NFLX Beats But Guidance Stuns Stock -19% From Friday's Close, Margins Implode

Tyler Durden's picture

Netflix headlines may appear rosy as top and bottom lines were a beat but guidance on revenues and subrscriber adds perhaps rings the death knell on this mythical beast...

  • *NETFLIX SEES 2Q REV. ABOUT $873M-$895M; EST. $893.4M :NFLX US

We can only hope that AAPL does not miss in any way on any metric ever...

Here is what not to put in your letter to investors when you are a zero barrier to entry streaming company whose business model is being assaulted by everyone, not least of all Apple.

We think our 2012 domestic streaming net adds will be about the same as in 2010, and that gross adds will approximately follow the 2010 seasonal pattern.




Due to the increased net adds quarterly seasonality, Q2 net adds will be below those of 2010, despite Q2 net adds following the traditional seasonal pattern, and despite us expecting to match 2010 in annual net additions.

and the funniest line ever in an official company filing:

We see nothing new or particularly concering this quarter to date in our member viewing, acquisition and retention. All are healthy.

Except your stock price...

Finally, this is how you destroy your company. What can one say but sweet streaming jesus: this must be what an exponentially accelerating dead cut has to look like.

And another hilarious chart: total "profit" per foreign international paying sub. We only hope they can make up for it in volume...

Full letter:


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
mrdenis's picture

OH the inhumanity ...........

Animal Cracker's picture

Nah.  They just need a solid Groupon deal.

ACP's picture

But CNBC said earnings were better than expected!

Where's Steve LIESman to tell everyone how margin compression is a good thing?!?


Vampyroteuthis infernalis's picture

I was told BTFD. What could possibly go wrong?

Trimmed Hedge's picture

I believe what Taylor is trying to tell us in his own quirky little way, is... "BTFNFLXD"


; )

dannyboy's picture

Is Tilson still long this? If so.. so, so painful.

stocktivity's picture

About a month ago, I got an offer for a free one month trial. I wonder if I would have counted as a new subsciber if I had accepted?

CPL's picture

Yup.  It how bell dresses up quarterly numbers with their ISP sympatico and sat tv.  Once they have the CC number you are "subscribed" because you'll more than likely miss the cancel date then you'll justify how cheap it is.

jus_lite_reading's picture

WARNING: The biggest ponzi stock out there right now is LNKD... the same person who warned about NFLX, GRPN, and a whole handful of ponzi banks is saying LNKD is the next one to say adios!!

Stochdoc's picture

They need to start including porn on streaming.  That'll squeeze the shorts.

NewThor's picture

The IPO on NETDICKS is going to be huge.

The Axe's picture

THE SEC would use all the bandwidth

GMadScientist's picture

1 colo machine at their ISP and we're all good.


ACP's picture

That would be a huge government contract.

Oh regional Indian's picture

Now that is Funny New Thor. 

But it also sounds creepy when you've just watched Idiocracy. 


Conman's picture

Ya stream porn on the net, no ones doign that .. they'll corner the market... ooh wait..

ebworthen's picture

That's why they'll call it "Cumcast".

And...did you say corner?

mayhem_korner's picture



Today is a cue Tom Petty day...

I'm free fallin'

Temporalist's picture

Robo I'm sure you bought at the lows and sold at the highs.

nyse's picture

Pretty sure those are the only kinds of trades he makes.

The Axe's picture

At least I am not Whitney....

azzhatter's picture

but......but....Cramer said

Conman's picture

But bad news is good news, so buy? Also does this mean that all the free subs they added wont stick around for next Q?

t0mmyBerg's picture

I was actually just grateful that the CNBS coverage today reminded me to cancel my wifes subscription.  The morons over there still will not acknowledge the historically epic f*ckup they made last summer.  I want streaming AND dvd all on one login and all for less than the cost of doing both separately.   in other words, the way it was when the price had a 2 handle in the major slot and the price was triple digits.  but they just will not do it.  could they be that stupid?  apparently yes, yes they can.

Conman's picture

Can't blame Netflix, they did what they had to do. They obviously could not survive with the old model since shipping physical dvds costs too much vs all the streaming content rights they already aquired and paid for. They have good penetration but as a growth stock this thing is done, put a fork in it.

adr's picture

Uh, yes you can. Sure the stock may not have gone full retard on its way to the heights reached last summer without the streaming business model. But the streaming model killed the company. The movie selection is terrible and most people still lack the bandwidth to enjoy it.

You see that margin compression, that's all streaming. The DVD by mail business was doing fine and gave Netflix great margins.

Netflix brass decided to concentrate on what would be best to pump its stock with hype vs what would really be good for business. Of course the executives pocketed millions through insider stock sales and the 100% bounce from the bottom gave them another great grant and cash opportunity.

Netflix isn't about movies anymore. The company produced and sold stock certificates, DVDs by mail was just an advertising campaign.

Conman's picture

Hey im not arguing that streamign killed the business - just reiterating the streaming costs forced them to segreagate teh businesses. I do disagree that dvd gives them better margins, that business was probably killing them with increaed usps costs every year.

Also im sure they saw the kiosk dvd renters were getting some penetration as well coinstar, redbox, blockbuster. logical place to go was streaming. but now thats even crowded. Lets face it this business model offers no barriers to entry. which means growth is dead for this crap stock.

Cathartes Aura's picture

I was with them in the beginning, DVD's by mail was a good model, and I was able to get independent / foreign (ie less "popular" content) without having to live in a city with "alternative" shop providers. . .

but no, that wasn't good enough for NetFlix - they had to GROW AND GROW, until they were mainlining shitty TeeVee and acting like BlockBuster in their DVD selections - and upping the prices again and again. . . AND an obnoxious CEO. . . they pushed out their first-in folks, mocking us as we un-subscribed.

fk 'em.

fx's picture

Having good penetration is a nice starting advantage - for streaming porn right to the SEC, that is.

stocktivity's picture

I actually flipped over to fox Business channel today. Was like watching CNBC from the past ....Liz Claman, Melissa Francis, Dennis Kneale...still cheerleaders but different faces.

mayhem_korner's picture



Notice when the stock price drops, the fire at the bottom gets higher...

Temporalist's picture

Oh and Facebook had a 12% loss in the last quarter

NewThor's picture

Facebook has a top secret Space Exploration team that is currently extracting Valarian diamonds from Mars.

Once the IPO is done, they will announce it to the world and become the

greatest. corporation. of. all. time. (not counting the catholic church)

Problem Is's picture

Smoke weed... not meth, there Thor...

YesWeKahn's picture

People will be scaried tomorrow. If AAPL does this, the darn market will be halted a few times.

John Law Lives's picture

"We can only hope that AAPL does not miss in any way on any metric ever..."

AAPL sandbags when they project future EPS estimates.  Nonetheless, when APPL does eventually lay an egg with a major product release, the market response should be swift and brutal.


GMadScientist's picture

T-shirt recently seen on a friend:

"I was a Mac developer when Apple was doomed."


SheepDog-One's picture

AAPL is about as good as its ever going to get right now, that mid $600 range was tops. 

stocktivity's picture

Appl can't even think a negative word tomorrow.

buzzsaw99's picture

a weaker usd and the BRIC will help them get a bonus.

SheepDog-One's picture

Last time I used Netflix was at a party a couple months ago, I just played a bunch of Trailer Park Boys episodes....other than that, Netflix is pretty much worthless. Cancelled it.