Former Obama Officials Urge Foreign Governments To "Quietly Gather Evidence" On Hegseth
Three former US national security officials, two of whom served in the Obama administration, have laid out how foreign governments could prosecute Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and two top commanders for murder over the boat strikes in the Caribbean and Pacific - suggesting that officials in Colombia, Ecuador or other affected countries "could quietly gather evidence of the crimes and wait to issue indictments until Trump is out of office."

The road map appeared in a May 27 essay at Just Security, the national security journal housed at NYU School of Law, written by Tracey Begley, Benjamin Farley and Sarah Harrison. It drew fresh attention this week after journalist Natalie Winters flagged it, just as the journal's own editors, both former government lawyers, published their plan for how a post-Trump government should go after the President's officials.
Former Obama advisers are openly calling for foreign countries to pursue criminal cases against Secretary Hegseth.
Their proposal: "quietly gather evidence" now and wait until Trump leaves office to issue indictments. pic.twitter.com/jxfKyxXdyJ— Natalie Winters (@nataliegwinters) November 14, 2026
Harrison was counselor to the Secretary of Homeland Security from 2015 to 2017 and later an associate general counsel at the Pentagon, according to her CNAS profile. Farley was a senior adviser to the State Department's special envoy for closing Guantanamo from 2013 to 2017 and later ran its Office of Terrorist Detentions, per his University of Minnesota bio. Begley is a former senior adviser in the State Department's Office of Global Criminal Justice.
The essay calls the strikes "unjustified summary executions - murder," and names three "high-level potential perpetrators": Hegseth, "who frequently posts on social media about the killings"; Adm. Frank Bradley, the US Special Operations commander; and Gen. Francis Donovan, head of US Southern Command. "Somewhat ironically," the authors write, the administration's own public identification of the three may have helped foreign prosecutors - and by repatriating survivors, Washington "has furnished potential victim-witnesses."
The authors concede there are "obvious geopolitical downsides" for Colombia or Ecuador in going after American officials. "But these States do not have to act immediately," they write, because murder and attempted murder typically carry no statute of limitations, or one of 20 or 30 years.

Custody is the obvious problem, and the essay has an answer for that too: a prosecuting country could turn a national warrant into an international one or invoke its extradition treaties. That, the authors argue, would impose some consequence "even if the consequences are merely the perpetrators' self-imposed travel restrictions to avoid arrest, along with public condemnation."
Countries with no link to the victims could act as well: 99 UN member states have universal jurisdiction laws covering crimes against humanity, "including the majority of NATO countries," and the authors argue the strikes may qualify. And while they expect the International Criminal Court to move cautiously, they float jurisdiction through the boats' countries of registration and point to former Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte, now awaiting trial in The Hague over his drug war: "Trump's substantially similar conduct toward alleged drug traffickers means he or other U.S. officials involved could eventually face similar treatment by the Court."
"Accountability Begins At Home"
The essay is back in circulation as Democrats prepare to take the House in January and the same publication sketches what comes next. On Nov. 10, Just Security co-editors Tess Bridgeman, a White House lawyer and deputy legal adviser to the National Security Council under Obama, and Ryan Goodman, a former special counsel to the Pentagon's general counsel, argued that it is "unacceptable to disavow accountability for an ongoing, public campaign of state murder."
They expect the President's promised "tremendous numbers of pardons" to take federal prosecution off the table for many of his officials, but note that a pardon "does not shield anyone from testifying before Congress," and that anyone who lies to cover up wrongdoing could still be prosecuted for perjury. "Congress would be wise to watch carefully who is pardoned, for which offenses, and ensure that those individuals either tell their truth ... or face the consequences," they write. They cite Hakeem Jeffries' Nov. 4 letter announcing his run for Speaker, which they say is clear: "accountability begins at home."
A week earlier, former Air Force Secretary Frank Kendall published a nine-step plan for the Pentagon, starting with how the boat strikes, "including survivors in the water," were authorized. That fact-finding, he wrote, "can start under the next Congress." Kendall also flagged the "distinct possibility" of pardons and argued criminal charges should be reserved for "gross and knowing violations of law."
"This Is Sabotage"
At a Nov. 10 press conference against Rep. Thomas Massie's impeachment articles, Hegseth said every operation they targeted was lawful, ordered by the commander-in-chief, notified to Congress and carried out by "warriors who delivered decisive results," according to the White House, which headlined his remarks: "This Is Not Patriotism; This Is Sabotage."
WATCH IN FULL: @SecWar's powerful press conference dismantling the politically motivated impeachment hoax against him. pic.twitter.com/XS4dnHyEbh
— Rapid Response 47 (@RapidResponse47) November 10, 2026
As we reported, House Republicans sent Massie's articles back to the Judiciary Committee that night, effectively killing the effort until Democrats take over Congress - and 11 Democrats who could have stopped them never voted.
The strikes have continued since the essay counted at least 193 people killed across 57 incidents in May: by late October the death toll from the campaign stood at at least 240 since September 2025. The authors close with a line aimed squarely at foreign capitals: "We hope those with the power to do so eventually muster the will."
