As if the imposition of a new "National Security" law by the Politburo Standing Committee wasn't enough of a kick to the face for Hong Kong's pro-democracy movement, the city's own executive council, which over the years has been packed with pro-Beijing lawmakers via anti-democratic tactics, has just made it illegal to "disrespect" the Chinese national anthem.
What's worse: the new law, perhaps the biggest move by the legislature to suppress political freedoms in the city to date, was passed on the anniversary of "the June 4 incident" - better known in the US as the Tiananmen Square massacre, which WSJ noted is a "poignant day" for Hong Kong.
For the first time, the HK Tiananmen vigil is banned.— Melissa Chen (@MsMelChen) June 4, 2020
Anyone calling the crackdown on demonstrators here “America’s Tiananmen” is being facile.
We’re able to talk honestly about our flawed past and move the moral needle. For 31 years, China has buried the memory of Tiananmen.
Many suspect that the law was passed as part of an effort mandated by Beijing to crack down on an annual vigil to honor the victims, which the authorities are refusing to allow this year for the first time since the incident occurred.
The vote was held on a poignant day in Hong Kong, where for the first time in 30 years, authorities refused permission for a mass vigil to mourn the deaths of the pro-democracy students gunned down by Chinese soldiers in Tiananmen Square 31 years ago. Police objected to the vigil, citing social-distancing rules amid the continuing coronavirus pandemic, and threatened to arrest those who violated the ban.
Vigil organizers and opposition groups have accused officials of using those regulations for political means to stifle dissent in the city, which was gripped by months of social unrest last year. China is in the process of passing national-security laws in the city to prevent a recurrence of the sometimes violent protests that drove the city into recession, a move opposition groups fear will permanently end the annual June 4 vigil and curb other demonstrations.
On Thursday, authorities put up extra barriers around parts of the park where the vigil, which often draws tens of thousands of people, is held each year. Parts of the park where vigil participants typically gather have been closed for weeks as the city fought to contain the spread of the coronavirus, which is now largely under control in Hong Kong.
Criticizing the anthem, or not showing appropriate respect, is now punishable by a penalty of up to three years in prison, and a maximum fine of HKD$50,000 ($6,400). The law was approved by a 41-1 vote in the legislature, according to WSJ.
Notably, the penalties for disrespecting the anthem are similar to penalties for desecrating China's flag.
The anthem law bans acts including insulting the anthem - "March of the Volunteers" - in public, or playing and singing it in a distorted or disrespectful way. The penalties are similar to those in an existing law that criminalizes the desecration of China’s flag.
With the vigil canceled, other activities had been organized across the city. Some still said they would go to the park, while others planned events at churches and universities.
With the vigil now cancelled, some Hong Kongers are organizing other peaceful events. But don't be surprised if there's more unrest on the streets this weekend.