Uranium: Max Pain
A month ago we wrote that the listed physical uranium funds, Sprott Physical Uranium Trust (SPUT) and Yellow Cake (YCA), were trading at valuation levels we had seen only a handful of times since 2022. Since then, the discount has not corrected. It has got worse.
YCA now trades at its deepest discount to NAV since the depths of Covid, only around 4 percentage points away from matching the widest discount of that entire 2020 panic. On our numbers it is more than 3 standard deviations cheap versus its own history in terms of discount to NAV, and more than 2 standard deviations cheap versus its larger peer SPUT in terms of the relative upside it offers to NAV. SPUT itself is trading more than 2 standard deviations cheap versus its own history.
YCA own relative NAV valuation historically, and share price (%, GBp)

Source: Asymmetric Research, company reports
YCA excess upside to NAV offered versus SPUT, and share price (%, GBp)

Source: Asymmetric Research, company reports
Put in terms of what you are actually paying, YCA is effectively discounting a uranium price of $68/lb, and SPUT around $77/lb, adjusted for fund operating costs. That $68/lb is nearly 10% below the floor price Cameco is currently signing with utilities.
The stock has been caught in the broader malaise, and worsened by its confirmed exclusion from MSCI indices at the end of this month. That is a one-off event, and one we think is well in the price already.
One objection we keep hearing is that these funds are discounted because of the potential arrival of physical uranium futures from CME. We think that is wrong. If anything, futures should give speculators the ability to hedge and arbitrage the discount away, not entrench it.
Meanwhile the physical market is doing the opposite of what the equities are implying. Despite uranium equities being dragged around alongside AI and volatility baskets, the uranium spot price continues to hold firm at $90/lb, and term uranium is at record nominal highs of $97/lb, while the equities imply something far lower.
SPUT relative NAV valuation historically, and its implied uranium price versus spot and term prices (%, $/lb)
Source: Asymmetric Research, company reports, Numerco, UxC
Implied uranium price in SPUT versus term price (%)

Source: Asymmetric Research, Numerco, UxC
Our bull thesis on uranium rests on four pillars:
1. A persistent deficit. On a deliberately conservative basis, assuming zero incremental demand from SMRs, no additional data-centre demand and no utility restocking, we still see a deficit persisting until NexGen’s projects come online around 2030, and that is close to a best case for new supply.
2. Kazakhstan’s strategic uranium reserve. We think utilities are underappreciating the significance of Kazakhstan’s decision to build a strategic reserve, and what it implies for the supply that is actually available to the rest of the market.
3. A structural shift in energy security. Since the Iran war, we believe there has been a fundamental reassessment of energy security, in some ways analogous to the shift that followed the 1973 oil embargo. In our view this could usher in a new nuclear dawn, not necessarily led by the West, but increasingly by countries that have felt the consequences of relying heavily on LNG for power.
4. Utility inventory coverage. Many Western utilities hold only around three years of inventory coverage, a level that looks increasingly obsolete set against Kazakhstan’s targeted 80-plus years of coverage for its own planned nuclear programme.
The equities are pricing total fear. The detailed work behind the sector and the equities, the underlying models, and our ongoing coverage as this plays out are on our Substack.
Subscribe for our model-driven analysis and takes, and direct access to us:
https://asymmetricresearch.substack.com/
***
Disclaimer: This note is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or a personal recommendation. Past performance is not indicative of future results. The value of investments can go down as well as up. Commodities and mining equities are highly volatile. Readers should seek independent professional financial advice before making any investment decision. We own shares in Yellow Cake (YCA).

