If you've been waiting for the opportunity to trade convertibles, options, variance swaps and other complex derivatives tied to the price of bitcoin, well, you soon might be in luck.
WSJ reported on Wednesday that several firms are launching new derivative products tied to bitcoin, some relying on "complex formulas" to determine how much shall be paid out. Crypto firms have been working on "structured products" (think contingent convertibles and other bond-like derivatives) that they hope to market to sophisticated investors (mostly family offices). Retail traders will most likely be off limits - at least in the beginning.
And given bitcoin's intense volatility - just look at the trading action over the past two weeks - it's hardly surprising that the WSJ story elicited widespread mockery on twitter (though, to be fair, the headline makes this trend seem much more well-established than it is). According to WSJ, this year's bitcoin rally has revived interest in these esoteric products tied to bitcoin, just as the last rally gave birth to bitcoin futures.
For anybody hoping to trade these products, a word of caution: We all remember how Wall Street banks' creation of synthetic CDOs and other complex derivatives tied to housing worked out. Some assets simply aren't well-suited for these types of derivatives.
But in reality, the evidence for this market is pretty flimsy. From the looks of it, WSJ could only find two firms that are actively working on building these products - and even these firms said they don't expect bitcoin derivatives to be widely traded.
Cipher Technologies, a crypto hedge fund in Greenwich, Conn., began offering structured products on bitcoin earlier this year. The firm has done several such deals, mainly with entities that manage money for wealthy families and individuals, said Cipher’s founder and managing partner, Gerald Banks.
"We would not fathom pushing this to anyone who would not be fully versed in the risk or in the nature of the underlying asset," said Mr. Banks, who helped develop Merrill Lynch’s structured-products business in the 1990s and early 2000s.
One of Cipher’s products is a bond-like contract known as a reverse convertible. In such a deal, the client loans money to Cipher in return for monthly interest payments, with Cipher paying back the loan once the contract expires. But before then, if bitcoin falls below a predetermined level - a 19% drop, in one version of the product from earlier this year - then Cipher returns the principal to the client, minus the amount bitcoin has lost.
Though one firm was founded by a former Goldman derivatives trader.
GSR, a cryptocurrency-trading firm led by former Goldman Sachs Group Inc. commodities traders, has unveiled several new bitcoin structured products since March. These include variance swaps, which pay out for their buyers if bitcoin’s volatility increases, and binary options, which pay out either a fixed sum or nothing, depending on whether bitcoin trades above or below a specified price.
Most of GSR’s revenue comes from algorithmic trading of digital currencies, and the firm has only done a small number of structured-products trades, said the firm’s co-founder and co-head of trading, Richard Rosenblum, a former global head of oil-derivatives trading at Goldman.
Most of the space in the story was devoted to a former SEC official warning that creating derivatives linked to such a volatile asset as bitcoin is clearly a bad idea - former SEC economist Craig McCann said "there are all kinds of problems associated with any structured product tied to bitcoin" - and a CFTC enforcement director advising firms working on these products that they must adhere to derivatives-trading rules from Dodd-Frank.
Obviously, trading in complex bitcoin derivatives (obviously this doesn't include the bitcoin futures contracts trading on CME and Cboe) isn't really "a thing" just yet.
But we'll know things are getting serious when Goldman Sachs launches its crypto-derivative trading desk.