print-icon
print-icon
Add ZeroHedge as a preferred source on Google

A Heated Hold: FOMC Minutes To Show The Hawks Were Closer To Winning Than The 10-2 Vote Suggested

Tyler Durden's Photo
by Tyler Durden
Authored...

At 2pm today the Fed releases the minutes of the October 27-28 FOMC meeting, and if there is one thing everyone agrees on it's that they won't matter very much.

Recall that three weeks ago the Fed held rates at 3.75%-4.00% in a 10-2 vote, with Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack dissenting in favor of an immediate 25bp hike. It was Cook's first dissent since joining the board in 2022 and, per Fortune, the first time a governor and a regional Fed president dissented on the same side since October 1992. The statement also upgraded the economy to "strong" from "solid" and promised that the "accumulation of more information" would guide the next move. Translation: we're hiking in December, we just didn't want to do it a week before the midterms (a point several strategists made out loud at the time). Or, as we put it the day after, the hawks lost a vote rather than an argument.

Since then, the "more information" has arrived, and almost all of it has pointed the same way: core CPI rose 0.3% for a third straight month (a 3.7% annualized pace), core retail sales jumped 0.6% in October (pushing Goldman's Q4 GDP tracking to 2.4%), and the 10Y is sitting at 5.10%. Which is why, maybe, the minutes are a backward-looking document about a debate that has already moved on.

"A Heated Hold"

Still, the minutes will show just how wide the split really was among the 19 participants, not just the 12 voters. BofA's economists expect the divide to have been considerably deeper than the vote count let on, as BofA puts it in its preview Oct FOMC minutes preview: "A heated hold" (available to pro subs):

We expect the Oct FOMC minutes to reveal a deeper divide over the decision to be on hold than the 10-2 vote suggested. Those favoring a hold likely argued the rise in yields was doing some of the Fed's work and pointed to financial market concerns. Those opposed likely emphasized the economy's underlying strength and the risk of falling behind the curve. The subsequent data flow should reinforce the latter camp's concerns, and lead them to push for picking up the pace of hikes going forward.

Put differently, the doves' case boiled down to letting the bond market do the tightening (and worrying about what it was doing to financial conditions), while the hawks argued the economy was too strong to sit still. With the 10Y now at 5.10% and the Nasdaq retesting its lows, both camps can probably claim they were right, which is the kind of outcome central bankers tend to enjoy most.

What to look for at 2pm:

  • How many "participants" wanted to hike. Watch for "several" or "many" non-voters siding with Cook and Hammack. The more there are, the more locked-in December becomes (as if it isn't already).
  • The yields-did-the-work argument. Any language crediting higher long-end yields with tightening financial conditions is the dovish tell, and it reads very differently with the 10Y at 5.1%.
  • Assumptions and balance of risks. Goldman's econ team says it will be combing the minutes for the assumptions behind participants' economic outlooks and their views of the balance of risks at the time.
  • The meeting schedule and the shortened presser. Any discussion of Warsh's move to a six-meeting calendar, and of why the press conference was cut to roughly 30 minutes.

Waller Has Already Moved The Goalposts

The bigger problem for the minutes is that this morning Governor Waller made them even more stale. Speaking on CNBC, Waller said inflation is still headed in the wrong direction and that the Fed should consider a 50bp hike at the December 9 meeting, reprising the half-point call he first floated last week. The 2Y yield erased a 2.5bp drop and rose as much as 2.8bp to 4.83%, yet OIS still prices just a full 25bp hike plus about 3bp extra, or roughly a 10% chance of a 50bp move.

In other words, the market believes in December, it just doesn't believe Waller.

Three Camps, One Consensus Taker

That's where UBS comes in. In a note from Monday titled "Fed's Warsh Presented With Three December Scenarios", UBS argues Warsh "seems to be a consensus taker," and will let the committee fight it out on December 9 before picking a winner. The three camps:

  • Waller: inflation is about to break loose again, so pounce with 50bp to show intent.
  • Dallas Fed's Logan: 50bp increments risk signaling panic, so go back-to-back 25bp in December and January.
  • Cleveland's Hammack: stick with the gradual, quarter-a-quarter pace. She repeated as much late Monday: inflation expectations look anchored but inflation is broadening, so move in steady increments.

UBS sketches what Warsh does with that menu:

Warsh is likely to set Waller’s idea to one side, raise by 25bp in December and then allow the committee to spend January considering whether a back-to-back is needed. December could be another unsatisfactory press conference then, with Warsh spending his 30 minutes explaining why the Fed has done what it’s done (which the market already understands) and saying nothing about what it’s going to do next (for which the market does need guidance).

Which, to be fair, would be par for the course for a chairman who, ahead of the October meeting, was expected to deliver the "hawkish form" of no forward guidance at all.

The Minutes Are History, December Is The Story

So, the minutes will likely confirm what everyone already suspects: a committee that wanted to hike in October, held off for (mostly) calendar reasons, and has since been handed every excuse it needs to move in December. The only open questions are by how much and how often, and those won't be answered at 2pm today.

Our take: BofA's hawks win, Waller's 50bp gets politely shelved, and Logan's back-to-back gets more airtime than the market expects, especially with inflation broadening and Treasury buyers already demanding 5%+ on the 10Y. And with Lisa Cook now threatening to skip her own firing hearing, this may well be the last set of minutes in which one of the hawkish dissenters is still a sitting governor.

0