This Week's Three Scenarios For US-China Trade Talks

This week will mark another round of talks between the United States and China in an attempt to resolve the ongoing trade war, after President Donald Trump and China's Xi Jinping ordered their officials to hammer out a deal by March 1 on "structural changes" to China's economic model.

Failure to reach an agreement will result in Trump raising the tariff rate on $200 billion in Chinese imports from 10 percent to 25 percent, and would "dash hopes of a lasting truce that would remove one of the darkest clouds hanging over the world economy," reports Bloomberg

Starting Wednesday, US Trade Representative Robert Lightnizer will meet with Vice Premier Liu He in Washington for two days, building on negotiations ranging from soy beans to subsidies Beijing provides to various state-owned companies. 

And while a final deal isn't likely this week, negotiators will hopefully produce a package of proposals to bring back to both administrations, said former Clinton Commerce official William Reinsch. 

"Everybody’s divided, because President Trump is so unpredictable," said Reinsch.

"It’s probably 50-50 whether he’ll accept it."

Here are the good, the bad and the ugly scenarios according to Bloomberg


Base Case

Even if Lighthizer and Liu reach an agreement this week, it will probably take time to brief the two presidents, then for Trump and Xi to decide if they’re satisfied. Don’t expect much in the way of explanation from either Liu or Lighthizer, who rarely say much to the packs of reporters staking out the talks.

That leaves vague official statements as the best way to determine how much progress was made. Following the last meetings in Beijing, the two sides put out separate statements. The U.S. acknowledged progress on issues such as purchases of U.S. products, but added that any deal would need to include “ongoing verification and effective enforcement.” The Chinese has called the talks “extensive, in-depth and detailed.”

The broad outlines of a deal are clear at this point. The Chinese will probably agree to buy more American goods, Beijing may promise to stop stealing intellectual property, and the two sides could develop a workable enforcement system to give the deal teeth.

If officials indicate that they plan to hold another round of talks, that would be a sign that the two sides still think a deal can be done before March 1, even if they’re not willing to lay out the whole package. Another possible outcome if the sides agree to meet again, would be for an extension to the tariff truce.

“The easier things for trade negotiators to announce are procedural things,” said Jennifer Hillman, a law professor and trade expert at Georgetown University in Washington.

“We’re going to meet, we’re going to talk. If you can’t agree on that, you’re in bad shape."

Breakthrough Case

In the best-case scenario, the Chinese come to the table with an offer on economic reforms that’s more ambitious than expected. That convinces Lighthizer, a China hawk who has said progress with Beijing will take years, that the Chinese are serious about opening up their state-driven model. That could be enough for Trump or the White House to hail a deal in principle. Markets would rally, shrugging off months of anxiety about a global trade war.

The problem is the Chinese would need a game-changing offer that shows they’re serious about loosening the grip of the state on the world’s second-biggest economy.

“The U.S. wants broad changes to China’s corporate governance,” said David Loevinger, a former Treasury official who is now a managing director at TCW Group Inc. “It’s just very hard to do.”

Breakdown Case

If there’s no statement of any kind at the conclusion of talks, look out. A fiery Trump tweet may not be far behind, expressing frustration with the lack of progress.

Trump has walked away before. In May, the two countries issued a joint statement in which China agreed to increase of farm goods and energy exports, and it recognized the importance of intellectual property protections. Within days, the president rejected the framework and sent his negotiators back to the drawing board.

A similar reaction by Trump could put the talks on ice for a long time. Much will depend on how hawks in his administration -- including Lighthizer, White House adviser Peter Navarro and Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross -- react to China’s offers.

“What worries me is that over the course of the last year the balance of power has shifted toward the China hawks,” said Loevinger. “It’s still not clear what will take the U.S. to say yes.”

If they don’t, it could be a long time before the next campaign of shuttle diplomacy between Washington and Beijing.