Biderman Responds

Tyler Durden's picture

The Zero Hedge audience have always been tough task masters and will hold people's feet to the fire. While markets have been a little tempestuous to say the least recently, TrimTabs' Charles Biderman comes out swinging with a spirited and honest defense of his calls - and quite frankly we still tend to agree with his bigger picture view of where this ends. From his Facebook miss to short-term fluctuations in the equity market (that now seem precipitously away from credit market reality), Biderman responds to comments here and elsewhere on both position sizing and perhaps most importantly risk management - adding (and this is where we believe he is dead right though timing the call is practically impossible) that "when the collapse happens it will happen overnight - that is why [he wants] to be short but safe at the same time."


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Rahm's picture

Difidently a clown, but he beats the S&P which is better than 95% of fund managers out there.... plus holds 23% gold!

veyron's picture

At the end of (a video that mysteriously didnt appear on ZH) there was a comment:


"All that is known is that Biderman took money from GS. It's very well possible that ZH itself is sponsored by GS.?"


Did ZH take money from goldman sachs?

Rahm's picture

Vey, your posts used to be informative, now you have turned into a troll obsessed with Biderman.  Perhaps people should go back to your seeking alpha account and troll your troll account there:


veyron's picture

This is fight club, and questions about the ownership of ZH are fair game.  If not, that makes us no better than CNBC.

Pladizow's picture

Someone's You Tube Comment:

"Hey Charles, why do not show your REAL track record, the model portfolio of your institutional? Liquidity Review.

Wait, it is DOWN 90% IN THE PAST 4 YEARS!!! and this does not include this year's losses, I cancelled 6 months ago. Now that you lost all credibility with institutions, you try to rip off retail investors for $250 .... PATHETIC!"


Any truth here?

CrazyCooter's picture

Aren't all his calls public via his letters after some time? Would just require someone going back through it all.

I don't have a horse in this race, I am just watching. :-)



Northeaster's picture

I would also add ZH does in fact have a disclaimer, but doubtful anyone reads such trivial things.

In the case of Biderman, he doesn't exactly have a great track record, but does provide great confirmation bias for the now regular readers/posters here at ZH.

The days of old, he would have been ripped apart here by people in the business.

veyron's picture

That is tantamount to Biderman saying he works for TrimTabs.  


I'm asking if ABC Media is owned by Goldman Sachs ...

oddjob's picture

I'm asking if your pathetic avatar makes you feel better about yourself?

Mr Lennon Hendrix's picture

I am asking if there is one thing that Biderman brings to Zero Hedge that is proprietary?

Other than going long FB at the IPO and going all in (by placing FB on his conviction buy list) at 31.

Northeaster's picture

I can't comment on ABC. However, I can comment on CBS, as my ex-managing partner is also the VP and Board Member of CBS per the Viacom split.There is also the interconnected client base, which of course I can't publish, but a who's-who of everything you see and hear.

The firm is boutique, mostly tax, for high end only and Goldman was (most likely still is) the go to "bank" for clients. How do I know? I read the client letters before we sent them out to move their money there (GS) the night Madoff was arrested.

My regret? Working corp, during the massive M&A years, instead of being honest, I should have profited off that knowledge and been retired by now. Stupid me for believing in the massive hypocrisy that this country is, just too naive back then.

Dapper Dan's picture Whois Information Domain Name: ZEROHEDGE.COM
Whois Server:
Referral URL:
Status: clientTransferProhibited
Status: clientUpdateProhibited
Updated Date: 02-may-2012
Creation Date: 11-jan-2009
Expiration Date: 11-jan-2017

ABC Media Ltd
P.O. Box 3
Sofia, Sofia 1784
Domain name: ZEROHEDGE.COM
Administrative Contact:
Hristozov, Georgi
P.O. Box 3
Sofia, Sofia 1784
+359 2 875 35 99
Technical Contact:
Hristozov, Georgi
P.O. Box 3
Sofia, Sofia 1784
+359 2 875 35 99
Registrar of Record: easyDNS Technologies, Inc.
Record last updated on 02-May-2012.
Record expires on 11-Jan-2017.
Record created on 11-Jan-2009.
Domain servers in listed order:
Domain status: clientTransferProhibited
You have 99 lookups left today ZH has not provided many stories concerning GS of late, just saying.

i-dog's picture

a) ZH does not censor any comments about GS

b) TD rips GS a new one quite frequently

c) ZH gives GS's [often contradictory] analysts plenty of rope to hang themselves

d) WB7 and other contributors here crucify GS constantly

e) The NWO will be taking all the banks down...when they are ready with a global electronic currency (that's the reason, IMO, for the increasing volume of anti-MegaBanks propaganda recently ... it's not just to divert attention away from the political ideology of the NWO)

... however:

f) Don't think for a minute that ZH is not a honeypot - whether wittingly or unwillingly.



PS. Biderman sucks ... big time! jmo....

Northeaster's picture

"If you actually trade based on information provided in a blog, zerohedge or any other, you need your head examined." -

Which is what the disclaimer basically says here on the ZH site. Which of course a cursory search will show the interconnections of that website as well.

Panafrican Funktron Robot's picture

"If you actually trade based on information provided in a blog, zerohedge or any other, you need your head examined."

Bolded part is important, because advice on gambling is what it is.  Someone is trying to give you advice on what horse to pick.  Period, end of story.  Let's review kids:

1.  You can't predict the future.

2.  The house always wins.


larz's picture

1. Dont need to predict anything to trade successfully

2. The house can win always only IF YOU ALLOW IT TO

DoChenRollingBearing's picture

Would ABC Media, Ltd. of Bulgaria have ANYTHING to do with ABC News / ABC / Disney here in the USA?

Or is ABC Media, Ltd. its own organization?  I think that is a fair question to ask.

Panafrican Funktron Robot's picture

For those like DoChen that are too fucking retarded to even consider the idea of a Google search.

pd45's picture

"I'm asking if ABC Media is owned by Goldman Sachs ..."

Worse, the Bulgarian proxy is DHS honeypot. Sign off now or else..%$_&(01a

resurger's picture


excellent post on Biderman video.

So biderman fleeced GS by buying his own shares at "fractions" from that squid... If what he says is true (which i doubt) is a good thing.



Mr Lennon Hendrix's picture

He is a carnival barker, and nothing more.

vast-dom's picture




Dr. Engali's picture

Straw man argument. Saul would be proud. The focus needs to be on his call and whether or not you agree. Nobody is right all the time when it comes to market. The question is are you more right than wrong. In this case I agree with him.

veyron's picture

I made two major calls this year: short FB (31.50) and long ARNA (2.50).  I talked about it with many people on the chat.  Both have been exceptional.

It should have been obvious that FB was a flop, and in fact others are reporting that the institutional product has been a massive money loser.  No surprise goldman sachs sold its stake in TT at a major loss ...

Dr. Engali's picture

Nice attemt at misdirection, please try to stay focused. Most of us here made the same call on the  Facebook flop ,however that is a mute point. The topic is about his overall call on the broader market. and whether or not you disagree. The rest is all background noise. 

ArrestBobRubin's picture

Mute? Make that a "moot" point Dr. E

Dr. Engali's picture

Thanks. Don't know what I was thinking. Listening to a compliance video and trying to post at the same time.

Mr Lennon Hendrix's picture

Biderman sold a stake of Trim Tabs to Goldman:

Then Goldman Sachs buys facebook:

Then Biderman starts hawking Facebook before the IPO:

Finance is a dirty busines, and I think Biderman's actions are louder than his words, which are pretty damn loud.

i-dog's picture

Yeah ... and also make Biderman's newfound religion a "stating the bleeding obvious" point!

Dr. E. knows it, too.

SheepDog-One's picture

Veyron did you see I put your name in a comment on that video? lol

Tyler Durden's picture

"Did ZH take money from goldman sachs?"

Are you seriously that stupid?

If ZH took money from goldman sachs, this site would have been long shut down.

Dr. Engali's picture

He's/she is  paid troll not worthy of response.

ROCE's picture

Absolutely true !!

But GS's Prop Desk = Biggest Client of Trim Tabs = VERY FISHY

veyron's picture

This site would not be shut down.  Rather, it would slowly temper its tone on GS, so that people wouldn't notice for a long time.


Maybe I'm reading too much into this, but the content was much more ... aggressive in pursuing GS back in 2009 compared to now.

Tyler Durden's picture

Back in 2009 people didn't believe that the Fed was manipulating the stock market. People didn't know what prop trading was nor that, as we exposed, Goldman was the primary abuser and beneficiary of this. People didn't know what HFT was either. People thought Europe was "fine."

What exactly is your point?

If you would like to define the editorial content of ZH, perhaps you would like to buy a stake?

veyron's picture

Actually, if you would seriously entertain such an idea, I would like to buy a stake.

Ghordius's picture

I did. And it was nice to find ZH and see that I was not the only one.

Nevertheless, it's not really an argument - ZH could still be a "special ops". If not the Squid, how about a Russian KGB or better, a Bulgarian? Or funded by Chinese money? Live with it, this is the price of anonymity. Some punches are to be rolled with...

And keep up the good work ;-)      How much is a stake?

hannah's picture

what is so funny is...even if zerohedge is a chinese spy or a ex-kgb hookie...?...who cares. what can a website do yo you...? i love conspiracy theories but some people are just beyond stupid...


BTW...i heard that tyler durden was the person that actually stuck the rubber tube up marilyn monroes ass and delivered a fatal dose of drugs...? i demand an answer to this serious allegation.

Neethgie's picture

haha the second Wall street film right?

whats your number?


ACP's picture

I would like to buy a stake also, and please post more on Biderman. The comments exchanged are always the best.

redguard's picture

Tylers' How much to bring the captcha back?

ElvisDog's picture

Conspiracy-theory guys will believe anything that suits their world view. I'm sure you can convince yourself that ZH's tone towards GS has tempered. You probably also think NASA faked the moon landing or that the government has an alien spaceship at a secret base in Nevada.

HeavydutyMexicanOfTheNorthernKingdom's picture

yeah, i saw tyler walk right up to lloyd b and punch him right in the face.....just for beer money.  

kliguy38's picture least Bidee puts himself out there......he may be shill for the game but my guess is he's pumpin just to hang on in the BEAR of all Bidee......when this bear is through with us.......we'll all be wishing we could eat Alpo.

TWSceptic's picture

Difidently a clown


You win the ironic quote of the month.

jeff montanye's picture

and, unlike biderman, he's not too shy to accept it.