Was Seth Klarman Just Exposed As Bank Of America's Biggest Short (And A Covert MBIA Long?)

Tyler Durden's picture

While we have extensively covered the blood feud between Bank of America, and its archnemeis, the mysteriously titled Walnut Place in the past (see here and here and here and here and most importantly here) which just happens to be the entity that successfully scuttled Bank of America's "proposed" $8.5 billion settlement with a bevy of so called litigants (among which BlackRock, PIMCO and the New York Fed for god's sake - the very entities who survival depends on BAC's continued existence) who in realty were merely subversive agents seeking to settle $424 billion in misrepresented mortgage CFC trusts just so the status quo would not be impaired, we never asked one simple question: just who is Walnut Place? Now, courtesy of Reuters, we know, and the revelation is quite stunning, because it means that the person who potentially has the biggest short in Bank of America either via equity or CDS (which do not have to be publicly desclosed) is the legendary head of Baupost: Seth Klarman. Reuters reports: "Walnut Place, a group of undisclosed investors who oppose Bank of America Corp's $8.5 billion mortgage bond settlement, is the Baupost Group, a distressed debt fund, according to an attorney for the bank. "Walnut Place is actually a made up name," Theodore Mirvis, an attorney with Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz who represents Bank of America, said at a hearing in New York state Supreme Court Thursday. The "real" firm, which sued Bank of America and Bank of New York Mellon BKNYK.UL, as trustee, over mortgage-backed securities trusts is Baupost -- "known as a distressed debt or sometimes a vulture fund," Mirvis said." As a reminder, Baupost is one of the world's biggest hedge funds at $23 billion, and unlike other fly-by-night one hit wonders, is not down 47% YTD. In fact, the mere name of Seth Klarman being long or short a stock has typically had a huge impact on the stock price. And since by implication in his continued efforts to destabilize the proposed settlement, Klarman is either short BAC, or long the beneficiaries of ongoing, and successful, litigation such as MBIA, this means that the pain for BAC is about to magnified as the traditional 13F clones jump on board the pair trade, and short BAC while going long MBIA et al (incidentally this is half the thesis that we presented back in September 15, when we said to... go long MBIA and short Bank of America).

From Reuters:

Walnut Place is involved in separate cases against Bank of America.


In August, 11 entities sharing the name Walnut Place filed to remove the global $8.5 billion settlement case from New York state to federal court, citing its size and complexity.


The settlement was intended to resolve much of Bank of America's remaining legal liability tied to its disastrous 2008 purchase of mortgage lender Countrywide Financial Corp. The deal, which was reached with over 20 institutional investors, would apply to other investors as well.


The decision to remove the case to U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York is on appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit.


Bank of New York Mellon is the trustee for the 530 mortgage securitization trusts covered by the proposed agreement.

Granted, with full Kudos to Reuters, the identity of the mysterious pair trader could have been uncovered long before:

In a May court filing, Bank of America said that Baupost sent letters to the Bank of New York Mellon, claiming it was a certificate holder and that loans in two trusts did not comply with representations and warranties made by Countrywide Home Loans. They said appraisals were inflated and other information had been misrepresented.

Baupost demanded the trustee give notice of the alleged breaches to Countrywide, according to the document, and require Countrywide to repurchase the loans. On December 21, 2010, the trustee received a letter concerning one of the trusts from entities including the "Walnut Place" entities.

"The Walnut Place entities claimed to have been assigned Baupost's interest in that trust," the document said.

Either way, now that it is known that the nemesis of Bank of America is one of the truly most successful investors in history, Brian Moynihan's life just got much more difficult.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
CrazyCooter's picture

BOFA was fucked when I saw that look on the CEOs face (Ken Lewis) when they ponied up at trough thinking they were NY bankers.

This bank will go down and the others will feed on the carcass.



Pladizow's picture

"Margin of Safety" - Bitchez!

maxw3st's picture

This has all the makings of a Hollywood movie.

J 457's picture

There was the anti-Tilson fund.  Now where's the short BAC/long MBIA fund?

Ted Baker's picture


zorba THE GREEK's picture

There is a good chance BAC will go down in 2012, along with every other large financial company on the planet.

It's time to prepare for the worst, my friends. 

Zaphod B.'s picture

Wow, holy shit! That's a total of five (5) here's in the first sentence...a record?

H to the 5th power. 

Tyler Durden does his homework. Now take your punk ass back home because tomorrow is going to be the best day of your life. Breakfast will never taste better....


JimRogers's picture

George Washington blushes...

Ineverslice's picture

"Who killed Frank Pentangelli?

"The Rosato Bros."

"Yeah, but who gave the go-ahead?"

Flakmeister's picture

Can I haz BAC putz?? Pleeze??

Schmuck Raker's picture

Taking a banker's life is amoral. Ruining a banker's life, OTOH, I'd consider a moral victory.

ghostfaceinvestah's picture

You are really stretching now, Manal.

Hicham's picture

Well I hope it does nicely for FAZ. Bought in after it dropped from 50-42 in a day. Bought a little more after it fell even further so won't take much of a rise to make al ittle profit.

Moon Pie's picture

Short BAC with both arms.....go long Michael Carney v. Bank of America et al. (9th Circuit Court of Appeals #11-56421).  Ruling due in January.

I has it on good info that US Bank and MERS are buying CDO's at issue max.

Between that and $75 Trillion in synthetics, It's like Green Bay laying 14 at Indy.  No brainer.

PMakoi's picture

Book, "Margin of Safety".  If you want to read it;


linli1234's picture


Welcome to buy stylish and fashionable Nike Air Jordan Shoes from Our Jordan Shoes are combined with innovational technology and first class craftsmanship to bring its wearer extremely comfortable feeling. And the appearance is also great,Jordan 5 Although this website is established not long time ago, actually our company has several years experience on the Cheap Jordan Shoes trading. Compare with other seller,Retro Jordan 5 we can provide you more professional advice. In addition,Air Jordan 6 Rings we have built long term cooperation with American Nike company, all of our collection are 100% authentic. We keep upload the latest style timely. You must will seek out what you want here! Wish you have a nice shopping on Jordan Shoe Sale!

Various kinds of stylish Air Jordan Shoes are hitting the shelves from cheapajclearance.com.jordan 1 So you can get the chance retro jordan 7 to collect your ideal cutting-edge style with high technology.air jordan 3 Each new retro jordan 11 items feature a perfect combination retro jordan 5 of forward-thinking technological advances in comfort air jordan 2 and functionality along with innovative designs and appealing detailing. New Arrival Discount Retro Jordans Shoes with full range air jordan 8 of styles and colorways for your selection.retro jordan 9 With the fantastic features of these Cheap Nike Jordan Sale, whatever models you choose,air jordan 4 shoes you will enjoy them very well!Be sure to check out our entire collection to fit your style.

yxj55's picture


This pair of shoes is a feature of innersleeve with traditional lace,air max online breathable type tongue. The Phylon midsoles raised volunteers, a lightweight buffer, so won't you feel bogged down feet still air max 2011. With the air force per unit length of amplification, this pair of heels are double stacked on the impact resistance of products, to protect you, with your best game.

Thanks spend your precious time to browse this Cheap Nike Shoes integrated website. Both Discount and Cheap Air Max are our main products. Meanwhile, Nike Shox Shoes and Air Max Shoes also won good reputation of clients, no matter the old or new customers.Nike Shoes Sale According to almost of our clients, Cheap Nike Shox is really breathable and comfortable.While Nike Air Max which installed the air cushion makes its wearer feel like walking in the cloud.The more important is that our Nike Shox Cheap Air Max online store provide them with 100% superior quality and large discount.

yxj55's picture


Cheap Nike shoes, they even developed more complex and elegant. A breath of fresh Cheap Air Max conditioning into the bottom, and the production capacity of the couple. Nike shop, Air Max Online only more skills used in the production of plastic materials used to deliver double gradient on there. Nike Air Max TN pairs of shoes, each pair of occupies a single consciousness and producing sports shoes head use. Nike Air Max LTD has a long path of the original investigation to dispute the facts before.

Nike Shox R4 New Zealand, observe the shadow said: "but I timberland become Britain, or let me Cheap Nike Shox Sale, the debate over the people, a red hair, he is now the most stubborn, and many of the infinite, this is a rather position present station, 1,Cheap Nike Shox above the humble our boots live in will do.

Know these shoes durable, wholesale nike shoes so don't worry about your efforts to use their wear will cause they spread out on you. Nike running shoes cheap sneakers cushion was designed for hard, daily use.Nike Shox TL1 Shoes They are in our website, now hot sale.cheap air max We guarantee its quality. You can buy cheap Nike shox on the Internet and the best price and high quality.Nike Shox OZ Shoes Don't miss it!

yxj55's picture


In the heel and jordan 4 sole before the part between cheap jordan 2 the small holes to increase design special air permeability,Cheap Jordan and especially bootlace increased a layer of vamp to make in the fierce the basketball game is not easy to loose. Discount Jordan Shoes Foam plus leica artificial elastic fiber design air jordan 6 rings can be completely brought waiting on Nike Jordan Sale, make the wearer this pair of Discount air jordan 1 sale have a comfort.Retro Jordan Sale heels place installed high-tech designedly carbon fiber to provide the extra support retro jordan 1 to ankle stable.

thank you very much! i like it!Cheap Air Jordan The biggest characteristic is match colors much more special.cheap jordan 1 At the time of the very popular shoes holder design and built-in air mattress.Although this may be a great progress in the process of innovation Air Jordan Shoes, fresh birth certificate the brand air jordan 3. Because a pump design, so that, when you wear Discount Air Jordan, you can adjust the pump in what way as you like. air jordan 6 rings.

valueslots's picture

You can also read up-to-date news about Seth Klarman at: http://valueslots.com/legendary-investors/seth-klarman/

It follows every move the investor makes and his comments and views.