RBC Warns January Is Setting Up As A "Massive Mean-Reversion" Month

Following Friday's report by RCB's Charlie McElligott which sought to answer "THE" question every investor is asking, namely "what could derail this rally", today's the cross-asset strategist has released a follow up analysis in which he warns that even though the bond battering continues - and is likely to continue for a while - the market is now being set up for a "massive mean-reversion" counter-trend rally as soon as January.

His arguments why are presented below:


Bonds further ‘wearing it’ on multiple-fronts this morning (monster TY put block overnight, likely hedging against MTM losses being accumulated--H/T Alex Redhead) as once again, the 5+ year rates trader playbook is torn-up with weakness during the Asian session overnight—five points I’m highlighting:

  1. Crude oil is +5% (highest levels in 17 months) after further Saudi commitment to cut output following the non-OPEC states agreement this weekend to do the same.  RBC’s Chief Commodities Strategist Helima Croft is calling this “OPEC’s ‘whatever it takes’ moment,” and global developed market inflation expectations are again being ‘reset’ higher;
  2. Front-loaded UST issuance calendar this week ahead of Fed, with 3Y and 10Y auctions Monday and 30Y on Tuesday;
  3. Nikkei press report that 2017 BoJ issuance will set a new record, specifically highlighting plans to issue Y3T of 40Y JGBs against a reduction of sales in the front-end / belly.  Accordingly, we see JGB 2s30s and 5s30s curves making new nine-month steeps;
  4. Western financial press reports noting that the BoJ may have to reduce asset purchases by as much as 10% in light of the move already seen in US rates / the impact this is having on JGBs (FWIW, our Japan USD rates team is pointing out that no local press is talking about this tapering story—as such, we continue with status quo of the ‘policy divergence’ trade, as the Yen drop to new 10 month lows against the USD overnight);
  5. ‘Unwillingness’ to catch the falling knife from overseas real money investors (who have been “the” bid in USTs for years), voicing a preference to wait until 2017 to target ‘more attractive’ entry points for longs.  This comes with domestic real money funds already being sellers as they work to shed duration.  The sense is that leveraged funds will continue to press shorts on this trade which has been exceptionally profitable thus far.  As such, the rates move to the upside could be magnified even further into certain illiquid year end conditions with dealer balance sheet / financing constraints.

The danger for risk assets of course is a ‘disorderly’ rates move, as noted in Friday’s “Big Picture” as one of the chief concerns with regards to potential disruptors of the “reflation trade.”  VaR stress -induced deleveraging has repeatedly ‘spilled-over’ into other asset classes in every ‘taper-tantrum’ episode we’ve witnessed since ’13, especially on account of the proliferation of “short convexity”/“short correlation” strategies which have grown massively popular with the asset liability management community in the post-GFC period.  When their long fixed-income portfolios come under enough stress to ‘trip’ vol targets, mechanical deleveraging occurs across their asset portfolios. 

The aforementioned bond bull market of course engendered these leverage carry strategies under the façade of “low volatility” in bonds, as global rates act as the Central Bank ‘lynchpin’ for all monetary policy.  This in turn suppressed volatility in equities, credit and FX as well—by design.  Now that we have the Fed, the ECB and the BoJ acknowledging the limits of QE (the beginning of the end of the ‘monpol only’ regime) while at the same time,the geopolitical populist shift is agitating for a fiscal stimulus ‘lever,’ positioning / asset allocation needs to be reset for real and leveraged money, while these volatility trigger strategies too must be re-formatted against a backdrop of higher rates—which simply means volatility normalization (and within equities for example, actual thematic / factor / sector dispersion).

But well beyond certain strategy types, this is a reassessment which ALL investors HAVE to be dragged-into—because this marks a dramatic narrative shift.  I have made my position on bonds evident in ‘broken-record’-fashion over the past nine months—an impossibly-crowded and lazy ‘duration long’ had been accumulated into an inflection point within the 35-year bond bull market and a ‘peak’ in CB / QE largesse hit earlier this Summer…and now we are seeing this metastasize into the next leg of the unwind / re-allocation into a world where there are now more than nascent signs of a growth- and reflation- impulse.  Long-term, curves will continue to steepen, and yields will push higher—especially with the table set for continued inflation trajectory and thus, more hikes being priced-into rates expectations.

For equities, the impact is nuanced—it’s about the difference between a bond market sell-off driven by higher inflation expectations (a stocks +++) versus one driven by higher real interest rates, which is the ‘financial tightening’ downside (whether it be equity risk premium / earnings multiple driver being unwound, or the bigger picture loss of liquidity in the global economic / funding engine that comes with higher rates / higher Dollar). 

But for all of the reasons noted Friday, it’s very likely we’ll see periods of violent bond rallies during this shift (‘positioning-excess’ driven—a.k.a. tactical trading opportunities)—with this set-up into January being a prime example.  The issue is this: between the purely mechanical “rebalancing” that tends to occur at the world’s largest pensions at the end of Q4 / end of year—ON TOP OF the proclivity of active managers to “window dress” portfolios by adding “stuff that has worked / ‘winners’” and selling “stuff that has underperformed / ‘losers’” for optics in December, a massive signal is generated which the quant community ‘laps up.’  And this is why January has shown a tendency since the turn of the millennium to be an enormous “mean reversion” month—whether across assets or intra-asset (i.e. stock factor or sector performance).  

The concern is that the extent of the current bond short (record short positions in FV and Eurodollar from leveraged funds seen in Friday’s CFTC data as shown in the charts below)...




... will exacerbate the already strong trend of this “January” effect (SPX on avg since 2003 -1.3% in January / -3.8% on average over the past 3 Januarys; against TLT (iShares 20+ year Treasury ETF) on avg since 2003 +5.6% / +7.2% on average over the past 3 Januarys)…especially as consensual as the ‘set-up’ is again into the start of ’17 -> “long stocks on positive ‘economic escape velocity and growth’ expectations against short USTs,” especially off the back of Fed hikes.  History rhymes…and when you add in the view that overseas real money is waiting until the start of 2017 to pounce on better levels to pounce, there is certainly the kindling for a serious Treasury melt-up fire.

And again as per Friday’s note, this isn’t just a ‘bonds vs stocks’ rebalancing dynamic trade—as it too would mean that the ‘value vs growth’ or ‘cyclicals vs defensives’ trades would see significant reversion to the mean within equities, which would cause performance pain in light of the recent exposure grab there.  Further moves into the end of the month are key “tells” with regards to “momentum” and “anti-beta / low vol” outperformance, which would increase the likelihood success with a January “reversal strategy” (buy bottom decile, sell top decile)—again, WHICH IF IT TRIGGERS could be a set-up for ‘low vol’ and ‘growth’ outperformance against recent ‘value’ and ‘cyclical’ leadership.  A similar ‘mean-reversion’ observation could then be extrapolated into other asset classes.

The point I’m trying to make is that the LONGER-TERM story on higher rates and the rotation into a more reflationary ‘pro-growth’ allocation mix still stands (see any “RBC Big Picture” for the evidence of global developed inflation expectations, enormous trajectory of global data--especially PMIs, of ‘confidence’ and other indicators of ‘animal spirits’ accelerating etc)…BUT we are nearing that counter-trend rally—with January as ‘the chalk’ for a likely start date.  Strategic vs tactical.