Citigroup Explains How The ECB Will Drive The EUR Today

Tyler Durden's picture

Citi's Steven Englander shares his outlook on what the key things to look out for, in the 8:30 am press conference, are. One variable in his forecast has already been presented: the cut was 25 bps not 50 bps. As he says: "By contrast, if they did 50bps and indicated that more aggressive measures might be forthcoming, the pendulum could swing to positive." In other words, the kneejerk jump in EURUSD following the ECB has been largely misguided for now, especially with forward EONIA rates jumping across the curve confirming that European liquidity is about to get far tigher all over again.

From Citigroup:

The ECB is the not the only game in town, but it is the first , so it is useful think about how its moves may affect the euro until the Summit results start emerging. Our economists write: “The ECB Governing Council is likely to cut rates today by at least 25bp to 1.0% (maybe even by 50bp to 0.75%) …. downward revision of the Eurosystem’s staff forecast for GDP growth in 2012 and the outlook for weak GDP growth and low inflation for 2013 …  probably will announce an extra LTRO with a maturity of at least 25 months and is likely to widen the collateral pool. ”

Importantly they add: “ we do not expect additional announcements from the ECB to support euro area sovereigns ...  [needing] further action from EU governments in order to see further action from the ECB.”

The two areas of uncertainty are 50bps vs 25bps and no additional bond activity versus some indication of more-to-come in terms of bond market intervention.
If the ECB does 25bps on rates plus the other expected measures, it is likely to come across as a bit disappointing to markets and EUR negative. Given that all political comments in the last two weeks have been aimed at getting the ECB more involved, the FX market would see it as a negative if they proved reticent. 

The most EUR positive outcome would be some commentary that is supportive of more engagement in bond markets, either by indicating that governments appear to be headed on the right track in fiscal terms or focusing on the degree to which the current rate structure represents unwarranted monetary tightness given the likely path of inflation and growth.  There is some debate over whether additional ECB engagement in sovereign bond markets would be a EUR plus or a negative. The argument for EUR-plus is that tail risk will fall, the EUR has been correlated with positive risk appetite for some years now and that convergence trades would attract capital in a euro zone without tail risk – I think this is the correct logic. The argument for EUR negative is that it would be viewed as a form of QE and put the ECB into the same category as the Fed and BoE in the eyes of investors.

The most uncertainty is what if they do 50bps, but give no nod to bond buying. This may be close to neutral, with the demonstration that they are willing to be aggressive on conventional monetary policy offsetting the disappointment on the long end. If they shut down the possibility of additional engagement in the sovereign bond market, the outcome would swing to EUR negative. Most FX investors see the problems of the euro zone as focused  on risk premia rather than the base level of rates, so adamantly sticking to central bank knitting would disappoint. By contrast, if they did 50bps and indicated that more aggressive measures might be forthcoming, the pendulum could swing to positive.

The EUR move could be quite large if the ECB was seen as laying down a marker one way or another. Most likely the reaction will be muted by the knowledge that there will be leaks galore out of the Summit the next two days, and investors will want to assess the net of fiscal and monetary policy outcomes, rather than a single leg. 

Out of these possibilities, I see a little more room for disappointment than for a positive EUR surprise, since the ECB emphasis could be on the conventional rather than non-conventional side.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
GeneMarchbanks's picture

Can kicking 'nuff said...

Irish66's picture

mild recession in europe, downgrade 

Sandy15's picture

Cutting the rate causes the Euro to go down and dollar to go up on in normal conditions........  Why is the Euro going up?

MFL8240's picture

Not when the Euro has dropped as it has, it will trick people into a false sence of security and the Euro will rally.

The 100 Trillion Dollar Man's picture

You are thinking about the situation where the rate staying unchanged is the most likely event. Here there were two outcomes, which had been priced in. If a 50bps cut would lose the euro 100 pips relative to a 25bps cut, and there was a 20% chance of that, then that would be weighing down the price by 20% of 100=20 pips (all roughly), so when that possibility was removed this morning, the Euro rose by that amount.

MFL8240's picture

Another day of games, lies, deception, courrption and deceit.  By next tuesday the house will be back on fire.

el-kalif's picture

CitiGroup eurozone forecasts:

Our economists believe the sovereign debt and banking crises are causing a renewed recession in the Euro Area. Beginning in 4Q 2012 [Sic], they forecast real GDP to contract for 6 consecutive quarters. It is expected to be an especially protracted recession. Not even in Japan, during its lost decades, did real GDP decline for 6 consecutive quarters. Our economists’ Euro Zone forecasts imply real GDP will be some way below the trend established during the first 10 years of Euro inception (Figure 3) and not get back to previous peak levels for many years to come.

Snakeeyes's picture

I gave a presentation on the Euro crisis, and some dolt in the audience said "I agree with what you are saying, but it will never impact the US." Apparently he doesn't read the news.

ECB Does Quantitative Easing, Eurozone Bonds Drop, Franco/German Proposal In Jeopardy