On one of the busiest days in Q3 earnings season, following some impressive earnings from P&G, Biogen, UTX and UPS, moments ago the Dow Jones was dragged lower as heavyweight component McDonalds reported earnings that missed on the top and bottom line, while US comp sales disappointed lofty expectations.
For Q2, McDonalds reported non-GAAP EPS of $2.11, down 2% from 2.16 a year ago, and also below the $2.21 consensus estimate. Revenue also missed, with the company reporting $5.431BN in Q2 sales, below the $5.49BN expected, while operating income of $2.41 billion, declined 0.3% Y/Y and was not only below the estimate of $2.51 billion, but also below the lowest estimate in the range ($2.45 billion to $2.59 billion).
However, the reason for the market's violent response was not so much earnings, as the company's comp store sales number, which while beating globally, with a 5.9% increase, up from 4.2% Y/Y, and above the 5.7% expected, it was the US that traders were focused on as US comp sales rose 4.8%, which while double last year's 2.40%, was below the 5.2% consensus estimate.
This is an issue because, as Bloomberg explains, McDonald’s gets more than a third of revenue from the U.S., where it’s been having a hard time luring more diners, especially during the morning hours. And it’s getting more crowded: Burger King is trying to improve its coffee lineup, Dunkin’ is introducing Beyond Meat breakfast sandwiches nationwide and Wendy’s is planning to re-enter the morning market with a big push next year.
As a result, amid rising competition, CEO Steve Easterbrook has been investing heavily in technology (think robots who demand a $0.00 minimum wage everywhere). That includes delivery, making it easier to reorder on the company’s mobile app and adding smart-tech like license-plate scanners to drive-thrus; yet the beneficial effect of these appears to have topped out.
Meanwhile, as Bloomberg also notes, investors would love to know more about the chain’s plant-based ambitions in the US, but it hasn’t let slip who it’s considering for its 14,000 locations in that market. That said, MCD did announce a test with Beyond Meat in Canada last month. McDonald’s former CEO Don Thompson was an early investor in Beyond through his Chicago-based Cleveland Avenue fund.
In any event, the kneejerk reaction to the miss in earnings and comp sales was not taken well by the market, and the stock slumped as low as $200, down 4% and the lowest level since June (the stock had climbed 18% through Monday)...
... and since MCD is among the biggest Dow Jones members, its results pushed the "industrial" average back in the red.