Fiscal And Monetary Policy Insanity - Realized Depopulation Vs. Potential Pandemic

Authored by Chris Hamilton via Econimica blog,

There is great concern (rightly) about the current Coronavirus and potential for a regional or global pandemic.  The loss of life and associated deceleration of economic activity have a fair number of folks pretty concerned and market riggers working overtime to avoid an asset "panic" (aka, free market price discovery).  However, how bad and widespread this may get is unknowable and speculative.

What is known before any pandemic is that the four regions of the world that make-up just 36% of global population but nearly 80% of global GDP (plus 80% of commodity / energy consumption) including East Asia (Japan, China, Taiwan, S/N Korea), Western Europe, Eastern Europe, and North America (US, Canada) all have declining under-60-year-old populations as of 2019.

As the chart below shows, all four regions are now in decline and the under 60 year-old declines are projected to continue and worsen through 2040 in all but North America.  As for the US, the projections of a return to high rates of immigration and significant increases in fertility and births are unlikely to play out.  North America's under 60 year-old population is much more likely to hug the zero growth line through 2040 than return to growth.

Below is what this looks like on an annual change basis in millions of persons.  Noteworthy is 2009 was the gateway from centuries of secular growth to what is now decades or perhaps centuries of secular decline.  2020 is really the jumping off point, as a period of minor under 60yr/old population declines ends, and the downside speed accelerates in these four regions (particularly China in East Asia).  In 2020, the global population of consumers will decline by 5 million.  By 2030, the decline will be "at least" 17 million annually.  Why "at least"? 

This data from the UN assumes birth rates and total births in these four regions far above what was observed in 2018 and 2019 and these UN assumptions of rising fertility and births is projected through 2040.  Since 2007, birth rates and total births are significantly breaking to the downside, particularly in 2019... and the difference in these four regions was over 2 million fewer births in 2019 alone and the delta is only growing over time.

The actual declines in the under-60 population will likely be in excess of 20 million a year by 2030.  Simply put, in 2020, we are looking at a 0.2% to 0.3% annual decline in consumers with the jobs, income, savings, and/or access to credit to consume.  By 2030, the annual decline will be up to 0.7% to 0.8%.  It is very hard to grow when you are shrinking...and all the poor and third world nations are dependent on the demand growth among these four consumer regions for their growth.  You can see the problem (unless you are paid quite handsomely not to see it).

Strangely, the Federal Reserve and like central banks, in conjunction with federal governments, are making money ever cheaper with the aim of a continuation in global productive capacity...in the face of fast declining populations that do all the consuming. 

We are officially in a period of fiscal lunacy in the face of depopulation among the global consumer base.

Data via UN World Population Prospects 2019