What "Off The Grid" Indicators Reveal About The True State Of The US Economy

By Nicholas Colas, from DataTrek Research

It’s that time of quarter again; today we review our “Off the Grid” economic indicators. And they all look pretty good in terms of launching the American economy into 2018. Pickup truck sales and used car prices remain robust, and there’s some actual inflation in our Bacon Cheeseburger Index. One warning: “Bitcoin” is among the top Google search autofills for the phrase “I want to buy…

We started our “Off the Grid” economic indicators in the aftermath of the Financial Crisis as a way to dig deeper into the longer-lasting effects of that event on the American consumer. It seemed to us that standard economic measures like unemployment or CPI inflation missed a lot about the state of the country. So we started gathering up a list of intuitive metrics that could fill those gaps.

A few examples from these datasets over the years:

#1 Participation in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (commonly called Food Stamps) went from 26 million Americans in November 2006 to a high of 48 million in late 2012. At that high water mark, 16% of the entire US population needed government support to put food on the table. And since participation in the program is based on income, this meant a substantial portion of the US population was living at/near/below the poverty line.

The latest data is more upbeat: as of August 2017 (latest data available), there are 41 million people enrolled in the program. Some of this reduction comes as states return to pre-Crisis rules for program participation, and some comes from rising incomes that allow households to exit the program. Another positive: Google searches for “Food Stamps” are back to pre-Crisis levels after a blip higher in the wake of the hurricanes in Florida and Texas.

#2 During the Financial Crisis and its aftermath, Americans bought large amounts of gold and silver coins as a hedge against instability in the banking system. In any given month from 2009 to 2013, the US Mint shipped over $100 million in gold coins and $75 – 100 million in silver coins to dealers for retail sale.

Demand for gold and silver coins in the US is now a fraction of those levels, averaging just $15 million and $7 million, respectively, per month in the second half of 2017. Google search volume data confirms the decline in interest, with “Gold coin” queries lower than at any point since 2004 (the start of the time series).

#3 Sales of large pickup trucks, most commonly purchased by small businesses, reached a low of 70,000 units a month in early 2009. In November 2017, they were 191,000.

Just as important, sales of large pickup trucks have been stable since 2014, growing at mid-single rates even as overall vehicle sales have plateaued. That’s a positive sign – small businesses don’t buy pickups for show. These are work vehicles, and an investment in a new one means they see business conditions remaining strong in 2018.

With those three examples, you get the idea: the US economy has not only recovered from the Financial Crisis, but in many ways is firing on all cylinders. Our other OTG indicators generally point to the same conclusion.

Here they are:

Despite many pundits predicting their decline, used car prices are holding up well. The Manheim Used Vehicle Index (real price data from thousands of auctions) is our data source here. Their November 2017 reading is up 7.8% from last year. And since new car buyers almost always trade in their existing vehicle to buy a new one, higher used car prices effectively lower the cost of purchasing a new vehicle.



New vehicle inventories at dealer lots are currently at a seasonally normal 71 days supply. The caveat here: the hurricanes in Florida and Texas destroyed hundreds of thousands of cars and trucks. Selling rates in Q4 were therefore higher than usual, and “Days supply” is based on current rates. But given a strong economy, we are not overly worried that sales will fall off a cliff in the New Year.

The amount of cash spent by the average American on a daily basis is up to $98/day, a post-Crisis high. (Source: Gallup Organization)

We’ve seen a lot of change in Google’s autofill suggestions for “I want to buy” and “I want to sell”. Recall that the search engine tries to complete your partially entered query with words commonly used by other users. In Q4 2017, the most common thing users finished “I want to buy” was “a timeshare” (an obviously discretionary purchase). It dethroned “House”, which has been the most common entry since Q2 2015.

A word of warning: “Bitcoin” has never made it into the top 4 autofills for “I want to buy”. Until now.


We measure visible consumer inflation with our “Bacon Cheeseburger Index (BCI)”, equal weights of ground beef, cheese and bacon price data from the Consumer Price Index data. Good news here for the US Federal Reserve: consumers should start feeling a little more inflation in 2018. After a long bout of cheaper inputs for America’s favorite meal (well, mine anyway), the BCI is up 1.4% year over year. A year ago at this time, it showed a -5.7% decline.

Our “Take This Job and Shove It” indicator is also in very healthy territory. This is a measure of quits as a percentage of total separations from the monthly JOLTS data. In October 2017, 61.4% of workers who left their jobs did so with a resignation letter rather than a pink slip. That’s not quite as high as the record 62.2% in September 2016, but still quite strong. And since Quits/Total Separations is a good proxy for Consumer Confidence, that important economic barometer has a full head of steam as we enter 2018.

* * *

The bottom line here: with few exceptions (Food Stamps, notably), the US economy is in exceptionally strong shape as we enter 2018. Small business confidence is strong, and savers do not see the need to hedge their bank accounts with gold coins. Timeshare salespeople are busy. Inflation that consumers use to anchor their expectations is rising at a modest pace.

All that may be “Off the Grid”, but it gives us confidence that the standard – and currently quite bullish - economic data is actually on the mark.



FreeShitter Fri, 12/29/2017 - 18:35 Permalink

 "Small business confidence is strong, and savers do not see the need to hedge their bank accounts with gold coins."


There you have it bitchez, life is all good and this time it's different...


Ron_Mexico Fri, 12/29/2017 - 18:47 Permalink

The problem with this analysis is that it does not see the forest for the trees. And the forest, in a word, is demographics. With the Boomers in or near retirement, I foresee demand destruction across the entire spectrum of consumer goods, including investment assets. The term "Eurosclerosis" comes to mind.  Europe and the USA have been living off the economic dynamism of China and other Asian countries for 10 to 20 years. And, like any other codger, they are bound to be put on an "allowance" eventually.  All of this is just convenience store anecdotalism masquerading as some sort of insight.

ds Sat, 12/30/2017 - 00:48 Permalink

First to get out of the 08 GFC painfully. More pains are required. The US real economy is not ready to claim victories. However, the pains have just begun in once touted growth area. This includes China.

Erwin643 Sat, 12/30/2017 - 03:55 Permalink

These are "off the grid" indicators? 


The don't even know what "off the grid" means.

How about these: Money spent at flea markets and gun shows (currently horrible, btw. Yes, some people do make a living this way, as vendors)? Private contracts on real estate purchases (No banks involved, and many times no real estate agents, either! Just a good down payment to seal the deal. 

How about the underground economy in general: House sitters, caretakers, caregivers, companions, etc.

I guess these people have never read Paladin Press books, such as Ragnar's Guide to the Underground economy.

Let it Go Sat, 12/30/2017 - 07:38 Permalink

A series of what would have at one time been considered outlandish  ideas, such as a war on cash, forgiving debt through a debt jubilee, giving everyone a guaranteed income, and even injecting money into the economic system by dropping it from a helicopter have all found their way into conversations about ways to keep this economy going. This should be a reason for concern.

An example of just how delusional we have become as to the fragility of our financial system is that many people have taken comfort in the efforts to control the banking sector through legislation following the 2008 crisis. The Dodd Frank Act of over 2,300 pages and still growing, is the longest and most complicated bill ever passed by the U.S. legislature. The article below makes a case that claims of economic stability are just an illusion.


Consuelo Sat, 12/30/2017 - 14:31 Permalink



To the author, Mr. Colas:


Upon which platform did/does all of this economic glad tiding float...?

For whatever reason, you failed to mention the most important/key element in all of your glorious, upbeat findings.

Hint: It's a 4-letter word which begins with a capital 'D' and ends with a 't'...