberg. “What this signals is that the crown prince is strengthening his position to continue with pushing forward with the reforms that are needed.”

But analysts say the actions by MBS could undercut one his own top priorities: Attracting international investment, specifically for the IPO of Saudi Aramco. The arrests without due process “sends a chill down the spine of foreign investors,” Bernard Haykel, a professor at Princeton University, told the New York Times in an interview. Moreover, a Saudi Aramco board member and former finance minister was actually included in the series of detentions.

Meanwhile, Saudi Foreign Minister Adel al-Jubeir said on Monday that the Saudi government has the right to respond to Iran’s “hostile actions,” after a missile was reportedly fired by Houthi rebels from Yemen. The missile was intercepted, but Saudi state press said the government “considers this a blatant act of military aggression by the Iranian regime, and could rise to be considered as an act of war against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.”

And to make matters even more bizarre, a Saudi prince was killed in a helicopter crash near the border with Yemen on Sunday, a seemingly unrelated event with an unknown cause.

The sudden turmoil in Saudi Arabia likely helped push oil prices to their highest level in two and a half years on Monday, with Brent breaking $64 per barrel and WTI moving past $57 per barrel during intraday trading.

However, the Saudi purge does not necessarily mean a change in oil policy. Saudi officials have been pushing for an extension of the OPEC cuts through the end of 2018, particularly as they prepare the IPO of Aramco.

“We believe the kingdom will stick to the OPEC+ deal and continue to focus on reducing global oil inventories,” UBS oil analyst Giovanni Staunovo told Reuters.

At the same time, the political intrigue has introduced an element of geopolitical risk, which could be helping to add a bit of bullish momentum to oil prices.

“Uncertainty about core regime stability has gone up a bit, so a higher risk premium is justified,” Samuel Ciszuk, a senior adviser to the Swedish Energy Agency, said at the Reuters Global Oil Forum.

With all of that said, there are more important factors governing the price of oil. The fate of the OPEC extension is first and foremost. After that, oil investors are keeping an eye on the response from U.S. shale to rising oil prices. The sharp decline in the rig count last week is probably more important in the eyes of some oil traders than the purge in Saudi Arabia.

The latest events come as oil prices had already been gaining strength. A recent Wall Street Journal poll of 14 investment banks finds an averaged predicted Brent price in 2018 at $54 per barrel, an increase of $1 per barrel since September and the first increase in six months for the poll.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
LawsofPhysics's picture

Irrelevant, the relevant question is how many calories do you have to invest to extract that barrel of oil (calories)?

Late onset ADHD's picture

energy in... energy out... assume you're talking about 'calorie' joules energy expenditures...

LawsofPhysics's picture

Exactly.  Moreover, talking about the "price" of anything in the absence of a mechanism for true price discovery is a fool's errand.

Late onset ADHD's picture

I miss 'true' price discovery... a lot...

it's been relegated to "Santa" status...

DrumpFired's picture

I emailed shepwave about this. Let's see what they say. Their calls on oil have been spot on.

khnum's picture

Interesting that all US carriers are elsewhere if the situation worsens the straits of Hormuz may get blocked

Peak Finance's picture

"Modernize" the economy?

Maybe their reserves are not what the world thinks they are?  

asteroids's picture

Explain to me why it would be a problem to arrest Gates (for Windows) or Buffet (for asset stripping)? /s

NDXTrader's picture

Oil will continue to push higher until ARAMCO is listed. Way too many billions to be made on Wall St and in the ME for it to not happen. $70-75 is an easy first target 

serotonindumptruck's picture

Like somebody else mentioned earlier in a different thread, perhaps this so-called 'purge' was designed to create a crisis that justifies speculation in higher oil prices, as $50 per barrel of oil was killing them.

 

NoWayJose's picture

Until someone starts shooting at the future king, this is just a yawn. The House of Saud controls the oil, the electronic money, the military, and the financial assets of anyone capable of challenging them.

shortonoil's picture

 

The day is never coming when the economy will be using $2 worth of oil to produce a $1 in goods and services. If you don't have a means to calculate the value of oil to the economy your don't have a clue as to where its price may go.

 

http://www.thehillsgroup.org

earleflorida's picture

i'm sure iran and iraq are pumping as fast as humanly possible with a windfall of $2-$4 /bbl on top of established profits--- the shia`crescent thanks mbs/bibi for millions (perhaps billions?) $$$ gift 

hola dos cola's picture

Beware of too high expectations of the OPEC meeting.

I think the outcome is destined to underwhelm.

The carrot dangling by the usual suspects is unconvincing*. And the 'market' seems to be pricing in failure**, happily piggy backing on the IPO expectations and orchestrated regional tensions. (and supported by the weekly FAKE NUMBERS ofcourse)

 

* setting up for an excuse to be pulled from the hat.

** to be taken advantage of to the short side by the 'insiders' at t=0.

 

P.S. Any agreement will be short lived, actually starting to unravel from day 1, and inevitably leads towards a price war. The challenge for the 'financial industry' is to prevent the outbreak until after the IPO. Popcorn!