The Demise Of Dissent: Why The Web Is Becoming Homogenized

Tyler Durden's picture

Authored by Charles Hugh Smith via OfTwoMinds blog,

In other words, we'll be left with officially generated and sanctioned fake news and "approved" dissent.

We've all heard that the problem with the web is fake news, i.e. unsubstantiated or erroneous content that's designed to mislead or sow confusion.

The problem isn't just fake news--it's the homogenization of the web, that is, the elimination or marginalization of independent voices of skepticism and dissent.

There are four drivers of this homogenization:

1. The suppression of dissent under the guise of ridding the web of propaganda and fake news--in other words, dissent is labeled fake news as a cover for silencing critics and skeptics.

2. The sharp decline of advertising revenues flowing to web publishers, both major outlets and small independent publishers like Of Two Minds.

3. The majority of advert revenues now flow into the coffers of the quasi-monopolies Facebook and Google.

4. Publishers are increasingly dependent on these quasi-monopolies for readers and visibility: any publisher who runs afoul of Facebook and Google and is sent to Digital Siberia effectively vanishes.

The reason why publishers' advert incomes are plummeting are four-fold:

1. Most of the advert revenues in the digital market are being skimmed by Facebook and Google, as the chart below illustrates.

2. Ad blockers have become ubiquitous.

3. Few people click on the display ads that are the standard in desktop web publishing; in other words, these ads simply don't work very well, and much of the revenue being generated is click-fraud, i.e. bots not real people clicking on adverts because they're interested in the product/service. As a result, advertisers are pulling away from these type of ads as they search for advert models that aren't so vulnerable to click-fraud.

4. The web is increasingly shifting to mobile, which has fewer advert spots due to the small size of the display. In addition, major third-party advert services such as Google Adsense place restrictions on the number and size of ads being displayed on publishers' sites.

The systemic erosion of advert revenues for everyone other than FB and Google is evident everywhere: for example, BuzzFeed Set to Miss Revenue Target, Signaling Turbulence in Media Prospects for a 2018 initial public offering by the high-profile publisher now appear remote.

Digital publisher BuzzFeed is on track to miss its revenue target this year by a significant amount, the latest sign that troubles in the online-ad business are making it tough for new-media upstarts to live up to lofty expectations.

As a result of these two dynamics--the censorship of dissenting views under the excuse of limiting fake news, and the erosion of advert income--independent publishers are losing ground. While those posting on Facebook and other social media sites have little expectation of monetizing their content, many web publishers made enough income off adverts or affiliated income (from YouTube channels, for example) to justify the enormous time and effort they expended keeping their channel/site going.

As advert income has dwindled, there are only two other revenue models available to publishers: a subscription service or Patreon, i.e. the direct financial support of users/readers/viewers. Major publishers are struggling to build a subscription base large enough to fund their operations, a task made more difficult by the expectation that all content is free or should be free.

Patreon has been a boon for thousands of independent writers, journalists, cartoonists, filmmakers and other creators of content. The Patreon model (as I understand it, and yes I have a Patreon campaign) is not based on content that's behind a paywall available to subscribers only, but on providing incentives in the form of content or other rewards to those who choose to contribute.

The Patreon model only works if enough users/readers/viewers step up to support content creators they value. I think the success of Patreon suggests that many people are willing to support the content creators they value. But like all voluntary revenue models, there's the free-rider issue: people who may have the income to pay a bit for content choose not to, and in essence free-ride on those few who do contribute/pay for content.

Some people have advanced the model of micropayments as the solution to the problem of compensating content creators fairly. While this model has some obvious benefits--pennies charged for access to content might add up to a living for content creators if their audience was large enough--it would still be a voluntary system, and thus it would have the same free-rider issue as every other voluntary payment-for-content idea.

Posting "free" content on social media ends up driving advert revenues to the social media and search monopolies, leaving nothing for the content creators. There is only so much serious content that can be created for free.

If what we're left with is "free" content (i.e. the creator gets no income for creating and posting content), Facebook, Google and click-bait link farms of sensationalist headlines, we'll end up with a thoroughly homogenized web of "approved content" underwritten by lobbyists, the entertainment industry and elitist foundations/think tanks, and little in the way of real dissent or diversity of independent analysis.

In other words, we'll be left with officially generated and sanctioned fake news and "approved" dissent: unemployment is at record lows, inflation is near zero, the "recovery" is alive and well, Russia is the enemy and any suggestion to the contrary is propaganda that must be eradicated as fake news, etc.

Simply put, the web is becoming Orwellian. There's plenty of approved "diversity of opinion," but dissent is being sidelined to the fringes as a risk to the perfection of managed content.

*  *  *

If you found value in this content, please join me in seeking solutions by becoming a $1/month patron of my work via Check out both of my new books, Inequality and the Collapse of Privilege ($3.95 Kindle, $8.95 print) and Why Our Status Quo Failed and Is Beyond Reform ($3.95 Kindle, $8.95 print, $5.95 audiobook) For more, please visit the OTM essentials website.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
God Emperor's picture

Don't you just love your joo masters?

Meanwhile, while the internet is still a bit's some leaks. Hollywood leaks, not White House leaks:


chunga's picture

The web will always be full of SPAM.

Tyler if you're paying attention, or care, this ^^^ is the same turd who had 50 fake ZH accounts to pump the dailywestern malware site. The site the spammer accounts are pumping now, from what I've heard it brag about, is porn.

JRobby's picture

It will be like the TV..........but worse

Herd Redirection Committee's picture

I hate to be the purveyor of fake news, but on the off chance it is dead on, there are reports of a plane/helicopter collision in Aylesbury/Buckinghamshire, England, with JACOB ROTHSCHILD among the dead.

JRobby's picture

nnettle !!! Great news source!!

"In other news, a 30 ft tall rooster ran through Manhattan today with the nude, dead copses of Lloyd Blankfein strapped to one leg and Jamie Dimon strapped to the other. Police were able to subdue the mutant bird creature by using military assault hardware but only after the bird ran amok for well over 2 hours."

NumbersUsa's picture

I do believe sam clemens would have got a good belly laugh out this one 

bobcatz's picture

"the censorship of dissenting views..."

... started a while back when no one could question the Holohoax. Still can't in the "free" West.

NumbersUsa's picture

Very Very Good !  Copied, Printed & Archived-Thanks.

Very intriguing statement/quote from the article:

"Note how documents about the author of the revolt were “discovered” in the occupied West Bank in the 20th century (1960-1961) in the Cave of Letters. Said “discovery” was quite fortuitous and convenient, especially as it occurred right in the midst of the establishment of a Jewish state on the stolen land of Palestine which they fraudulently claimed as their Abrahamic inheritance, when converted Jews of today are NOT even remotely bloodline descendants of Abraham."

BennyBoy's picture


I hereby approve my bland, sterile, non-fake post.

All downvotes will result in death.

cheka's picture

judeo-bolshevism at work

Ex-Oligarch's picture

Fake news.  I've never seen a rooster taller than 25 feet.

JimmyJones's picture

I heard about the crash, I know it happened over a Rothschild estate but I didn't hear about who was on board the helicopter and air plane.

Herd Redirection Committee's picture

Crime syndicate probably wants to delay the news.  Like when a king dies, you want to position yourself accordingly, before letting the public know.

Blue Steel 309's picture

They are more powerful than any mere king has ever been.

Justin Case's picture

Russia fights back MSM with secret weapon.

Russian MoD appoints 26yo spokeswoman - and she’s already a social media sensation

Pic on RT News. Hottie.

GunnyG's picture

Can't make the snowflakes cry, i.e., calling out niggers as low IQ criminals not worth the welfare they get.

ted41776's picture

trust your government, anti-trust laws will protect the tax paying masses from their corporate overlords. everything is awesome. spend, consume, and think less. it's your patriotic duty and the 'murcan way

Mr Hankey's picture

"Obey. Consume.Reproduce."


Addendum,circa 2020 ..".as long as you are non-white"

rf80412's picture

Caught between a rock and a hard place: between the bought and paid for government on one hand and the people who bought it on the other.  People have faith that the government at least in theory answers to us, and how corrupt it can get is limited, while believing that living completely at the mercy of big business in the ancap "paradise" can only be worse.

TheLastTrump's picture

How you people remember how to tie your shoes is beyond me.


“This reminds me of anti-Semitism,” Putin said. “The Jews are to blame for everything. An idiot cannot do anything himself, so the Jews are to blame. But we know what such attitudes lead to. They end with nothing good.”

JRobby's picture
TheLastTrump Personal information

“This reminds me of anti-Semitism,” Putin said. “The Jews are to blame for everything. An idiot cannot do anything himself, so the Jews are to blame. But we know what such attitudes lead to. They end with nothing good.”

If the shoe fits, wear it.

Member for
51 weeks 5 days


Herd Redirection Committee's picture

Don't overestimate your enemies, but don't underestimate them either.

JRobby's picture

Whatever the fuck that means? It's the internet! Silly!

Herd Redirection Committee's picture

Don't blame your enemies for everything, but don't convince yourself that they aren't 'that influential' either.

GeezerGeek's picture

The last pair of shoes with shoelaces was given to me by Uncle Sam in 1969. Mostly I just wear boots - one never knows when it's going to snow in Ft. Lauderdale.

Mr Hankey's picture

You are going to cut and paste that out-of-context snippet until the sun burns out,aren't you,bloody tip-licker.

Mr Hankey's picture

You sound like a Velcro dual-shitizen to me.

ebear's picture

Irony is not his strong suit.

I doubt he's even read the full speech.

NumbersUsa's picture

"They end with nothing good.”

They would have ended very good if the supremacist warmongering jews had not declared war on the good German people in march 1933.

This forced the good German people to pass the Nuremberg laws in 1935 which was a wonderful thing. The murderous jew supremacist forced both jew war I & jew war II upon the world just as they are trying to force jew war III upon us now. Look who pushes the middle-east warmongering- nothing has changed its the jew supremacist-period.

Putin, the man stuck with a jew supremacist bolshevik history that he must defend at least in measure. At the same time dealing with the trecherous jew supremacists still currently left in his country. The proverbial rock and a hard place. Then add the constant warmongering jew supremacist hissing that flows from jewmerica- he has a plate full of jew. 

Putin-The Man:

Herd Redirection Committee's picture

In South Africa, you have a couple ethnicities that make up the majority of the population.  Blacks 70%+, whites 10%, mixed 10%, Jews and Indians and others, the remaining 10%.

Well, what you have is many of prominent members of the small ethnic groups PITTING THE whites and blacks against each other!

NumbersUsa's picture

Here in jewmerica its the jew supremacist created & funded Naacp doing the same.

Add in the jew supremacist Splc, Aipac, Adl (former b'inai brith) Wjc, Zoa, Etc... and its "the PITS of a life time".

They (jews) have created a spectacular worlwide collesium of hate & murder that puts the Roman one to shame.

land_of_the_few's picture

Astroturfing fake-antisemitics. Heck, you probably work with them.

You do know it's an illegal use of state funds, right?

Breaks rather a lot of quite interesting state and international laws...

JRobby's picture


That is a great site!

I often wonder what delusion 24/7 could be like

Rainman's picture

Teevee and internet ads are about as welcome as a fart in the elevator.

Chupacabra-322's picture

Technocratic Tyrannical Lawlessness.

Sonder's picture

The computing revolution opened pandora's box and they'll never be able to lock it up again. Clamp down on existing infrastructure and we'll create new networks. Crush our message boards and websites and we'll create new ones in different formats. Try and directly control every aspect of our UI through operating systems and we'll program new OS's/use old OS's that are no longer officially supported. Take a look at China's internet firewall, sure it stops your typical normie from being able to see what they don't want them to see. But no government/mega-corporation can resist the ferocity of thousands of determined programmers working in an autistic frenzy. 

Mr Hankey's picture

You are a 4-chan baby,arent you!  : -)

Sonder's picture

There's more than one Chan sir. 

verumcuibono's picture

Persistence is a bitch.

The ONLY hope I have is for the hacker underground. Trouble is, they keep getting infiltrated by the deep state. they gotta figure this out.

pigpen's picture

Web publishers are going to be collateral damage when people start destroying the digital advertising goobook monopolies.

Everybody needs to download brave browser immediately. Brave blocks ads, tracking and malware by default.

What is digital ad business worth if they can't serve an ad, you don't see the ad and they can't track you.



pigpen's picture

Obtw brave works on any operating system and device. So simple even granny can figure it out.



Mr Hankey's picture

Will it allow me to vote& comment on an android?

pigpen's picture

Mr. Hankey, yes it will. Also run social media out of brave to block ads.

Works great on fortune or Forbes or any garbage BuzzFeed site.



Mr Hankey's picture

Niggers,symptom. Jew,disease.

Along with general white cuckfaggotry .

NumbersUsa's picture

Adolf Hitler so rightfully said, " Everything about the behavior of the American society reveals that it's half judaized and the other half negrified"