Why The Market Is Slowly Dying

Tyler Durden's picture




 

Three years ago, when virtually nobody had yet heard of High Frequency Trading, Zero Hedge wrote "The Incredibly Shrinking Market Liquidity, Or The Upcoming Black Swan Of Black Swans" in which we asked "what happens in a world where the very core of the capital markets system is gradually deleveraging to a point where maintaining a liquid and orderly market becomes impossible: large swings on low volume, massive bid-offer spreads, huge trading costs, inability to clear and numerous failed trades?" Subsequent to this, our observation was proved right on both an acute (the May 6, 2010 Flash Crash), and chronic (the nearly 50% collapse in average daily volumes since the 2008 top) secular basis. And while we are not happy to have been proven correct in this particular forecast, as it ultimately means the days of equity capital markets in their current configuration are numbered, we now note that none other than Morgan Stanley's Quantitative and Derivative Strategies released a note which, with a three year delay, effectively predicts the end of capital markets in a world where every declining retail participation (another topic we have been hammering for the past 3 years as it is only the most natural response to a world in which not only equities are openly manipulated by central banks, but in which perpetrators for massive market disturabances are neither identified nor prosecuted) is replaced by artificial high frequency trading churn, which never was and never will be a true liquidity provider on a long-term basis.

To wit from Morgan Stanley: "In our mind, many of the approaches to algorithmic execution were developed in an environment that is substantially, structurally different from today’s environment. In particular, the early part of the last decade saw households as significant natural liquidity providers as they sold their single stock positions over time to exchange them for institutionally managed products... While the time horizon over which liquidity is provided can range from microseconds to months, it is particularly shorter-term liquidity provisioning that has become more common." Translation: as retail investors retrench more and more, which they will due to previously discussed secular themes as well as demographics, and HFT becomes and ever more dominant force, which it has no choice but to, liquidity and investment horizons will get ever shorter and shorter and shorter, until eventually by simple limit expansion, they hit zero, or some investing singularity, for those who are thought experiment inclined. That is when the currently unsustainable course of market de-evolution will, to use a symbolic 100 year anniversary allegory, finally hit the iceberg head one one final time.

How does Morgan Stanley frame their analysis? First, MS notes the ever increasing ownership of the stock market by big institutions, as retail investors took a back seat to investment allocation decisions, a secular theme until 2008, which however has subsequently plateaued:

Asset management has become increasingly institutionalized over the years. Individuals have outsourced their wealth management to institutions, whether pension funds, insurance companies or investment advisors. These, in turn, invest mostly in institutionally managed products such as mutual funds, ETFs, or long/short vehicles. The net result of this is that the vast majority of investable assets are held through institutionally managed vehicles. Exhibit 1 shows the evolution of ownership vehicles of corporate equity in the US. 37% of the USD 22tn of corporate equity is held by ‘Households and Nonprofits’ now, down from 50% at the turn of the century. This segment includes endowments and foundations, as well as on-shore hedge funds. Arguably, these should be counted as institutional investors as well. This means that direct household ownership of corporate equity is substantially below this figure.

 

For a universe of large-cap stocks4, Exhibit 4 shows the evolution of the percentage of ownership attributable to 13F filers and mutual funds since Dec 2001. This data corroborates Exhibit 1 on the increase in institutional ownership – on average, institutional ownership increased from 54% in March 2000 to 81% at the end of 2011.

 

Following the rapid growth of institutional asset management, however, the pace of increase in institutional ownership has slowed since 2008. We see this as one of the key drivers of the change in market structure and liquidity sourcing opportunities in recent years.

As more and more "equity capital" was concentrated into the hands of fewer and fewer people, the only logical outcome took place:

Trading decisions have become more concentrated as asset management has institutionalized. There are fewer decision makers (fund managers) now than in a world where management is dispersed across households. The size of their parent orders, on the other hand, has grown. The basic set up of the market – in terms of a continuous auction limit order book supplemented with ‘upstairs’ solutions –  has not changed. The details of the implementation have adjusted, of course – such as competition in execution venues, new order types,  and greater use of technology.

 

One of the most significant results of the tension between fewer market participants and larger parent order sizes is that the share of ‘real’ trading volume has declined by around 40% in the last five years. In Exhibit 5, we show the average proportion of quarterly trading volume that is attributable to changes in the 13f filings of each institution. We use this as our definition of ‘real’ trading volume. We also calculate the trading volume from our separate dataset of mutual fund holdings. We aggregate ‘buys’ (positive position changes) and ‘sells’  separately for each institution and mutual fund, on a per-stock basis, and calculate the average percentage of volume across stocks in our universe.

As a result, reports of the market's evaporating volume are not greatly exaggerated.

In our mind, these numbers constitute a lower bound on the amount of ‘real’ trading volume in the market (defined as the trading volume from market participants that hold assets for longer periods).

 

The share of real trading volume shows three distinct phases. From 2001 to 2006, institutional buys accounted for 27% of total trading volume on average, while sells accounted for 20%7. The asymmetry between buys and sells reflects the growth in the institutional share of ownership over the period (see Exhibit 4). From 2008 to 2011, we see a significantly lower share of trading volume – buys represent just 16%, and sells 13%, a drop in market share of almost 40%.

 

The 2007/2008 period represents a transition period, with a rapidly declining share of ‘real’ trading volume. This period coincided with rapidly increasing overall trading volume (Exhibit 6) – in 2006, the ADV was 4.8bn shares, while in 2008 it was 8.8bn shares. Volume has since declined again – YTD ADV is 6.9bn shares.

While it will not come as news to any of our regular readers, the disappearance of retail investors has meant the incursion of electronic trading in the form of relentless rise in HFT dominance.

Throughout the last decade, the share of institutional trading volume by each institution type has been remarkably constant (Exhibit 7). This means that the reduction in institutional share of overall trading volume between 2007 and 2008 was not due to a reduction in trading activity by any one institution type, but rather due to the introduction of a new type of trading volume.

 

A potential reason [for the drop in our measure of the share of ‘real’ institutional trading volume] is that institutional execution strategies have made liquidity more challenging to find. Concentration in assets under management has led to larger order sizes. One of the responses to this has been automation in execution strategies. The algorithms used tend to split parent orders into smaller child orders. As a result, we find that block trades, which made up around 30% of trading volume in 2003, accounted for just over 5% of trading volume in 2011 – see Exhibit 8. At the same time, the average trade size has fallen to around 250, from more than 1,000 back in 2003. Both data series are based on NYSE listed stocks.

 

Next Morgan Stanley explains precisely why the current market is no longer fit to deal with the existing roster of players, fit for a previous iteration of capital market topology such as that which prevailed when Reg-NMS was conceived, but certainly not the current one, especially if retail continues to withdraw from trading equities and invest its cash forcibly into that other terminally epic bubble - bonds.

In our mind, many of the approaches to algorithmic execution were developed in an environment that is substantially, structurally different from today’s environment. In particular, the early part of the last decade saw households as significant natural liquidity providers as they sold their single stock positions over time to exchange them for institutionally managed products. Adjusting the institutional execution strategy to capture this liquidity was a rational thing to do.

But...

This institutionalization of asset management is mostly done by now, as we showed in Exhibit 4. As a result, execution strategies that were calibrated on the earlier market environment may no longer be optimal. The rise in trading volume since 2007 (when the growth in institutional ownership leveled off) reflects the growing challenges of sourcing liquidity. The way this has been resolved is through the introduction of more ‘market making’ activity in the form of liquidity provider trading.

Let's repeat that for the cheap seats: "As a result, execution strategies that were calibrated on the earlier market environment may no longer be optimal" and we could in theory just end it here. 

We all know that the bulk of HFTs close each day flat to avoid overnight holding risk, which they do by increasing churn amongst each other to unprecedented levels, in the process generating massive momentum swings as every player piggybacks on either side of the move. End result: even Moran Stanley admits that churn is not liquidity, and that the inability of HFT to carry inventory and have a longer-term bias is the fatal flaw in the current market topology, precisely as we warned back in April 2009!

The risk-carrying capacity of these providers is limited. If natural liquidity does not materialize, they may trade with another intraday liquidity provider to manage their inventory. This is particularly true if the institutional parent orders are larger and hence typically longer lasting.

From here, everything else follows:

Typical market-making liquidity provisioning strategies can be modeled as mean reversion strategies. If liquidity demand is persistently one-sided (such as in the case of large parent orders), it is rational to flatten the market maker position faster if the risk-carrying capacity is limited. In the absence of natural liquidity on the other side, this will often be through a trade with another intraday liquidity provider.  The net result is that the the amount of trading volume that is attributable to this segment of the market will increase.

Thus: lim investing time horizons approaches 0 as HFT ->  infinity

While the time horizon over which liquidity is provided can range from microseconds to months, it is particularly shorter-term liquidity provisioning that has become more common. This is partially a reflection of the changing nature of the default liquidity provider – ‘High-Frequency Trader’ is a commonly applied term.

Unfortunately, the "High Frequency Trader" is NOT, as explained, a liquidity provider in the conventional sense: it is an ultra-short time horizon churn facilitator and liquidity extractor (when the meager rebate for providing liquidity does not offset the capital holdings risk) and nothing else. Which is why just like the Fed has become the artificial lender of last resort in a regime that is unsustainable and where central banks are forced to grow their assets exponentially (as shown on Zero Hedge) just to preserve the flow so very needed to keep equities from collapsing, so HFT has become the artificial provider of fake liquidity.

The problem is that just like the half lives of central bank intervention, so the incremental benefits of ever greater HFT penetration are becoming less and less.

What happens next? Here Morgan Stanley, while trying to be diplomatically correct, comes to precisely our conclusion - trade while you can.

In our view, many of the changes in the market environment – such as the decline in trading volume – are secular. The trade from household direct share ownership to institutionally managed ownership has happened, removing one of the natural sources of liquidity. At  the same time, the micro-efficiency of the market in identifying and exploiting liquidity demand, exemplified by the growth in intraday liquidity provisioning strategies, is here to stay.

 

What are the implications for institutional execution strategies? The first implication is a re-evaluation of parent order sizing. Liquidity for institutional trades is now ultimately sourced from other institutions for the most part, rather than from households. The share of trading volume from these institutions has been falling by almost 40% over the last five years. This means that the amount of liquidity we can reasonably expect to source in the market should also fall by a similar amount. For example, we find that the upper limit of the percentage of ADV that can be traded in a VWAP-type strategy without undue price impact is typically around 4-5% now, versus 10-15% in the period before 2007.

 

The second implication is that execution strategies have to focus on maximizing the likelihood of being a liquidity provider. This has always been the objective of portfolio managers (‘Buy Low, Sell High’). Within the institutional asset management process, that has not always  been as central to the execution strategy. The assumption has been that liquidity will be available in the markets, and that the cost of demanding that liquidity (the market impact cost) was small relative to the alpha potential over time. As the composition of trading volume changes, this assumption has become more problematic. Having urgency constraints (e.g. having to finish a trade at a particular time)  becomes increasingly costly relative to the alpha potential.

Where Morgan Stanley stops short is the logical next question: what will detour this transition to a market driven by quantized incremental binary decision-making, aka RISK ON, RISK OFF, where with every passing day, we get greater and greater volatility shifts? The answer: nothing, unless of course, for some reason retail investors do come back, however with Lehman, the Flash Crash, MF Global, central planning, forced media propaganda telling everyone "it is a once in a lifetime opportunity to buy", even as markets in real terms are still down nearly 40% from 2000, retail has had enough of the rigged stock market casino.

Simply said: they are done.

Hence HFT will have no choice but to become a greater and greater role in equity trading, pardon, churning. Until one day, by logical extrapolation, only HFT is the marginal setter of prices, with no regard for value, logic or analysis, and a price-determining function set purely by historical precedent yet a precedent which will be no longer applicable in the least as the paradigm shift to a conceptually different "market" will have then happened. Or said otherwise: "large swings on low volume, massive bid-offer spreads, huge trading costs, inability to clear and numerous failed trades"... just as we predicted back in April 2009.

Just as simply said: with its advent, HFT sowed the seeds of its own self-cannibalization.

Which also goes back to another key concept, and arguably the biggest flaw in all of modern economics: it is never about the stock. It is all, and always has been, about the flow. Last week Goldman tacitly acknowledged it for the first time. Expect more and more economic hacks to follow suit.

The irony that ties it all together, is that if indeed for some reason retail investors do come back, and do pile their over $8.1 trillion in fungible money currently stored under the electronic cushion as we described in This Is Where "The Money" Really Is - Be Careful What You Wish For, which in turn would also unleash the titanic wall of money hidden behind the Shadow Banking dam wall (at last count about $35 trillion contained among the custodial holders of all securities why are quietly swept into the shadow banking system's re-re-rehypothecated pseudo asset pyramid and regulated by exactly nobody), which no conventional economic theories account for, yet which as Ben Bernanke this week, and Zero Hedge for the past 2 years, has been warning is the real catalyst of the (hyper) inflationary spark, then the Fed will be powerless to stop the biggest avalanche of empty artificially created fiat currency ones and zeros to ever hit the monetary system in the history of the world since Weimar. Only this time it will have the added benefit of HFT to accentuate every move imaginable as cash transitions from an inert form to an active, asset managed one.

But this is far beyond what one learns in Econ 101, which is why we will have to wait at least another 3 years before the Morgan Stanleys and all other bandwagon chasers of the world close the loop on what we are (and have been for a while) warning right now.

In the meantime, we are confident readers will enjoy the supreme irony: in their attempt to perpetuate the insolvent status quo farce, the central planners are now forced to choose between the terminal Scylla and Charybdis: a pyrrhic Schrödinger [alive|dead] market, or an even more pyrrhic Schrödinger [alive|dead] monetary regime.

We hope they choose wisely.

0
Your rating: None
 

- advertisements -

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Sat, 04/14/2012 - 14:04 | 2345445 GeneMarchbanks
GeneMarchbanks's picture

Black Box, Bitchez!

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 15:05 | 2345488 Oh regional Indian
Oh regional Indian's picture

It's going to be a nuclear winter all around.... almost like it's willed...

A white-out of blinding intensity. Thus the name Flash Crash....

Market is just a fractal reflection of our collective condition..... slowly dying...

Not being defeatist, I'm speaking as a species...

ori

/stream-of-consciousnesstwo/

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 15:38 | 2345548 max2205
max2205's picture

Sorry Dark pool trade match increase negate all the words above

There are delayed prints of enormous size each day.

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 16:41 | 2345660 johnu1978
johnu1978's picture

Here's a little break from the Doom Porn:

Edible Plant Tours - Primitive Shelter Building Classes
http://www.heartrootnatureconnection.com/

 

 

Enjoy,
John

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 17:03 | 2345689 Cadavre
Cadavre's picture

Just saw the EUR/USD print on the Bloomberg TV (16:00 Saturday). Don't know where it came fro, but the EUR was down more than a penny (-.011 to be precise).

 

Monday should be interesting

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 21:24 | 2345937 AldousHuxley
AldousHuxley's picture

Because market became globalized and NYSE is just a slice of a pie no longer THE pie.

 

NYSE+NASDAQ is only 35% of world's total market value.

 

Thanks to retarded US corporate execs, China was able to steal US industry and float Chinese corporations in Shanghai and Hong Kong instead of NYSE or NASDAQ. China will kick US out of the global economic dominance picture when the time is right.

 

 

 

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 17:43 | 2347173 fockewulf190
fockewulf190's picture

No wonder CNBC built their studio right onto the floor of the NYSE. The NYSE needs all the revenue it can get so thex might as well pimp out their floor space.

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 12:16 | 2346615 Diogenes
Diogenes's picture

Not retarded, just extremely clever, extremely short term thinking. It makes perfect sense to kill the golden goose, roast it and eat it if 1) you get paid enough for doing this to retire in luxury for the rest of your life and 2) it wasn't your goose to begin with.

The most notable quote in the above story is the one where liquidity is defined in terms of microseconds to months. And planning your investments months in advance must seem quaint to the quants. Only a few dinosaur hedge funds think in terms of months, as they still make their money by tearing apart old companies and destroying them, and they are dying now as they run out of old line companies to devour.

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 22:16 | 2345985 BeetleBailey
BeetleBailey's picture

Not unusual for a 100 pip (in this case, if the -.011 is correct) no big deal. Sunday opens produce spikes one way or the other in many major pairs - sometimes, for no good reason.

Sunday night FX trading - to many - is amateur hour. The London open is considered the "start" of the week.

The USD in this case, sucks to, so it's been a tug of war over the 1.30 handle for the last month or so....

Both currencies are weak....Paired, both are volatile - good for trading - as both suck, fundamentally as well as fiscally

- apologies for using the word fiscal in the sentence, for both regions either manipulate, print, and or. 

Neither deserves any favor.

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 11:46 | 2346530 DeadFred
DeadFred's picture

The EURUSD sits on a fairly precarious support now (by my less-than-expert reading). A significant drop is likely to have a strong follow through. With all the gloomanddoom I'm reading we're either being led into a bear trap or a significant correction. Time will tell.

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 15:42 | 2345555 falak pema
falak pema's picture

the ups and downs of the eternal world order; personal karma and universal dharma.

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 18:53 | 2345790 Manthong
Manthong's picture

There is a reason maggots feasting on a carcass increase exponentially until they don’t.

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 05:21 | 2346234 Sudden Debt
Sudden Debt's picture

That is a very good anology!

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 10:04 | 2346427 francis_sawyer
francis_sawyer's picture

The market is dead... Long live the market...

(this post was randomly generated by FRANCIS SAWYER, a strawman)...

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 10:11 | 2346431 espirit
espirit's picture

Either that or they're trying to slip retail a "blue pill".

Good thing I'll never be dependant on a public pension with a guarranteed return of 7.5 or 8%.  If I were, would be sweating bullets. 

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 11:12 | 2346501 engineertheeconomy
engineertheeconomy's picture

Maggots feasting on a carcass increase exponentially until the combination of  hyperinflation and unemployment  cause a revolution and the people eat their captors (1% central banker asada tacos) will be the rage

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 22:42 | 2346012 New_Meat
New_Meat's picture

but here, we're talking about "Instant Karma" - Ned

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 01:26 | 2346151 Oh regional Indian
Oh regional Indian's picture

The EWO..... I like it Falak!!!

ori

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 15:09 | 2345497 knukles
knukles's picture

HFT and the raft of financial sins abounding in my not so humble opinion are not the reason that markets are dying; they are but a symptom.
Markets are dying as those responsible for the regulation of particpants therein (and in the case of US markets, the oligopolistic regulatorily enhanced behavior is desperately in need of true regulation if only to break up the TBTF via anti-trust regulations amongst many other options and venues) are not enforcing the laws of the land. 
The rule of law has died. 
Not as in dying, diminishing, disappearing.... it's gone, nada, zilch, nope, no longer, over and done with.
The reason that the rule of law is extinct is best demonstrated by a pronouncement, referred to as a "demand" made by our leader, that Mr. Romney show us who he really is.
My Lord, a serious, application of the first rule of propagandizing... divet and discredit.
No discussions as to the law, constitution, morals or ethics, nothing about principles, but a continued dismemberment of reality through divisive nit picking over the immaterial in order to distract from the important.
That's why we're fucked.
Nobody cares. 
Nobody (or at least not enough to matter) truly cares anymore.
The self centered egomaniacal generations. 
Attention spans have become akin to that of walnuts or earthworms, whilst the electorate's desire for information has become confused with affirmation and entertainment.
That's why we're fucked.
Nobody truly cares anymore.
That's why markets are dead.
Because we as a society have destroyed everything that matters; ethics, morals, character, and have no intention of admitting our faults and making necassary amends, setting things right.
 

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 16:44 | 2345665 iDealMeat
iDealMeat's picture

+1   it is the   " i "  world after all..

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 16:45 | 2345667 knukles
knukles's picture

Beautifully said.

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 17:58 | 2345745 Eireann go Brach
Eireann go Brach's picture

Well said Knuckles! One just has to log onto their facebook to see the nonsense the mindnumbing pathetic masses care about!

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 23:09 | 2346039 natty light
natty light's picture

Post anything to fb that challenges the normalcy bias and the psychology of the previous and you most likely get :crickets:

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 23:56 | 2346085 Real Estate Geek
Real Estate Geek's picture

. . . and that's coming from a person who uses Facebook!

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 06:38 | 2346274 Element
Element's picture

I'm just going to have to take your word for that.

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 19:10 | 2345805 IToldYouSo
IToldYouSo's picture

+1 

iDealMeat, A thought I have had banging around my skull for a while now. The I-phone is almost the perfect analog for todays "society". Except I call it the ME-phone.

ME ME ME ME ME blooby MEEEEEEEEEEE!

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 06:43 | 2346277 Element
Element's picture

And you can get the iMe 4.0 with the NOW 2.633 app space operating system totally free for only $76 per month for 36 months.

iMe 4.0 NOW is so advanced you can even make phone calls with it!

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 20:03 | 2345863 Freddie
Freddie's picture

Because we as a society have destroyed everything that matters; ethics, morals, character...

+1

Post of the year.  I have a little hope because no one junked you.  I expected some might be "offended" that you actually mentioned ethics, morals and character.  3 key things required in a civilized society.

 

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 22:55 | 2346026 StychoKiller
StychoKiller's picture

The age of kali yuga will end, because ALL things must pass!

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 20:32 | 2345898 PoliticalRefuge...
PoliticalRefugeefromCalif.'s picture

Well that pretty much sums it up for a lot of us I suppose, "without a vision the people perish"- I am not sure that I have ever seen a period in my lifetime with such a vacuum of statesmanship. but it is for the very reason you listed in the last paragraph..

"Because we as a society have destroyed everything that matters; ethics, morals, character, and have no intention of admitting our faults and making necassary amends, setting things right"

Yep, they have us where they want us, it would take a very strong person to fight the headwind those deviations from normalcy will bring to the table, we are watching the ship scuttled before our eyes and they demand we focus on mythological problems instead.. and beyond belief... we oblige them.

Gold star for the "oligopolistic regulatorily enhanced behavior" definition, can't wait to use that term at the hockey forums..

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 22:17 | 2345988 TooBearish
TooBearish's picture

Well said knucles - don't stop there - take it to the logcial end.  The German people went along with their Facist leader to get along after the economic ravishes of WWI reparations and the Weinmar hyperinflation, their collective madness and soulless indulgences in nationalist pride bought about generational devisation.  No one stood in the way, though there were some serious efforts of a few....we have all see this movie before...

Yet here we stand looking down the same abyss, 80 years later, morally and literally bankrupt, going along to get along...while TPTB run rampant -ripping apart the foundations that made this country and society unique, distroying the family, stealing thru taxation and inflation, corrupting our children in a dysfuntional national eduation system,lining the pockets of the cartels that run the country and quasing individual liberty all along the way.  AND YET WE WILLINGLY EMBRACE IT.

Darkness is elimated by light, good trumps evil and God will beat the Devil, yet the final showdown is yet to come...prepare...

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 01:06 | 2346137 knukles
knukles's picture

Interestingly, I am re-reading William Schrier's Rise and Fall of the Third Reich. 

Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.
                     -
George Santayana

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 08:24 | 2346332 AnAnonymous
AnAnonymous's picture

after the economic ravishes of WWI reparations

____________________________________

No. They were cancelled when the nazi party rised in Germany.

Unjust people can not rely on a just follower to get away with their unjust actions.

The only way they get away with them is by clinging to power.

This is what US citizens do.

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 22:44 | 2345996 LongSoupLine
LongSoupLine's picture

you completely nailed it knukles, nice.

 

I would like to add that the symptoms you speak of have become so severe at this point, they are easily a cause in their own way.  However, this only serves to reinforce how completely fucked the culture of leadership in this country (and world) has become.  In the end, it has been allowed to happen in many ways by the very people who these "leaders" are supposed to serve.   Because the "people don't care", power is left to it's own checks and balances.  Needless to say, those in power do not have checks and balances other than the ones they self generate and display to the numb masses on CNBC and MSM.

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 22:48 | 2346020 New_Meat
New_Meat's picture

knuckles: it gets to the point where contracts can be broken at political will (thanks ruthie, but not only you) and it all falls apart.  takes a bit of while to get the word out.  then the whole system's participants withdraw from playing.

part o'the plan.

- Ned

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 08:33 | 2346336 AnAnonymous
AnAnonymous's picture

Because we as a society have destroyed everything that matters; ethics, morals, character, and have no intention of admitting our faults and making necassary amends, setting things right.

_____________________________________________

When were US citizen ethics destroyed?

US citizenism has not changed one bit since its inception. More fabled past. Best is that call is covered later by stuff like "a continued dismemberment of reality"

Quite funny.

US citizenism have always toyed with reality. From the start.

When US citizens started by hijacking humanity through ascribing fantasical values to human beings like supposedly unalienated creator given rights, making the call for the rest of the whole humanity, it ended with the other fantasical story that some human beings were not human beings, but sub or non human beings.

Performed so that US citizens could keep their slavery business.

For the US citizen fantasies to come alive, the reality of the human being condition had to be denied.

Nitpicking on divisions? ah, but the divisions brought by US citizenism are real. The world was divided before the rise of US citizenism for sure, but nothing compared to US citizenism legacy.

US citizens have certainly never destroyed US citizen ethics.

US citizen ethics are reigning supreme.

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 10:15 | 2346435 DOT
DOT's picture

Stole that sub-human idea from those Chinese !

Not that it was a good idea ( needed some work ) but we  "Eternals" sometimes like to play around a bit.

Ni hao.

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 08:51 | 2346355 GCT
GCT's picture

Well said knukles.  What is worse to me is when you try to have a conversation with a friend or even here now, you get the huffpo and the red state foks that do not want to learn.  True not all ZH articles are written for someone to learn from, but at least you have the freedom to read articles and some smart people state facts you can actually find.  I am tired of being called a malcontent, racist, trouble maker or worse. Some day people will realize the Dems and the Repubs are one of the same with just a different message.    

The strangest thing happened to me the other day when I showed the some of our staff that comical video about the Euro problem.  Some of the staff got it.  I shook my head and actually was happy they woke up to what is going on.  Most people working where I do could not even locate Greece on a map. 

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 09:53 | 2346413 Pairadimes
Pairadimes's picture

“Only a virtuous people are capable of freedom.” - Benjamin Franklin

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 15:10 | 2345501 Eireann go Brach
Eireann go Brach's picture

There once was a man called Ben,

According to his wife was the weakest of all men,

He printed and lied,

Until the Hewlett Packards fried,

Ben didn't know what to do anymore, so he died!

 

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 05:24 | 2346238 Sudden Debt
Sudden Debt's picture

Poets, what would we do without them :)

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 18:30 | 2345779 vast-dom
vast-dom's picture

have no fear with the rise of HFT at expense of all other trading, VIX will one day go exponential.

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 14:05 | 2345446 Earl of Chiswick
Earl of Chiswick's picture

somewhat off topic but does 'bare' a resemblance to Robo's avatar and tells you just how much infor your iPhone embeds

 

Suspected Anonymous Hacker Busted By FBI — Thanks To A Racy Photo

http://houston.cbslocal.com/2012/04/13/anonymous-hacker-busted-by-fbi/

 

The FBI found the image in February and checked the exchangeable image file format, or EXIF data, for evidence. EXIF data is information that a digital camera imprints onto an image. This particular image’s EXIF data revealed that it came from an iPhone near Melbourne, Australia, which then led the FBI to Ochoa’s Facebook page. The page featured other images of the girl, who turned out to be his girlfriend.

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 14:19 | 2345456 Alcoholic Nativ...
Alcoholic Native American's picture

A hacker with a facebook/twitter account and a smart phone got busted?  They really need to throw the book at this guy.

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 06:34 | 2346271 EvlTheCat
EvlTheCat's picture

....and a girlfriend? w/ tits?

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 07:43 | 2346296 ExpendableOne
ExpendableOne's picture

He's a plant, no self respecting hacker has an iPhone, facebook and a girlfriend (with tits!).

Sun, 04/15/2012 - 12:06 | 2346584 DeadFred
DeadFred's picture

If he was a successful programmer it could be a rent-to-own gf

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 14:20 | 2345459 Beam Me Up Scotty
Beam Me Up Scotty's picture

Soon there will be nowhere to hide from the watchful eye of Big Brother.  Unless you totally unplug from the matrix.

Sat, 04/14/2012 - 16:59 | 2345666 Vince Clortho
Vince Clortho's picture

dupe

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!